Stack Creamery

- 465 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307

Stack Creamery has quickly become a beloved destination for dessert lovers in the New Jersey area, and their Jersey City location, situated in the bustling Heights neighborhood, stands out as a must-visit spot. Specializing in highly customizable, artisanal ice cream sandwiches, this family-owned shop takes a classic treat and elevates it to a whole new level. When you step inside, you're immediately greeted by the comforting aroma of freshly baked cookies, which are made from scratch daily using their own family recipe. This commitment to homemade quality is what sets Stack Creamery apart and makes it a cherished local favorite.

The core philosophy of Stack Creamery is all about customization and premium ingredients. They don't just offer pre-made options; they invite you to become the architect of your perfect dessert. By pairing their warm, soft cookies or brownies with locally made, super-premium ice cream, and topping it all off with a variety of sweet and crunchy additions, they ensure every visit delivers a unique and satisfying experience. Whether you’re looking for a quick scoop, a memorable group dessert, or a midnight treat delivered right to your door, Stack Creamery offers a playful and indulgent way to satisfy your sweet tooth in the heart of Jersey City.

Stack Creamery's Jersey City outpost is perfectly positioned to serve the community, located at 465 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307, USA. This address places the ice cream shop directly on Central Avenue, a vibrant and well-supported commercial corridor in the Jersey City Heights neighborhood. For local users, this spot is easily accessible and a convenient stop during a stroll through the area.

Accessibility is a key feature of the location. Stack Creamery's establishment includes a wheelchair-accessible entrance, making it easy for all members of the community to enjoy their delicious treats. Inside, the atmosphere is described as casual and trendy, with pastel-colored decor that matches the playful nature of their menu—a great spot for a quick visit, a fun family outing, or even a solo dining experience. Customers have noted that there is often seating available both inside the store and outside to comfortably enjoy their stacks.

For those planning their dessert runs, it is always a good idea to check the most current operating hours, but the Jersey City location has typically welcomed guests late into the evening. While hours can vary, common operating times are:

• Monday - Thursday: Often open until 10:00 PM
• Friday - Saturday: Often open until 12:00 AM (Midnight)
• Sunday: Often open until 10:00 PM

Stack Creamery is more than just an ice cream shop; it's a full-service dessert experience. Their wide array of offerings caters to individual cravings, family gatherings, and special events.

• Custom Ice Cream Sandwiches: This is the signature offering, allowing you to choose your cookie, ice cream flavor, and toppings to create your perfect "Stack."
• Ice Cream Cookie Pies: A full-sized, ready-to-share dessert, such as the Cookie Monster Pie or the Classic Vanilla Chip Pie, ideal for parties or a decadent night in. These large desserts are consistently priced at $35.99.
• Build Your Own Milkshake: For those who prefer their treats blended, they offer custom milkshakes starting at $10.99.
• Pre-Packed Ice Cream Sandwiches: Ready-to-eat options in a 4-pack for convenience, with favorites like the Classic OG 4-Pack and Birthday Cake 4 Pack available for $35.99 each.
• Individual Cookies and Brownies: Freshly baked cookies are available for $2.75 and brownies for $3.00.
• Ice Cream Pints: Take your favorite flavors home in a pint. Standard pints are priced at $10.99, including popular flavors like Cookie Monster, Mint Chip, and Mudslide.
• Vegan Options: Catering to various dietary needs, they offer Vegan Vanilla Bean Pint and Vegan PB&J Pint for $12.99.
• Delivery and Takeout: For maximum convenience, the shop offers delivery and in-store pickup options, utilizing popular platforms like Grubhub, Uber Eats, and DoorDash, in addition to takeout and onsite services.
• Bundle & Save Packages: Perfect for groups, these bundles include a mix of cookies, ice cream pints, and toppings. The Ice Cream & Cookie Bundle for 2-4 people is $35.99, while the 6-8 person size is $65.50.
• Beverages: Coffee and other drinks are available to accompany your dessert.

The success and popularity of Stack Creamery in Jersey City are driven by several key features that resonate with the local dessert scene.

• Homemade Cookies and Brownies: All cookies and brownies are baked fresh daily in-house using original, quality recipes. Customers often comment that they can smell the fresh baking as soon as they walk in.
• Premium, Locally-Sourced Ice Cream: The ice cream is super-premium, handcrafted, and sourced from a local small-batch producer, ensuring a creamy, high-quality base for all their creations.
• High Degree of Customization: With dozens of combinations possible, patrons can mix and match their favorite fresh-baked cookies (like Death by Chocolate or Birthday Cake) with ice cream flavors (like Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel or Cake Batter) and various toppings for a truly personalized dessert. The Build Your Own Ice Cream Sandwich starts at approximately $10.50 (note: delivery prices may vary slightly).
• Diverse Menu Options: Beyond the famous sandwiches, the menu includes pints, cookie pies, milkshakes, and customizable cookie boxes (6 cookies for $15.00 or a Dozen for $24.99), providing a treat for every occasion and craving.
• Welcoming Atmosphere: The shop boasts a casual and trendy environment that is very kid-friendly and popular for a quick visit or solo dining.
• Vegan and Dietary-Conscious Selections: The inclusion of vegan options, such as the Vegan Vanilla Bean and Vegan PB&J pints (both $12.99), demonstrates an effort to serve a wider range of customers in the diverse Jersey City community.
• Family-Owned Local Business: Stack Creamery is owned and operated by three siblings, bringing a genuine, passionate, and community-focused feel to their service.

For residents and visitors looking to enjoy a custom ice cream sandwich, here is the essential contact and location information for the Jersey City Heights spot:

• Address: 465 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307, USA
• Phone Number: (201) 984-0261 (Also contactable via mobile at +1 201-984-0261)
• Payment Options: They accept Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for your convenience.

While everything on the menu at Stack Creamery is crafted with care, the main attraction and what makes the shop truly unique is the Custom Ice Cream Sandwich. This highly personalized dessert allows you to match your favorite fresh-baked cookie flavor with a premium ice cream scoop, creating a handheld masterpiece. Customers rave about this ability to fully customize their treat, which guarantees a flavor combination they will love every time.

For those who prefer a decadent grab-and-go option, the Ice Cream Cookie Pies are an excellent choice for sharing. The Cookie Monster Pie ($35.99), in particular, is a crowd-pleaser, featuring Cookies n Cream ice cream, Cookie Monster ice cream, Oreo and cookie crumbles, and a drizzle of vanilla and chocolate. The pints are also a fantastic value, offering unique, creamy flavors like Cookie Monster Pint and Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel Pint at $10.99 for a perfect take-home treat.

Stack Creamery in Jersey City Heights is a testament to quality, customization, and local community support. It’s an essential stop for anyone in North Jersey seeking a premium, handmade dessert experience. The focus on fresh ingredients, especially the warm, homemade cookies, ensures that this ice cream shop is more than just a place for a cold treat—it’s a destination for a moment of pure, decadent enjoyment. Whether you’re a local stopping by for a familiar favorite or a newcomer looking for the best ice cream sandwich in New Jersey, Stack Creamery delivers a satisfying and delightful experience every time.

Stack Creamery

465 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307, USA