Tony's Pizza: A Historic Brooklyn Gem for Authentic Pizza and More

Tony's Pizza Introduce

In the rich and storied landscape of Brooklyn's culinary scene, Tony's Pizza holds a special place. It’s more than just a pizza restaurant; it’s an institution that has been a part of the neighborhood for years, a place where, as one long-time customer puts it, "they make you feel safe and at home." This establishment stands out not only for its commitment to classic New York-style pizza but also for its incredibly diverse menu that caters to virtually every taste and dietary need. The atmosphere is a perfect blend of historic charm and modern trendiness, creating a cozy and comfortable space that feels both familiar and exciting. Tony's is a true neighborhood gem, known for its high-quality food, friendly service, and a menu that goes far beyond a typical pizzeria.

The sheer breadth of Tony's Pizza's menu is one of its most impressive features. While its traditional New York-style pies and slices are a local specialty, the restaurant also serves as a comprehensive Italian restaurant, a pasta shop, and even a hamburger restaurant. Pizza aficionados will be thrilled with the unique specialty pies, which range from the savory Bacon Double Cheeseburger Pizza to the creative Macaroni & Cheese and the classic Grandma Sicilian Pizza. The menu is also incredibly accommodating for a variety of diets, with extensive vegan and vegetarian options, including a VEGAN Veggie Burger Pizza and a dedicated vegetarian lasagna. This commitment to inclusivity, which also includes Halal food options, ensures that every member of a group can find something delicious to enjoy.

Beyond pizza, Tony's offers a full range of comfort foods, from hearty appetizers like Mozzarella Sticks and Garlic Knots to satisfying baked entrees like Lasagna and Stuffed Shells. The burger selection is also noteworthy, with options like the Brooklyn's 'Best' Burger and a variety of vegan and vegetarian burgers. This expansive menu solidifies Tony's Pizza's reputation as a one-stop-shop for a satisfying meal at any time of day, whether it's breakfast, brunch, lunch, or a late-night bite.

Tony's Pizza is conveniently located at 443 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237, in the heart of a vibrant and historic neighborhood. The restaurant's location is easily accessible, and for those who drive, both free and paid street parking are available, which is a major convenience in this part of the city. For those using public transportation, the surrounding area is well-served, making it a simple journey from other boroughs. The historic building itself adds to the charm of the establishment, making a visit to Tony's feel like a step into a beloved local landmark.

The venue is also fully accessible, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, ensuring that everyone can visit comfortably. This commitment to accessibility, combined with the multiple dining and service options, makes Tony's Pizza a practical and welcoming choice for a wide variety of customers. Its presence on a busy avenue makes it a go-to spot for locals and tourists alike, cementing its status as a cornerstone of the community.

Services Offered

Delivery, Takeout, Dine-in: Tony's provides multiple ways to enjoy their food, whether you want to eat in, grab your order to go, or have it delivered directly to your door.
Catering: For larger events, Tony's offers catering services, allowing you to bring their delicious food to your party or gathering.
Counter service: The traditional counter service setup allows for quick ordering, perfect for those on a "quick bite" mission.
Private dining room: The availability of a private dining room is a great feature for hosting small, intimate events or family celebrations.

Features / Highlights

Extensive menu: From traditional pizzas and Italian entrees to burgers, salads, and an impressive selection of vegan and vegetarian options, the menu has something for everyone.
Serves local specialty: Tony's is celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza, a local specialty that it serves to perfection.
Late-night food: The restaurant offers late-night dining options, making it a reliable spot for a satisfying meal long after many other places have closed.
Family-friendly and group-friendly: The casual and cozy atmosphere, coupled with high chairs and a kids' menu, makes it a great choice for families and large groups.
Historic atmosphere: The venue has a historic feel that adds to its charm, making it a trendy and interesting place to dine.
Inclusive environment: Tony's is proudly LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safespace, ensuring a welcoming environment for all customers.

Contact Information

Address: 443 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237, USA

Phone: (718) 455-9664

Mobile Phone: +1 718-455-9664

What is worth choosing

Tony's Pizza is an excellent choice for a wide range of reasons, but its most compelling attributes are its unmatched menu variety, its commitment to inclusivity, and its long-standing reputation as a beloved community staple. While a recent customer had a negative experience regarding a pet policy—an issue that the business should address clearly—the food itself received high praise, with the customer confirming that it is "very good." This feedback aligns with another review that praises the "amazing food" and the "safe and at home" feeling the place provides. The fact that customers have been coming here since they were kids speaks volumes about the quality and consistency of the food and the overall experience.

For a single location, Tony's Pizza manages to offer the services of a full-fledged restaurant, a quick-service cafe, and a catering company. Its ability to serve high-quality Italian food, classic New York pizza, and a surprising variety of healthy, organic, vegan, and Halal options sets it apart from competitors. The historic and cozy atmosphere makes it an ideal setting for any occasion, from a solo lunch to a large family dinner. The staff's dedication to creating a welcoming environment, as highlighted by a returning customer, further solidifies its appeal. For anyone in Brooklyn, whether you're a long-time resident or a tourist looking for an authentic taste of the borough, Tony's Pizza is a destination that delivers on its promises of great food and a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Tony's Pizza Menu

Tony's Specialty Pizza Pies
For whole wheat flour add *$1.50 (PERSONAL)/ **$3.00 (MD/LG/SICILIAN) to below prices. For personal sicilian (12"), add $3.50 to personal prices. For GLUTEN FREE (14" round only) option add $4.50
Bacon Double Cheeseburger Pizza (Stuffed)
Order comes w/ French Fries or Onion Rings. Mouthwatering blend of American & mozzarella cheeses on our perfectly seasoned ground beef with crisp beef bacon bits, luscious romaine lettuce & diced tomatoes. No Bacon or Turkey Bacon options available
Bacon Cheese Fries Pizza
Seasoned curly fries with Beef or Turkey Bacon & smothered w/ Am, Cheddar & Mozz.
Baked Ziti
Al dente ziti smothered in Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Baked to perfection w/ ricotta & mozzarella cheeses & garnished w/ freshly chopped basil
BBQ or Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Tender breaded chicken marinated in BBQ or Buffalo sauce & topped w/ Sizzling mozzarella cheese
Brooklyn's Own
Tender breaded chicken, crisp pepperoni & glazed Italian sausages. Topped w/ cheddar & mozzarella cheeses & garnished w/ fresh oregano
Chicken Caesar Pizza
Crisp romaine lettuce, grilled chicken & caesar dressing
Cinco de Mayo (Mexico's Special)
Sauteed onions & jalapeno peppers w/ spicy chorizo sausage smothered in sizzling mozzarella & cheddar cheeses
Chicken Parmigiana
Diced chicken cutlet topped with Tony's prized zesty garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce & fresh mozzarella cheese
Cinque Formaggi Pizza (No Sauce)
Blend of mozzarella, cheddar, Mont. Jack, Pecorino Romano & ricotta
Bacon, Egg & Cheese - or Ham - Hashed Browns Pizza (Stuffed)
Shredded hashed browns w/ eggs, American cheese, bacon or ham
Grandma Sicilian Pizza (Thin Crust)
Home-made fresh mozzarella cheese & blend of Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano tomato sauce w/ roasted garlic, basil & olive oil base
Gyro Pizza (Beef/Lamb or Chicken)
Beef/lamb or chicken gyro strips with tomato, lettuce & tzatziki sauce
Ham and Cheese Triple Decker Pizza
Smoked, BLK Forest, & Virg. ham with/sizzling Am. cheese & Mozz.
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham & crushed pineapple topped w/ mozz. cheese
Lasagna Pizza
Layers of lasagna noodles, meat sauce & sizzling mozzarella, ricotta, & parmesan cheeses topped w/ Tony's specially made garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Classically seasoned & baked to perfection
Macaroni & Cheese
Classic macaroni smothered in cheddar & Mozzarella Cheeses
Margherita
Tony's specially made garlic & basil San-Mazano marinara sauce & fresh mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection & garnished w/ fresh basil and Pecorino Romano cheese (crust glazed with extra-origin olive oil)
Mediterranean Pizza
Falafel & tabouli with freshly made hummus
New Yorker
Freshly diced portobello mushrooms, glazed Italian sausages, crisp pepperoni & Tony's house sauce. Topped w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese
Pastrami & Swiss
Mildly smoked pastrami sliced & cooked to perfection. Topped w/ crisp bacon, sauteed red onions, Swiss, Mont. Jack & mozzarella cheeses
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (Stuffed)
Our prized hand-made pizza shell stuffed w/ sauteed onions, thinly sliced steak & sizzling Mozzarella & American cheeses
Pico de Gallo Pizza
Chopped blend of chili peppers, cilantro & Roma tomatoes topped w/ avocado & mozz. cheese. Add grilled chicken or chicken cutlet $3.25*/$5.50**/$6.50***
Popcorn Shrimp Pizza (or Buffalo Shrimp)
Seasoned Shrimps with sizzling mozzarella & cheddar cheeses
Potato Lover's Pizza
Seasonal mashed potatoes, crisp bacon & mozzarella & cheddar cheeses
Roast Beef & Cheddar Pizza
Seasonal roast beef, sauteed red onion & crisp bacon topped with mozzarella & cheddar cheeses
Sicilian
Tony's prized San-Marzano sauce topped w/sizzling mozzarella cheese
Taco Pizza
Seasoned ground beef, crisp romaine lettuce & freshly chopped tomatoes smothered in sizzling cheddar & mozzarella cheeses
Ti Amo Dessert Pizza
Nutella chocolate smothered with strawberries & marshmallows
Traditional New York-Style Neapolitan Pizza
San-Morzano Tomato Sauce topped w/ sizzling Mozzarella Cheese
Tuna Melt Pizza
Seasoned tuna with tomatoes, romaine lettuce, carrots & mayo
Upside Down Sicilian
San-Marzano marinara sauce over sizzling fresh mozzarella cheese
Veggie Lovers Pizza
Chopped blend of vegan vegetables topped with hummus
VEGAN Veggie Burger Pizza (Stuffed)
Chopped blend of vegetables, vegan American and Mozzarella cheeses and vegan bacon
White (Cheese Only) Pizza
Seasonal blend of mozzarella & ricotta cheeses. Cherry tomatoes optional
MVP
Tony's specially made garlic & basil spicy San-Mazano marinara sauce, vodka sauce, pesto sauce & fresh mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection & garnished w/ fresh basil and Pecorino Romano cheese (crust glazed with extra-origin olive oil)
Egg & Cheese - Stuffed Pizza
Shredded hashed browns w/ eggs and American cheese
Stella D'Oro Pizza
Specially made garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce, glazed Italian sausages, thinly sliced ham and soppressata, fresh mozzarella & shaved Pecorino Romano cheeses. Garnished w/fresh oregano.

Traditional Slices & Pies
Traditional Slices & Pies

Add 1 Topping
Slice/Silician
Personal 14" Pies
Md/Sicilian 16" pies
Large 20" Pies

Meats / Seafood
Anchovies***
Bacon Bits**
BBQ Chicken***
for organic, add $3
Buffalo Chicken**
Calamari****
grilled / breaded
Chicken Cutlet**
for organic, add $3
Chorizo**
Clams****
sauteed
Crab Meat****
Genoa Salami**
Grilled Chicken**
Ground Beef***
Gyro***
beef or chicken
Ham*
Lobster Meat****
Meatballs*
Muscles****
steamed
Pancetta***
Beef Pepperoni**
Prosciutto di Parma***
Sausage
sweet or spicy
Scallops****
grilled
Shrimp****
grilled / breaded
Soppressata***
Steak***
Tilapia****
Tofu*
grilled
Turkey
Veal Cutlet****
Vegetarian Sausage***
Pepperoni*

Veggies, Herbs, Fruits & Seeds
Artichokes*
Arugula
Avocado**
Basil
Black Olives
Broccoli
Brussels Sprouts*
roasted
Calabrian Chili*
Capers*
Chia Seeds*
Corn
Egg
diced
Eggplant
Figs**
Garlic*
roasted
Garlic*
sauteed
Chickpeas*
Jalapeno Peppers*
Kale
Mushrooms
Onions
sauteed
Pepperoncini*
Pineapple
crusted
Porcini Mushrooms*
Portobello Mushrooms*
Potatoes*
mashed
Radicchio*
Red Cabbage*
Red Onions
Roasted Peppers*
Scallions
Shiitake Mushrooms*
Spanish
sauteed
Sun-dried Tomatoes*
Sweet Potato**
mashed
Tomatoes
roma
Walnuts*
roasted
Wheat Grass**
White Truffle Oil**
drizzle
Zucchini*
grilled

Cheeses
American*
Buffalo**
Cheddar*
Feta**
Fresh Mozzarella**
Goat**
Gorgonzola**
Grana Padano***
shaved
Jalapeno**
Mt. Jack
Mascarpone**
Mozzarella*
Muenster**
Pecorino Romano**
Peperoncino**
Provolone**
Ricotta*
Swiss**
Vegan**
mozz. or cheddar

Sauces
Alfredo Sauce*
Artichoke Spinach Cream Sauce*
Bolognese Sauce**
Carbonara Sauce**
San-Marzano Marinara
San-Marzano Pizza Sauce
Meat Sauce**
Pesto**
Vodka Sauce*

Tony's Freshly Grilled Burgers
Add Cheese (For Vegan Cheese add additional $1.50 to price); Add Deluxe: freshly chopped organic lettuce, tomatoes, onions & crisp French, curly, sweet potato or waffle fries - $3
Burger $7.75
Tony's freshly-made and seasoned 1/2 pound Angus beef or turkey burger on kaiser roll
Bacon Burger $8.75
Tony's freshly-made & seasoned 1/2 pound Angus beef or turkey burger w/ crisp bacon on kaiser roll
Tony's Italian-Style Pizza Burger $9.00
1/2 lb. beef or turkey burger or kaiser roll smothered in San-Marzano Marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese
Brooklyn's 'Best' Burger $11.75
1/2 lb. seasoned Angus Beef burger w/ sizzling ham, egg & hash brown
Bacon Double Cheeseburger Slice $7.50
Special: order comes w/ small fries
Vegan Veggie Burger $12.50
Freshly-made Plant-based meat (BEYOND MEAT)
Veggie Burger $7.75
Freshly chopped blend of Vegetables Burger

Premium Salads - Step #1
Choose Your Greens
Arugula, Crisp Romaine, Iceberg, Kale, Mixed Greens, Radicchio, Red Cabbage, Spinach, Wheat Grass (ADD $2.00)
Caesar Salad
Add $2.75; Shaved Parmesan, Romaine Lettuce, Croutons (Herb)
Garden Salad
Add $3; Red Onions, Cucumbers, Carrots, Roma Tomatoes

Premium Salad - Step #2
Toss-In Selection $0.75
Beets / Broccoli, Carrots / Celery / Chick Peas, Cucumbers / Green Peas, Mixed Beans, Mushrooms, Portobello Mushrooms, Radish / Raisins / Red Onions, Roma Tomatoes, Shiitake Mushrooms, Tri-colored Peppers, Walnuts
Toss-in Choices #2 $2.00
Avocado, Bacon Bits, Blue Cheese, Brussels Sprouts (roasted), Banana Chips (dried), Cauliflower / Cheddar / Chia Seeds, Coconut-Crusted Cashews, Capers / Cheddar Cheese, Eggplant / Feta Cheese, Coconut (dried) / Figs, Egg (hard boiled), Egg-whites, Fennel, Fresh Mozzarella, Granola, Muenster / Pepperoncini Cheese, Mango (dried), Mont. Jack Cheese, Pepperoncini, Pineapple (dried) / Pistachios, Roasted Peppers, Sharp Provolone Cheese, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Swiss Cheese
Toss-in Choices #3 $1.00
Asparagus / Artichoke, Capers, Cherry Tomatoes, Cherries (Dried), Corn / Cranberries, Croutons (Multi-Grain), Jalapeno Peppers, Kalamata Olives, Olives (Black or Spanish), Sesame Seeds, Sun-dried Tomatoes, Zucchini
Toss-in Choices #4 $3.50
Buffalo Cheese / Bire Cheese, Chicken (Buffalo or BBQ), Chicken (Cutlet or Grilled), Goat Cheese, Gorgonzola Cheese, Grana Padano (Shaved), Ham / Meatballs, Prosciutto / Salami, Sausage / Shrimp, Scallops (Grilled), Sopressata / Tilapia (Chipotle), Tofu (Grilled), Tuna / Smoked Turkey, Vegan Mozz. or Cheddar Cheese, Vegetarian Sausage
Toss-in Choice #5 $5.50
VEGAN Chicken, VEGAN Meatballs, VEGAN Sausage

Premium Salad - Step #3
Choose Dressing
Balsamic Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese, Cole Slaw, Caesar, Creamy Italian, Ex. Virgin Olive Oil Vinegar, French, Italian, Italian (fat free), Lemon Herb, Ranch, Russian, Sesame Seed oil, Thousand Island, Tartar, Truffle Oil, Wheat Grass Vinaigrette

Tony's Hearty Appetizers
Antipasto Salad
Tossed choice of salad topped with choice of Italian cold cuts & cheeses. Served w/Roasted Garlic Bread Stick.
Artichoke Flowers (3) (Grilled or Breaded) $13.50
Seasoned Artichokes (grilled or breaded) in white wine butter sauce.
Bacon Cheese Fries
Seasoned French Fries topped w/ crisp bacon bits & smothered in sizzling choice of cheeses
Baked Clams Oreganata
Little neck clams baked to perfection with seasoned bread crumbs in a sultry butter-based lemon sauce
Beef Pattie $3.50
Mild Jamaican meat (beef) pattie
Broccoli Rabe $10.25
Sauteed broccoli rabe in a garlic and extra-virgin olive oil sauce
Bruschetta Pomodoro $7.50
Toasted Italian bread served with traditional Italian topping of chopped fresh garlic, Roma tomatoes, fresh basil & extra-virgin olive oil
Calamari Fritti $11.75
Golden fried calamari served w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce
Chicken Thumbs $10.50
Tender chicken thumbs served w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce
Chicken Tenders $10.50
Boneless chicken tenders (6) served w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce
Chicken Roll $6.50
Diced tender breaded chicken smothered in mozzarella cheese & Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce
Eggplant Rollatini $14.50
Breaded eggplant (3) rolled to perfection with seasoned ricotta, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses. Topped with marinara sauce & sizzling mozzarella cheese
French Fries
Fried Ravioli $10.75
Freshly prepared breaded ravioli (10) fried to perfection & served w/ San-Marzano based marinara sauce
Garlic Bread
Freshly baked Italian hero or roll topped w/ roasted garlic & extra-virgin olive oil. Seasoned & toasted to perfection
Garlic Knots $3.50
Freshly baked knots (6) in a fresh garlic & extra-virgin olive oil sauce. Seasoned to perfection
Hot Dog (Combo Special) $7.75
Grilled Hot Dog (2) served w/ fries or chips
Hot Dog Mini Rolls (6) $3.75
Pizza dough rolled w/ mini hot dog & blend of mozzarella & American cheeses. Baked to perfection
Knish $3.50
Seasoned potato pattie baked to perfection
Mini Phillies (Combo Special) $8.25
Two Mini Philly Cheese Steak sandwiches served w/ fries or chips
Mozzarella Sticks $8.25
Seasoned mozzarella cheese sticks (6) served w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce
Onion Rings $5.50
Golden fried onion rings served with choice of sauces
Pepperoni Wheel $3.50
Pizza dough rolled with crisp pepperoni or spinach & sizzling mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection
Pizza Fries
Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce & sizzling mozzarella cheese
Pizza Sub $4.25
Freshly baked-Italian hero topped with Tony's prized garlic & basil based sauce & sizzling mozzarella cheese
Quesadilla $9.95
Tortilla / Flat Bread toasted w/ grilled chicken, bell peppers & onions, mozzarella & Am. cheese. Baked to perfection
Rice Ball (2) (Arancini) $4.75
Ball of rice filled with meat sauce and peas. Seasoned to perfection
Sausage & Peppers Roll $6.50
Glazed Italian sausages w/ sauteed onions & bell peppers smothered in sizzling mozzarella cheese
Sesame Seed & Roasted Garlic / Onion Cheese Twists $1.75
seasoned cheese twists
Shrimp Cocktail $15.50
Freshly breaded tiger shrimp (6) fried to perfection & served w/ San-Marzano based marinara sauce
Shrimp (Buffalo or BBQ Style) $14.50
Spicy Buffalo / BBQ - popcorn style shrimp served with blue cheese dipping sauce and celery stix
Sliders (Combo Special) $8.00
Mini Cheese Burger / Meatballs sliders (2) served w/ fries or chips
Stuffed Mushrooms $10.50
Shapely mushrooms filled with sultry blend of seasoned breadcrumbs, Pecorino Romano, garlic, parsley and extra-virgin olive oil. Topped w/ a Southern Italian vegetable mix
Wings (Regular of Buffalo Style) $13.75
(spicy or mild) Buffalo (8) served with bleu cheese dipping sauce and celery stix
Zeppoles
Classic Italian battered dough balls (6) served with powdered sugar
BBQ Wings $15.75
BBQ Wings (8) served with bleu cheese dipping sauce and celery stix

Tony's Hearty Calzones
Calzone order comes with complimentary side of Tony's San-Marzano based garlic and basil based marinara sauce
Calzone $8.25
blend of sizzling mozzarella and seasoned ricotta cheese
Calzone $10.50
w/ any one Meat topping
Calzone $10.00
w/ any one Veggies & Herb topping
Lasagna Calzone $10.75
lasagna noodles, blend of sizzling mozzarella and ricotta cheese & seasoned meat sauce

Baked Entrees
Gnocchi
Italian-style potato dumplings w/ our San-Marzano marinara sauce & mozzarella
Lasagna (See Vegetable Entrees for Vegetarian Lasagna)
Layers of lasagna noodles, meat sauce & mozzarella, ricotta & parmesan cheeses classically seasoned & topped w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese & garnished w/ fresh parsley
Manicotti
Manicotti can be stuffed w/ any type of meat, seafood or vegetable for additional cost. Ricotta and parmesan cheeses & herbs baked in freshly made pasta rolls & topped w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese & garnished w/ fresh parsley
Ravioli
Freshly made beef, cheese, portobello mushroom, roasted vegetable or spinach ravioli served in your choice of sauce & baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese
Stuffed Shells
Shells can be stuffed w/ any type of meat, seafood or vegetable for additional cost. Freshly made pasta shells stuffed w/ seasoned ricotta cheese & topped w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara. Baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese & garnished w/ fresh parsley
Tortellini
Freshly made beef or cheese tortellini served in your choice of sauce of sauce & baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese
Ziti, Rigatoni, Spaghetti, Penne, Linguini or Fettuccine Parmigiana
Freshly made pasta w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese. Garnished w/ fresh parsley

Pasta Entrees
Add: Meat Sauce or Chicken (Platter) $4.50, (1/2 Tray - 6-8 People) $20, (Full Tray - 10-14 People) $35; Add choice of Cheese (Platter) $1.50, Catering Platter - (1/2 Tray - 6-8 People) $10, Catering Platter - (Full Tray - 10-14 People) $20
Arrabiata
Spicy San-Marzano based marinara sauce w/ chopped blend of spices
Alfredo
Classic parmigiano-reggiano cream sauce (pink sauce upon request)
All' Aglio e Olio (Garlic and Oil)
Freshly chopped garlic sauteed in seasoned Extra - Virgin Olive Oil
Alla Bolognese
Southern Italian-style meat sauce w/ a touch of parmigiano-reggiano cream & herb
Alla Carbonara
Minced onions, pancetta (bacon) & egg yolk in parmesan based cream sauce
Alla Marinara
Classic garlic & basil based San-Morzano sauce
Alla Pesto
Classic and savory pesto sauce w/ chopped blend of basil, garlic, parmesan cheese, pine nuts & extra-virgin olive oil
Alla Romano
Tony's classic parmesan based cream sauce, peas & prosciutto
Alla Vodka
Smooth parmesan-based cream sauce w/ a sultry blend of vodka. San-Marzano based tomato sauce, mushrooms, Italian bacon & herbs

Vegetable Entrees
Add choice of Cheese (Platter w / pasta) $1, (Hero) $0.75, (Roll) $0.50, Catering Platter - (1/2 Tray - 6-8 People) $10, Catering Platter - (Full Tray - 10-14 People) $20
Broccoli, Broccoli Rabe or Spinach All' Aglio e Olio (Garlic & Oil)
Sauteed Broccoli or spinach in Extra Virgin Olive Oil & freshly chopped garlic
Eggplant
Lightly breaded eggplant topped w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce
Potatoes, Peppers, Onions and Eggs
Potato medley, bell peppers, onions & eggs (2) cooked & seasoned to perfection
Primavera
Sauteed garden vegetables in a cherry tomato cream sauce or garlic sauce w/ fresh mozzarella
Vegetarian Lasagna
baked with mozzarella cheese

Chicken or Veal
For Veal: Add to listed price - (Platter) $5.50, (Hero) $3.50, (Roll) $2, Catering Platter - (1/2 Tray - 6-8 People) $35, Catering Platter - (Full Tray - 10-14 People) $55; Add choice of Cheese (Platter) $1.50, (Hero) $1, (Roll) $0.50, Catering Platter - (1/2 Tray - 6-8 People) $10, Catering Platter - (Full Tray - 10-14 People) $20; Note: Chicken in below entries can be substituted for any other type of meat (except veal) at no additional cost
Chicken Alla Palermo
Sauteed cutlets & broccoli (or spinach) in Tony's garlic based cream sauce. Tossed w/ parmesan cheese fresh mozzarella & topped w/ a touch of lemon sauce
Chicken Cutlet (Served without Pasta)
Tender breaded cutlets served with or without lettuce & Romano tomatoes (grilled chicken upon request)
Chicken Florentina
Sauteed tender cutlets, sauteed spinach & fresh mozzarella cheese tossed in a creamy pink sauce
Chicken Francese
Battered cutlets in a buttery white-wine lemon sauce
Chicken Marinara
Perfectly breaded cutlets topped w / Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce
Chicken Marsala
Tender cutlets sauteed w / mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce
Chicken Pizzaiola
Sauteed tender cutlets, sauteed onions & bell peppers tossed w / fresh mozzarella & Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce
Chicken Primavera
Sauteed tender cutlets, fresh mozzarella, bell peppers, onions, spinach, broccoli, cherry tomatoes & mushrooms in a boldly arrabiata (spicy) basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce

Meat
Add choice of cheese: (Platter) $1, (Hero) $0.75, (Roll) $0.50, Catering Platter - (1/2 Tray - 6-8 People) $10, Catering Platter - (Full Tray - 10-14 People) $20
Alla Palermo
Glazed sweet Italian sausage & sauteed broccoli in Tony's garlic based cream sauce. Tossed w/ Parmesan cheese, fresh mozzarella & topped w/ a touch of lemon sauce
Bolognese (Meat Sauce)
Seasoned ground beef in a Southern Italian style cream sauce (spicy upon request)
Sausages
Glazed sweet Italian sausages w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce (spicy upon request)
Meatballs
Perfectly baked home-made meatballs topped w/ garlic & basil based San-Marzano Marinara Sauce (spicy upon request)
Philly Cheesesteak
All Platter served with garlic stix. Thinly sliced steak, sauteed onions & sizzling mozzarella & Am. cheeses. Served w/ out pasta

Seafood
Add choice of Cheese: (Platter) $1, (Hero) $0.75, (Roll) $0.50, Catering Platter - (1/2 Tray - 6-8 People) $10, Catering Platter - (Full Tray - 10-14 People) $20
Calamari, Clams, Mussels, Scallops, Shrimp or Tilapia Scampi
Sauteed in a white wine-based buttery lemon sauce. Dish garnished w/ freshly chopped parsley
Calamari, Clams, Mussels, Scallops, Shrimp or Tilapia Marinara
Served in Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce (spicy upon request). Dish garnished w/ freshly chopped parsley
Calamari, Clams, Mussels, Scallops, Shrimp or Tilapia Primavera
Served w/ sauteed bell peppers, onions, cherry tomatoes, broccoli, spinach & mushrooms. Dish garnished w/ freshly chopped parsley
Calamari, Clams, Mussels, Scallops, Shrimp or Tilapia
Buttery garlic & oil cream sauce

Desserts, Milkshakes & Smoothies
Cakes $6.95
Assorted and freshly baked
Cannoli/Choc. Cannoli
Freshly-baked & filled
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries (6) $15.00
Freshly Baked Choc. Chip Cookies $2.50
Fresh Fruit Salad
Gelato
Assorted
Milkshakes
Vanilla/Strawberry/Chocolate

Coffee Bar
Coffee/Tea
Iced Coffee/Tea
Espresso $3.50
Hot Chocolate

Beverages
Snapple/Gatorade $2.75
Assorted
Jaritos $3.00
Assorted
2 Liter Sodas $4.00
Assorted
Tropicana / Apple Juice $3.25
Bottles Water $2.25
San Pellegrino
Bottled Sodas $3.00
Coke, Sprite or Fanta
Soda $1.50
Can

Tony's Pizza Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Great coffee
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Halal food
Healthy options
Late-night food
Organic dishes
Private dining room
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Historic
Trendy

Crowd
College students
Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free street parking
Paid street parking
Parking

Tony's Pizza Photos

Tony's Pizza Location

Tony's Pizza

New York Kings County Bushwick Knickerbocker Avenue

443 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237, USA

Tony's Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 1664 user reviews.

garlic knotsbest pizzazeppolesgelatosicilian sliceTVvodkaoreosvegan pizzatransformers

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Today I had a very bad experience at this place. I'm a regular customer; I come here at least once a week, and I've come here several times with my dog. Today I received a comment from an employee waiting for us to eat, telling us that the dog had to wait outside. He's a small emotional support dog. He's very well-behaved. The employee saw us come in, took our order, and everything. However, he waited until we were seated to eat before telling us that the dog had to wait outside. This place didn't specify anywhere that pets weren't allowed. In fact, they have pet-friendly utensils, which seems illogical to me if they don't allow them. I'm not criticizing the food because it's very good, and my family and I really enjoyed it. But today we had a very bad experience with our pet.
August 26 · Melina Miranda
Tony’s pizza never disappoints such an amazing gem 💎 with amazing food and they make you feel safe and at home. I love this spot since a kid !!
August 19 · priscilla pagan
The slices were huge!! $5 per specialty sliceVery delicious, cheesy and the sauce had a hint of sweetness to it!So many varieties to choose from!The service was super fast and & friendly Staffs 😊It was house full when I went in on a Friday afternoon
June 20 · Shajeentha Sabaratnam
Wow wow wow! My grandmother was the first person to introduce me to Tony’s years ago. It was a great memory being in her neighborhood eating the best pizza in Brooklyn! The pizza and Sicilian were fresh, delicious and the right amount of heat.
May 08 · Emerald Green
Excellent vegan pizza! You can create individual slices with whatever toppings they have (vegan chicken, sausage, pepperoni, cheese + regular pizza toppings). They are made to order. Crust was doughy and crunchy but not too thick. I got one veggie and one sausage. The slices are huge and around $6 each. My partner enjoyed his non-vegan pizza as well. They have vegan desserts but they didn’t look great. The people working there were so helpful and nice explaining how the vegan options work. Bathroom was clean. Definitely recommend.
October 17 · Erica M