Stuff A Bagel: Your Premier Farmingdale Destination for Fresh Bagels, Breakfast, and Lunch

Stuff A Bagel Introduce

Stuff A Bagel in Farmingdale, NY, is more than just a typical bagel shop; it’s a local institution and a comprehensive breakfast and lunch destination. Serving the community with a wide-ranging menu that goes far beyond the classic bagel with cream cheese, this establishment caters to every appetite, whether you're rushing to work or settling in for a hearty weekend meal. Known for their dedication to variety and fresh ingredients, Stuff A Bagel has established itself as a must-visit spot for locals and visitors in the greater New York region looking for a taste of authentic Long Island breakfast and deli fare.

The core of the offering remains their freshly baked bagels and "Flagel's" (a flattened bagel), available plain or toasted and paired with an extensive list of spreads. From the essential plain or flavored cream cheeses to indulgent options like Lox Spread and Lox Strips with Cream Cheese, the menu honors the timeless New York bagel tradition. Beyond the basics, the shop truly lives up to its name, 'Stuff A Bagel,' by offering over-stuffed sandwiches, omelette platters, and a full-service deli and grill.

The shop's commitment to providing an all-encompassing menu ensures that patrons can find their perfect meal at any time of day, transitioning seamlessly from a morning caffeine fix and breakfast to a substantial lunch. Their menu versatility makes it an excellent choice for individuals, families, and businesses in the area, all while maintaining a friendly and professional service approach.

Location and Accessibility

Stuff A Bagel is conveniently situated at 234 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735. This central location places it right in the heart of the Farmingdale area, making it easily accessible for local residents and those commuting through the Long Island region. The shop is designed with customer convenience in mind, offering multiple accessibility features to ensure a welcoming experience for all members of the community.

For visitors, the location provides several amenities that simplify the dining experience:

Accessibility: The premises feature a wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a wheelchair accessible restroom, ensuring comfort for patrons with mobility needs.
Parking: Customers benefit from both a free parking lot and the availability of free street parking, taking the hassle out of a quick stop or a relaxed dine-in visit.
Planning: The environment is geared for a quick visit, perfect for grabbing your morning bagel and coffee on the way to work, or for a fast and satisfying lunch break.

Services Offered

Stuff A Bagel prides itself on offering flexible service options to meet the needs of a busy New York clientele. The array of services ensures you can enjoy their food wherever you are:

Delivery for those who can't step out of the office or home.
In-store pickup for quick retrieval of pre-ordered meals.
In-store shopping, allowing you to browse the fresh selections.
Takeout service for an easy grab-and-go option.
Dine-in seating to enjoy your breakfast or lunch in a comfortable setting.
Full-service breakfast and lunch menus.
Catering services for business meetings, parties, and large events (offering platters of mini bagels, cold cuts, salads, and more).

Features / Highlights

The extensive menu and thoughtful offerings are what truly make Stuff A Bagel a standout local eatery. The highlights showcase the breadth and depth of their culinary focus, moving well beyond the typical expectations of a bagel shop:

Bagel & Spread Variety: Featuring classic bagels and 'Flagel's, alongside a selection of house-made cream cheese flavors, Lox Spread, and Bagel with Lox Strips.
Comprehensive Breakfast Menu: Offering everything from simple Bagel with Butter, to elaborate Breakfast Sandwiches (like the Bacon, 2 Jumbo Eggs, and Cheese favorite), and the massive Hungry Man on a hero.
Gourmet Omelette Platters: The menu includes specialty omelette platters such as the Rodeo, Traditional Western, California, Taste of Italy, and Healthnut, all served with a bagel or bread and home fries.
Full-Scale Grill & Griddle: Featuring popular items like Pancakes (including varieties with eggs and meat), Thick French Toast, Belgian Waffles, and the decadent Signature Croissant Stuffed French Toast.
Diverse Lunch Offerings: A full deli menu including Over Stuffed Sandwiches (like the California Turkey or Godfather Hero), a variety of Pressed Panini (such as the Italian Chicken Panino and The Daler Panino), and Wraps (including the Apple Chicken Walnut Wrap and Chipotle Chicken Wrap).
Health-Conscious Choices: Options like the Fresh Homemade Oatmeal, 3 Egg Whites and Turkey sandwiches, and a full Chopped Salad Bar cater to lighter or specialized diets.
Beverage Selection: A wide range of hot and iced coffee, as well as specialty espresso drinks like the Vanilla Latte, Mocha Latte, Caramel Macchiato, and Cappuccino.
Fresh Baked Goods: A tempting assortment of sweet treats including Muffins, Danish, Cinnamon Rolls, Croissants, Crumb Cake, Brownies, and the famous Black And White Cookie.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about catering, or find out more about the daily specials, you can reach Stuff A Bagel using the following information:

Address: 234 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Phone: (516) 420-4287

Mobile Phone: +1 516-420-4287

What is Worth Choosing

For residents and workers in New York's Long Island area, Stuff A Bagel is an excellent choice for a few key reasons. Firstly, the depth of their menu is unparalleled for a business categorized as a bagel shop. You can satisfy a craving for a traditional New York-style bagel breakfast, a hearty diner-style omelette platter, a sophisticated pressed panini, or a customized salad, all in one place. The sheer variety—from classic cold cut sandwiches like Roast Beef to specialty melts like The Old American and unique wraps—ensures that repeat visits never grow stale.

Secondly, the convenience factor is a major draw. With easy accessibility, ample parking, and multiple service options including dine-in, takeout, and delivery, the shop makes it simple to incorporate their fresh food into a busy daily routine. Their full range of Boar's Head meats (as noted in certain specialty sandwiches) and fresh coffee ensures a high-quality product that meets the discerning standards of New York-area diners. For those hosting, the comprehensive catering menu is a reliable solution for everything from office breakfasts to larger gatherings, making Stuff A Bagel a truly valuable local business in Farmingdale.

Stuff A Bagel Vibe

Beverages
Hot Coffee
Swiss Miss Hot Chocolate
Tea
Please contact the restaurant for current selections.
Box Of Java $25.99
10-12 cups.
Super Box Of Java $37.99
18-22 cups.
Fountain Drink
Iced Coffee
Double brewed from our dark roast.
Vanilla Latte
Mocha Latte
Caramel Macchiato
Caffe Latte
Cappuccino

Breakfast Bagels and Rolls
Bagel
Please indicate quantity and type of bagels in special instructions box.
Flagel's Bagel
Mini Bagel $1.45
Toast Bagel $2.32

Breakfast Bagels and Spreads
Bagel With Butter $3.50
Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese $4.89
Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese $5.60
Bagel With Cream Cheese And Jelly $5.60
Bagel With Lox Spread $7.50
Bagel With Lox Strips And Cream Cheese $14.29

Breakfast Sandwiches
2 Jumbo Eggs $5.40
Ham, 2 Jumbo Eggs And Cheese $7.75
Bacon, 2 Jumbo Eggs And Cheese $7.75
Sausage Patty, 2 Jumbo Eggs And Cheese $7.75
Ham, Bacon, Sausage, 2 Eggs And Cheese $7.50
3 Egg Whites, Turkey And Cheese $9.99
3 Egg Whites, Turkey And Spinach $9.99
3 Egg Whites, Spinach And Feta Cheese $9.99
3 Egg Whites Veggie $10.60
Peppers, onions, mushrooms and spinach.
The Friendly Wrap $10.60
Three egg whites, turkey, peppers and onions on a wrap.
Hungry Man $12.75
Three eggs, bacon, ham, sausage and cheese on a hero.
3 Egg Whites, Chicken And Spinach $10.60
Egg white, grilled chicken and spinach on a wrap.
Ham, 1 Egg, Cheese On A Toasted English Muffin $7.10
1 Egg $4.70
Spanish Wrap $10.60
3 Egg Whites, Ham, Peppers, Onions, Jack Cheese, Salsa
Good Morning Wrap $10.60
2 Eggs, Bacon, Cheddar, Home Fries, Salsa
Energy Wrap $10.60
Peanut Butter, Sliced Banana, Granola, Raisins, Walnuts, Honey

Breakfast Omelette Sandwiches
Create Your Own Omelette Sandwich $12.00
Your choice of any five items.

Breakfast Gourmet Omelette Platters
Rodeo Omelette Platter $13.75
Sauteed mushrooms, bacon and Swiss cheese. Served with buttered bagel or bread, home fries
Traditional Western Omelette Platter $13.75
Ham, peppers, onions and cheese. Served with buttered bagel or bread, home fries
California Omelette Platter $14.25
Avocado, tomato and monterrey jack.
The Mess Omelette Platter $14.25
Hashbrowns, onions, peppers, bacon and ham.
Taste Of Italy Omelette Platter $13.75
Sun-dried tomatoes, sausage and mozzarella. Served with buttered bagel or bread, home fries
Popeye Omelette Platter $13.75
Sauteed spinach, tomatoes and feta cheese. Served with buttered bagel or bread, home fries
Healthnut Omelette Platter $13.75
Egg whites, Alpine lace and honey turkey. Served with buttered bagel or bread, home fries

Breakfast from the Grill
3 Pancakes $10.50
3 Pancakes With Eggs $12.30
3 Pancakes With Eggs And Meat $15.30
3 Pancakes With Bacon $13.50
3 Pancakes With Sausage Patty $13.50
3 Pancakes With Toppings $10.50
Thick French Toast $10.50
Two slices.
Thick French Toast With Eggs $12.30
Two slices.
Thick French Toast With Eggs And Bacon $15.30
Two slices.
Thick French Toast With Bacon $13.50
Two slices.
Thick French Toast With Sausage Patty $13.50
Two slices.
Thick French Toast With Fresh Fruit
Two slices.
Belgian Waffle $11.50
Belgian Waffle With Eggs $13.30
Belgian Waffle With Eggs And Meat $16.30
Three strips.
Belgian Waffle With Meat $14.50
Our Signature Croissant Stuffed French Toast $12.75
Croissant french toast stuffed with cream cheese, fresh strawberries and bananas.
Gourmet Waffle $13.00
Choice of flavor with whipped cream.

Breakfast Oatmeal and Cereal
Fresh Homemade Oatmeal
Steel cut oatmeal made with sauteed apples, strawberries and our own secret ingredients.

Chopped Salad Bar
Large Chopped Salad Bar $9.99
With your choice of lettuce, three add-ins and dressing.

Salads to Go
Garden Salad $12.00
Iceberg lettuce, red and green peppers, red onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, shredded carrots and black olives.
Greek Salad $12.60
Crisp romaine lettuce, sliced cucumbers, green peppers, black olives, red peppers, red onions and tomatoes. Topped with feta cheese and Greek vinaigrette.
Chef Salad $14.25
A mixture of iceberg and romaine lettuce, ham, turkey, American cheese, hard-boiled eggs, green and red peppers, red onions, cucumbers and tomatoes.
Caesar Salad $10.60
Fresh romaine, shaved Parmesan cheese and garlic croutons with Caesar dressing.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $13.50
Fresh romaine, shaved Parmesan cheese and garlic croutons with Caesar dressing. Topped with grilled chicken slices.
Monterey Spinach Salad $12.75
Fresh organic baby spinach, sliced strawberries, diced fresh mozzarella cheese and caramelized pecans. Topped with a balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
Apple Walnut Chicken Salad $14.25
Grilled chicken, apples, craisins, Gorgonzola and candied walnuts over a bed of mixed greens.
Grilled Chicken BLT Salad $14.25
Grilled chicken, crispy bacon and tomatoes on a bed of lettuce.
Cobb Salad $14.25
Grilled chicken, ripe tomatoes, sliced egg, Gorgonzola, black olives and crispy bacon over a bed of mixed greens.
Oriental Chicken Salad $14.25
Marinated chicken, iceberg lettuce, green onions, crisp bacon, toasted sesame seeds and sliced almonds topped with Oriental noodles.
Nutty Chicken Salad $14.25
Mixed greens, marinated chicken, grapes, apples, feta, glazed walnuts, raisins, sunflower seeds and craisins.

Over Stuffed Sandwiches
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $8.75
Your choice of melted cheese. Served on a bagel.
Grilled Cheese And Bacon Sandwich $11.50
Served on a bagel.
BLT Sandwich $9.50
Crispy bacon, lettuce and tomatoes. Served on a bagel.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel.
Fried Chicken Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel.
BBQ Chicken Sandwich $11.50
Boar's Head BBQ chicken breast, cheddar cheese and honey BBQ sauce. Served on a bagel.
California Turkey Sandwich $14.25
Turkey, crisp bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing. Served on a bagel.
Manhattan Sandwich $14.25
Grilled chicken breast, melted Alpine lace, avocado and leaf lettuce on a roll.
Godfather Hero Sandwich $15.50
Genoa salami, cappi ham, pepperoni, provolone, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, onions and red roasted peppers drizzled with oil and vinegar. Served on a bagel.
Black Forest Sandwich $12.00
Honey maple turkey, muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing.

Over Stuffed Melts
Ham And Cheese Melt $11.50
Ham and melted Swiss cheese with butter and garlic. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.
Turkey Melt $11.50
Turkey and melted Swiss cheese with your choice of dressing. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.
Roast Beef Melt $13.50
Roast beef and melted mozzarella cheese with butter and garlic. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.
Pastrami Melt $13.50
Pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and mustard. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.
Reuben Melt $13.50
Steaming hot corned beef and melted Swiss cheese with sauerkraut and mustard. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.
The Old American $15.00
Roast beef, melted cheddar cheese, bacon and BBQ sauce. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.
Tony's Tuna Melt $12.00
Tuna fish, melted American cheese, & tomato. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.
Turkey Supreme Melt $14.25
Turkey, melted Swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and your choice of dressing. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.
Old Bethpage Melt $15.00
Fried chicken cutlet, melted American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and horseradish Dijon. Served on a bagel and grilled to perfection.

Pressed Panini
Italian Chicken Panino $13.50
Grilled chicken breast, roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella cheese. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
The Reuben Panino $13.50
Corned beef, Swiss, Russian dressing and sauerkraut. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
Fresh Mozzarella Pesto Panino $13.50
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted peppers and pesto. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
Buffalo Chicken Panino $13.50
Boar's Head blazin' Buffalo chicken breast and Monterey Jack cheese. Served with Buffalo dipping sauce. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
Ham And Swiss Panino $13.50
Boar's Head ham and Swiss cheese. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
Honey Turkey Panino $13.50
Boar's Head honey turkey and Alpine lace Swiss cheese. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
Roast Beef And Mozzarella Panino $13.50
Oven cooked roast beef and mozzarella. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
Maple Lover's Panino $13.50
Boar's Head honey maple turkey and mozzarella with a sweet honey Dijon dressing. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
The Kickin' Turkey Panino $13.50
Salsalito turkey, Monterey Jack cheese and tomatoes with a chipotle sauce. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
The Daler Panino $13.50
White meat chicken breast, fresh mozzarella, tomato, caramelized red onions and creamy horseradish. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
The Main St. Panino $13.50
Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, sauteed mushrooms, red roasted peppers and garlic mayo. Grilled to perfection on European flat bread and served with your choice of side.
Valencia Panino $13.50
Grilled chicken cutlet, red roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella and balsamic vinaigrette on a kaiser roll. Served with your choice of side.

Wraps
Apple Chicken Walnut Wrap $13.50
Grilled chicken, apples, craisins, Gorgonzola and candied walnuts in a balsamic vinaigrette. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Chicken Cutlet Wrap $13.50
Your choice of fried or grilled chicken cutlet with lettuce and tomato. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $13.50
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce and Caesar dressing. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $13.50
Fried chicken, homemade hot sauce, blue cheese dressing, diced carrots and celery with green leaf. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Ranch Wrap $13.50
Grilled chicken, American cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato tossed in ranch dressing. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Chicken Pesto Wrap $13.50
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella and pesto mayo. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Club Wrap $13.50
Turkey, bacon, Muenster, lettuce, tomato and honey Dijon. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Roma Wrap $13.50
Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella and red roasted peppers. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Chipotle Chicken Wrap $13.50
Grilled chicken, chipotle mayo, lettuce and tomato. Served on your choice of wrap with your choice of side.
Feel Good Wrap $13.50
Boar's Head oven gold turkey, Alpine lace Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard dressing.
Veggie Tuna Salad Wrap $13.50
Tuna salad with light mayo, freshly chopped vegetables, lettuce and tomato wrapped up in a spinach tortilla.

Cold Cut Sandwiches
Ham Cold Cut Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Turkey Cold Cut Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Maple Turkey Cold Cut Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Salsalito Turkey Cold Cut Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Chicken Breast Cold Cut Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Buffalo Chicken Cold Cut Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Pastrami Cold Cut Sandwich $12.75
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Corned Beef Cold Cut Sandwich $12.75
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Genoa Salami Cold Cut Sandwich $12.00
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Prosciutto Cold Cut Sandwich $12.75
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Roast Beef Cold Cut Sandwich $12.75
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Cappy Ham Cold Cut Sandwich $10.60
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Bologna Cold Cut Sandwich $8.50
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.
Cheese Cold Cut Sandwich $8.50
Served on a bagel with your choice of side.

Salad Sandwiches
Egg Salad Sandwich $10.00
Served on a bagel.
Tuna Salad Sandwich $11.50
Served on a bagel.
Mexican Tuna Sandwich $11.50
Served on a bagel.
Springtime Tuna Sandwich $11.50
Served on a bagel.
Lite Veggie Tuna Salad Sandwich $11.50
Served on a bagel.
Buffalo Chicken Salad Sandwich $11.50
Served on a bagel.
Chicken Salad Sandwich $11.50
Served on a bagel.
Craisin Chicken Salad Sandwich $11.75
Served on a bagel.
Avocado Chicken Salad Sandwich $11.75
Served on a bagel.
Apple Walnut Chicken Salad $12.25
Served on a bagel.

Sweet Treats
Muffin $4.00
Danish $4.00
Cinnamon Roll $4.00
Croissant $4.00
Chocolate Croissant $4.00

Cakes and Cookies
Crumb Cake $4.00
Raspberry Crumb Cake $4.00
Brownie $4.00
Our Famous Black And White Cookie $4.00
Linzer Tart $4.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie $4.00

Mini Treats
Mini Black And White Cookie
Mini Chocolate Chip Cookie
Mini Double Chocolate Chip Cookie
Mini M&M Cookie
Mini Peanut Butter Cookie
Mini Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Mini Sugar Cookie

Desserts and Snacks
Fresh Seasonal Fruit Cup $4.99
Rice Pudding $4.99
Chocolate Pudding $4.99
Chips $3.50
Please contact restaurant for flavors.
Yogurt Parfait $5.99
Fat free vanilla strawberry yogurt with granola and seasonal berries.

Stuff A Bagel Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Restroom

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Stuff A Bagel Photos

Stuff A Bagel Location

Stuff A Bagel

New York Nassau County Farmingdale Main Street

234 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA

Stuff A Bagel Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 378 user reviews.

egg sandwichownermealmanagerdelisaladfrench toastraspberrywrapmuffins

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Used to be good. Ever since new ownership a few years ago it's gone down hill quite a bit. Prices are through the roof and service is in the gutter
September 28 · Matthew Holmes
Dear Owner,I want to begin by acknowledging that you have a great establishment and an excellent product. However, I feel compelled to bring to your attention a serious concern regarding the conduct of your manager, Eric.Unfortunately, my recent experiences with him have been extremely disappointing. I found his approach to customer service lacking, and his communication style unprofessional and dismissive. This has not only impacted our overall experience but has also led us to discontinue our business with Stuff a Bagel.I’m sharing this feedback not to be critical, but because I genuinely believe in the potential of your business and hope to see it thrive. Should you wish to discuss this matter further, I would be happy to speak with you directly and provide more context.Please feel free to respond with your contact number and email address.Sincerely,
June 11 · F M
This is the worst experience that I’ve ever had. They forgot a bagel in my delivery and I called back and they kept passing me off and hanging up on me. I don’t know what happened to this place, but it definitely went down. The food isn’t even the same. This will be my last time ordering from them.
August 03 · Frances Perez
Expensive for what it is. Macaroni salad was sour and went bad. Bagel was pretty hard. The tuna salad had good flavor though.
January 31 · Lexi C
A great breakfast stop! Great egg sandwich’s Nice seating with great view of the now busy downtown Farmingdale scene. Large selection. Good coffee. Definitely stop in! S
November 19 · Audrey
We used to love this place but not anymore. Went today for turkey and ham on a flagel, chicken wrap and 2 cookies. Paid $30 for 2 pieces of turkey and ham and a cookie with a bite out of it that was hard as a rock.The woman in front of me got chicken salad on a bagel and when they handed it to her she said “pretty skimpy on the chicken salad!” They looked at her and said nothing.Seems like they are trying to save money by putting minimal amounts on sandwiches.Not sure what happened to this place, but won’t be going back! Check out the photos
July 20 · Brian Fullerton