The Buttery

- 1761 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314

For New York diners on the hunt for a superior, flavor-focused burger and sandwich experience, The Buttery on Staten Island is a must-try destination. Situated on Victory Boulevard, this establishment has quickly made a name for itself by elevating classic American comfort food to gourmet status, all while operating as a dedicated Halal restaurant. This dual commitment to premium ingredients and inclusive dining makes The Buttery a standout option in the borough for anyone seeking delicious, high-quality, and trustworthy meals.

The core of The Buttery’s menu is its impressive selection of smash burgers and inventive sandwiches. Unlike conventional hamburger joints, The Buttery emphasizes quality and creative flavor combinations. Their specialty burgers, like the 'Eggcellent' (featuring a fried egg) and the spicy 'Señor Jalapeños' (complete with whipped cream cheese), take familiar favorites and inject them with bold, modern twists. This creativity extends to their much-lauded Cheesesteaks and unique 'Hot Dog Splits,' ensuring that the menu offers a satisfying option for every craving.

Adding to its appeal is the distinctive side menu, which encourages exploration beyond standard fries. The signature Golden Tallow Fries, cooked in beef tallow, promise an unmatched depth of flavor and texture that many customers have noted is "different" and superior. Paired with specialty lemonades and rich, thick milkshakes—including the highly popular 'Biscoff Cookie Butter' flavor—The Buttery provides a complete, indulgent, and satisfying meal experience that is perfect for local New Yorkers who appreciate attention to detail in their comfort food.

The Buttery is conveniently located in the Sunnyside neighborhood of Staten Island, making it an accessible spot for residents across the borough. Its address places it on a major roadway, simplifying travel for those coming from other parts of the island or the surrounding New York area.

The physical location is:

1761 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314

While the establishment offers a comfortable Dine-in experience, New York City traffic and parking are always considerations. The parking options available to guests are:

• Paid street parking: Available in the vicinity of the restaurant, allowing for easy access for a quick pickup or a relaxed sit-down meal. Customers should check local signage for rates and time limits.

Being situated in a high-traffic area like Victory Boulevard ensures that The Buttery is well-placed for both local patronage and visitors passing through the area looking for a quality meal.

The Buttery is structured to accommodate the fast-paced life of a New Yorker, offering a variety of service methods for maximum convenience and flexibility:

• Dine-in: Guests can enjoy their food and milkshakes in the clean, well-organized environment noted by customers, offering a traditional restaurant experience.
• Takeout: Ideal for quick meals, all menu items are available for easy pickup at the counter.
• Delivery: The restaurant partners with delivery services to bring its full menu directly to customers' homes or offices across the local New York area.
• No-contact delivery: A safe and convenient option for those who prefer minimized interaction when ordering food delivery.
• Online Ordering: Offering the ability to place and manage orders digitally for all service options, ensuring efficiency.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts most standard forms of payment, including credit cards and cash, though customers should be aware of a potential small surcharge for card usage as noted in reviews.

The Buttery distinguishes itself from other local hamburger and sandwich shops through several key features that focus on quality and unique flavor profiles:

• Certified Halal Menu: A defining feature that ensures all meat products are prepared according to Halal standards, broadening its appeal to a wider community of New York diners.
• Gourmet Smash Burgers: Known for its signature smash patty technique and creative burger recipes, such as the 'EGGCELLENT' and 'SWEETIE' with its apricot and peach glaze.
• Specialty Cheesesteaks: Offering a selection of rich, savory cheesesteaks, including the classic preparation and unique variations like the 'HERBAL KISS' and the 'CHIPOTLE JAWN.'
• Signature 'Buttery' Sides: Moving beyond standard fare with side dishes like the highly-rated GOLDEN TALLOW FRIES, unique ELOTE FRIES (fresh-cut potatoes with Mexican street corn toppings), and the classic New York DISCO FRIES.
• Handcrafted Milkshakes and Lemonades: A wide array of specialty beverages, including rich, creative milkshakes like BISCOFF COOKIE BUTTER and refreshing, fruit-infused lemonades (Peach, Strawberry, Raspberry, Dragonfruit).
• Clean and Organized Setting: Customer reviews consistently highlight the restaurant's very clean and well-organized appearance, contributing to a pleasant dining atmosphere.
• Excellent Customer Service: Patrons have noted the great customer service provided by the staff, enhancing the overall experience.

New York residents looking to place an order, make inquiries about the Halal certification, or confirm operating hours can reach The Buttery at the following contact points. The restaurant operates daily, ensuring consistent availability for both lunch and dinner crowds.

Address: 1761 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314

Phone: (929) 202-1957

Operating Hours: Generally open from 11:00 am to 9:30 pm (or 10:00 pm, depending on the day of the week). Customers should consult the most up-to-date online information or call ahead to confirm evening hours.

The Buttery is an excellent choice for any New Yorker seeking high-quality comfort food with a guarantee of Halal preparation. This dual focus is rarely found in a dedicated gourmet burger and sandwich shop, immediately setting The Buttery apart from its competitors in the Staten Island dining landscape.

While some customer reviews suggest that the price point is slightly higher for the portion size, particularly noting the single smash patty on the burger, the overwhelming consensus is that the food is "good and fresh." This is the key value proposition: you are paying for premium, fresh, and Halal-certified ingredients, along with unique preparation methods like the use of beef tallow for the fries, which results in a distinct, superior flavor.

The variety of menu items ensures there is something to satisfy every craving. Whether you are in the mood for an authentic, New York-style chopped cheese, a gourmet cheesesteak, or one of their innovative chicken sandwiches, The Buttery executes classic American fare with a meticulous, high-quality twist. For dessert lovers, the scratch-made milkshakes, especially the unique Biscoff Cookie Butter flavor, are a perfect, rich, and decadent conclusion to the meal. Ultimately, The Buttery is worth choosing for its unwavering commitment to cleanliness, excellent service, and a truly unique, Halal-focused menu that delivers on flavor and freshness, making it a valuable addition to the New York food scene.

The Buttery

1761 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314, USA