Mike's Pasta Shoppe

- 95 Harrison St, Nutley, NJ 07110

For residents across Essex County and North Jersey, Mike's Pasta Shoppe in Nutley has firmly established itself as a beloved local institution, expertly blending the nostalgic charm of an old-school Italian deli with the high-quality standards of a modern, chef-driven restaurant. Located at 95 Harrison Street, Mike's is more than just a place to grab lunch; it’s a premier source for incredible Italian sandwiches, gourmet deli salads, and, most notably, truly fresh, homemade pasta and sauces ready to take home.

Co-founded by seasoned chefs Michael Carrino and Michael Cosenza, the shop’s mission is to put exceptional ingredients and culinary passion into every item. This commitment is evident in their critically acclaimed menu. The Signature Sandwiches are legendary in the Nutley area—large, inventive, and packed with flavor. Customer favorites include the immense Mike's Chicken Cutlet and the locally inspired The Nutley sandwich, which features breaded chicken cutlets topped with Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, and Roasted Peppers. For those who crave heat, the Spicy Grilled Cheese has garnered significant media attention for its decadent use of cheese and Calabrian pepper spread.

Beyond the incredible sandwiches, what truly defines Mike's Pasta Shoppe is its dedication to the foundation of Italian cooking: pasta. They offer fresh, daily-made pasta in both Long Cut and Short Cut varieties, available Per Lb. for retail sale, alongside quarts of their fantastic, house-made sauces, including classic Marinara Sauce, rich Pork Ragu Sauce, and creamy Vodka Sauce. This dual focus on both a traditional deli and a specialty pasta shop is what makes Mike's Pasta Shoppe a uniquely valuable resource for the New Jersey home cook and the lunchtime crowd alike.

The atmosphere, described as having an old deli feel, is casual and inviting. Customers browse cases of deli meats and refrigerated sections filled with take-home products and homemade salads, like the unique Truffle Mac Salad and classic Potato Salad. The experience at Mike's is not limited to counter service; they also offer private, fun, and delicious experiences, such as pasta making classes, which have been praised as a phenomenal, memorable, and fun way to celebrate special occasions while enjoying a multi-course meal.

Conveniently situated in the tight-knit Nutley community, Mike's Pasta Shoppe serves as a central hub for food lovers throughout Essex County.

The full street address for this local culinary landmark is: 95 Harrison St, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA.

Accessibility for New Jersey Users: The shop is located on Harrison Street in a residential part of Nutley, making it a quick and easy stop for locals and those commuting from nearby towns like Bloomfield, Clifton, and Belleville.

Parking and Transportation: The location is accessible with Free street parking available for patrons. This is a highly valued amenity for a quick grab-and-go spot in the area.

Inclusive Design: Mike's is committed to serving all members of the community, offering a Wheelchair accessible entrance.

Contact Information: Customers can easily reach the Shoppe for orders, questions about catering, or to inquire about reservations for private classes:

Phone: (973) 542-8822

Mobile Phone: +1 973-542-8822

Mike's Pasta Shoppe provides a robust and unique range of services designed to meet the needs of the modern North Jersey patron, combining the quick-service deli model with specialty retail and event catering.

• Signature Sandwich Service: Offering a diverse menu of ready-made, gourmet Italian and classic deli sandwiches, including hot options like Meatball Parmesan and cold cuts like Prosciutto Di Parma.
• Retail Fresh Pasta and Sauces: The core specialty of the shop, providing Fresh Pasta (long and short cuts) and house-made sauces (Vodka Sauce, Pork Ragu, etc.) for customers to cook at home.
• Gourmet Deli Extras: A selection of homemade salads (Truffle Mac Salad, Chickpea Salad, Potato Salad) and pre-made frozen platters (Chicken Parm Platter (Frozen), Eggplant Parm Platter (Frozen)) for convenient meals.
• Custom Deli Sandwiches: A Build Your Own option featuring a variety of high-quality meats and cheeses such as Prosciutto, Hot Sopressata, and House-Made Roast Beef.
• Full Catering Service: Providing comprehensive catering options for parties and events, from Sandwich Box #1 and Sandwich Box #2 to half trays of Chicken Parm, Eggplant Parm, and House Made Pasta And Sauce.
• Special Events and Classes: Accepting reservations for unique activities like private pasta making classes, which include a multi-course dinner following the instruction.
• Convenient Ordering: Focused on Delivery and Takeout service options to maximize convenience for the busy New Jersey customer.

Mike's Pasta Shoppe’s dedication to quality ingredients and inventive Italian-American cuisine makes it a standout choice among Nutley’s food establishments.

• Unrivaled Sandwich Quality: The sandwiches are the stuff of local legend, with customers consistently praising the generous size and quality of favorites like the Chicken Parmesan, the locally named The Nutley sandwich, and the popular Mike's Chicken Cutlet.
• Authentic Homemade Pasta & Sauces: The shop is known for its culinary backbone—daily made Fresh Pasta and authentic, slow-simmered sauces, allowing patrons to bring the taste of a chef's kitchen into their own home.
• Unique Customer Experiences: The offering of a private, hands-on pasta making class is a major highlight, celebrated by customers for its fun, educational, and delicious four-course dinner that follows.
• Gourmet Deli Sides: Their selection of high-quality deli salads, particularly the Truffle Mac Salad and Antipasto Mac, elevates the traditional deli experience.
• Culinary Reputation: Co-owned by a New Jersey Culinary Chef, the business operates with classical training and a passion for homemade goods, ensuring an inventive and high-quality take on classic Italian staples.
• Community Catering: An ideal choice for hosting parties, the catering options, including convenient Sandwich Boxes and trays of customer favorites like Eggplant Parm, are widely praised for their quality and convenience.

To place an order, book a catering service, or inquire about their signature pasta-making classes, please use the following contact details:

Address: 95 Harrison St, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA

Phone: (973) 542-8822

For New Jersey residents looking for an authentic, high-quality Italian food experience that goes beyond the standard pizzeria or deli, Mike's Pasta Shoppe is unequivocally worth choosing.

The primary reason to visit is the seamless combination of two stellar offerings: the Gourmet Sandwich and the Retail Pasta. If you need a quick, satisfying, and high-quality lunch, you cannot go wrong with their signature items. The Mike's Chicken Cutlet sandwich is widely considered one of the best in the area, a testament to their commitment to fresh, perfectly prepared ingredients. The inventive takes, like the Spicy Grilled Cheese or the Chicken & Nduja, show a modern culinary edge rarely seen in a local deli format.

However, the true value lies in the retail side. Being able to take home Fresh Pasta, Long Cut, Per Lb. and a quart of their homemade Vodka Sauce or Pork Ragu Sauce instantly elevates your weeknight dinner. It provides a taste of scratch-made, chef-quality Italian dining without the effort, making it an essential resource for busy families and dedicated food enthusiasts in the region.

Finally, for a memorable special occasion, the unique opportunity to participate in a pasta making class led by the chefs themselves offers an incredible value that combines entertainment, education, and a phenomenal four-course meal. Whether you are grabbing an Italian sandwich for lunch, stocking up on Meatballs In Marinara (Quart), or planning a catered event with their half trays of Chicken Parm, Mike's Pasta Shoppe delivers exceptional quality and flavor, making it a must-visit in Nutley, NJ.

Mike's Pasta Shoppe

95 Harrison St, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA