Tasty Pastry Shoppe Brooklyn: Italian Delights, Gluten-Free Options, and More in Dyker Heights

Tasty Pastry Shoppe Introduce

When it comes to the heart of New York City’s authentic, old-school Italian-American culinary scene, few neighborhoods hold as much tradition and flavor as Brooklyn. Nestled in the beloved Dyker Heights area, the

Tasty Pastry Shoppe

stands as a genuine institution, frequently lauded as one of Brooklyn's top destinations for dessert. This is far more than just a place to grab a quick cookie; it is a destination where family recipes meet contemporary dietary needs, offering a vast and dazzling array of baked goods that have earned it a loyal following across the boroughs and beyond.

The bakery is a true testament to the passion of its Italian Culinary Chefs, who skillfully blend time-honored recipes with modern culinary flair. The result is a selection of treats that are not only visually stunning—perfect for any New York celebration—but also crafted using only the freshest and finest ingredients. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted by the intoxicating aroma of freshly baked goods, a symphony of sweets and savories that immediately explains why this spot is a local legend.

For residents of Brooklyn and visitors exploring the area,

Tasty Pastry Shoppe

is a must-visit. It successfully marries the rich heritage of a traditional Italian bakery with the inclusive demands of modern-day dining, ensuring everyone, regardless of dietary restrictions, can indulge in something truly delicious. They’ve managed to maintain the cherished quality of an authentic Italian bakery—a rarity in a rapidly changing city—while continually innovating with new trends and offerings.

Location and Accessibility in Dyker Heights, Brooklyn

The

Tasty Pastry Shoppe

is conveniently situated in the vibrant Dyker Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for a quick visit or a planned stop to pick up a special occasion cake or large catering order. Its specific location at

8216-18 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA

places it right in a bustling community hub.

For New Yorkers driving to the location, both free and paid street parking options are available, though as with most highly popular Brooklyn spots, it is wise to plan for busy periods, especially on weekends when the shop can get exceptionally crowded. For those utilizing public transit, the location is well-serviced, positioning it as an ideal stop for those traveling throughout the borough. The bakery's accessibility is further enhanced by a wheelchair-accessible entrance, promoting a welcoming environment for all customers.

The operating hours cater perfectly to the New York lifestyle, starting early and closing late, allowing for everything from a morning coffee and pastry run to an after-dinner dessert pickup. The shop is open from Tuesday to Saturday, 6:30 AM to 8:00 PM, and on Sunday from 6:30 AM to 5:00 PM. Note that the bakery is typically closed on Mondays, except during major holidays, so it's always a good idea to check ahead on those days. This schedule ensures that your craving for a world-class dessert can be satisfied nearly any day of the week.

Extensive Menu and Services Offered

The menu at

Tasty Pastry Shoppe

goes far beyond the standard bakery fare, offering both traditional Italian-American sweets and a robust selection of savory options. Their commitment to quality means using fresh ingredients for all their products, baked daily. The comprehensive offerings cater to almost any taste or dietary requirement, making it a true one-stop-shop for all things delicious.

Pastries: An enormous selection including traditional favorites like Cannoli (traditional, chocolate-covered, and Nutella-filled), Sfogliatelle, Creampuffs (cannoli or custard cream), and classic Italian and French Napoleons. Other options include Tiramisu, Fruit Tarts, and a variety of Mousse-based treats like Chocolate, Black & White, and Ferrero Mousse.
Cakes and Cheesecakes: Available in a multitude of flavors and for all occasions, including specialities like Cassata Cake, Mango Cheesecake, Passion Fruit Cheesecake, Ferrero Rocher Cheesecake, New York Cheesecake, Red Velvet Cake, Chocolate Mousse Cake, and more. Custom and specialty cakes are available by special order.
Cookies and Small Treats: A vast assortment of cookies sold by the pound, including Scottish shortbread, Nutella filled cookies, lemon crisps, anise biscuits, Pignoli nut cookies, and the famed rainbow cookies. They also offer Cupcakes, Cake Pops, Donuts, and the popular Nutella Lobstertail.
Specialty Dietary Items: The bakery boasts one of the largest selections of specialty items in Brooklyn, catering to various needs with dedicated products that do not compromise on flavor, including Sugar-Free, Gluten-Free, and Vegan products. This selection includes cookies, pastries (like sugar-free Tiramisu and French Napoleon), and flourless chocolate cake.
Savory Lunch and Bread Items: Uniquely, they offer a savory menu that includes Traditional New York Style Pizza, Fresh Mozzarella Pizza, Mixed Toppings Pizza (with options like mushrooms, zucchini, or spinach), Focaccia, and various Rolls (such as eggplant parm, chicken parm, spinach, or sausage and pepper). Also featured are Rice Balls (with mozzarella or Sicilian style meat sauce and peas).
Beverages: Coffee is available to pair with your breakfast or sweet treats.
Seasonal and Holiday Items: During the warmer months, the shop serves Italian Ices and Gelato. For holidays, they create elaborate, festive specialties and take orders for cookie and pastry trays, wedding cakes, and other party favors.
Service Options: The shop offers Takeaway, In-store pick-up, and On-site services for a convenient customer experience.

Distinguishing Features and Highlights

What truly sets the

Tasty Pastry Shoppe

apart in the competitive New York bakery landscape are its key distinguishing features. The family's dedication to high-quality ingredients and a blend of old-world Italian tradition with new-world creativity has secured its reputation as a leading bakery in Brooklyn.

Award-Winning Desserts: The bakery has been repeatedly voted 'Best Dessert in Brooklyn' by local polls (including in 2025, 2023, and 2022), a clear indication of its status as a borough favorite.
Unrivaled Selection of Dietary Options: They are particularly famous for having one of the largest, if not the largest, selections of Sugar-Free, Gluten-Free, and Vegan desserts in the region. This commitment to inclusivity is a major highlight, allowing those with specific needs to enjoy traditional Italian-American sweets.
Authentic Italian Heritage: The family of Italian culinary chefs uses time-tested, old-world recipes, ensuring an authentic taste of Italian specialties like the classic cannoli and cassata pastry.
Beyond Sweets: Unlike many bakeries, they also offer a substantial savory menu, including various pizzas, rice balls, and savory rolls, making it a viable spot for breakfast or a full lunch.
High-Quality and Freshness: Customers consistently rave about the freshness of the baked goods, which are made daily, and the high quality of the ingredients used.
Friendly Service and Efficient System: The bakery is known for its friendly, attentive staff and a clean, bright interior. On busy days, the implemented ticket system ensures a fast and efficient experience, even with high foot traffic.

Contact Information

For all inquiries, special orders, and hours confirmation, locals can reach the

Tasty Pastry Shoppe

using the following details.

Address:

8216-18 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA

Phone:

(718) 833-9493

Email:

tastypastryshop@aol.com

What is Worth Choosing: A Local Perspective

For New Yorkers—especially those in Brooklyn—the

Tasty Pastry Shoppe

is more than a convenience; it’s a neighborhood treasure. The choice is simple: if you are looking for that authentic taste of a traditional Italian-American bakery, this is where you go. Customers consistently highlight that every item, from the large, beautiful cakes to the small, perfectly executed cookies, is phenomenal and fresh.

What makes it truly special and worth the trip (even from outside Dyker Heights) is its incredible dual appeal. On one hand, you have the classic, rich Italian pastries like the

cassata cake

—a staple for holidays and birthdays—and the creamy, delicious

cheesecake

. On the other, the bakery is a haven for the health-conscious or those with allergies. The customer sentiment is clear: for those on a diet, entering this bakery is a delightful form of self-sabotage because the selections, including the

gluten-free and sugar-free options

, are so numerous and delicious that they are indistinguishable from their regular counterparts. The sheer variety ensures that whether you're craving a decadent

Nutella Cannoli

, a savory

Chicken Parm Roll

, or an exceptional

Flourless Chocolate Cake

, you will find a treat that makes the visit worthwhile. It remains one of those few great, old-school bakeries left in Brooklyn, solidifying its status as a must-visit culinary spot in New York City.

Tasty Pastry Shoppe Photos

Tasty Pastry Shoppe Location

Tasty Pastry Shoppe

New York Kings County Dyker Heights 13th Avenue

8216-18 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA

Tasty Pastry Shoppe Reviews

This is one of those few Italian bakery’s left in Brooklyn! Love this place everything is so delicious and fresh. You can’t go wrong with anything there. Pastries, cookies, cake and their ice cream are better than you can imagine! The only problem is that if you’re on a diet lol you’re doomed! Oh they even have gluten free and sugar free options!
September 30 · P Lugo
Great bakery with a ton of selections. The cookie selection has something for everyone and the cream puffs were excellent. Bring extra cash as it is pricey.
July 20 · Tom Reitemeyer
We came here on a whim. There was a lineup of people. The service was fast.They have a big variety of stuff. From pies, croissants, cookies, breads, cinnamon rolls, cheesecakes, cakes…They have the biggest selection of gluten free desserts that I have ever seen.We got cannolis, lobster tail, raspberry jam squares, lemon cookies and cheesecake slices.The cheesecake is phenomenal! So creamy and delicious. Easily one of the best ever. The other stuff was all good. The cheesecake is out of this world!
January 13 · A Bousi
I used to live in Long Island and I would travel to Brooklyn just to take home as many sugar free treats as I could from this wonderful bakery. Everyone is so nice and welcoming. The atmosphere is pristine. And well their food is to die for. I am currently too far away to be able to go to this bakery but you bet I am currently day dreaming about it. Blessed be the hands that prepared this food and blessed be the mind behind this joyous place.
September 13 · Gaby Carreon
Lots of pastry varieties to make your head spin and your mouth water. Their cakes look fantastic. I have yet to try them. I only tried their sugar-free creampuffs & hot cocoa on my first visit. No place to sit. Takeout only.
December 25 · Fayvenn