Kitty O'Hara's: The Best Irish Pub, Food & Live Music in Baldwin, NY

Kitty O'Hara's Introduce

For New York residents, especially those calling Long Island home, finding that quintessential neighborhood spot—the one with truly great food, a phenomenal drink selection, and an atmosphere that genuinely feels like an extension of your living room—is always the goal. On Nassau County’s South Shore, Kitty O'Hara's in Baldwin, NY, is not just a bar; it’s a beloved local institution and community hub. It perfectly embodies the spirit of a traditional Irish pub while serving up a diverse, satisfying menu that goes far beyond typical bar fare.

Located conveniently on Merrick Road, Kitty O'Hara's has earned its reputation as a "Cheers-like" spot, where a welcoming staff makes both regulars and newcomers feel immediately at home. Patrons consistently praise the incredibly warm, loving, and inviting nature of the team, fostering an environment where a simple night out transforms into a wonderful, memorable experience. This friendly, family-oriented atmosphere, combined with high-quality food at incredibly reasonable prices, makes it an essential visit for anyone in the Baldwin and greater Long Island area.

The establishment is designed to be a true all-in-one destination. Whether you're stopping by for a casual solo dining experience, gathering groups of friends for a major sporting event, or seeking out the best live music and karaoke in the area, Kitty O'Hara's delivers a lively, yet casual and cozy, setting. The extensive menu, covering everything from classic pub grub to full entrees and even Breakfast Classics on the weekends, ensures that whatever your craving, this bar can satisfy it with speed and exceptional quality.

---

Location and Accessibility

Kitty O'Hara's is ideally situated in the Nassau County town of Baldwin, ensuring easy access for residents across the South Shore of Long Island. You can find this popular bar at:

845 Merrick Rd, Baldwin, NY 11510, USA

The location on Merrick Road is highly convenient, offering excellent road access and making it simple to find for both locals and those traveling from nearby towns like Rockville Centre, Oceanside, and Freeport. Recognizing the importance of ease of visit for all members of the New York community, the bar provides top-tier accessibility features:

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensuring easy entry for all guests.
Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Convenient, designated parking spaces.
Wheelchair Accessible Restroom: Commitment to comfort and convenience for every visitor.
Parking: Guests benefit from both a Free parking lot and Free street parking, removing any hassle associated with finding a spot.

---

Services Offered

The pub’s service model is built for modern convenience and traditional hospitality, offering a full range of options to enjoy the food and atmosphere:

Dine-in and Table Service: Enjoy the full, cozy experience with seating and dedicated table service in the casual, inviting atmosphere.
Outdoor Seating: Perfect for enjoying drinks and food on a pleasant evening in Long Island.
Takeout: Order your favorite Irish dishes, burgers, and wraps for quick and convenient pickup.
Delivery: Have the full menu, including their famous wings and house specials, brought right to your home.
Reservations Accepted: Ideal for Groups or planning a special evening, you can call ahead to secure a spot.
Flexible Payment: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

---

Features / Highlights

Kitty O'Hara's stands out in the crowded Long Island dining scene by blending authentic Irish tradition with modern American pub culture. The highlights offer a compelling mix of quality, variety, and entertainment:

Exceptional Beverage Program: The bar boasts a Great beer selection with an impressive 28 Draft Beers on Tap, catering to all tastes from local craft brews to imported favorites. Their cocktail and spirits selection is equally stellar, featuring Hard liquor and an impressive array of signature Cocktails, including warming classics like Irish Coffee and Bailey's Coffee.
Authentic Irish House Specials: The menu is anchored by traditional, hearty Irish favorites, ensuring a true taste of the Emerald Isle. Must-try dishes include the rich, savory Beef Stew, the comforting Shepherds Pie (chopped beef in a secret spice gravy topped with mashed potato), and the classic Irish Bangers And Mash. The Fish N Chips is also a popular choice, made with deep-fried, beer-battered cod.
Vibrant Entertainment Schedule: The pub is a dynamic entertainment venue, offering multiple nights of excitement, including Live music on weekends, engaging Karaoke nights with a friendly host, and dedicated Sports viewing (with ample TV screens for NFL games and other events). Check out their weekly schedule for special events like Thursday Trivia nights and Wing Wednesday specials.
Diverse Menu Beyond the Pub: While the Irish food is fantastic, the menu caters to everyone. The Burgers and Things section allows you to Design Your Own Burger or try the hefty Big Belly Buster Burger. The Whole Package section offers full entree dining, with items like Flat Iron Steak, Salmon Ala Pesto, and specialty chicken dishes like Gaelic Chicken (in an Irish Whiskey cream sauce) and Our Favorite Chicken (prosciutto and mozzarella in a sherry sauce).
Happy Hour & Food Specials: Guests can enjoy excellent value with dedicated Happy hour drinks and Happy hour food. The customer-favorite Kitty's Famous Wings (available in Buffalo, BBQ, or Teriyaki) and the full Teasers section, which includes Irish Nachos and the famous Spring Rolls (shredded corned beef or Buffalo chicken), make for perfect appetizer dining.
Family and Weekend Offerings: The pub offers a specific Kids Menu for families and features an expanded Breakfast Classics menu on the weekends, including Kitty's Steak & Eggs and the full Irish Breakfast, complete with dedicated brunch sides.

---

Contact Information

Kitty O'Hara's is ready to take your reservations or takeout orders. Here is how to reach them:

Address: 845 Merrick Rd, Baldwin, NY 11510, USA

Phone: (516) 208-5520

Mobile Phone: +1 516-208-5520

---

What is worth choosing

Choosing Kitty O'Hara's means opting for a unique Long Island experience that perfectly balances the warmth of an old-world pub with the energy of a modern American sports bar. For New Yorkers in the Nassau County area, this bar offers a compelling set of reasons to make it your new local haunt.

The primary draw, consistently highlighted in customer reviews, is the Incredible Hospitality. The staff is frequently described as "family-friendly," "warm, loving, and inviting," and the sentiment that "they make us feel like part of their family" speaks volumes. In a sprawling metropolitan area, finding a place with such genuine community spirit is rare, making Kitty O'Hara's stand out as the place where you can truly relax and feel known.

Furthermore, the Culinary Excellence and Value are top-tier for a bar environment. The food is described as "phenomenal" and "a delight," with prices that are "incredibly reasonable for the quality offered." You can enjoy premium cuts like the Flat Iron Steak or classic, satisfying dishes like the Chicken Parmigiana alongside the famous Irish fare. The sheer depth of the menu, from salads and wraps to full pasta entrees and specialty seafood like Sole Francais, means you can dine here multiple times a week without repetition, catering to everyone from the casual diner to the foodie.

Finally, the Total Entertainment Package seals the deal. It is one of the best locations on Long Island to enjoy a pint, a craft cocktail, and the night's entertainment. With 28 Beers on Tap and a regular rotation of Live Music and Karaoke, the ambiance is electric and engaging. Whether you’re cheering on the Jets or Giants, or just looking to enjoy a cocktail during a lively Happy Hour, Kitty O'Hara's provides the backdrop. The combination of excellent food, a massive drink list, year-round events, and a genuinely friendly team ensures that your money is well-spent and your time is always enjoyable, solidifying its place as a five-star favorite in Baldwin, NY.

Kitty O'Hara's Food & drink

Soups and Salads
French Onion Soup $7.00
House Salad $5.95
Caesar Salad
Chicken Caesar Salad $16.95
Comes with tender strips of grilled chicken.
Cajun Chicken Caesar Salad $16.95
Cajun Shrimp Caesar Salad $19.95
Angel Salad
Caesar salad topped with angel hair pasta.

Teasers
Kitty's Famous Wings $12.95
Buffalo (hot, medium, or mild) barbeque or teriyaki. Served with carrots, celery and blue cheese dressing.
Kitty's Boneless Wings $11.95
Served the same way as our famous wings without the hassle of the bones.
Kitty's Sampler $16.95
Wings, potato skins, chicken tenders and mozzarella sticks.
Paddy's Poppers $7.95
Deep fried breaded jalapeno poppers stuffed with cheddar cheese.
Irish Nachos $7.95
Your choice of Cajun or steak fries covered in melted cheddar and mozzarella cheeses topped with scallions and bacon bits.
Baked Clams $9.95
5 homemade tasty bites.
Annie's Spud Scraps $9.95
3 large potato skins covered in melted cheddar cheese and loaded with bacon bits and served with sour cream.
Mario's Cheese Sticks $9.95
Fried mozzarella sticks served with a warmed homemade marinara sauce.
Spring Rolls $9.95
Shredded corned beef with saurkraut and cheese or Buffalo chicken.
Zucchini $7.95
Panko crusted, sliced zucchini with chipotle sauce.
Dippin' Shrimp $12.95
Seasoned and breaded shrimp deep fried and served with a spicy homemade dippin' sauce.
Chicken Quesadilla $14.95
Grilled flour tortilla stuffed with cheese, chicken and grilled vegetables, served with guacamole and sour cream.
Garlic Bread $4.50
Garlic Bread With Cheese $5.50
Jackie's Tenders $11.95
4 pieces of tender, breaded chicken breast fried golden brown.

House Specials
Beef Stew $19.95
Chunks of tender steak, cooked with herbs and spices, carrots, peas, onions and celery in a rich brown gravy served over boiled potatoes.
Shepherds Pie $18.95
Chopped beef, peas, carrots, baked beans and small strips of bacon in our own secret spice gravy topped with mashed potato.
Irish Bangers And Mash $18.95
4 Galtee Irish Sausages served with mashed potato, bachelors beans and a side of gravy.
Fish N Chips $18.95
Deep fried, beer battered cod served with french fries.

The Whole Package
Our Favorite Chicken $19.95
Breast of chicken with prosciutto and mozzarella cheese in a light sherry sauce.
Flat Iron Steak $21.95
An 8 oz. beauty!!
Big Stuf Sole $19.95
Fresh sole filled with our homemade crabmeat stuffing and baked just right.
Sole Francais $19.95
Sole sauteed in white wine and lemon butter sauce.
Gaelic Chicken $19.95
Sauteed breast of chicken in a light Irish Whiskey cream sauce.
City Chicken $19.95
Breast of chicken topped with asparagus and mozzarella in a Medeira sauce.
Frenchie's Chicken $19.95
Breast of chicken sauteed in white wine and lemon butter sauce
Oriental Stir Fry $19.95
Chicken mixed with vegetables in a Teriyaki sauce.
Dublin Broil $19.95
A hearty helping of London Broil served in a Guinness gravy.
Salmon Ala Pesto $20.95
Broiled, marinated filet on a bed of rice with a chardonnay pesto sauce.
Salmon Knowledge $20.95
A 10 oz. filet marinated in seasoned herbs and served with a mushroom and Irish Whiskey sauce.

Burgers and Things
Design Your Own Burger $16.95
1/2 lb. of Black Angus beef with lettuce and tomato and a choice of any three toppings.
Big Belly Buster Burger $16.95
Fresh ground sirloin burger seasoned with spices, topped with mozzarella and cheddar cheeses and served with our special sauce.
Turkey Burger $14.95
Veggie Burger $14.95
Grilled Chicken Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. Served with onions, peppers and cheese.
Grilled Steak Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. Served with onions, peppers and cheese.
Grilled Combo Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. Served with onions, peppers and cheese.
Cajun Chicken Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. Served with lettuce, tomato and cheese.
Chicken Caesar Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. Served with with romaine lettuce and Caesar dressing.
BLT Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. Served with bacon, lettuce ad tomato with mayo.
Chicken Club Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. Served with lettuce, tomato, bacon and mayo.
Corned Beef Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. Served with hot pepper Jack cheese and mustard.
Paul's Wrap $15.95
That's a Wrap Folks. A club wrap made with chicken tenders.
Philly Cheese Steak $16.95
In steak strips sauteed with red and green peppers, onions, topped with melted mozzarella served on a hero.
Steak Tidbits $18.95
Tender strips of London Broil smothered in melted mozzarella cheese served on a toasted garlic hero and cut bite sized.
Chicken Tidbits $16.95
Grilled chicken smothered in melted mozzarella cheese, served on a toasted garlic hero and cut into finger bites.
Buffalo Chicken $16.95
A tender grilled chicken cutlet marinated in Louisiana Hot sauce with bleu cheese dressing and melted mozzarella cheese served on a garlic hero.
Chicken Parm Sandwich $16.95
Chicken breast topped with melted mozzarella and Parmesan served on a hero.
Our Favorite Chicken Sandwich $16.95
Chicken breast topped with prosciutto, melted mozzarella in a light sherry sauce with a side of coleslaw on a hero.
Reuben Sandwich $16.95
Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on toasted rye bread.
Skinny Chicken $15.95
Plain grilled chicken on a bun, with lettuce, tomato and onion.
Pirates Paradise $16.95
A deep fried, beer battered filet of cod served on a garlic hero with lettuce, tomato, melted cheddar and tartar sauce.
Mad Munchie Sandwich $16.95
Cajun breast of chicken, sliced tomato and melted mozzarella cheese with ranch dressing on a garlic hero.

Pasta
Penne Ala Vodka $15.95
Penne tossed in a pink vodka cream sauce with prosciutto. Add extras for an additiona charge.
Pesto Salmon $20.95
Salmon tossed in a light pesto sauce with broccoli served over linguini.
Chicken Carbonara $19.95
Chicken sauteed with bacon and peas in a creamy Alfredo sauce served over penne.
Heart Smart Penne $19.95
Fresh julienne vegetables tossed in a chicken stock sauce with grilled chicken.
Chicken Parmigiana $19.95
Chicken Parmigiana over linguini in a garlic tomato sauce.

Kids Menu
Kids Hamburger $8.95
Kids Cheeseburger $8.95
Kids Chicken Tenders $8.95
Kids Mozzarella Sticks $8.95
Kids Grilled Cheese Sandwich $8.95
Kids Small Bowl Of Pasta $8.95

Drinks
Coffee $2.50
Tea $2.50
Soda $2.50
Seltzer $2.50
Tonic Water $2.50
Juice $3.00
Milk $2.50
Chocolate Milk $2.50
Irish Coffee $8.00
Mexican Coffee $8.00
Bailey's Coffee $8.00

Desserts
Chocolate Cake $6.95
Chocolate Cake With Ice Cream $8.95
Cheesecake $6.95
Cheesecake With Ice Cream $8.95
Ice Cream $5.00

Breakfast Classics
Kitty's Steak & Eggs $19.95
Flat iron steak with 2 eggs any style.
Irish Breakfast $15.95
Galtee sausages and bacon, black and white pudding, Bachelor beans, and 2 eggs any style.
Baldwin Breakfast $11.95
2 eggs cooked your way with bacon or sausage.
Sunday Omelette $13.95
2 egg omelet with choice of ham, bacon or sausage, green or red peppers, onions, mushrooms and cheese.
All American Sandwich $11.95
Bacon and egg, your way, on choice of bread.
Eggstra Hot!! $11.95
2 eggs your way, topped with a spicy marinara sauce and jalapenos, served with bacon or sausage.
Honey Cakes $12.95
Honey infused pancakes served with bacon or sausage. Choice of original, blueberry or chocolate chip.
Cobb Salad $12.95
Bacon bits, hard boiled egg, avocado and crumbled bleu cheese over greens with your choice of dressing.

Brunch Sides
Home Fried Potatoes $4.00
Pancakes $4.00
Bacon $4.00
Sausage $4.00

Kitty O'Hara's Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Live music
Live performances
Sports

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Food
Food at bar
Happy hour drinks
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Wine

Dining options
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Kitty O'Hara's Photos

Kitty O'Hara's Location

Kitty O'Hara's

New York Nassau County Baldwin Merrick Road

845 Merrick Rd, Baldwin, NY 11510, USA

Kitty O'Hara's Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 289 user reviews.

atmospherepriceslive musicbandsgameslunchentertainmentfunTVfries

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Came for a few birthday drinks with a friend. Unfortunately they never showed up. So we decided to have dinner with a few drinks. Staffing very family-friendly. Enjoy karaoke 🎤 experience with pep., gentlemen whose hosting that.
August 24 · Priscilla Reese
We absolutely love Kitty O'Hara in Baldwin! Since opening our paint and sip, we've visited so many times, and each experience has been nothing short of wonderful. The staff is incredibly warm, loving, and inviting, making us feel like part of their family every time we walk in.The food is phenomenal—each dish is a delight, and the prices are incredibly reasonable for the quality offered. It's always a treat to dine here, and we genuinely appreciate how they make us feel welcome. If you're looking for a fantastic meal in a friendly environment, don't hesitate to visit Kitty O'Hara. We can’t recommend them enough! Five stars from us!
July 18 · Painting with a Twist Baldwin, NY
We went in on a Sunday night & were seated right away. This was such a nice place to get hood food and watch some football. Staff were friendly & attentive. The food was delicious. I will definitely be back.
November 16 · Dawn D
The food is amazing, the beers are cold and the bartender Lynn is amazing.Now the whole business is awesome, new owners are a blue collar restaurant that understands people that work in the pits of NYC, Lynn is an amazing bartender,
August 26 · Billy Hoyos
Great atmosphere and generous pours. We had the corned beef grilled cheese which was thoroughly enjoyed. You have to check this place out!
August 20 · Donald Rizzuto