Pugsley Pizza

- 590 E 191st St, Bronx, NY 10458

Nestled on a small side street just a stone's throw from Fordham University, Pugsley Pizza is more than just a place to grab a slice—it's a bona fide Bronx institution. For decades, this family-owned pizzeria has been serving up authentic New York-style pizza and a sense of community that is hard to find anywhere else. The restaurant's history is deeply woven into the fabric of the neighborhood, and its welcoming, unpretentious vibe has made it a home away from home for generations of college students, locals, and even curious tourists. The atmosphere is a delightful mix of cozy and historic, with every wall covered in photos, quotes, and graffiti that tell the story of the place and its patrons.

What sets Pugsley Pizza apart is not just the food, but the unforgettable experience. Owners Sal and Pina Natale, who hail from Sicily, have created an environment that is both warm and lively. You might walk in to the sound of Sal playing his saxophone, or the clang of a gong announcing that a fresh pizza is ready. This unique and charming atmosphere, combined with a genuine passion for hospitality, makes every visit feel special. Pugsley Pizza is a place that feels real and keeps it real—a stark contrast to the sometimes gruff stereotype of New York City. The friendly staff and the owners' personal touch are consistently praised by visitors, who often return years later for a taste of their favorite pizza and a chance to catch up with the Natales.

While the ambiance is a major draw, the food is the heart of the operation. Pugsley Pizza’s menu is a comprehensive celebration of classic Italian and American comfort food. From a wide variety of pizzas and calzones to an extensive selection of heroes and pasta dishes, there is something for every palate. The kitchen prides itself on using high-quality ingredients, and the dedication to their craft is evident in every bite. Whether you're a college student looking for a late-night bite, a local family gathering for dinner, or a group of friends celebrating an occasion, Pugsley Pizza provides a casual and memorable setting for a great meal. The restaurant is a true Bronx gem, a place where food, family, and tradition come together to create an experience that is nothing short of magical.

Pugsley Pizza is a bit of a hidden gem, located at 590 E 191st St, Bronx, NY 10458, USA. It's situated on a small street that runs parallel to Fordham Road, tucked away behind a BP gas station. This somewhat secluded location adds to its "secret hangout" charm and requires a bit of careful searching for first-time visitors, but its proximity to Fordham University makes it an ideal spot for students and faculty. The restaurant is easily reachable for those on foot and offers convenient parking options. Customers can take advantage of both free parking in a nearby lot and free street parking, which is a significant bonus in a busy urban area like the Bronx. The establishment is also accommodating for guests with children, offering high chairs, and even welcomes dogs in its outdoor seating area.

Pugsley Pizza provides a variety of service options to meet the needs of its diverse clientele, from quick meals to large-scale events.

• Dine-in: Guests can enjoy the historic and cozy atmosphere by dining in. The restaurant provides seating for lunch and dinner, making it a great place for both solo diners and groups.
• Takeout & Curbside Pickup: For those on the go, Pugsley Pizza offers quick and easy takeout and curbside pickup options. You can place your order by phone or online for a fast and convenient experience.
• Delivery & No-Contact Delivery: The restaurant provides delivery services, including a no-contact option, ensuring you can enjoy their delicious food from the comfort of your home.
• Catering: Pugsley Pizza offers extensive catering services for various events and gatherings. Their catering menu includes large portions of pasta, salads, and more, making them a great choice for parties.
• Accepts Reservations: While not a formal dining establishment, Pugsley Pizza can accommodate reservations, which is particularly useful for planning group dinners.

Pugsley Pizza's unique character is defined by several standout features that go beyond a typical pizzeria.

• Unbeatable Atmosphere: The restaurant is famous for its lively and artistic environment. The walls are covered in colorful graffiti and memorabilia, and the ambiance is enhanced by the owner, Sal Natale, who is known to play his saxophone for guests.
• Iconic Gong: A much-loved tradition at Pugsley Pizza is the playing of a gong before every pizza is brought out to a table, adding a celebratory and engaging element to the dining experience.
• Local and Family-Owned: As a family-run business since 1984, the owners, Sal and Pina Natale, are often on-site, creating a personal and welcoming connection with every customer. This strong community bond has made the restaurant a historic local favorite.
• Late-Night Food: With operating hours that often extend into the early morning, Pugsley Pizza is a perfect spot for late-night cravings, especially for college students.
• Generous Portions: The menu offers large portions, from the hearty heroes to the sizable calzones and pizzas, ensuring that every customer leaves feeling satisfied.
• Diverse Offerings: Beyond the signature pizza, the menu is extensive, including a wide array of appetizers, pasta dishes, heroes, and even vegetarian and vegan options like the Vegan Cheese Pizza and Veggie Pizza.

For inquiries, to place an order, or to learn more about their services, you can reach Pugsley Pizza using the contact information below:

Address: 590 E 191st St, Bronx, NY 10458, USA

Phone: (718) 365-0327

While every item on the menu is crafted with care, there are a few standouts that define the Pugsley Pizza experience. Of course, the pizza is the main attraction, with popular choices including the classic Cheese Pizza and the well-loved Pepperoni Pizza. The restaurant is particularly known for its great flavors and thick, doughy crust that has just enough crisp to avoid being floppy. The Penne Vodka Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza are also highly recommended for those looking for a unique and flavorful twist on a classic pie.

Beyond the pizza, the menu is filled with other must-try items. The Chicken Roll is often cited as a hidden gem and a "real star of the show," offering a delicious combination of chicken, mozzarella, and seasonings wrapped in a pizza dough. The heroes, served on homemade bread, are also a fantastic choice, with the Meatball Parm Hero and Eggplant Parm Hero being customer favorites. For a savory start, the Garlic Knots, available supreme or deluxe, are a perfect snack. And for a sweet finish, the Cannoli and Nutella Love Pie are indulgent and delicious choices that showcase the restaurant’s versatility. The menu's variety and the consistent quality of the food make it a place where you can try something new on every visit and always be satisfied.

Pugsley Pizza

590 E 191st St, Bronx, NY 10458, USA