Mama Theresa's: Premier Pizza, Italian Cuisine & Catering in Garden City Park, NY

Mama Theresa's Introduce

For decades, Mama Theresa's has stood as a beloved fixture in Garden City Park, solidifying its reputation as a true Long Island institution for exceptional Italian cuisine. Categorized as both a premier Pizza restaurant and an authentic Italian restaurant, this establishment transcends the typical pizzeria experience, offering a comprehensive menu that rivals any full-service Italian eatery in the region.

This local favorite is known for providing a complete dining package: from the classic New York-style Neopolitan Pie and thick, satisfying Sicilian Pie, to elaborate Entrees such as Veal Marsala and Shrimp Francese. It is a place deeply ingrained in the local community, with long-time patrons often citing it as a "staple" for their families, a testament to its consistent quality and welcoming environment. In fact, one loyal customer highlights that they still frequent Mama Theresa's as an adult, recommending the classic pizza options alongside their famous Garden Salad with Chicken and Cheese, which is so popular it's also offered as a specialty pizza.

Mama Theresa's is an ideal destination whether you're looking for a quick and easy Slices for lunch, a cozy spot for a large Family-friendly dinner, or a comprehensive catering solution. Despite the potential for a small wait—a sign of its immense popularity—the combination of Fast service, great food, and a warm, Casual atmosphere makes the experience truly worthwhile for New Yorkers.

Location and Accessibility

Mama Theresa's is strategically located on 2429 Jericho Tpke, Garden City Park, NY 11040, USA. This placement on a major Nassau County artery makes it highly accessible for residents of Garden City, New Hyde Park, Mineola, and surrounding Long Island towns. The venue’s location is designed for maximum convenience, accommodating both those who are picking up a quick order and those staying for a full meal.

Accessibility for all guests is a priority. Mama Theresa's offers complete wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot, a comfortable wheelchair accessible restroom, and well-placed wheelchair accessible seating. Furthermore, parking is never an issue with options for free parking lot access, on-site parking, and free street parking available, ensuring a stress-free visit from arrival to departure.

Services Offered

Mama Theresa's provides a comprehensive suite of dining and convenience services, tailored to the high expectations of the New York market:

Dine-in and Table Service: Enjoy a relaxed meal in a Cozy setting with full Table service. The restaurant is well-equipped for various groups, featuring Seating, High chairs for children, and Wi-Fi.
Takeout and Delivery: For maximum convenience, they offer quick Takeout, standard Delivery, and No-contact delivery options, ensuring high-quality food reaches your home or office efficiently.
Full Bar Service: The restaurant is equipped to serve a variety of alcoholic beverages, including Beer, Wine, Cocktails, and Hard liquor, making it an excellent spot for a casual date night or group dinner.
All-Day Dining and Catering: Serving Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, they are a versatile dining choice throughout the day. They also offer full-service Catering for larger events and parties, with an extensive menu of large pasta dishes and platters.
Quick Bite and Late-Night Options: Known for Fast service, Mama Theresa's is perfect for a Quick bite and an ideal spot for Solo dining.

Features / Highlights

Mama Theresa's is distinguished by its vast menu and dedication to quality in multiple Italian categories, offering several unique selling points:

Extensive Pizza and Specialty Pie Menu: The pizza selection includes classic Sicilian and Neopolitan pies, a wide variety of Pizzettas (smaller, specialty pies), and over a dozen large Specialty Pies such as the customer favorites Drunken Grandma, Chicken Marsala Pie, and Buffalo Chicken Pie.
Full Italian Entrée Selection: The menu rivals traditional Italian dining rooms with over 20 unique Entrees featuring Veal, Chicken, and Seafood preparations, including popular dishes like Chicken Francese, Shrimp Oreganata, and Grilled Salmon Entree.
Variety of Pasta Options: They offer both individual Lunch Pastas and large Pastas suitable for family dinners or catering. The selection is vast, including the classic Large Pasta Alla Vodka, Large Pasta Clam Sauce, and the unique Large Pasta Alla Mama Theresa.
Exceptional Desserts and Coffee: Mama Theresa's is highlighted for having Great dessert, featuring classics like Tiramisu, NY Cheese Cake, and Cannoli, perfectly paired with their reputed Great coffee.
Appetizer and Side Dish Variety: The restaurant provides numerous options for starting the meal, from Calamari Fritti and Zuppa Di Cozze to Baked Clams Oreganate, ensuring a full multi-course dining experience. They also feature specialty items like Homemade Italian Style Sausage Tomato Sauce and Broccoli Rabe.

Contact Information

For takeout orders, reservations for family dining, or catering inquiries, please contact Mama Theresa's directly:

Address: 2429 Jericho Tpke, Garden City Park, NY 11040, USA

Phone: (516) 747-3111

What is Worth Choosing

For a Long Island patron visiting Mama Theresa's, the best choice depends on the occasion, but several items are non-negotiable classics that define the restaurant’s appeal.

For the quintessential Long Island pizza experience, you absolutely must try the Sicilian Slice or a full Sicilian Pie. This thick, spongy, and perfectly crusted classic is a reason why families have been coming back for generations. Pair it with the equally famous Buffalo Chicken Slice or Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice to experience their popular specialty pizza offerings. If feeding a group, choosing the Grandma Pie offers a delicious thin-crust alternative that is beloved by all.

If you are planning a sit-down meal, the full Italian offerings are worth exploring. Start with the Baked Clams Oreganate or Calamari Fritti before moving to a classic main course. A standout choice from the Platters is the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Platter, or for something more complex, select an entrée like Chicken Marsala or Eggplant Rollatine. The portions are generous, securing your value for money.

Lastly, don't overlook their unique salads and sides, which are a signature highlight. The local favorite, the Large Garden Salad, especially when ordered with chicken, is a fresh, abundant meal in itself, known for its quality ingredients. And because the restaurant is known for its sweet endings, ensure you save room for a piece of Tiramisu or the classic Cannoli—a perfect conclusion to an authentic Italian meal in Garden City Park.

Mama Theresa's Menu

Pizza Pies
Sicilian Pie $29.50
Thick crust pan pizza with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Neopolitan Pie $28.32
(8 slice) ''New York style'' 18'' pizza with mozzarella & tomato sauce

Pizzettas
Alla Melenzana Pizzetta $21.83
Vegetarian Pizzetta $21.83
Tomato basil sauce topped with a combination of sauteed fresh spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, flame-roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella.
White Pizzetta $20.06
Crispy round pie topped with fresh mozzarella, aged Romano cheese and seasoned ricotta drizzled with fresh garlic oil.
Buffalo Pizzetta $23.01
Our signature pizza! Crispy thin crust topped with Louisiana style spicy chicken pieces, blue cheese sauce and mozzarella.
Insalata Pizzetta $21.83
Extra thin crust pan pizza layered with garlic and San Marzano crushed plum tomato sauce, topped with a chopped garden salad tossed in house Italian.
Fra Diavolo Pizzetta $21.83
Tomato basil sauce topped with fresh mozzarella crumbled Italian style hot sausage and a touch of cherry peppers.
Prosciutto Arugula Pizzetta $23.01
Fresh mozzarella, imported Fontina cheese, and Parma prosciutto finished with arugula, white truffle oil and Reggiano cheese shavings.
Margherita Pizzetta $18.88
Traditional Neapolitan style thin crust pizza topped with our crushed san Marzano plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil and a whisper of extra virgin olive oil.

Calzones
Calzone $10.62

Panini
Rustico Panini $11.80
Fresh baked garlic and herb basted roll stuffed with Parma prosciutto, sliced vine ripe tomatoes and fresh mozzarella, drizzled with a homemade pesto aioli.
Buffalo Chicken Panini $11.80
Fresh baked garlic and herb-basted roll stu ed with Louisiana style bu alo chicken cutlets and fresh mozzarella, drizzled with blue cheese sauce.
Americano Panini $11.80
Broccoli Rabe Panini $11.80
Tramezzino Panini $19.47
Fresh baked folded at bread stuffed with grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, fontina cheese, arugula, roasted peppers and drizzled with white truffle oil.
Melanzane Pepper Panini $11.80
Fresh baked garlic and herb basted roll stuffed with grilled marinated eggplant, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella, drizzled with homemade pesto aioli.
Grilled Chicken Panini $11.80
Fresh baked garlic and herb-basted roll stuffed with grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, lettuce and tomato.

Side Pastas
Side Pasta Butter $15.23
Pasta with butter sauce.
Side Pasta Pink Sauce $17.00
Tomato sauce with a touch of cream.
Side Pasta Tomato Sauce $17.00
Traditional tomato sauce.
Side Pasta Bolognese $17.00
Southern Italian style hearty ground veal meat sauce.
Side Plain Pasta $17.00
Side Pasta Pesto $16.70
Fresh basil sauce, grated Parmesan cheese, pignoli nuts and Italian seasonings.
Side Pasta Alfredo $17.00
Classic Parmesan creamy cheese sauce.
Side Pasta Clam Sauce $19.99
Our authentic clam sauce includes shelled little neck clams & chopped baby clams, sauteed in a garlic and extra virgin olive oil sauce - or - marinara sauce.
Side Pasta Marinara $17.00
Old world style garlic and herb plum tomato sauce.
Side Pasta Garlic & Oil $17.00
Sauteed garlic and olive oil.

Salads
Caprino Caprino Salad $26.55
Fresh-grilled jumbo shrimp, mesclun greens, flame-roasted peppers, grilled asparagus, crumbled goat cheese, cherry tomatoes, red onions and balsamic vinaigrette.
Large Pecan Salad $19.47
Mesclun greens tossed with fresh arugula, honey roasted pecans, and Gorgonzola crumbles tossed with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette.
Tuna Salad Platter $21.83
Garden salad topped with our delicious homemade tuna.
Large Mediterranean Salad $18.29
Romaine hearts, cherry tomatoes, diced cucumbers, green peppers, Kalamata olives, onions, sliced pepperoncini, crumbled feta cheese and red wine vinaigrette.
Tuscan Bistro Salad $26.55
Fresh-grilled skirt steak served over mesclun greens, topped with diced Roma tomatoes, red onions and Gorgonzola crumbles drizzled with our Tuscan style Italian dressing.
Large Garden Salad $15.34
Iceberg and romaine mix, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, vinegar peppers, green and black olives drizzeled with our house Italian style dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Salad $24.19
Romaine hearts, diced plum tomatoes, shredded carrots, and red onions tossed with our creamy bleu cheese dressing topped off with warm buffalo chicken pieces.
Large Caesar Salad $16.81
Romaine hearts topped with homemade focaccia croutons, shaved reggiano cheese, and Dijon Caesar dressing.

Side Orders
Side Of Dressing $2.65
Two Grilled Chicken $14.75
Brushetta $7.08
One Grilled Chicken $7.37
Homemade Italian Style Sausage Tomato Sauce $14.75
Home made Italian sausages in our home made Italian tomato sauce 3 per order.
One Homemade Style Meatballs $4.42
Home Made Italian Meatballs in our home made Italian tomato sauce.
Side Of Meatballs $14.75
Four meatballs.
One Baked Chicken $7.37
Side Ricotta $3.54
Side Of Mozzarella $3.24
French Fries $7.67
Side Pita Bread $2.65
One Fried Chicken Cutlet $7.37
Fried breaded chicken cutlets.
Side Grated Cheese $2.65
Two Fried Chicken Cutlets $14.75
Fried breaded chicken cutlets.

Baked Pasta
Homemade Meat Lasagna $23.01
Baked Ziti Siciliana Style $21.83
Baked Cheese Ravioli $22.42
Baked Ziti $21.83

Beverages
Can Of Soda $4.13
Acqua Panna $8.26
2 Liter Soda $7.37
Gatorade $4.72
Snapple $4.72
Large Pellegrino $8.26
Bottle Water $4.13
Medium Pellegrino $4.72
Apple Juice $4.72

Pastas
Large Pasta & Broccoli $29.73
Fresh broccoli florets, sauteed in a light roasted garlic and extra virgin olive oil sauce.
Large Pasta Campagnola Dinner $32.34
Pasta tossed with fresh broccoli rabe, crumbled sausage and cannellini beans, sauteed in a light roasted garlic and extra virgin olive oil
Large Pasta Calamari Marinara $34.11
Calamari sauteed or fried with marinara sauce.
Large Pasta Oreganate $33.52
Fresh shrimp and asparagus sauteed in a classic garlic and white wine scampi sauce finished with toasted bread crumbs.
Large Pasta Seafood $34.45
Fresh shrimp, mussels and baby clams sauteed in your choice of: garlic and extra origin olive oil or marinara sauce.
Large Pasta Melanzane $30.57
Fresh oven-roasted eggplant, sauteed in a unique Marsala infused plum tomato sauce, crowned with fresh ricotta cheese.
Large Pasta Aglio & Olio $29.09
Sauteed garlic and olive oil.
Large Pasta Casalinga $32.34
Fresh broccoli rabe and grilled chickens strips, sauteed in light roasted garlic and extra virgin olive oil sauce.
Large Pasta Marinara $24.08
Old world style garlic and herb plum tomato sauce.
Large Pasta & Meatballs $29.09
Traditional old-world Italian tomato sauce topped with our homemade meatballs.
Large Pasta Butter Sauce $24.08
Pasta with butter sauce.
Large Pasta Bolognese $32.34
Southern Italian style hearty ground veal meat sauce.
Large Pasta Primavera $24.67
A colorful melange of assorted fresh garden vegetables sauteed in a light tomato basil sauce, or garlic and extra virgin olive oil.
Large Pasta Fiorentina $32.93
Fresh chicken pieces, spinach and mozzarella tossed in a creamy pink sauce.
Large Pasta Alla Vodka $29.98
Creamy vodka pink sauce sauteed with diced imported prosciutto.
Large Pasta Alfredo $29.09
Classic Parmesan creamy cheese sauce.
Large Pasta Tomato Sauce $24.08
Our homemade tomato sauce.
Large Pasta Clam Sauce $33.27
Our authentic clam sauce includes shelled little neck clams & chopped baby clams, sauteed in a garlic and extra virgin olive oil sauce - or - marinara sauce.
Large Pasta Alla Mama Theresa $29.09
Alfredo cream sauce sauteed with green peas, onions and ham.
Large Pasta Gamberi $34.70
Calamari sauteed or fried with marinara sauce.Fresh broccoli florets sauteed with shrimp and cubed tomatoes.
Large Pasta Shrimp Marinara $34.70
Fresh shrimp sauteed in a traditional garlic and herb plum tomato sauce.
Large Pasta Toscana $34.70
Broccoli rabe, sauteed shrimp, white wine and pignoli nuts topped off with toasted bread crumbs.
Large Pasta Pesto $28.21
Fresh basil sauce, grated Parmesan cheese, pignoli nuts and Italian seasonings.
Large Pasta Spinach $26.48
Fresh spinach sauteed in a light tomato basil sauce or garlic and extra virgin olive oil.

Soups
Homemade Vegetable Minstrone $12.39
A hearty combination of fresh vegetables and ditalini pasta served in a tomato vegetable broth.
Lentil Soup $12.39
Lentils in a hearty homemade vegetable broth.
Pasta E Fagioli $12.39
A classic Italian favorite with small tubular shaped pasta, white and red cannellini beans with a touch of fresh crushed plum tomato, roasted garlic and extra virgin olive oil.
Chicken Noodle Soup $12.39
A hearty combination of fresh vegetables and ditalini pasta served in a tomato vegetable broth.
Cheese Tortellini Brodo $12.39
Cheese tortellini pasta served in a light chicken brodino.
Stracciatella Alla Romana $12.39
Roman-style spinach and egg drop soup.

Platters
Sausage Parmigiana Platter $31.68
Meatball Parmigiana Platter $31.68
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Platter $32.86
Shrimp Parmigiana Platter $35.22
Grilled Chicken Parmigiana Platter $32.86
Grill Chicken Broccoli Rabe Platter $34.04
Eggplant Parmigiana Platter $31.68
Chicken Alla Vodka Platter $30.20
Fried chicken cutlets topped with a creamy Alla Vodka pink sauce and homemade fresh mozzarella.
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Platter $34.04

Appetizers
Chicken Fingers $15.34
6 per order. Golden fried and served with a side of honey mustard or tomato sauce.
Garlic Bread $10.32
Freshly toasted Italian bread wedges basted with extra virgin olive oil and seasonings.
Zuppa Di Cozze $22.71
Fresh cultivated mussels, steamed and seasoned in your choice of a white wine garlic and herb sauce or in fresh garlic and crushed plum tomato brodino.
Mozzarella Sticks $15.34
Homemade pan-fried fresh mozzarella sticks served over marinara sauce.
Calamari Fritti $22.42
Serves 2. Golden fried calamari served with a side of marinara sauce.
Zucchini Fritti $18.29
Handcut, julienne style fresh zucchini, golden fried and nestled over marinara sauce.
Calamari Arrabbiata $25.07
Serves 2. Golden fried calamari tossed with flame-roasted peppers in a spicy arrabbiata plum tomato sauce.
Bar Pizzetta $17.40
Whole wheat ultra thin bar pizzetta topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Baked Clams Oreganate $19.76
Garlic Bread With Fresh Mozzarella $12.09
Freshly toasted Italian bread wedges basted with extra virgin olive oil, seasonings and melted mozzarella.
Stuffed Artichoke $15.04
Buffalo Chicken W $0.00

Entrees
Branzino Mediterraned $42.59
Oven-roasted Mediterranean sea bass filet, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil, lemon, and fresh herbs, served over sauteed fresh spinach.
Veal Piccata $41.41
Tender pan-seared veal scallopine sauteed with capers and artichoke hearts in white wine, lemon beurre blanc sauce.
Chicken Cardinali $39.64
Egg battered breast of chicken sauteed in butter & white wine with prosciutto, eggplant & sliced tomato with mozzarella cheese & a touch of marinara sauce
Chicken Marsala $37.58
Chicken scallopine simmered in a classic mushroom and marsala wine brown sauce.
Chicken Verdi $39.64
Egg battered breast of chicken sauteed in a white wine, lemon & butter sauce with fresh broccoli or spinach & melted mozzarella
Chicken Valdostana $39.64
Fresh breast of chicken stuffed with sauteed spinach and mozzarella breaded, baked and served in a mushroom and Marsala wine brown sauce.
Eggplant Rollatine $34.04
Fresh battered eggplant rolled with seasoned ricotta baked parmigiana style with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
Filet Of Sole Oreganata $42.59
Fresh filet of lemon sole topped with seasoned oreganata bread crumbs, broiled and served in a garlic and white wine ''scampi '' sauce.
Chicken Alla Marco $37.58
Baked breaded chicken cutlets or grilled chicken topped with a fresh diced plum tomato, red onion, and basil bruschetta salad.
Chicken Alla Vodka $34.04
Baked breaded chicken cutlets or grilled chicken topped with a fresh diced plum tomato, red onion, and basil bruschetta salad.
Chicken Francese $37.58
Fresh egg battered breast of chicken, sauteed in a classic, white wine, lemon and butter sauce.
Veal Francese $41.41
Fresh egg battered breast of veal, sauteed in a classic, white wine, lemon and butter sauce.
Veal Marsala $41.41
Veal scallopine simmered in a classic mushroom and Marsala wine brown sauce.
Shrimp Monachina $42.59
Fresh pan fried jumbo shrimp (five per order) simmered in a mushroom and Marsala brown sauce, layered with melted mozzarella.
Chicken Milanese $37.58
Salmon Piccata $42.59
Pan-seared Norwegian salmon sauteed with capers and artichoke hearts in a white wine, lemon beurre blanc sauce.
Veal Alla Marco $41.41
Baked, breaded veal topped with a fresh diced plum tomato, red onion & basil Bruschetta Salad
Grilled Salmon Entree $42.59
Fresh-grilled Norwegian salmon filet served over sauteed broccoli rabe and Tuscan white beans.
Veal Pizzaiola $41.41
Tender pan-seared veal scallopine topped with julienne bell peppers and onions sauteed in white wine, garlic and crushed plum tomato sauce.
Shrimp Francese $40.82
Fresh egg battered jumbo shrimp, sauteed in a classic, white wine, lemon and butter sauce.
Shrimp Oreganata $42.59
Fresh jumbo shrimp topped with Italian style seasoned bread crumbs, broiled in a classic garlic and white wine scampi sauce.
Chicken Pizzaiola $37.58
Tender pan-seared chicken scallopine topped with julienne bell peppers and onions, sauteed in white wine garlic and crushed plum tomato sauce.
Grilled Balsamic Chicken $37.58
Fresh breast of chicken marinated in balsamic vinegar, olive oil & spices
Chicken Primavera $37.58
Fresh breast of grilled chicken marinated in balsamic vinegar and imported seasonings, topped with a medley of sauteed fresh garden vegetables.
Chicken Piccata $37.58
Tender pan-seared breast of chicken sauteed with capers and artichoke hearts in a white wine, lemon beurre blanc sauce.
Filet Of Sole Francese $40.82
Fresh filet of lemon sole, sauteed in a classic, white wine, lemon and butter sauce.

Specialty Pies
Eggplant Delight Pie $38.94
Eggplant, mushrooms and tomatoes
Drunken Grandma $38.94
Thin crust pan pizza layered with fresh mozzarella and pecorino cheese spotted with our creamy vodka pink sauce.
Insalata Pie $38.94
Extra thin crust pan pizza layered with garlic and San Marzano crushed plum tomato sauce, topped with a chopped garden salad tossed in house Italian.
Di Casa Pie $45.72
Homemade mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomato and basil, virgin olive oil and balsamic glaze.
Margherita Pie $38.94
Old world style pan pizza topped with our traditional garlic and herb plum tomato sauce, Romano cheese, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.
Buffalo Chicken Pie $45.72
Our signature pizza. Crispy round pie topped with Louisiana style spicy chicken pieces, blue cheese sauce and mozzarella.
Baked Ziti Pie $38.94
Crispy round pie topped with traditional style baked ziti, mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Spinach & Broccoli Pie $38.94
Crispy round pie topped with spinach & broccoli, fresh garlic & mozzarella cheese.
White Pie $38.94
Crispy round pie topped with fresh mozzarella, aged Romano cheese and seasoned ricotta drizzled with fresh garlic oil.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie $45.71
Chicken Marsala Pie $45.72
A classic combination of fresh chicken and mushrooms sauteed in a Marsala wine brown sauce, topped with mozzarella, served over a crispy round crust.
Bakers Pie $29.50
Grandma Pie $29.50
Extra thin crust pan pizza layered with fresh mozzarella and spotted with garlic and San Marzano crushed plum tomato sauce and finished with a whisper of extra virgin olive oil.

Sauteed Vegetables
Escarole & Beans $12.98
Primavera Vegetables $12.39
Side Escarole $12.39
Broccoli Rabe $13.57
French Fries $7.67
Broccoli Spears $12.39
Sauteed Spinach $12.39
Fresh spinach sauteed with fresh garlic and extra virgin olive oil.
String Beans $12.39

Desserts
NY Cheese Cake $11.21
Biscotti $5.31
Cannoli $11.21
Italian Cheese Cake $11.21
Carrot Cake $8.85
Tiramisu $11.21
Molten Chocolate Lava Cake $11.21

Slices
Buffalo Chicken Slice $7.67
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice $7.67
Margherita Slice $6.49
Old world style pan pizza topped with our traditional garlic and herb plum tomato sauce, Romano cheese, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.
Spinach & Broccoli Slice $6.49
Crispy slice topped with spinach & broccoli, fresh garlic & mozzarella cheese.
Di Casa Slice $7.67
Homemade mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomato and basil, virgin olive oil and balsamic glaze.
White Slice $6.49
Crispy slice topped with fresh mozzarella, aged Romano cheese and seasoned ricotta drizzled with fresh garlic oil.
Neopolitan Slice $4.72
Mozzarella & tomato sauce
Sicilian Slice $4.72
Thick crust pan pizza with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Chicken Marsala Slice $7.67
A classic combination of fresh chicken and mushrooms sauteed in a Marsala wine brown sauce, topped with mozzarella, served over a crispy round crust.
Eggplant Delight Slice $6.49
Old world style pan pizza topped with our traditional garlic, and herb plum tomato sauce, Romano cheese, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.
Insalata Slice $6.49
Extra thin crust pan pizza layered with garlic and San Marzano crushed plum tomato sauce, topped with a chopped garden salad tossed in house Italian.
Bakers Slice $4.72
Grandma Slice $4.72

Lunch Pastas
Lunch Pasta Aglio & Olio $15.23
Sauteed garlic and olive oil.
Lunch Pasta Shrimp Marinara $24.08
Fresh shrimp sauteed in a traditional garlic and herb plum tomato sauce.
Lunch Pasta Butter Sauce $15.23
Pasta with butter sauce.
Lunch Pasta Fiorentina $22.90
Fresh chicken pieces, spinach and mozzarella tossed in a creamy pink sauce.
Lunch Pasta Campagnola $22.60
Pasta tossed with fresh broccoli rabe, crumbled sausage and cannellini beans, sauteed in a light roasted garlic and extra virgin olive oil
Lunch Pasta Primavera $20.88
A colorful melange of assorted fresh garden vegetables sauteed in a light tomato basil sauce, or garlic and extra virgin olive oil.
Lunch Pasta Calamari Marinara $22.90
Calamari sauteed or fried with marinara sauce.
Lunch Pasta Oreganate $23.19
Fresh shrimp and asparagus sauteed in a classic garlic and white wine scampi sauce finished with toasted bread crumbs.
Lunch Pasta Alfredo $19.95
Classic Parmesan creamy cheese sauce.
Lunch Pasta Vodka $20.83
Creamy vodka pink sauce sauteed with diced imported prosciutto.
Lunch Pasta Pesto $22.01
Fresh basil sauce, grated Parmesan cheese, pignoli nuts and Italian seasonings.
Lunch Pasta Clam Sauce $22.94
Our authentic clam sauce includes shelled little neck clams & chopped baby clams, sauteed in a garlic and extra virgin olive oil sauce - or - marinara sauce.
Lunch Pasta & Broccoli $20.58
Fresh broccoli florets, sauteed in a light roasted garlic and extra virgin olive oil sauce.
Lunch Pasta Toscana $24.08
Broccoli rabe, sauteed shrimp, white wine and pignoli nuts topped off with toasted bread crumbs.
Lunch Pasta Bolognese $22.60
Southern Italian style hearty ground veal meat sauce.
Lunch Pasta Casalinga $22.60
Fresh broccoli rabe and grilled chickens strips, sauteed in light roasted garlic and extra virgin olive oil sauce.
Lunch Pasta Marinara $15.23
Old world style garlic and herb plum tomato sauce.
Lunch Pasta Spinach $20.29
Fresh spinach sauteed in a light tomato basil sauce or garlic and extra virgin olive oil.
Lunch Pasta Seafood $23.83
Fresh shrimp, mussels and baby clams sauteed in your choice of: garlic and extra origin olive oil or marinara sauce.
Lunch Pasta Melanzane $21.42
Fresh oven-roasted eggplant, sauteed in a unique Marsala infused plum tomato sauce, crowned with fresh ricotta cheese.
Lunch Pasta & Meatballs $19.95
Traditional old-world Italian tomato sauce topped with our homemade meatballs.
Lunch Pasta Gamberi $24.08
Calamari sauteed or fried with marinara sauce.Fresh broccoli florets sauteed with shrimp and cubed tomatoes.
Lunch Pasta Alla Mama Theresa $19.95
Lunch PastaTomato Sauce $15.23
Our homemade tomato sauce.

Rolls
Rice Ball $7.67
Garlic Knots $4.72
Sausage Roll $10.62
Chicken Roll $10.62
Buffalo Chicken Roll $10.62
Eggplant Roll $10.03

Heros
Grilled Chicken And Broccoli Rabe Hero $19.76
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero $20.94
Grilled Chicken Parmigiana Hero $17.11
Sausage Parmigiana Hero $17.11
Sausage Pepper And Onion Hero $17.11
Fried Chicken Club Hero $17.11
Grilled Chicken Club Hero $17.11
Meatball Parmigiana Hero $17.11
Chicken Alla Vodka Hero $19.76
Fried chicken cutlets with a creamy Alla Vodka pink sauce and homemade fresh mozzarella.
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero $18.58
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $17.11
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero $19.76

Lunch Salads
Lunch Pecan Salad $14.75
Mesclun greens tossed with fresh arugula, honey roasted pecans, and Gorgonzola crumbles tossed with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette.
Lunch Caesar Salad $11.80
Romaine hearts topped with homemade focaccia croutons, shaved reggiano cheese, and Dijon Caesar dressing.
Lunch Garden Salad $10.62
Iceberg and romaine mix, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, vinegar peppers, green and black olives drizzled with our house Italian style dressing.
Lunch Mediterranean Salad $13.57
Romaine hearts, cherry tomatoes, diced cucumbers, green peppers, Kalamata olives, onions, sliced pepperoncini, crumbled feta cheese and red wine vinaigrette.

Mama Theresa's Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great coffee
Great dessert
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
College students
Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Planning
Usually a wait

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking
Parking

Mama Theresa's Photos

Mama Theresa's Location

Mama Theresa's

New York Nassau County Garden City Park Jericho Turnpike

2429 Jericho Tpke, Garden City Park, NY 11040, USA

Mama Theresa's Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 1238 user reviews.

piepaninisicilian sliceclamsvealbuffalo chicken pizzarice ballssalad dressinglinguinegarlic knots

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We went as a big group for a family dinner. The waiter was attentive and patient. We asked if we could split the bill, and after a lot of back and forth, we ended up not splitting the bill. There was a large menu with lots of options, including gluten free. Dessert looked good too but we didn’t try it.
August 03 · Dan Spencer
Long time staple for my family growing up and I still go now as an adult. Sicilian pizza and a buffalo slice can't go wrong but the star of the show is the garden salad with chicken and cheese. They also make it as a pizza if you are feeding a crowd, great spot.
June 01 · Michael Nathan
This place has to be our new favorite spot for pizza. We have tried some of the renowned restaurants in the city and the island. Move over L&B in Brooklyn there is a new top Sicilian square.
September 15 · Franklin Olmo
Above average pizzeria/restaurant.Superb experience.Chicken Parm Platter w/side Linguine white clam sauce.Spinach/Broccoli Rabe kinish type thing.We left there completely satisfied with the food & service. Will definitely be back.So we’ve been back twice since my 5 Star review above was posted. Disappointed each time. Now both times the White clam sauce is now just one notch above being plain hot water and the baby clams are now something unrecognizable. Won’t be back for awhile. And $$$$ !!!Mama Theresa’s in Garden City Park.
August 21 · Jimmy G.
It is very rare to give the food a lower rating than the service. This place has good food, sometimes better than other times. Consistency is the issue at Mama T's. Service was excellent and has been for many years. Melvin is a very good waiter, topnotch. The host, I think her name is Samantha, is very nice and helpful. She gave us options on where to sit and made us feel welcomed.
August 31 · phillip salli