Ottos

- Freeport, NY 11520

Otto's, more formally known as Otto's Sea Grill, stands as a true institution on Long Island's famous Nautical Mile in Freeport, NY. This historic establishment is far more than just a typical Restaurant; it is a beloved piece of local history, having reportedly celebrated 95 years in business. It has survived major historical events like the Great Depression and multiple severe storms, demonstrating remarkable resilience and a deep connection to the New York community.

Otto's specializes heavily in Seafood, which is central to its identity as a Nautical Mile fixture. The menu is robust, offering everything from fresh raw bar items to hearty cooked platters. Options include classic starters like Otto's baked clams and Coconut Shrimp served with mango salsa, to main courses such as the Surf & Turf (boneless rib eye and lobster tail) and a dedicated Fried Fishermen Platter (featuring fried shrimp, clam strips, scallops, and the fish of the day). Patrons can also explore a range of specialty items like Lobster Mac & Cheese, various seafood pastas, and different preparations of fresh lobster and crab.

While seafood is the star, Otto's also ensures it caters to broader tastes by offering substantial Comfort food selections, including various Sandwiches and Burgers. Notable items include the Blackened Chicken Sandwich and the substantial Surf & Turf Burger topped with shrimp, crabmeat, and cheese sauce. The atmosphere is consistently described as Casual, providing a relaxed setting for New York locals and visitors alike to enjoy their meal, whether sitting inside or, often, on an accessible boardwalk deck overlooking the water.

The restaurant is a popular destination for both Lunch and Dinner, fitting easily into a day spent on the Nautical Mile. The menu also includes basic beverages, listed under Offerings as Coffee, rounding out the dining experience.

***

Otto's Sea Grill is perfectly situated on the iconic Nautical Mile at Freeport, NY 11520, USA, with a more specific operational address often cited as 271 Woodcleft Ave, Freeport NY 11520. Its location offers picturesque views, which greatly enhance the dining experience, particularly when seating is available on the deck.

The restaurant is well-regarded for prioritizing accessibility, which is important for the diverse New York crowd:

• Accessibility Features: Otto's provides key accommodations, including a Wheelchair accessible restroom and Wheelchair accessible seating. While the area involves sidewalks and a boardwalk deck, previous patrons have noted features like a curb cut in front of the main entrance to facilitate easier access to the venue.
• Parking: Convenient On-site parking is available to customers, which is a highly valued amenity in a busy area like the Nautical Mile. Street parking may also be available.
• Service Options: Customers have the option for traditional Dine-in service to fully enjoy the atmosphere, or quick Takeout for those preferring to enjoy their meal at home or elsewhere.

The Atmosphere is welcomingly Casual, which, combined with the accessible location and parking, makes Otto's a stress-free option for many families and groups on Long Island.

***

Otto's Sea Grill focuses on providing a classic, full-service dining experience, leveraging its picturesque location and reputation for hearty food.

• Full Dining Service: Offers traditional table service for both Lunch and Dinner.
• Takeout Availability: Provides a convenient Takeout option for customers in the area.
• Seafood Specialization: Features an extensive menu emphasizing fresh catches, raw bar items, and classic seafood preparations.
• Comfort Food Selection: Offers a diverse range of non-seafood options, including various burgers, chicken, and sandwiches.
• Family-Friendly Offerings: Includes a dedicated "Little Mates" menu with options like Kids Hamburger and Kids Chicken Tenders, making it Good for kids.
• Basic Beverages: Provides Coffee as part of its standard offerings.
• Full Amenities: Offers a well-maintained Restroom for patron use.

***

The highlights of Otto's Sea Grill revolve around its history, prime location, and deep menu of New York seafood classics.

• Historic Landmark: A multi-generational Long Island establishment, having celebrated over 95 years in business on the Nautical Mile.
• Prime Waterfront Location: Its location in Freeport offers a unique, attractive dining experience, especially for those seated on the outdoor deck overlooking the water.
• Extensive Seafood Menu: Specializes in every form of seafood, from the chilled Mermaid - Cold Seafood Tower to hot preparations like the King Neptune (hot tower), clam dishes, and various fish entrees.
• All-in-One Entrees: Features substantial platters like the Fried Fishermen Platter and the classic Surf & Turf, ensuring a filling and satisfying meal.
• Accessibility Commitment: A focus on accessibility, noted by both the Wheelchair accessible seating and restroom, and the general ease of access to the deck area.
• Comfort & Variety: Offers a reliable source of Comfort food and classic American fare, alongside its seafood specialization.
• Convenient Parking: The availability of On-site parking directly addresses a common inconvenience in busy tourist areas.

***

For New York customers interested in visiting or inquiring about Otto's Sea Grill, please note the following information. The primary address for the area is:

Address: Freeport, NY 11520, USA (Specific location: Nautical Mile, near 271 Woodcleft Ave)

Phone: (516) 321-0633 (Based on public records, this number is often associated with the business)

***

Choosing Otto's Sea Grill is about embracing a piece of Long Island's culinary and cultural history while enjoying a satisfying meal in a picturesque location. For New Yorkers, the most compelling reason to visit is the restaurant’s unparalleled longevity and status as a local landmark; nearly a century of operation is a testament to its enduring quality and community trust. It offers more than just a meal—it offers an authentic Nautical Mile experience.

The menu is designed to impress any seafood lover. The extensive selection of fresh and prepared seafood, including high-end options like Lobster, Oysters, and Steak & Seafood combinations, establishes Otto's as a premier destination for maritime dining on Long Island. For those visiting the coast, the Fried Fishermen Platter is a fantastic way to sample the kitchen's capabilities, while those seeking something different can enjoy a hearty burger or sandwich.

Despite one customer review noting that their fried seafood was "fried too hard," the fact that the restaurant has been consistently awarded and highly praised by the local community over decades strongly suggests that this feedback represents an exception rather than the norm. The business continually strives to provide a great experience, as highlighted in their own statements. The combination of its accessible facilities (Wheelchair accessible restroom and seating), convenient On-site parking, and its prime Casual waterfront setting makes Otto's Sea Grill an essential, high-value choice for both Lunch and Dinner on the Nautical Mile.

Ottos

Freeport, NY 11520, USA