Cello's Pizzeria

- 36 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003

In a city filled with endless pizza options, Cello's Pizzeria stands out as a true gem on the legendary St Marks Place. This is more than just a place to grab a slice; it’s a quintessential New York experience. With its casual, simple, and honest approach, Cello’s focuses on what truly matters: a perfectly crafted pizza. The vibe is retro and laid-back, offering a much-needed sense of authenticity and simplicity in a world that can often feel over-the-top. For New Yorkers and tourists alike, it’s a spot where you can count on a no-fuss, high-quality meal that perfectly captures the essence of classic New York pizza.

While some may be skeptical of a reheated slice, Cello’s has perfected the art of serving up a delicious piece of pizza with fast and efficient service. The true test of a great pizza place is its ability to consistently deliver a satisfying product, and Cello's has earned its reputation by doing just that. One visitor, whose brother-in-law lives in the neighborhood, described it as a place that "really was" one of the best. The rave reviews for their perfectly cooked crust, with its "great texture and flavor," are a testament to the dedication of the small team working behind the counter. Cello's is proof that you don't need a massive operation to produce something truly amazing.

The retro feel of the space, with just a few people working, creates a genuine and intimate atmosphere. It’s the kind of place that becomes a great recommendation among friends and family, a spot that doesn't disappoint. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, Cello's offers a moment of simple joy in the midst of the city's chaos. It's a place where you can quickly grab a bite, sit down and enjoy a delicious meal, and feel like you've stumbled upon a cherished neighborhood secret.

Cello's Pizzeria is perfectly located at 36 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003. This address places it directly in the heart of the East Village's most famous street. St Marks Place is a cultural landmark known for its vibrant energy, diverse crowds, and bustling nightlife. Cello's Pizzeria's location makes it a highly convenient spot to visit whether you're starting your night out, taking a break from shopping, or simply craving a classic New York slice.

The pizzeria is exceptionally accessible via public transportation, which is a major benefit for anyone in the city. The 6 train at Astor Place is just a short walk away, providing an easy connection from Midtown and other parts of Manhattan. The N, Q, R, and W trains at 8th Street - NYU are also nearby, and the L train at 1st Avenue offers a direct link from Brooklyn. This makes Cello's a great spot for both locals and tourists to visit without the need for a car. For those who do drive, there is both free and paid street parking available in the vicinity. The restaurant's outdoor seating area is a popular feature, and as a bonus, it is pet-friendly, so you can bring your dog along to relax outside while you enjoy your meal.

Cello's Pizzeria offers a straightforward but delicious menu that focuses on what they do best: pizza.

• Pizza Pies: The core of the menu is their selection of large pizzas. They offer a "Regular Pie" and a "Tomato Pie" for those who love the classics. For more adventurous eaters, they have a "Vodka Pie," which is a favorite among locals, a "Margherita Pie," and a popular "Pepperoni Pie." They also offer a "Broccoli Rabe + Sausage Pie" and a "Tomato Burrata Pie."

• Specialty Slices: While the menu lists full pies, the restaurant is known for its slices, which offer a quick and convenient way to try a variety of their flavors. The "Vodka slice" is particularly praised for being "so tasty."

• Sandwiches: In addition to pizza, Cello's offers "The Mancini Sandwich" and a side of "Meatballs." These options provide a great alternative for those who want something different.

• Beverages: The drink menu includes a variety of sodas and waters, including classic "Mexican Coke" and "Mexican Sprite," as well as "High Noon Seltzer" and other beer and wine options, making it a complete dining destination.

• Dine-In, Takeout, and Delivery: Cello's offers multiple service options to fit your needs, whether you want to enjoy your meal in their casual dining area, grab a pie to go, or have it delivered right to your door.

Cello's Pizzeria's reputation is built on a few key features that make it a standout among the many pizza joints in New York.

• Authentic New York Pizza: The focus on simple, high-quality ingredients and a perfectly cooked crust gives Cello's a truly authentic New York pizza feel. The crust is consistently praised for its flavor and texture.

• Casual and Retro Atmosphere: The small, no-frills setting creates a comfortable and genuine vibe. It’s the kind of place that feels like a classic slice shop, and its retro style adds to its charm.

• Fast and Efficient Service: For a quick bite in a busy neighborhood, Cello's is a top choice. The service is fast, and they are quick to get your order ready.

• Delicious Signature Pies: The "Vodka Pie" is a particular highlight and a must-try for new visitors. Its unique flavor makes it a standout.

• Great Location: Situated on the famous St Marks Place, Cello's is in the center of one of the city's most vibrant and exciting neighborhoods, making it a perfect spot to drop by.

• Outdoor and Dog-Friendly Seating: The availability of outdoor seating and the fact that dogs are allowed outside make it a great option for a sunny day with your furry friend.

To get in touch with Cello's Pizzeria or to place an order, you can use the following information.

Address: 36 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003, USA

Phone: (917) 475-1637

For a true New Yorker, choosing Cello's Pizzeria is an easy decision. It’s a place that delivers on its promises of "simple and honest" pizza, which is a welcome change in a city where everything can feel overly complicated. What makes it truly worth choosing is its ability to nail the basics: a great crust, flavorful sauce, and quality toppings. The vodka pie is a standout, and a must-try for anyone visiting, but even the regular pie is a testament to their dedication to classic flavors.

Beyond the food, the vibe is perfect for the neighborhood. It's a casual, unpretentious spot where you can grab a quick and satisfying meal, whether you're a student, a local, or a tourist. The fast service and convenience of takeout and delivery make it an incredibly practical choice, while the small, cozy dine-in space offers a charming place to sit down. While some may prefer their pizza fresh from the oven, the fact that their reheated slices are still so beloved by many speaks volumes about the quality of the product. Cello's Pizzeria is a go-to spot for a reason; it's a place that consistently provides a taste of classic New York pizza that is both delicious and reliable.

Cello's Pizzeria

36 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003, USA