The Astarita: Premier Pizza, Pasta & Italian Comfort Food in Brooklyn, NY

The Astarita Introduce

Introduction / Overview

The Astarita, a true Brooklyn gem located at

797 5th Ave

, is more than just a pizza restaurant; it is a dedicated Italian eatery with a heart firmly rooted in tradition and quality. For New Yorkers in search of that perfect, unforgettable slice, this establishment has quickly become a standout destination, celebrated for its commitment to high-quality ingredients and a warm, hospitable atmosphere. The owner, who grew up in the pizza business, infuses a deep appreciation for hand-crafted pizza into every pie, ensuring a superior dining experience.

The menu at The Astarita goes beyond the standard pizzeria fare, offering a full range of Italian comfort food. While the 16" Pizzas are the undisputed star—praised by patrons for their

perfectly crispy crust

and

top quality cheese

—the menu extends to include satisfying Pastas, fresh Salads, and classic Sandwiches. Favorites include the aptly named

The Astarita Pizza

(a Margherita with fresh ricotta) and the decadent

The Truffle Oil Pizza

, showcasing both traditional and innovative recipes.

The restaurant fosters an inviting and authentic environment. The atmosphere is described as

Casual

Cozy

, and

Trendy

, making it an excellent setting for any occasion—from a family dinner (

Family-friendly

and

Good for kids

) to a quick, solo lunch. With a strong commitment to inclusivity, The Astarita proudly offers

Halal food

options,

Vegan options

, and

Vegetarian options

, ensuring that all members of the diverse New York community can enjoy their exceptional food. This combination of culinary excellence, welcoming service, and commitment to the community has firmly established The Astarita as a

hidden gem

and a favorite among

Locals

in the 11232 zip code.

Location and Accessibility

The Astarita is conveniently located at

797 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

, positioning it in a dynamic and easily reachable part of Brooklyn. This central location ensures it is accessible to a wide clientele, from neighborhood residents to visitors specifically seeking out quality Italian cuisine.

Accessibility is a clear priority, as the restaurant features a

Wheelchair accessible entrance

, ensuring that all members of the community can dine comfortably. The dining options are diverse to suit the fast-paced New York lifestyle, offering traditional

Dine-in

with

Table service

Takeout

for those on the move, and the highly desirable

Outdoor seating

option, perfect for enjoying a meal during pleasant Brooklyn weather. For those arriving by car, there is

Free street parking

available, which is a significant amenity in the borough. The ease of access, combined with a variety of service options and amenities like

Restrooms

and a

Gender-neutral restroom

, makes The Astarita a supremely convenient and comfortable choice for

Lunch

and

Dinner

Services Offered

Full Dining Services: Offers
Dine-in
service with
Seating
and
Table service
for Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert.
Outdoor Seating: Provides an attractive
Outdoor seating
area, perfect for enjoying meals in a relaxed setting.
Convenient Takeout: Customers can utilize the
Takeout
service option for quick, at-home enjoyment.
Reservations Accepted: For planning family events or dinners, the restaurant
Accepts reservations
.
Extensive Menu Options: Offers
Comfort food
,
Small plates
(Appetizers),
Quick bite
items, and a robust selection of
Halal food
,
Vegan options
, and
Vegetarian options
.
Beverage Selection: Serves a variety of drinks, including
Alcohol
,
Beer
,
Wine
, and
Coffee
.
Catering to All: Designated as
Family-friendly
and
Good for kids
, ensuring a welcoming environment for all ages.
Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods including
Credit cards
,
Debit cards
, and
NFC mobile payments
.

Features / Highlights

Exceptional Crust Quality: Customers consistently highlight the pizza's
perfectly crispy crust
that holds up well under toppings and doesn't get soggy—a hallmark of quality pizza making.
Premium Ingredients: The use of
top quality cheese
and fresh components, often sourced locally, elevates the flavor of all dishes.
Diverse Specialty Pizzas: Offers a wide range of unique 16" pizzas like
The Truffle Oil Pizza
(featuring smoked scamorza cheese and pancetta) and the
Mr. William Pizza
(with pepperoni and hot honey), alongside classics like the
Margarita Pizza
.
Inclusivity Focus: Features a valuable selection of offerings, including
Halal food
,
Vegan options
(mentioned specifically in reviews), and
Vegetarian options
, making it accessible to a broader New York clientele.
Full Italian Menu: Beyond pizza, the menu includes authentic Italian fare such as Homemade Meatballs, various Pastas (Pesto Pasta, Linguini with Meatballs), fresh Salads (Seasonal Salad), and the Housemade Tiramisu dessert.
Welcoming Atmosphere and Service: Known for
Great staff
, a
Cozy
and
Trendy
atmosphere, and
Fast service
, ensuring a pleasant and efficient dining experience for
Locals
.

Contact Information

Address: 797 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

Phone: (718) 306-8289

Mobile Phone: +1 718-306-8289

What is Worth Choosing

The Astarita is the definitive choice for New Yorkers prioritizing genuine quality, ingredient excellence, and a welcoming dining atmosphere. Its pizza alone, with a

perfectly crispy crust

and

top quality cheese

, is considered by patrons to be among the best they have tried—a high compliment in a city famous for its pies. Even a simple

Margarita Pizza

is said to be perfect, highlighting the strength of their foundational recipe.

What sets The Astarita apart is its ability to cater to a diverse modern palate while retaining an Italian soul. The inclusion of unique pizzas like

The Truffle Oil Pizza

offers a sophisticated twist, while the wide range of

Halal food

Vegan options

, and

Vegetarian options

ensures that groups with varied dietary needs can dine together happily. This inclusivity is a major benefit for New York families and friend groups.

The overall experience is further enhanced by the practical amenities it offers, such as

Outdoor seating

, the convenience of accepting

reservations

, and

Fast service

. Whether you are settling in for a leisurely

Dinner

with wine, grabbing a

Quick bite

for

Lunch

, or looking for a

Family-friendly

spot, The Astarita delivers an unforgettable experience that blends premium Italian cuisine with true Brooklyn charm. It is, quite simply, a local business that passionately delivers on its promise of great food and hospitality.

The Astarita Food & drink

16" Pizza
The Truffle Oil Pizza $36.00
Smoked scamorza cheese, scallions, and pancetta topped with truffle oil.
Pizza Capriccioso $35.00
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, portobello mushrooms, olives, prosciutto cotto
The Napoli Pizza $34.00
Tomato sauce, anchovies, olives, capers, fresh garlic.
Margarita Pizza $26.00
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmigiana cheese and fresh basil.
4 Seasons Pizza $40.00
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, artichoke hearts, olives, mushrooms, imported prosciutto di Parma.
Arugula Pizza $34.00
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, imported prosciutto di Parma, arugula, shaved Parmigiano Reggiano.
Pizza Bianco $27.00
Fresh mozzarella, fresh ricotta.
The Rose Pizza $30.00
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, pepperoni, crushed red pepper, basil (no sauce)
The Astarita Pizza $30.00
Margherita pizza with fresh ricotta
Quattro Formaggi Pizza $32.00
Fresh mozzarella, fontina, Gorgonzola, smoked mozzarella.
Classic NY $27.00
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and east coast mozzarella blend., taste like a classic NY slice.
Greenwood Vegetable $34.00
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, portabello mushrooms, red peppers, fresh garlic, shallots, artichoke hearts
Mr. William Pizza $28.00
Tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, pepperoni, hot honey.

Sandwich
Caprese $19.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, arugula, pesto sauce on seeded Italian bread.
Poscutto Mozzarella $19.00
Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, tomato, arugula, olive oil tomatoes .
Meatball Sandwich $19.00
Meatballs, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella. Fresh ricotta, parmigiana Reggiano on seeded Italian bread.
Italian Tuna $19.00
Italian tuna, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers. Tomatoes, Shallots, arugula on seeded Italian bread.

Salads
Seasonal Salad $18.00
Baby kale, shallots, walnuts, cranberries, green apples, goat cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette
Caesar Salad $18.00
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated Parmigiano Reggiano with Caesar dressing.
Antipasto $20.00
Fresh mozzeralla, tomatoes, olives , roasted red peppers and prosciutto Di Parm
House Salad $18.00
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, shallots, kalamata olives, grated Parmigiano Reggiano with house dressing.

Desserts
Miss Sofia $20.00
Pizza with Nutella, Fresh strawberries, bananas, powdered sugar, and mascarpone whipped cream.
Housemade Tiramisu $13.00

Pasta
Pesto Pasta $20.00
Spinach fusilli with pesto sauce served with grated parmigiano reggiano and fresh ricotta
Linguini With Tomato Sauce $18.00
Served with grated parmigiano reggiano
Linguini Pasta With Meatball $24.00
Served with tomato sauce and grated parmigiano reggiano

Calzone
Calzone $25.00
Fresh ricotta, fresh mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano.

Appetizer
Meatballs $20.00
Two large meatballs served with tomato sauce, freshly grated parmagiano reggiano, basil and fresh ricotta.
Antipasto $22.00
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, olives, roasted peppers, prosciutto di parma, partana olive oil

The Astarita Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Assistive hearing loop
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Coffee
Comfort food
Halal food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Locals

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free street parking
Parking

The Astarita Photos

The Astarita Location

The Astarita

New York Kings County Sunset Park 5th Avenue

797 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

The Astarita Reviews

An average rating of ★4.8 from 195 user reviews.

pepperonimeatballshoneycalzonetoppingsadditioncaesar saladcrustitalianoven

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Both non vegans and vegans enjoyed the food here! Great staff and the outdoor seating is cute!
September 26 · Tracy Marotta
This place is a hidden gem. I'm not sure why it wasn't more packed. The pizza was delicious. It was a perfectly crispy crust and didn't get soggy with all the toppings that we ordered. The cheese was absolutely top quality as well. This is one of the best pizza places I've been to and I make it a point to try a lot. I'd love to go back and just get the plain pizza. I'm sure it's perfect.
September 19 · Leah Schneider
Ok so yes 3 stars for food!! Burnt pizza which you can easily see in pics. A very easy fix by trimming off the burnt crust. Taste was good and holds up like it should. Veggie pizza was mixed with margarita but the veggie side was too sogged up and did not hold up to the amount of veggies that were on the pizza.This was a group of 7 and my daughter said it may have been an off night.. it’s Friday it should be your best night. I saw other pizzas that had same look of burnt pizza and where the crust was left behind bc it was way to burnt.
October 19 · Belkys Diaz
The laid back atmosphere made it easy and comfortable for dining with our kids, who are already asking when are we going back?! The pizza was absolutely delicious. Great sauce with a light and airy crust, you won't feel bad that you had four slices! The whipped marscapone on the Nutella pizza helped to make it the best I'd ever had. I will absolutely be going back very soon!
February 18 · Nora DeSimone
Top tier pizza, this neighborhood gem is hands down the best in the area. The Mr. Williams pizza did not disappoint.
July 13 · Deb West