New Sunset Deli

- 4228 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232

Welcome to New Sunset Deli, a true neighborhood institution nestled in the vibrant community of Sunset Park, Brooklyn, NY. In a city where quick and quality food is a necessity, this deli stands out as a reliable and friendly destination. More than just a place to grab a quick bite, New Sunset Deli is a local favorite, known for building incredible sandwiches with generous portions of fresh, high-quality ingredients. For New Yorkers searching for an authentic, satisfying deli experience, look no Sunset Deli offers a diverse menu that caters to all tastes, from classic cold cuts to hot-pressed heroes and a unique selection of Mexican specialties.

Deli culture is integral to the New York lifestyle, and New Sunset Deli proudly carries on this tradition. They are often praised by local customers for their commitment to using fresh ingredients, ensuring every sandwich, whether it’s a simple turkey and Swiss or a loaded Italian combo, is a delicious and fulfilling meal. The staff is frequently mentioned in reviews for their friendly demeanor and close-knit, welcoming service, which makes every visit feel personal and efficient—perfect for a New Yorker on the go. Whether you're stopping by for a hearty breakfast sandwich to kickstart your day, a robust lunch hero, or a dinner to-go, New Sunset Deli is ready to serve the Sunset Park community with speed and a smile.

The extensive menu goes beyond your typical corner deli. While you can find all the traditional, quality Boar's Head deli products and combination sandwiches, New Sunset Deli surprises and delights patrons with a range of unique offerings. Patrons can enjoy options ranging from massive, flavor-packed combination heroes to a full selection of hot sandwiches like the Chicken Parmesan, Philly Cheesesteak, or a classic Tuna Melt. Furthermore, the deli offers a fantastic array of Mexican food, including tacos, quesadillas, and hearty Cemitas, a poblano-style sandwich that brings an exciting culinary twist to the standard deli fare. This fusion of classic American deli and authentic Mexican cuisine is a signature part of New Sunset Deli's appeal and is a major reason why local customers keep coming back.

New Sunset Deli is strategically positioned at a prime, accessible location in one of Brooklyn's most diverse neighborhoods. Accessibility for locals and commuters is straightforward, ensuring that a great meal is never far out of reach.

Location and Accessibility

New Sunset Deli is conveniently located at the heart of the Sunset Park area, making it a highly accessible stop for residents, workers, and visitors navigating Brooklyn. Its specific address is 4228 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA. Situated right on the bustling 5th Avenue, the deli is easily identifiable and a quick visit is encouraged and facilitated. The neighborhood is well-served by public transportation, meaning those traveling from other parts of Brooklyn or New York City can easily reach the location via nearby subway lines and local bus routes. For those making a quick stop, the deli caters to customers looking for a speedy and efficient transaction, perfect for fitting into a busy New York schedule. The location’s inherent accessibility reinforces the deli's role as a true community hub for fast, fresh food.

For those living or working in the immediate vicinity of Sunset Park, New Sunset Deli serves as the ultimate local lunch or dinner spot. The welcoming atmosphere and dependable quality of food mean it's a constant go-to for many. They embrace the quick-visit culture of the city, ensuring minimal wait times without sacrificing the quality or freshness of your order. No matter how you arrive, the deli’s central placement in this busy Brooklyn corridor ensures your path to a great sandwich is short and convenient.

Services Offered

New Sunset Deli offers a comprehensive suite of service options designed to fit the fast-paced, demanding lifestyle of New York residents. They make it easy and flexible for customers to enjoy their food, whether on-site or on the move.

• Delivery: Customers can have their favorite sandwiches, hot meals, and drinks delivered right to their homes or offices, ensuring maximum convenience for a quick lunch or dinner.
• Takeout: Ideal for locals who want to place an order and pick it up quickly for a meal at home or on the job.
• In-store Pickup: A fast option for customers who have ordered ahead to minimize waiting time.
• In-store Shopping: Patrons can browse the full menu and selection of cold cuts, drinks, and grocery items in a traditional deli setting.
• Dine-in: Options are available for those who wish to sit down and enjoy their meal inside the deli.
• Onsite Services: General services that cater to the customer's needs while at the location.
• Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments: Offering modern payment flexibility for all customers.
• Accepts SNAP/EBT: Ensuring accessibility for all members of the community to purchase eligible items.

Features / Highlights

New Sunset Deli distinguishes itself from the competition through several key features and highlights that New York locals particularly appreciate, emphasizing quality, variety, and an authentic deli experience.

• Extensive Sandwich Selection: The menu features a vast range of deli sandwiches, combination heroes (like the Ham Capicolla, Salami, Provolone, and Hot Capicola combo), and hot subs (such as Chicken Cutlet, Philly Cheesesteak, and Pastrami with Melted Cheese). They are particularly renowned for their generously packed sandwiches, ensuring you get excellent value for your money.
• Quality Boar's Head Products: A commitment to using premium meats and cheeses, with many menu items proudly featuring trusted Boar's Head products.
• Unique Mexican Offerings: Beyond the classic American deli fare, New Sunset Deli serves a surprising and delicious variety of Mexican specialties, including Tacos, Quesadillas, and hearty Cemitas (Mexican sandwiches). This diverse menu makes it a true dual-cuisine destination.
• Friendly and Close-Knit Staff: Customers consistently praise the warm, efficient, and welcoming service provided by the staff, who are noted for their close ties and personal attention to orders.
• Diverse Drink Selection: The deli stocks a wide variety of beverage options, including soft drinks, Pellegrino, Red Bulls, coffee, and unique options like basil seed drinks.
• Amenities: The establishment provides comfort amenities for customers, including Wi-Fi, a restroom, and a gender-neutral restroom.
• Payment Flexibility: The acceptance of multiple modern payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, NFC mobile payments, and SNAP/EBT.

Contact Information

For New Yorkers looking to place an order or inquire about the menu, New Sunset Deli can be reached at the following contact points:

Address: 4228 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

Phone: (718) 362-4608

Mobile Phone: +1 718-362-4608

What is Worth Choosing

For any New Yorker seeking an outstanding meal in Sunset Park, New Sunset Deli is a top-tier choice for several compelling reasons. The core of its appeal lies in the exceptional value and quality of its signature offerings. What truly sets this deli apart is their philosophy that a sandwich should be built, not just made, which translates to a generous amount of fresh ingredients, ensuring no one ever feels "skimped" on meat and cheese. This commitment is evident in the positive customer feedback, which frequently highlights the freshness and the substantial portions they receive.

When reviewing the menu, one of the best choices is a made-to-order deli sandwich featuring any of their Boar's Head products. A classic choice, like a simple turkey and Swiss sandwich, is elevated by the quality of the cold cuts and fresh bread. For those looking for a power-packed breakfast or lunch, the praised egg white sandwich with turkey, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, and chipotle mayo on whole wheat bread is a fantastic, flavorful option that reviewers rave about. It perfectly balances a healthy base with rich, satisfying fillings and sauce.

For the adventurous or those seeking a taste beyond the traditional deli, exploring the Mexican specialties is highly recommended. The Cemitas, a Mexican sandwich served on a special poblano bread with ingredients like quesillo, chipotle, and avocado, offers a distinctly New York-meets-Mexico experience you won't find at every corner deli. Similarly, the array of hot sandwiches, such as the Chicken Cutlet options or the Philli Cheesesteak, are perfect for a colder day or when you need a hot, comforting meal.

In summary, New Sunset Deli is worth choosing because it embodies the best of a Brooklyn local business: exceptional food quality, fast and friendly service, and a surprisingly diverse menu that successfully marries classic American deli staples with authentic Mexican cuisine. Whether you are grabbing a quick Roast Turkey, Swiss, and Bacon combo for lunch, ordering in a full Carne Asada Mexican sandwich, or simply enjoying the warm local environment, New Sunset Deli consistently delivers a high-quality experience that earns its reputation as a Sunset Park favorite.

New Sunset Deli

4228 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA