Sinapi's Pizzeria

- 1583 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509

For New Yorkers seeking that classic, comforting taste of authentic Italian-American cuisine, particularly outstanding pizza, **Sinapi's Pizzeria** in Brewster is a name that frequently comes up. Nestled conveniently on NY-22, this local establishment is much more than your average pizza joint—it’s a full-service Italian restaurant committed to serving up delicious family recipes, generously portioned and offered at competitive prices. As a favorite among the local Putnam County community, Sinapi’s Pizzeria embodies the traditional New York pizzeria experience while extending its menu to cover an extensive range of Italian specialties.

The core of Sinapi's appeal lies in its dedication to serving a local specialty: quality pizza. From the simple, yet essential, **Cheese Pizza** ($20.95) and the thick-crust **Sicilian Cheese Pizza** ($25.00), to an array of creative and hearty **Sinapi's Special Pizza** varieties, there is a perfect pie for every taste. However, the menu's depth is what truly sets it apart. Diners can explore traditional Italian favorites, including various baked macaroni dishes, extensive poultry and veal selections, and a full line of seafood classics.

The atmosphere at Sinapi’s is consistently described as **casual**, welcoming **Groups** and **Locals** alike. It's an ideal spot for a quick and satisfying meal, as it is highlighted for its **Fast service**. It is crucial for prospective diners to recognize that, as with many local businesses, the quality of customer interaction can sometimes vary. While the food consistently receives praise, some non-regular customers have reported feeling less welcomed than the established "townies." Therefore, while the food quality is a major draw, a patient and friendly approach is recommended, particularly for first-time visitors.

---

Sinapi's Pizzeria is strategically located at **1583 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509, USA**. This address places it directly on a major thoroughfare in the Brewster area, making it highly accessible for both local residents in Putnam County and those traveling through the New York region.

The establishment is designed with customer convenience in mind, particularly regarding accessibility and parking:

• **Parking Ease:** Customers benefit from multiple parking options, including a **Free parking lot**, **Free street parking**, and convenient **On-site parking**. This significantly enhances the experience, especially during busy meal times.
• **Accessibility Features:** The restaurant is fully equipped for accessibility, offering a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**.

Its location off Route 22 makes it a highly practical stop for a meal when heading to or from other parts of the New York State area.

---

Sinapi's Pizzeria provides a comprehensive suite of dining and takeaway services designed to accommodate the busy schedules and preferences of the New York consumer:

• **Dine-in Service:** Offers comfortable **seating** and **table service** in a **casual** setting, perfect for **Lunch**, **Dinner**, or enjoying **Dessert**.
• **Delivery Options:** The restaurant offers both standard **Delivery** and the highly convenient **No-contact delivery**, allowing patrons to enjoy their favorite Italian dishes without leaving home.
• **Takeout:** Quick and easy **Takeout** service is available for those who prefer to pick up their order on the go.
• **Group Accommodations:** The venue **Accepts reservations** and is a popular spot for **Groups**, making it a great choice for family dinners or small gatherings.
• **Family-Friendly:** Sinapi's is recognized as **Good for kids**, and provides **High chairs** and a dedicated **Kids' menu**, making it a welcoming environment for families.
• **Beverage Offerings:** The menu includes a selection of alcoholic beverages, specifically **Alcohol**, **Beer**, and **Wine**, alongside non-alcoholic options like **Coffee** and **Soda** ($2.05).
• **Payment Convenience:** Customers can pay using modern, flexible options including **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**.

---

Sinapi's Pizzeria has become a local favorite in the New York region due to a number of key offerings and operational features that enhance the customer experience:

• **Extensive Specialty Pizza Menu:** The restaurant is highlighted for **Serves local specialty** with its wide range of unique pies. Signature options include the hearty **Lasagna Pizza** ($25.60), the flavorful **Chicken Marsala Pizza** ($26.35), the specialty **Old Country Pizza** ($25.00) and the classic **Margherita Pizza** ($26.00).
• **Traditional Italian Classics:** The menu extends far beyond pizza to include authentic Italian specialties such as **Veal Sorrentino** ($27.70), **Eggplant Rollatini** ($23.65), and a variety of baked macaroni dishes like **Lasagna** ($22.90) and **Stuffed Shells** ($21.55).
• **Hot & Cold Heroes:** A staple of New York dining, the menu features a robust selection of Heroes, including the popular **Sausage Parmigiana Hero** ($12.85), **Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero** ($14.80), and simple classics like the **BLT Hero** ($12.10).
• **Fast Service:** A significant highlight is the **Fast service**, which makes it a highly efficient option for a **Quick bite** or managing a busy lunch schedule.
• **Fresh Seafood Options:** Diners can enjoy several seafood classics, such as **Shrimp Oreganata** ($26.95), **Mussels Marinara** ($25.60), and the spicy **Shrimp Fra Diavolo** ($26.95).
• **Family Feast Value:** The **Family Feast** option ($44.95) provides excellent value for groups and family dinners, combining a selection of their best dishes for a satisfying meal.
• **Desserts:** Finish your meal with traditional Italian desserts, including **Cannoli** ($7.45) and **Tiramisu** ($7.45).
• **Dietary Accommodations:** The menu includes dedicated **Vegetarian options** and classic **Comfort food** items.

---

To place an order for delivery or takeout, make a reservation, or inquire about catering services, please use the contact details provided below:

Address: 1583 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

Phone: (845) 278-9632

Sinapi's Pizzeria is committed to providing quality meals, and for large groups or during weekend dinner rush, utilizing their reservation line is recommended to secure seating and ensure the best experience.

---

For New York-based users, choosing Sinapi's Pizzeria is choosing a truly authentic, one-stop Italian-American dining experience that is a beloved fixture of the Brewster community. It’s an ideal choice whether you’re passing through the area or are a regular local customer.

• **A Masterclass in Specialty Pizza:** This is the place to go beyond the basic slice. The selection of specialty pies—such as the unique **Michael Angelo Pizza** (Eggplant, basil, ricotta, fresh tomato, $25.60) and the customer-praised **Old Country Pizza** (Tomatoes, mushrooms, olives, fresh garlic, olive oil, $25.00)—offers a depth of flavor and creativity not found at every pizzeria. The ability to customize your pizza experience is a major asset.
• **Full Italian Menu Diversity:** Unlike purely pizza-focused locations, Sinapi's provides a sprawling menu of Italian restaurant classics. This makes it perfect for a meal where one person wants a slice of pizza while another is craving a full **Veal Piccata** ($26.95), **Shrimp Scampi** ($26.95), or the creamy **Penne With Vodka Sauce** ($21.55). The range of options accommodates every palate and occasion.
• **Exceptional Value for Families:** The generous portions and the availability of the **Family Feast** ($44.95) solidify Sinapi's as an affordable and satisfying choice for family meals. They cater directly to the needs of groups and local families seeking a high-quality meal without excessive cost.
• **Commitment to Convenience:** With options for **Dine-in**, **Takeout**, **Delivery**, and **No-contact delivery**, the restaurant maximizes convenience. The highlight of **Fast service** further ensures that whether you are eating in or taking out, your meal will be ready quickly.
• **Appetizers and Sides:** Start your meal with a substantial appetizer like the **Large Fried Calamari** ($18.85) or **Baked Clams Oreganata** ($15.55), or try one of their classic soups such as **Pasta Fagioli Soup** ($8.80) to complete the traditional dining experience.

Sinapi's Pizzeria offers a consistent quality of food that has earned it a loyal following in the New York area. Despite any potential for service variability during high-traffic times, the exceptional, comprehensive menu and dedication to classic Italian flavors make it a highly recommended destination.

Sinapi's Pizzeria

1583 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509, USA