Schreiber's Homestyle Bakery

- 424 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230

Welcome to the heart of Midwood, Brooklyn, where the aroma of freshly baked goods fills the air and tradition meets modern culinary convenience. Schreiber's Homestyle Bakery, located on Avenue M, is more than just a local shop; it's a neighborhood institution renowned for its authentic, high-quality, and completely kosher offerings. For New Yorkers in search of that perfect, comforting taste of home-style baking—whether it's for the weekly Shabbos table, a special holiday, or just a Tuesday morning treat—Schreiber’s is the trusted name. This bakery expertly blends old-world recipes with a diverse, expanded menu that caters to every craving, solidifying its reputation as one of the area’s premier bakeries.

Schreiber's has long been a favorite in the Brooklyn community, celebrated for turning simple ingredients into "food to write home about." While they started with tempting, yet simple, staples like challah, cookies, and cakes, the bakery has successfully modernized and expanded its simple, high-quality approach to a full-service experience. From the legendary home-style baked goods to a surprising variety of fresh, savory options, Schreiber's Homestyle Bakery provides a complete dining solution for a quick visit, a hearty breakfast, or a meal on the go.

For customers, the commitment to freshness and quality is immediately apparent. Reviewers often praise the friendly staff and the extensive selection, noting that while the prices reflect the high quality, the delicious food makes it worthwhile. The atmosphere is inviting, making every visit a pleasant experience, even if you’re just stopping by for a quick coffee and pastry before heading out to tackle the busy New York day.

The Midwood location is strategically placed to serve a busy, diverse Brooklyn populace. This branch of Schreiber's Homestyle Bakery is found at:

424 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230, USA

Being in the bustling Midwood neighborhood, accessibility is a key consideration for local patrons. The bakery makes a conscious effort to accommodate all members of the community by featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance. For those driving, the location offers the convenience of free street parking nearby, a notable benefit in this part of Brooklyn. The quick visit dining option is perfect for New Yorkers rushing to work or simply looking for a fast, delicious meal or snack. The bakery also facilitates easy transactions by accepting a wide range of payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, NFC mobile payments, and SNAP/EBT.

Schreiber's Homestyle Bakery has evolved to offer a comprehensive range of services, ensuring a convenient experience for every New York customer, whether you're grabbing a bite on your way or planning a meal at home.

• Delivery Service: Easily enjoy their famous baked goods and full menu from the comfort of your home or office.
• Takeout: Ideal for a quick stop to pick up a morning coffee, breakfast sandwich, or a box of pastries.
• Breakfast Dining Options: The menu offers various items perfect for starting your day right, including omelettes, egg sandwiches, and more.
• Specialty Coffee and Beverages: A full selection of hot and cold drinks, including fresh coffee, to pair with your baked treat or breakfast.
• Sandwich and Salad Bar: A well-stocked counter offering fresh, made-to-order sandwiches and a variety of salads, including tuna, egg salad, and specialized salmon options.
• Accommodations for Dietary Needs: The bakery caters to specific dietary restrictions by offering a wide range of kosher products and sugar-free items.
• Catering and Large Orders: Providing baked goods and prepared foods highly sought-after for Shabbos (Sabbath) and Yom Tov (Jewish holidays), including a variety of challah sizes and styles.
• Acceptance of Various Payments: Accepting credit cards, debit cards, NFC mobile payments, and SNAP/EBT for customer convenience.

What truly sets Schreiber’s Homestyle Bakery apart in the competitive New York food scene is its commitment to quality, tradition, and an expansive, fresh menu. These highlights make it a beloved local establishment and a must-visit for anyone in the area.

• Premier Kosher Certification: The bakery is renowned for its authentic kosher baked goods, offering peace of mind and catering to a significant portion of the Brooklyn community. The vast majority of its products are crafted to meet these strict dietary requirements.
• The "Heimish" Challah Selection: A signature feature, Schreiber's is famous for its diverse, fluffy, and delicious challah. This includes Heimishe Challah (made with a mix of egg and water for extra fluffiness), Egg Challah, Water Challah (also known as "the dip challah" for its crunchy exterior and soft interior), Whole Wheat Challah, and specialty rolls.
• Customer-Favorite Baked Goods: Beyond challah, the bakery is highly praised for its classic Jewish pastries, especially the Rugelach, often cited as a top-selling item, and rich, creamy Cheese Danish. Other beloved treats include Black & White Cookies, chocolate chip cookies, and the heavy, oozing Kokosh Cake.
• Expanded Menu Beyond Baking: Schreiber’s is not limited to sweet treats. The full menu offers savory options like various breakfast sandwiches (Omelette, Sunny Side Up Egg), Lox and Cream Cheese sandwiches, freshly made tuna and egg salad wraps, and several types of gourmet salads like Teriyaki Salmon Salad and a Four Scoops Salad.
• Accessibility and Convenience: The provision of a wheelchair accessible entrance and the allowance for free street parking make the bakery an inclusive and convenient stop. The availability of multiple service options—Delivery, Takeout, and Quick Visit planning—perfectly suits the fast pace of life in New York City.

For New York residents looking to place an order, inquire about catering, or confirm daily specials, here is the direct contact information for the Avenue M location:

Address: 424 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230, USA

Phone: (718) 758-9122

When visiting a bakery with such a rich and extensive menu, a first-time visitor or even a long-time patron might wonder what truly stands out. Based on customer sentiment and the bakery's reputation, several items are absolute must-tries for anyone in New York.

The Rugelach is arguably the sweet star of the show. Sold by the pound, this flaky, rolled pastry, often filled with chocolate, cinnamon, or raspberry, has a legendary status among local food enthusiasts. It is often cited in online platforms as one of the bakery's most liked items, consistently earning a perfect rating from reviewers. The care taken in preparing the pastry is evident in every bite.

For the savory breakfast seeker, the Breakfast Special 1 or a simple Omelette Sandwich with a coffee is highly recommended and an excellent value. Customers consistently praise the freshness and quality of the breakfast offerings, proving that Schreiber's is a competent morning stop, not just a pastry shop. The fresh, hot coffee complements the meal perfectly, as one customer noted, making the morning commute worthwhile.

Lastly, the Challah remains the foundation of Schreiber's renown. Whether you choose the Heimishe Challah for its exceptional fluffiness or the Water Challah for its pretzel-like crunch and soft interior, picking up a loaf on a Thursday or Friday for the weekend is a cherished tradition for many Brooklyn families. The wide variety of options, including whole wheat and spelt versions, ensures there’s a perfect loaf for everyone. For those planning a bigger meal, the full prepared salads, such as the Teriyaki Salmon Salad, offer a fresh, healthy, and high-quality lunch option. In short, whether you seek a sweet, traditional pastry, a fresh and filling breakfast, or the best challah in Brooklyn, Schreiber's Homestyle Bakery is the place New Yorkers turn to.

Schreiber's Homestyle Bakery

424 Avenue M, Brooklyn, NY 11230, USA