Siena

- 533 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11223

In a borough celebrated for its dynamic and diverse food scene, Siena stands out as Brooklyn's premier destination for elevated Kosher Italian dining. Located on the bustling Kings Highway, Siena isn't just another restaurant; it’s a refined culinary experience that seamlessly blends the authentic, comforting flavors of Italy with the requirements of kashrut. This dual focus allows Siena to fill a unique and highly demanded niche, providing an upscale, classy, and trendy atmosphere often reminiscent of high-end Manhattan establishments, making it a truly exceptional spot for New York patrons.

Siena is more than a casual Italian eatery; it's a fine Kosher Italian restaurant that commits to bringing the best of Italy to the Gravesend section of Brooklyn. The restaurant is known for its elegant design and intimate seating, with many patrons noting the comfortable booth arrangements that lend themselves perfectly to a date night or a family gathering. The ambiance is consistently described as "wonderful" and "classy," offering a sophisticated backdrop to an exquisite meal. The clientele often includes a trendy crowd, drawn in by the combination of chic decor, great location, and high-quality food.

The culinary offerings are the true heart of Siena. The kitchen specializes in house-made favorites, which include house-made pasta, artisanal pizzas, and meticulously prepared fish dishes. The menu demonstrates a modern, elevated take on Italian-Kosher cuisine, with dishes that are both classic and refined. Customer favorites like the Rigatoni Alla Vodka and the Eggplant Rollatini showcase the kitchen’s ability to execute comforting classics flawlessly. A notable highlight consistently praised by frequent guests is the Tuna Au Poivre, which is described as "out of this world" and a dish that "never disappoints," even when ordered well done, a testament to the kitchen's skill in handling premium ingredients.

For New Yorkers who observe kosher dietary laws, Siena offers an invaluable dining option. It provides a level of quality and atmosphere usually reserved for non-kosher fine dining establishments, all while operating under strict supervision to ensure the highest standards of kashrut. The commitment to a kosher/dairy/Italian premise, but executed with an elevated and modern approach, is what makes Siena a crown jewel in Brooklyn's dining landscape. Furthermore, the availability of vegetarian options, healthy choices, and thoughtful menu additions like the Cauliflower Pizza demonstrates a commitment to accommodating diverse dietary needs.

While the restaurant can get extremely busy, particularly on Thursday and Saturday evenings—suggesting that reservations are highly recommended—patrons who visit during less crowded times, such as lunch, often report "very attentive" service, underscoring the staff's dedication when they are not overwhelmed by peak volume. The cost, when sharing main courses family-style, is considered by many to be a pretty good value for the quality and experience provided, especially given the upscale nature of the restaurant and the quality of the ingredients. The dessert selection, featuring items like the Siena Cheesecake and the popular Brownie Sundae, also garners high praise, proving that the culinary excellence extends to the final course.

Siena’s presence on Kings Highway cements its status as a vital local restaurant, a place where people plan to celebrate special occasions or simply enjoy a top-tier Italian meal. The extensive kosher wine and premium liquor offerings complement the menu, allowing for complete pairings that enhance the dining experience. The involvement of experienced professionals, including the design of the menu in collaboration with an award-winning Chef (Mark Strausman, formerly of Campagna and Coco Pazzo, as noted in public information), further elevates the credibility and culinary ambition of Siena, making it a sophisticated choice for any Brooklyn food enthusiast.

Location and Accessibility

Siena is strategically located at 533 Kings Hwy in Brooklyn, NY 11223. This address places it in the vibrant and easily accessible Gravesend neighborhood, a major commercial area of Brooklyn. Kings Highway is well-known for its density of shops and dining options, making Siena a visible and convenient spot.

For New Yorkers utilizing public transport, the restaurant is easily accessible via the subway system and local bus routes that frequently run along Kings Highway. Parking can sometimes be found on the street, consistent with typical New York City commercial areas. Crucially, the establishment is designed with accessibility in mind, offering a wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, ensuring a welcoming experience for all guests.

Services Offered

• Dine-in Service: Enjoy the full experience in the cozy, romantic, and upscale atmosphere with table service.
• Takeout Service: Orders can be placed for easy pickup, perfect for enjoying high-quality Italian food at home.
• Reservations: Reservations are accepted and highly recommended, especially for dinner and weekend nights, to secure a table.
• Private Events & Catering: Siena is available for events and offers a catering service, with its elegant design making it a perfect setting for special occasions.
• Bar Service: A Bar onsite with an extensive selection of alcohol, beer, cocktails, hard liquor, and a great wine list.
• Dietary Accommodations: Provides numerous vegetarian options and healthy options within the Kosher framework.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: Serving both lunch and dinner with distinct menus, plus an excellent dessert selection.

Features / Highlights

• Kosher Italian Excellence: Recognized as a fine Kosher Italian restaurant, specializing in dairy cuisine under strict kashrut supervision, a rare feature for this level of quality.
• Signature Dish: The Tuna Au Poivre with a red wine reduction, garlic mashed potato, and sautéed spinach is a highly recommended customer favorite.
• House-Made Specialties: Commitment to authenticity shown through house-made pasta and artisanal pizza, featuring dough praised by customers.
• Elegant and Trendy Atmosphere: The decor and vibe are upscale and trendy, providing an intimate setting often compared to high-end Manhattan restaurants.
• Dessert Program: Offers Great dessert options, including the Siena Cheesecake and Brownie Sundae.
• Expert Consultation: Cuisine developed in collaboration with award-winning Chef Mark Strausman.
• Extensive Beverage Program: Known for Great cocktails and a Great wine list, complementing the upscale Italian menu.

Contact Information

Address: 533 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

Phone: (718) 676-5024

Mobile Phone: +1 718-676-5024

What is worth choosing

For any New Yorker seeking an exceptional Italian dining experience that doesn't compromise on dietary adherence or style, Siena is the unequivocal choice. You should choose Siena when you require a restaurant that masterfully blends the rich traditions of Italian cooking with the highest standards of Kosher supervision. This is not a casual pizzeria; it is a destination for elevated, modern Italian food.

What makes Siena worth choosing is its demonstrated commitment to quality ingredients and culinary sophistication. The fact that dishes like Rigatoni Alla Vodka and Spinach-Ricotta Gnocchi are crafted in-house, coupled with artisanal pizzas featuring impressive dough, speaks to a serious kitchen. Furthermore, the seafood and fish selections are standout features, particularly the highly-praised Tuna Au Poivre, confirming that this dairy establishment executes mains with finesse.

Beyond the food, you choose Siena for the atmosphere. The classy, romantic, and trendy vibe makes it ideal for a special date night or a celebratory group dinner. It offers an experience that is hard to replicate in the area—high-end dining, excellent cocktails, great desserts, and all within the Kosher dairy framework. By making a reservation, particularly during the busy evening hours, you secure your seat at one of Brooklyn's most sought-after and sophisticated Italian establishments, ensuring a meal that is consistently "amazing" and a true highlight of Kings Highway dining.

Siena

533 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA