Peter Pratt's Inn

- 673 Croton Heights Rd, Yorktown Heights, NY 10598

For those in the New York metropolitan area seeking a truly unique and elevated dining experience that marries deep American history with sophisticated modern cuisine, Peter Pratt's Inn stands as a premier destination. Located in the picturesque and historic setting of Yorktown Heights, Westchester County, this American restaurant is far more than just a place to eat; it is a meticulously preserved piece of the region's past, operating out of a Revolutionary War-era colonial homestead dating back to the 18th century.

The establishment is classified as an American restaurant, a Bar, and a sophisticated dining spot, specializing in fine cuisine and warm hospitality since 1965. Its storied past, which includes serving as part of the Carpenter-Davenport homestead and being situated near a Revolutionary War battle site, infuses the dining atmosphere with a cozy, historic, and undeniably romantic charm. The atmosphere is described as upscale, yet inviting, attracting both groups for celebrations and individuals seeking a special solo dining experience.

The current iteration of Peter Pratt's Inn—under the stewardship of the Pelinku Family, its seventh owners—retains this historic soul while embracing modern culinary excellence. Recent renovations have enhanced the interior and expanded the outdoor spaces, ensuring a joyful year-round experience for guests. The commitment here is to unpretentious fine dining, utilizing local specialty ingredients in a farm-to-table approach that delivers both classic American dishes and innovative, globally-inspired plates.

The core philosophy centers on a harmonious blend of rustic charm and culinary excellence, making it a beloved local gem and a destination for tourists and New Yorkers from beyond the immediate area. This is a restaurant where a great meal is complemented by a rich sense of place and history.

Location and Accessibility

Peter Pratt's Inn is located at 673 Croton Heights Rd, Yorktown Heights, NY 10598. The address places it in a tranquil, secluded part of Northern Westchester, surrounded by a rustic pine forest, which significantly contributes to its romantic and historic ambiance. While it offers a country hostel feel, it remains easily accessible for the greater New York region.

Accessibility for all guests is a clear priority. The inn is equipped with multiple features to ensure a comfortable visit:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot
• Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
• Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Parking is also very accommodating for diners traveling by car, which is typical for this part of New York state. Guests can utilize a free parking lot as well as free street parking, making arrival and departure hassle-free. The location, while steeped in history, is designed for the modern patron’s convenience.

Services Offered

Peter Pratt's Inn provides a full-service dining experience that highlights quality table service and a range of consumption options to suit various occasions. As an establishment that requires or recommends reservations, the focus is on a structured, high-quality guest experience.

• Dine-in: Full table service is provided across the cozy, historic, and newly renovated dining rooms and bar areas.
• Outdoor Seating: An expanded deck and a gorgeous sitting area surrounding a wood-burning fire-pit allow for enjoyable outdoor dining and events, particularly during the warmer months and shoulder seasons.
• Takeout: Meals can be prepared for off-site enjoyment.
• Delivery: The restaurant offers delivery service for those who prefer to enjoy their upscale cuisine at home.
• Table Service: All dining options feature attentive, professional service.
• Reservations Required/Recommended: Given the intimate, upscale, and popular nature of the Inn, reservations are accepted, and specifically recommended for dinner, to ensure seating availability.
• Private Events/Catering: The unique and beautiful setting, with its large lawn and historic structure, makes it a favored venue for private events, including weddings, with full in-house catering services available.

Features / Highlights

The features of Peter Pratt's Inn go beyond the menu to encompass a full sensorial experience that has earned it many accolades and positive reviews across the New York dining community. The Inn is distinguished by its atmosphere and a comprehensive beverage program.

• Historic and Romantic Atmosphere: The Inn's most compelling highlight is its ambiance—a blend of early American history and upscale, sophisticated charm. The colonial design, featuring thick, petrified chestnut beams resting on granite boulders, creates a cozy, historic, and romantic setting.
• Fireplace: A key atmospheric feature, the fireplace is specifically mentioned in customer reviews as highly desirable, adding significantly to the 'cozy' vibe, particularly on chilly New York evenings.
• Exceptional Beverage Program: The Inn is lauded for its bar offerings, including:
  • Great Cocktails: The bar serves specialty cocktails, such as the praised strawberry Moscow mule.
  • Great Wine List: An extensive selection of wines, along with a glass-enclosed wine tasting room, caters to oenophiles.
  • Happy Hour Drinks: Available for a more casual, social experience.
  • Full Bar: Offering Beer, Hard Liquor, and other Alcohol selections.
• Culinary Excellence and Variety: The menu features modern American fare with global influences, including starters like the inventive Peking Duck Quesadilla, Octopus Provencal, and East Coast Oysters. Entrées include premium cuts like Filet Mignon, the popular Lamb Lollipops, Hokkaido Scallops, and a comforting Saffron Seafood Risotto. The menu also offers a Scratchy Husband Pasta and Homemade Fettuccine.
• Noteworthy Desserts and Coffee: Recognized for having Great Dessert, including the Apple Strudel and Sticky Date Cake, as well as Great Coffee to conclude the meal.
• Serves Local Specialty: A commitment to local and seasonal ingredients reflects the upscale, modern farm-to-table ethos.
• Family Amenities: Despite the upscale atmosphere, the Inn remains welcoming to families, offering high chairs for younger guests.

Contact Information

To secure a reservation or inquire about private events, please use the following contact details:

• Address: 673 Croton Heights Rd, Yorktown Heights, NY 10598
• Phone (General/Reservations): (914) 962-4090
• Mobile Phone: +1 914-962-4090

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Peter Pratt's Inn is a decision to prioritize quality, atmosphere, and a truly memorable New York dining event. It offers a sophisticated retreat from the everyday, making it worth the drive for many in the tri-state area. The Inn excels in delivering a cohesive experience where the setting is as important as the meal.

The historic nature is its primary draw. Guests are not merely dining; they are experiencing a piece of Yorktown’s legacy. This blend of early American history and modern, sophisticated cuisine, as one customer noted, makes it a "Fabulous spot." The authentic colonial design, with its original structural beams, provides a depth of character unmatched by modern construction. The hope from a past patron that the cozy fireplace will be lit upon their return underscores the importance of this unique, warm atmosphere.

Culinary highlights include the premium cuts and refined seafood options, such as the perfectly executed Mussels and Steak Frite Bavette, often served with a luxurious peppercorn sauce. The attention to detail extends to the beverage menu, with the praise for the "great cocktails" and the highly-regarded wine list suggesting a well-curated selection designed to enhance the food. Offering small plates, happy hour drinks, and a full bar ensures the Inn is versatile enough for both a celebratory five-course dinner or a relaxing evening of cocktails and appetizers.

Furthermore, the availability of outdoor seating, surrounded by a 200-year-old pine forest, and a stunning wood-burning fire-pit area, ensures a magical setting, whether you’re celebrating an anniversary or simply enjoying a summer evening. The requirement for reservations for dinner signals the high demand and the structured approach to providing excellent table service.

For New Yorkers seeking an upscale, romantic, and history-rich American dining experience in Westchester County, Peter Pratt's Inn is an exceptional choice that delivers on its promise of amazing food, drinks, and a super cozy, unforgettable atmosphere.

Peter Pratt's Inn

673 Croton Heights Rd, Yorktown Heights, NY 10598, USA