Thin Cookies - Hicksville Introduce
Thin Cookies in Hicksville has quickly established itself as a beloved local gem on Long Island, seamlessly blending the comforting appeal of a classic **Cookie shop** with the essential services of a modern **Coffee shop**. It is a destination born from passion, offering a truly unique take on a timeless dessert. Unlike the thick, cake-like varieties found at other locations, Thin Cookies specializes in a thin cookie that manages to retain a soft, chewy center and perfectly crisp edges—a balance that customers consistently rave about, describing them as highly addictive.
The establishment's appeal extends beyond its unique texture. It’s a place where quality ingredients meet exceptional customer service, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The shop proudly identifies as a **women-owned** business, adding a valuable layer of local character and entrepreneurial spirit to the Long Island community. For users across the New York region, Thin Cookies offers the perfect stop for a quick indulgence, a post-dinner **Dessert**, or a large box of treats to share with family, friends, or coworkers.
The menu is designed to cater to sweet cravings and beverage needs alike, pairing freshly baked goods with essential coffee options. Customers can enjoy a single treat in the store, utilize the **Takeout** service, or stock up with various cookie box sizes, making it versatile for any occasion from a casual pit stop to large gatherings.
The Thin Cookies shop is conveniently located at **425 Jerusalem Ave #B, Hicksville, NY 11801**. This positioning in Hicksville makes it easily reachable for residents throughout Long Island's Nassau County, serving as an accessible destination for high-quality coffee and baked goods. Its presence in a local retail hub ensures that New York users seeking a quick and quality dessert or coffee fix can find it with ease.
Accessibility is a key priority for the business, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. The location provides a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, significantly simplifying the logistics of a visit for those requiring mobility assistance. Furthermore, the premises include a **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, indicating a commitment to accommodating all members of the community. This attention to accessibility ensures that everyone can enjoy the delights of the cookie and coffee shop in a welcoming environment.
For New Yorkers on the go, the store is set up for a **Quick visit**, allowing for fast **In-store shopping** or **In-store pickup** without unnecessary delays, which is a major convenience in a busy regional area like Long Island.
Thin Cookies offers a comprehensive set of services focused on providing maximum flexibility and convenience to the local customer base, combining traditional counter service with modern delivery and pickup options.
- **Multi-Channel Service Options:** Customers have the choice of **Dine-in** for a relaxed experience, **Takeout** for convenience, **In-store pickup** for pre-orders, and **Delivery** for enjoying treats at home or the office.
- **In-Store and Onsite Services:** The shop provides **In-store shopping** for browsing the daily selections, as well as **Onsite services** for patrons using the space to relax and enjoy their purchases.
- **Specialty Dessert Offerings:** Beyond the cookies, the shop offers **Dessert** items, most notably delicious Ice Cream products. Available flavors include Vanilla, Chocolate, Dulce De Leche, and Cookies & Cream, available in single scoops or as the signature **Ice Cream Sandwich**.
- **Beverage Service:** The menu includes basic drinks such as Water, Milk, and Chocolate Milk, but most importantly, they offer high-quality **Coffee** and barista drinks to perfectly complement the cookies.
- **Flexible Payment Methods:** To ensure a smooth transaction, the shop accepts a wide range of payment options, including **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and even **Checks**.
- **Cookie Box Options:** Catering to different needs, cookies are available in bulk boxes of **6 Cookies ($11.00)**, **12 Cookies ($18.00)**, and **24 Cookies ($34.00)**, perfect for parties or stocking up.
Thin Cookies distinguishes itself in the highly competitive New York dessert and coffee market through its specialized product focus, commitment to quality, and community-minded approach.
- **The Signature "Thin, Chewy, and Crisp" Cookie:** The core highlight is the unique cookie product. Customers consistently praise the perfect balance of a **thin profile** with a moist, chewy interior and slightly crisp edges, a contrast to popular thick, undercooked cookies. Flavors typically include classics like Chocolate Chip, Double Chocolate, and Snickerdoodle, often supplemented by rotating monthly specials.
- **Women-Owned and Local:** The business proudly identifies as **women-owned**, highlighting its status as a strong, independent, and locally-rooted Long Island venture, which resonates positively with consumers who value supporting small businesses.
- **Dual Coffee and Cookie Concept:** Successfully operating as both a premium **Cookie shop** and a reliable **Coffee shop**, it offers the ideal pairing of fresh, warm treats and quality hot or cold coffee beverages, ensuring it serves multiple daily cravings.
- **Excellent Customer Service:** Real customer reviews frequently highlight the phenomenal service, including instances of thoughtful gestures like offering free samples, which contributes significantly to a welcoming and positive shopping experience.
- **Full Accessibility:** The provision of both a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot** and a **Wheelchair accessible restroom** demonstrates a high standard of public accommodation and inclusivity for the community.
- **Amenities for Comfort:** The store is equipped with **Wi-Fi** and a clean **Restroom**, providing essential amenities for customers who choose to **Dine-in** and enjoy their treats onsite.
For those in the Long Island area wishing to visit, place an order, or inquire about the unique cookie selection and coffee offerings, here is the essential contact information for Thin Cookies - Hicksville:
Address: 425 Jerusalem Ave #B, Hicksville, NY 11801
Primary Phone: (516) 744-6911
Mobile Phone: +1 516-744-6911
Choosing Thin Cookies is an intentional decision for New Yorkers who prioritize exceptional product quality, support for local, **women-owned** businesses, and a personalized dessert experience over generic chain offerings. What makes this establishment truly worth choosing is the unparalleled quality and unique texture of its signature cookie. As one customer noted, the cookies are so good and addictive that once you start, it’s hard to stop. This sentiment is a powerful endorsement of their success in creating a truly stand-out product that is "definitely better than those other cookies."
The shop’s ability to flawlessly execute the delicate balance between a **crisp edge** and a **chewy interior** sets it apart from competitors whose products often lean towards being either too crunchy or too cakey. This attention to detail in baking is the core draw, making it a must-try for any serious cookie lover in the New York metropolitan area.
Moreover, the versatility of their offerings—from the perfect coffee accompaniment to the delightful **Ice Cream Sandwich** using premium ice cream—ensures the shop meets a variety of needs. Whether you need a small box of **6 Cookies** for a casual night or a large **24 Cookies** box for a celebration, the easy access through **Delivery**, **Takeout**, and the convenient **Quick visit** model means satisfying a craving is always simple. By choosing Thin Cookies, patrons are not just buying a sweet; they are investing in a high-quality, memorable, local Long Island business.
Thin Cookies - Hicksville Food & drink
Ice Cream
- Chocolate $6.50
- Vanilla $6.50
- Ice Cream Sandwich $9.50
- Dulce De Leche $6.50
- Cookies & Cream $6.50
Boxes
- 24 Cookies $34.00
Mix and match up to 6 flavors.
- 6 Cookies $11.00
Mix and match up to 6 flavors.
- 12 Cookies $18.00
Mix and match up to 6 flavors.
Drinks
- Chocolate Milk $3.50
- Milk $3.50
- Water $2.50
Thin Cookies - Hicksville Details
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Dessert
Amenities
- Restroom
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Checks
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
Thin Cookies - Hicksville Photos










Thin Cookies - Hicksville Location
Thin Cookies - Hicksville
425 Jerusalem Ave #B, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Thin Cookies - Hicksville Reviews
chocolate chipsnickerdoodlebutteryflavorpricelatteso deliciouslightboyfriendespresso machine
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I absolutely love Thin Cookies! From their classic flavors to the fun rotating flavors of the month, everything is so delicious. Once I start eating, I can’t stop until I finish the whole thing—that’s how good they are. So addictive! Definitely a must-try for cookie lovers! 🍪
August 29 · Aleli NaI've gone to both locations at this point and the customer service, as well as the cookies themselves, have been phenomenal. My boyfriend introduced them to me and then I did the same for my mom and aunt. When I brought them here they were going back and forth about what to try, even though there are only 6 cookies at a time, and the employee gave them a free cookie to try. That was very nice of him to do and we ended up buying 12. Cookies are chewy and have crisp edges, which is not easy to do. Definitely better than those other cookies.
July 06 · Sheena O'ConnorSo I used to really enjoy thin cookies but they have gone downhill. I ordered a cookie and a unsweetened hibiscus tea. Tell me why this is what I received. No ice in my tea, watered down insanely and this took them 15 min to make. My cookie was cold considering they make everything fresh they could’ve atleast warmed it up. Not to mention there workers stare you down and when you walk it it’s a very unwelcoming environment.
June 02 · Liz WHands down the best cookies in Long Island. The cookies are light , soft and amazing. Chocolate chip is my all time favorite. I have recommended them to my friends and family and they all enjoyed. They are a great sweet go to spot in the neighborhood with the most amazing staff and owners. Service is always great and friendly. 10/10
September 10 · Asif NasimThese cookies are soo good!They are noticeably thinner than the other specialty cookie places yet filled with deliciousness. The cookies were served in a cool box that has slots to keep the cookies standing up and separately.The cookies are moist yet slightly crispy (not dry and hard like the similar looking cookies).The store is immaculately clean and the staff are friendly, attentive and quick to get your order filled.The cookies smell as delicious are they taste.
August 31 · MAJ PCAbsolutely love these thin cookies! They’re perfectly crisp, full of flavor, and totally addictive — the kind of treat you can’t stop eating. Every bite tastes homemade and fresh. Please consider opening a location in Lynbrook or Rockville Centre — we’d be your biggest fans!
October 20 · Tatiyana Ferguson
More restaurants near me
Badshah Cafe4.0 (9 reviews)520 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Dunkin'4.0 (166 reviews)538 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Lemonleaf Grill4.0 (477 reviews)536 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Bikanervala Hicksville4.0 (951 reviews)594 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Kebab House (Halal)4.0 (1276 reviews)526 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
TEDDYS DELI3.0 (33 reviews)528 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Mitran Da Dhaba ( 100% Pure Vegetarian )4.0 (232 reviews)535 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Biryani House4.0 (427 reviews)476 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Gyro Spot4.0 (300 reviews)476 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
BBQ Nite3.0 (1079 reviews)470 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Singas Famous Pizza3.0 (343 reviews)464 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Subway2.0 (131 reviews)495 S Broadway Suite 4, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
New Sunrise4.0 (175 reviews)
New China Star3.0 (89 reviews)
Dunkin'4.0 (355 reviews)
Chen Mommy Kitchen4.0 (37 reviews)
Mona Ayala4.0 (53 reviews)
Exclusive Pizza4.0 (118 reviews)Top restaurants Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts
How Vegan Restaurants Are Creating Plant-Based Comfort Foods With Gourmet Flavors
The Appeal of French Restaurants for Special Occasions
Artisan Dessert Shops with Unique Flavor Profiles
Exploring Donut Shops That Offer Unique Seasonal Flavors
How Bagel Shops Are Reinventing Classic Breakfast Foods
How Brunch Spots Are Becoming Social Media Destinations
