Tarry Tavern

- 27 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591

Introduction / Overview

Nestled in the center of Historic Tarrytown’s bustling Main Street, Tarry Tavern stands as a quintessential New York dining destination—a modern, culinary renewal of the classic American Tavern. It has long been recognized as a 'culinary gem' in Westchester County, celebrated for its inviting atmosphere, attentive service, and a menu that masterfully weds traditional, hearty American flavors with contemporary, creative presentation.

Tarry Tavern operates as a sophisticated gastropub and full-service American restaurant, providing locals and visitors alike with a cozy yet elegant place to enjoy expertly crafted meals. The entire dining experience is designed to invoke a sense of comfort and tradition, complemented by a commitment to showcasing the bounty of the Hudson Valley through its diverse culinary offerings. The restaurant is particularly famous for its dual menu concept: a classic 'Tavern' menu offering familiar comfort foods, and a seasonally-driven 'Market' menu focused on fresh, local produce.

Patrons frequently praise the quality of the food and the attention to detail, noting that everything ordered is "fantastic," including the complimentary bread. The friendly staff and cozy, rustic cherrywood setting contribute to an ambiance that makes it an ideal spot for any occasion, be it a casual lunch, an intimate dinner, or a pre-show reservation given its close proximity to the Tarrytown Music Hall.

Location and Accessibility

Tarry Tavern is strategically located at 27 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA. This address places it directly in the heart of Tarrytown’s historic and vibrant downtown area.

Its location on Main Street makes it effortlessly accessible for local Westchester residents and visitors exploring the village. A key locational advantage is its position just steps away from the iconic Tarrytown Music Hall, cementing its status as a popular dining spot for show nights.

The restaurant is committed to ensuring comfort and access for all guests, with features that include:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
• Seating and Table Service available throughout the restaurant

Services Offered

Tarry Tavern offers a comprehensive range of dining and hospitality services to meet the diverse needs of the New York-area clientele:

• Dine-in Service: Full table service available for lunch, dinner, and brunch on weekends.
• Outdoor Seating: Patrons can enjoy al fresco dining on the charming patio, weather permitting.
• Reservations: The establishment accepts reservations, which are highly recommended, especially on busy weekend evenings and during the peak October season. During particularly busy periods, like October weekends, seating may be offered on a "First Come, First Serve" basis.
• Takeout and Delivery: Convenient options for those who prefer to enjoy their gourmet American cuisine at home or at the office.
• Full Bar Service: Features a Bar onsite with a wide selection of Alcohol, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and an extensive Wine list, alongside a thoughtful selection of 12 draft brews, predominantly craft and American.
• Catering and Private Events: The restaurant is available for Special Events and Catering, accommodating private dinners, business lunches, wedding celebrations, and cocktail receptions.
• Payment Options: Accepts modern payment methods, including Debit Cards and NFC Mobile Payments.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Tarry Tavern apart in the competitive Westchester dining landscape is its dedication to elevated American cuisine, ambiance, and a truly farm-focused philosophy:

• Dual Menu Concept: Diners can select from the cozier, comforting 'Tavern' menu or the highly seasonal 'Market' menu, which ensures a focus on the freshest local produce and ingredients from the Hudson Valley. This guarantees a rotating selection of innovative dishes.
• Signature Gourmet Comfort Dishes: The restaurant is renowned for taking classic American comfort food to a gourmet level, such as the famous 'Mac N' Cheese' elevated with ditalini pasta, Lobster, and white truffle oil ($32.00). Other highlights include the 'Braised Short Rib of Beef' ($34.00) served with Parmesan Polenta, and the 'Roasted Yukon Gold Potato Gnocchi' ($16.00).
• High-End Mains: The menu features prime cuts and fresh seafood, appealing to a sophisticated palate. Key offerings include the 'Creek Stone Farms NY Strip Steak' ($39.00), 'Roasted Hudson Valley Duck Breast' ($34.00), 'Seared Maine Sea Scallops' ($34.00), and 'Atlantic Salmon' ($32.00).
• Cozy and Elegant Interior: The atmosphere is described as casually elegant, featuring warm butter-colored walls, English Red Oak Paneling, exposed beams, and a richly lacquered bar, giving the feel of a "country farmhouse." This rustic yet refined setting provides a perfect backdrop for a leisurely, memorable meal.
• Focus on Fresh and Organic: The commitment to organic dishes and fresh, house-made foods, drawing inspiration from French and Italian culinary traditions, speaks to a higher standard of ingredient quality.
• Appetizers Worth the Trip: The small plates and starters are highly praised, including the highly-rated 'Niman Ranch Pork Cheeks' ($20.00), 'Yellow Fin Tuna Tartare' ($18.00), and the 'New England Clam Chowder' ($16.00).

Contact Information

For New York patrons interested in making a reservation, inquiring about the menu, or planning a special event, here is the essential contact information for Tarry Tavern:

Address: 27 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

Phone: (914) 631-7227

What is Worth Choosing

Tarry Tavern is absolutely worth choosing for anyone in the New York region seeking a superior dining experience that transcends the average restaurant visit. It offers a rare blend of warmth, sophistication, and genuine culinary quality that is often hard to find outside of Manhattan.

For Westchester locals, it's the perfect spot for date night, pre-theater dining, or a special occasion. You can count on the 'Braised Short Rib of Beef' to be a consistently satisfying choice, or you can venture into the exciting and ever-changing 'Market Menu' to sample the freshest seasonal ingredients the Hudson Valley has to offer. The reviewers consistently point out the exceptional service and friendly staff, proving that Tarry Tavern provides an experience where the care and attention to the guest are as high a priority as the quality of the food.

From the perfectly prepared seafood, such as the 'Seared Maine Sea Scallops,' to the decadent 'Mac N' Cheese,' the value lies in the gourmet twist on comfort food staples. The beautifully appointed dining room and the option for a relaxing meal on the patio only add to its appeal, making Tarry Tavern a true culinary destination in Tarrytown that you will want to return to time and again.

Tarry Tavern

27 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA