The Pie Store

- 100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043

---

Introduction / Overview

For New Jersey residents seeking the ultimate in comfort food, The Pie Store in Montclair stands out as an absolute local favorite. More than just a simple bakery, this charming establishment is a dedicated pie shop that specializes in both sweet and savory handcrafted delights, quickly becoming an essential stop for locals looking for a wholesome, high-quality meal or dessert. It’s the kind of place that greets you with the comforting, warm aroma of freshly baked goods the moment you step in, making you feel instantly at home.

The business proudly identifies as women-owned and maintains a welcoming, casual atmosphere that makes every visit a pleasant experience. While their name suggests a focus on dessert, The Pie Store offers a broad and satisfying menu that extends far beyond the typical sweet slice. Their commitment is to delivering authentic, flavorful, and filling meals, whether you're craving a rich, hearty pot pie, a flaky, handheld pasty, or a classic fruit pie that evokes nostalgia. From a quick lunch to a full family meal, The Pie Store provides delicious, ready-to-enjoy options that have earned them a loyal following throughout the Montclair community and the wider New Jersey area.

The menu balances traditional favorites with unique, globally inspired offerings. For instance, you can find the classic Chicken & Mushroom Pie alongside a Chana Masala Pasty or a Sweet Potato, Blue Cheese & Onion Pasty, catering to diverse palates. This blend of the familiar and the exciting is what makes The Pie Store a true New Jersey culinary gem.

The owners and staff at The Pie Store are known for their friendly service, ensuring customers not only leave with delicious food but also a genuinely positive experience. Their focus on quality ingredients and masterful baking techniques means every item, from their legendary crusts to their flavorful fillings, is crafted with care and passion.

---

Location and Accessibility

The Pie Store is conveniently situated in the vibrant Montclair, New Jersey area. You can find this local treasure at 100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA. Montclair is a highly accessible town in North Jersey, making the store a simple drive for residents throughout Essex County and neighboring regions.

The location on Watchung Avenue is well-known and easy to navigate for local users. For those planning to visit, the area offers a friendly, community-focused environment. While the ambiance is casual and welcoming, the store is highly efficient, perfect for a quick visit when you need to grab a meal on the go or pick up a pre-ordered item for a special occasion.

The business is also committed to serving a broad audience, fostering an atmosphere that is LGBTQ+ friendly. As a local establishment, they understand the importance of community, convenience, and providing a welcoming space for everyone in New Jersey.

---

Services Offered

The Pie Store is designed for modern convenience, offering multiple ways for New Jersey customers to enjoy their freshly baked goods. They offer service options that cover both in-person and remote transactions:

• In-store Shopping: Stop by to browse the daily selections of pies, pasties, and scones, and enjoy the inviting, casual atmosphere.
• Takeout: Perfect for locals in a hurry, you can place your order and quickly pick it up for an effortless meal at home or the office.
• In-store Pickup: Customers can conveniently order their favorite items—especially whole pies or family meals—ahead of time for a seamless and speedy pickup.
• Delivery: For those within their service area, the store offers delivery options, bringing the ultimate comfort food right to your front door.
• Onsite Services: While primarily a takeout spot, they provide services directly from their location for immediate consumption or pre-arranged orders.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts all major Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments for a fast and hassle-free checkout experience.

---

Features / Highlights

The Pie Store has built its reputation on several key features that set it apart as a premier bakery and pie shop in the New Jersey food scene:

• Women-Owned Business: A proud distinction that highlights their commitment to quality and community support.
• Specialty Savory Pies & Pasties: Known for hearty, flavorful entrees like the Chicken & Mushroom Pie, Steak, Ale & Mushroom Pie, and handheld Cornish Pasty, which are customer-favorites for lunch and dinner.
• Seasonal and Specialty Items: They offer coveted seasonal pies, such as the famous turkey pie around the holidays, which is described by customers as a “holiday miracle in pie form.”
• Diverse Savory Pocket Pasties: A convenient and unique selection of handheld savory options, including Sausage Rolls, BBQ Pork & Cheddar Pasty, and the vegetarian Chana Masala Pasty.
• Classic Sweet Pie Excellence: Their double-crust pies, such as the Double Crust Apple Pie and the Double Crust Raspberry-Blackberry-Apple Pie, are praised for having the perfect balance of sweet, tangy filling and a buttery, flaky crust.
• Homestyle Soups: A rotating menu of freshly made soups, like the Creamy Mushroom & Roasted Garlic (Vegetarian) and Carrot Ginger Soup, available in full quart size for a complete meal.
• Freshly Baked Scones: Offerings like the Extra-Sharp Cheddar Scone and Chocolate Chip Scone provide smaller, delightful baked treats.
• Community Focus: A welcoming and LGBTQ+ friendly environment, emphasizing their role as a local neighborhood institution in Montclair.

---

Contact Information

For New Jersey residents interested in placing an order or learning more about the daily specials, you can easily reach The Pie Store using the details below:

Address: 100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA

Phone: (973) 744-4424

Mobile Phone: +1 973-744-4424

---

What is Worth Choosing

If you are new to The Pie Store, you are in for a treat, and the decision on what to choose can be a delightful challenge, given the breadth of the menu. However, there are a few items that have achieved legendary status among local New Jersey customers and are definitely worth prioritizing on your first visit.

The Chicken & Mushroom Pie is often cited as a revelation. It embodies the perfect comfort food experience: tender, flavorful chicken and earthy mushrooms in a rich, savory sauce, all contained within the bakery's signature golden, flaky crust. Customers rave about its perfection, noting it's an ideal choice for a satisfying dinner or a special lunch. The savory items, in general, are a main draw, particularly the large, hearty pies and the handheld Cornish Pasty or Sausage Rolls—excellent options for a quick, filling meal.

For those with a sweet tooth, you cannot go wrong with the classic Double Crust Apple Pie. This pie is the benchmark of dessert excellence, featuring a blend of sweet and tangy apples with a hint of cinnamon, encased in that delicate, buttery crust. It’s a pure, warm hug in pie form that pairs perfectly with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Additionally, the Key Lime Pie offers a bright, tangy contrast for a lighter dessert.

What truly makes The Pie Store worth choosing is the combination of their diverse, high-quality offerings and their distinct New Jersey local business charm. Whether you need a full family-sized Shepherd’s Pie ($19.50) or a smaller indulgence like a Chocolate Chip Scone ($4.05), you’re guaranteed a product made with love and attention to detail. The ability to grab a sophisticated savory dinner, a simple handheld snack, and a dessert pie all in one welcoming, convenient location—with options for delivery, takeout, or in-store pickup—cements The Pie Store’s place as a must-visit Montclair establishment for quality comfort food in New Jersey. They offer genuine home-style cooking you don't have to make yourself.

The Pie Store

100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA