$1.50 Hot Pizza

- 255 Livingston St, Brooklyn, NY 11217

When the craving for a classic New York slice hits, but your wallet whispers caution, New Yorkers know exactly where to turn for the best intersection of quality, speed, and incredible value. Located in the bustling heart of Downtown Brooklyn, $1.50 Hot Pizza has firmly established itself as a local culinary hero, a true "hidden gem" that delivers on its name's promise and then some. This casual, no-frills establishment is more than just a quick stop—it’s a reliable destination for comfort food that remains consistently fresh and satisfying.

In a city famous for its pizza, but increasingly infamous for its high prices, $1.50 Hot Pizza stands out as a beacon of affordability. It captures the true, old-school spirit of a neighborhood slice shop, providing a delicious, authentic experience without the premium cost. For residents, students, and commuters in the New York area, this spot is an indispensable part of the daily routine, offering a quick, hot, and satisfying meal from a friendly local business. Whether you’re running between meetings, grabbing lunch on a budget, or feeding the whole family, this Brooklyn staple ensures you never have to compromise on taste or value.

The focus here is simple: great pizza, fast service, and unbeatable prices. Customer testimonials often praise the quality of the cheese and sauce, the perfect crispness of the crust, and the warm, friendly demeanor of the staff. It’s the kind of place that becomes an instant favorite, earning repeat business from people who appreciate its honest, straightforward approach to one of the city's most beloved foods. In a vibrant neighborhood like Downtown Brooklyn, the ability to find a fresh, crispy margarita slice right out of the oven for such a low price is a rare and celebrated find. It's a true slice of New York life—accessible, authentic, and delicious.

Location and Accessibility

The key to $1.50 Hot Pizza's popularity with the Downtown Brooklyn crowd is its prime and highly accessible location. Situated at 255 Livingston St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, the shop is a cornerstone of the neighborhood, perfectly positioned for anyone navigating the central Brooklyn area. The address places it near major transportation hubs, making it an ideal stop for commuters heading to or from work, or anyone needing a rapid meal before catching a train. Its proximity to major thoroughfares and subway lines ensures that grabbing a fresh slice is incredibly convenient, fitting perfectly into the fast pace of New York life.

For those traveling by public transit, the location is a dream, often described by customers as the perfect last stop before jumping on the A train or other local lines. While dedicated parking is not a feature, visitors can typically find paid street parking options nearby, as is standard for a busy metropolitan area like Downtown Brooklyn. The casual atmosphere of the shop makes it a welcoming spot for all, whether you're taking your meal to go or utilizing the limited seating for a quick bite. This combination of central location and easy accessibility solidifies $1.50 Hot Pizza as a premier local takeout choice.

Services Offered

$1.50 Hot Pizza specializes primarily in Pizza Takeout, ensuring every order is handled quickly and efficiently, catering to the needs of busy New Yorkers. The establishment's core focus is on providing comfort food and a quick bite option for both lunch and dinner.

• Wide Variety of Pizza Toppings: The shop offers a robust menu of 18 different pizza varieties, ensuring options for every taste and preference.
• Specialty Sides: Beyond pizza, the menu includes popular local favorites like various Beef Patties (plain, with cheese, or with cheese & pepperoni) and Buffalo Wings, allowing for a more complete meal.
• Dessert Options: Satisfy your sweet tooth with a classic Brownie for $3.50.
• Comprehensive Drink Selection: A full range of refreshments, from Can Soda ($1.50) and Bottle Soda ($2.50) to Gatorade ($2.50), Snapple ($2.50), Red Bull ($3.50), and Haritos ($3.50), are available.
• Dining Flexibility: Though geared toward takeout, the location offers casual dining options for both lunch and dinner.
• Multiple Payment Methods: Customers can easily pay using major Credit Cards and Debit Cards.

Features / Highlights

$1.50 Hot Pizza distinguishes itself in the highly competitive New York pizza market through a few critical features that resonate strongly with the local community.

• Unbeatable Value: The price point, especially for the plain cheese slice, is a significant draw, often highlighted in local reviews as a reason to choose this spot over competitors like Joe's Pizza. Customers note the incredible value of getting a quality, fresh slice for just $1.50, or a whole meal (like a pie and three drinks for around $16) at exceptionally low costs.
• High-Quality Slice: Despite the budget-friendly price, the pizza maintains a high standard of quality. Reviewers specifically mention the "crispy on the bottom, cheesy on the top" texture and the rich tomato sauce, confirming its status as a legitimately great New York slice.
• Extensive Topping Menu: The selection of 18 different full-pie options—including favorites like BBQ Chicken Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Mix Vegetables Pizza, and Sausage With Pepperoni Pizza—caters to diverse dietary preferences and cravings.
• Authentic Vibe and Service: The atmosphere is described as "Old school, no frills," offering a comfortable and casual setting. The friendly staff, particularly the main pizzaiolo, is a consistent point of praise from loyal customers, enhancing the overall experience.
• Convenience for Families: The shop is explicitly noted as being "Good for kids," making it a hassle-free and affordable dining option for families in the neighborhood.
• Hot and Fresh Guarantee: Customers frequently report getting "a fresh margarita out the oven," a testament to the high turnover and commitment to serving hot pizza.

Contact Information

For Downtown Brooklyn residents and visitors, $1.50 Hot Pizza is easy to find and contact.

Address: 255 Livingston St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

Phone: (718) 802-1942

What is Worth Choosing

While the entire menu at $1.50 Hot Pizza offers fantastic value, the true stars of the show—and what most New Yorkers line up for—are the basics. The plain Cheese Slice is the quintessential choice; its reputation for being crispy, cheesy, and having a rich tomato sauce at an unbeatable price is what defines this establishment. It’s the perfect, rapid-fire comfort food that is ideal for a quick lunch or an afternoon pick-me-up.

For those looking to expand beyond the classic, the Pepperoni Pizza is a highly recommended and affordable upgrade. Likewise, the specialty pies like the BBQ Chicken Pizza and the Mix Vegetables Pizza offer excellent ways to satisfy a specific craving while still benefiting from the shop's budget-friendly pricing, with full pies starting as low as $8.99. Don't overlook the popular side items either; the savory Beef Patties and the selection of Buffalo Wings make for a satisfying complement to your pizza order. Ultimately, what is truly worth choosing is the experience of great, classic New York pizza that proves high quality doesn't have to mean a high cost. It’s an essential piece of Downtown Brooklyn's local food scene.

$1.50 Hot Pizza

255 Livingston St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA