Plaza Pastry Shop

- 39 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110

Introduction / Overview

Plaza Pastry Shop, nestled in the heart of Nutley, New Jersey, is more than just a traditional bakery; it is a community fixture offering a surprisingly diverse and engaging culinary experience. While rooted in the classic tradition of providing fresh breads, pastries, and custom-made cakes, Plaza Pastry Shop has broadened its appeal by incorporating a delicious and popular selection of Mexican food. This unique blend of sweet and savory makes it an unconventional yet highly convenient stop for locals looking for a quick visit, a comforting cup of coffee, or a full takeout meal.

The bakery aspect of the shop continues to draw in patrons with an array of familiar and beloved sweet treats, from large chocolate chip cookies to specialty items like Portuguese custard, which one customer noted even gained the approval of their Portuguese partner. They cater to special occasions with custom cakes and a daily assortment of pastries and donuts. However, what truly sets this Nutley establishment apart is its extensive selection of Mexican favorites, referred to as 'Antojitos' and more. Patrons can pivot from ordering a pastry to grabbing Tacos (like Chile Verde and Barbacoa), Tostadas, or a Torta—all available for easy takeout.

Despite a mixed bag of customer experiences—some praising the deliciousness of specific items like the peanut butter cup and fresh Portuguese custard, while others have noted issues with the freshness of certain day-old items—the fact that Plaza Pastry Shop has maintained a strong local presence suggests a core following built around their specialty items and convenient, dual-purpose menu. It’s a compelling local business that deserves a closer look for anyone in the Nutley area.

Location and Accessibility

The prime location of Plaza Pastry Shop makes it a highly accessible spot for daily errands and quick stops in Nutley. Its address places it directly within a key commercial corridor for local traffic.

The shop’s address is:

39 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA

Franklin Avenue is a main artery, ensuring ease of travel to and from the location. For patrons utilizing a vehicle, accessibility is well-provided for with a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot. Furthermore, the venue features a wheelchair accessible entrance, making it a welcoming and convenient choice for all members of the community. Its easy access and dedicated parking make it an ideal place for a quick visit to pick up a coffee, pastries, or a savory takeout meal.

Services Offered

Plaza Pastry Shop focuses primarily on providing quick and convenient food service, specializing in takeout for both its baked goods and its Mexican menu.

• Takeout Service: The primary service model is takeout, allowing customers to quickly grab their coffee, pastries, or prepared food to enjoy on the go.
• Baked Goods and Pastries: The core offering includes a daily selection of pastries, donuts, cookies (including large chocolate chip cookies), and specialty items like Portuguese custard.
• Custom Cake Orders: The bakery prepares cakes to order for all occasions, suggesting a capability for detailed custom work perfect for local celebrations, weddings, and birthdays.
• Mexican Food (Antojitos) Menu: A full range of savory Mexican options is available, including Nachos, Gorditas, Tacos, Tostadas (including Camaron and Rancheras), and Torta sandwiches, providing a complete lunch or dinner option.
• Beverage Service: Coffee is offered, making it a convenient stop for a quick morning or midday pick-me-up paired with a freshly baked treat.
• Quick Visit Planning: The service is geared toward efficiency, designed for patrons who need a high-quality product in a short amount of time.

Features / Highlights

Plaza Pastry Shop’s main draw is its unique duality and convenience, which provides distinct benefits for the Nutley community.

• The Sweet-and-Savory Fusion Menu: The co-existence of traditional, custom-ordered baked goods (cakes, peanut butter cups, custard) and a separate, substantial Mexican menu (Tacos, Torta, Nachos) is a unique and highly practical feature, catering to varied cravings in a single location.
• Accessible and Convenient Location: With wheelchair accessible entrance and parking, plus its location on Franklin Ave, the shop prioritizes ease of access for all community members, making quick stops effortless.
• Diverse Payment Options: The acceptance of credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments makes transactions quick and easy, eliminating the need for cash and speeding up the purchasing process.
• Local Custom Cake Specialist: The capability to create custom cakes for all occasions positions the shop as a valuable resource for local event planners and families celebrating milestones.
• Portuguese Custard and Specialty Treats: Highly specific items like the Portuguese custard have received high praise, suggesting that the bakery excels in certain traditional, specialty pastry offerings that stand out among local competition.

Contact Information

For inquiries about custom cake orders, to confirm daily pastry availability, or to place a takeout order for Mexican food, customers in the New Jersey area can contact Plaza Pastry Shop using the following details.

Address:

39 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA

Phone:

(973) 661-0011

Mobile Phone:

+1 973-661-0011

What is Worth Choosing

Plaza Pastry Shop is a worthwhile choice for New Jersey locals because it brilliantly solves the "sweet or savory" dilemma, making it the perfect one-stop-shop for multiple needs. For a truly unique experience, you can grab a quick lunch of delicious Barbacoa Tacos or a Rancheras Tostada, and then select a highly-praised Portuguese custard or a chocolate chip cookie for dessert, all in one efficient takeout trip.

Its specialization in custom cakes makes it an essential local resource for celebrations, while its accessible location and convenient payment methods ensure that the entire process, from ordering to pickup, is hassle-free. While it is always recommended for patrons to ask about the freshness of certain display items—a common practice at any local bakery—the potential reward is a taste of an approved Portuguese specialty or a delicious Mexican treat. For the Nutley area, Plaza Pastry Shop offers a diverse, convenient, and locally-owned spot that caters to a wide spectrum of tastes, from a simple cup of coffee and a pastry to a full, flavor-packed Mexican lunch.

Plaza Pastry Shop

39 Franklin Ave, Nutley, NJ 07110, USA