4 Bros Pizza: Your Must-Try Local Pizza Gem in New Rochelle, NY

4 Bros Pizza Introduce

Welcome to 4 Bros Pizza, a shining example of the vibrant local food scene in New Rochelle, New York. More than just a pizza joint, this is a destination for Westchester County locals and visitors alike who appreciate quality ingredients, inventive menus, and a truly welcoming atmosphere. Born from a passion for the perfect slice, 4 Bros Pizza has quickly become a community hub, living up to its dedication to delivering 'the perfect crunch' with every order. Whether you're a long-time resident of New Rochelle, a student at a nearby college, or a tourist exploring the area, 4 Bros Pizza offers a comfortable, casual dining experience that caters to all tastes and crowds, including being LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space.

The restaurant proudly specializes in a wide array of options beyond the classic New York slice. Their menu is thoughtfully curated to provide comfort food favorites alongside unique, gourmet creations. From their signature Square Pizzas, like the Amore Vegetale or the highly-anticipated 'Loaded New Yorker,' to incredible pasta dishes, loaded fries, and satisfying sandwiches—there's always something new and delicious to try. The commitment to variety extends to offering an impressive selection of plant-based eats, ensuring everyone can find a meal they love. It's a professional and friendly establishment where every customer feels right at home, making it a true local gem in the heart of New Rochelle.

Location and Accessibility

4 Bros Pizza is centrally located at 23 S Division St, New Rochelle, NY 10805, USA. This prime New Rochelle address makes it highly accessible for the local community and those traveling through Westchester County. Its proximity to major thoroughfares and local landmarks ensures it’s an easy stop for lunch, dinner, or a quick bite.

Accessibility is a key focus at 4 Bros Pizza. The establishment is designed to be welcoming to all patrons, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, and wheelchair accessible seating. Parking options are also varied and convenient, with free street parking, paid parking lots, and paid street parking available nearby. The atmosphere is casual, making it an ideal spot for everyone from families and college students to solo diners and tourists. Furthermore, for those who enjoy dining with their pets, dogs are allowed in the outside seating area.

Services Offered

Dine-in: Enjoy the casual and friendly atmosphere in-house, with dedicated seating available for lunch and dinner.
Delivery and Takeout: Convenient options are available, including no-contact delivery, to enjoy their great food in the comfort of your home or office.
Counter Service: Quick and efficient service for those on a tight schedule.
Outdoor Seating: A great option for enjoying a meal on a nice day, including accommodating for pets (dogs allowed outside).
Catering: Services are offered for larger orders, perfect for parties, corporate events, or family gatherings.

Features / Highlights

Extensive Menu Variety: Offering more than just traditional pizza, the menu includes Wings (like the Bro Wings), a full range of Pastas (e.g., Vodka Pasta, Spaghetti & Meatballs), Entrees (including Vodka Chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant Rollatini Entree), Salads, and Desserts (such as Tiramisu and Nutella Pizza).
Specialty Pizza Selection: A wide variety of both Small (12" Round), Large (16" Round), and Square Pizzas are available, featuring unique pies like the 'Sweet Diavola,' 'Marsala Tartufo,' 'Arugula Di Parma,' and the decadent 'Fig & 3 Cheese' pizza.
Unique Hand-Cut Fries: A stand-out category featuring creative options such as Birria Fries, Vodka Parmesan Fries, Truffle Parmesan Fries, and Mike’s Hot Honey Fries.
Impressive Plant-Based Eats: A full section of the menu is dedicated to plant-based options, including specialty pizzas like 'The New Yorker, Plant-Based' and 'Amore Vegetale, Plant-Based,' and a Plant Based Slice, catering to vegetarian and vegan diets.
Late-Night Food and Quick Bites: Popular for lunch and dinner, the restaurant also provides late-night food options and quick bites for those with a craving at any hour.
Sandwich and Appetizer Excellence: Customer reviews highlight the quality of their Sandwiches, with one regular praising 'The Classic 4 Bros sandwich' and the 'divine - house made' bread. Appetizers like Loaded Garlic Knots and Loaded Calzone offer satisfying starters.

Contact Information

Address: 23 S Division St, New Rochelle, NY 10805, USAPhone: (914) 355-5178 or +1 914-355-5178

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing 4 Bros Pizza means opting for a consistently high-quality, memorable meal experience rooted in the spirit of New Rochelle. What truly sets this establishment apart is the blend of traditional Italian-American comfort food with a modern, inventive twist. The sheer depth of the menu, from specialty Square Pizzas to the distinct selection of Hand-Cut Fries and the impressive dedication to Plant-Based options, ensures there is a compelling dish for every palate and dietary need.

Local customers consistently praise the friendly staff, which a large party of 12 noted were 'amazing in accommodating us.' The commitment to a welcoming environment is evident in their designation as an LGBTQ+ friendly space. Ultimately, whether you are seeking 'the perfect crunch' in a slice of pizza, a comforting pasta dish, or a unique sandwich experience like the beloved Classic 4 Bros sandwich, this New Rochelle spot delivers on its promise of great food and community value. Their status as a local 'definite gem' is well-earned and makes it a must-visit for anyone in the New York region.

The unique fusion items, like the Birria Fries and the variety of Mike's Hot Honey-infused items (Bro Wings, Sweet Diavola Pizza), demonstrate a willingness to innovate while maintaining the high standards of a classic New York pizzeria. For a taste of professional dedication and community warmth, look no further than 4 Bros Pizza for your next meal.

The hours of operation are generally in the afternoon and evening, catering to the lunch, dinner, and late-night crowds. While specific hours can vary, the restaurant is known to open around noon and typically serves until 8:45 PM or later, with delivery and pickup windows running within those times. Always confirm the current hours directly, but the consistent availability for key dining periods underscores its role as a reliable choice for local New Yorkers.

4 Bros Pizza Pizza

Wings
Bro Wings $14.00
8 crispy JUMBO wings. your choice of our house made wing sauces w/ ranch or bleu cheese on the side

Pastas
5 Cheese Baked Fusilli Avellinesi $15.00
(baked ziti twist) fresh fusilli avellinesi pasta ricotta, pecorino romano, sharp cheddar, monterey jack & house made fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh fusilli avellinesi pasta & marinara baked to cheesy perfection
Fusilli Avellinesi Broccoli Rabe & Hot Sausage $17.00
fresh fusilli avellinesi pasta w/broccoli rabe & hot sausage
Vodka Pasta $14.00
fresh fusilli avellinesi pasta w/vodka sauce
Fusilli Avellinesi Alfredo $12.00
fresh fusilli avellinesi pasta w/alfredo sauce
Spaghetti Sausage & Peppers $17.00
fresh spaghetti pasta with sausage & peppers
Pasta W/Garlic & Oil $8.00
fresh pasta w/fresh garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Spaghetti Marinara $12.00
fresh spaghetti pasta w/marinara sauce
Spaghetti & Meatballs $18.00
fresh spaghetti pasta w/marinara sauce & meatballs
Pasta W/Butter $8.00
fresh pasta buttered

Drinks
Coca-Cola 2-Liter $4.00
Snapple Kiwi Strawberry $2.50
Poland Spring Water $1.50
Snapple Mango Madness $2.50
Ginger Ale 2-Liter $4.00
Snapple Apple $2.50
Diet Coke 2-Liter $4.00
Snapple Lemon Tea $2.50
Grape Soda Can $1.50
Sprite Can $1.50
Coca-Cola Can $1.50
Tropicana $2.50
Snapple Peach Tea $2.50
Seltzer Can $1.50
Ginger Ale Can $1.50
Snapple Raspberry Tea $2.50
7 Up 2-Liter $4.00
Diet Coke Can $1.50
Agua De Jamica $4.00
Red Bull $3.00
Inca Kola Can $1.50

Salads
Garlic Caprese, Small $8.50
layered house made fresh mozzarella & garlic seasoned sliced tomato, drizzled w/balsamic glaze
Insalata, Large $13.00
iceberg lettuce, grape tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, red onion, black olives, prosciutto, fresh basil w/italian dressing
The Garden, Large $10.50
iceberg lettuce, carrots, red onion, grape tomatoes w/italian dressing
Garlic Caprese, Large $10.50
layered house made fresh mozzarella & garlic seasoned sliced tomato, drizzled w/balsamic glaze
Citrus Dressing $1.00
house made
Arugula & Apple, Large $11.50
topped w/crushed walnuts, goat cheese, citrus dressing
Caesar, Large $10.50
iceberg lettuce, house made croutons, pecorino romano
Italian Dressing $1.00
house made
Caesar, Small $8.50
iceberg lettuce, house made croutons, pecorino romano
Arugula & Apple, Small $9.50
topped w/crushed walnuts, goat cheese, citrus dressing
The Garden, Small $8.50
iceberg lettuce, carrots, red onion, grape tomatoes w/italian dressing
Insalata, Small $11.00
iceberg lettuce, grape tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, red onion, black olives, prosciutto, fresh basil w/italian dressing

Hand-Cut Fries
Pizza Fries $7.50
hand-cut fries topped w/pizza sauce & mozzarella
Cheese Fries $6.50
hand-cut fries topped w/melted cheddar & monterey jack
Fries $5.00
hand-cut fries
Loaded Fries $8.00
hand-cut fries topped w/melted mozzarella & bacon bits
Mike’s Hot Honey Fries $8.50
hand-cut fries topped w/drizzled mike's hot honey
Garlic Parmesan Fries $7.00
hand-cut fries seasoned w/fresh garlic & parmesan
Birria Fries $12.00
hand cut fries topped with birria red onion cilantro and fresh mozzarella drizzled with consome
Vodka Parmesan Fries $9.00
hand-cut fries topped with vodka sauce and mozzarella
Truffle Parmesan Fries $8.50
hand-cut fries tossed in truffle oil and pecorino
Garlic Lemon Pepper Fries $7.00

Plant-Based Eats
The "Irwin Special", Plant-Based $27.00
fresh garlic & extra sauce made w/"good planet" plant-based mozzarella cheese. 100% plant-based!
Amore Vegetale, Plant-Based $28.00
broccoli rabe, red onion, panko bread crumbs & fresh lemon juice cheese pizza made w/"good planet" plant-based mozzarella cheese. 100% plant-based!
Sweet Tartufo, Plant-Based $28.00
marsala mushrooms, white onions & mike's hot honey cheese pizza made w/"good planet" plant-based mozzarella cheese. 100% plant-based!
The New Yorker, Plant-Based $23.00
cheese pizza made w/"good planet" plant-based mozzarella cheese. 100% plant-based!
Mike's Hot Honey Crunch, Plant-Based $26.00
panko bread crumbs & mike's hot honey made w/"good planet" plant-based mozzarella cheese. 100% plant-based!
Plant Based Slice $4.25
made w/"good planet" plant-based mozzarella cheese. 100% plant-based!
Loaded Veggie New Yorker, Plant-Based $32.00
plant-based new yorker topped with marsala mushrooms, black olives, bell pepper, and white onion. available with no sauce.

Appetizers
Single Garlic Knot $0.75
1 per order
Half Dozen Garlic Knots $4.00
6 per order
Cheesy Garlic Bread $6.00
loaf of house made garlic bread w/melted fresh mozzarella
Cheesy Bread $5.00
loaf of house made bread w/melted fresh mozzarella
Pepperoni Roll $4.50
Beef Patty $4.50
House made beef patty with cheese
Loaded Garlic Knots $7.00
6 garlic knots topped w/melted mozzarella & bacon bits w/side of marinara
Loaded Calzone $16.00
stuffed w/mozzarella, seasoned ricotta cheese, pepperoni, hot sausage, bacon & hot sopressata served with marinara sauce, 10-12"
Chicken Roll $5.00
Calzone $12.00
stuffed w/mozzarella & seasoned ricotta cheese served with marinara sauce, 10-12"
Cheesy Garlic Knots $6.00
6 garlic knots topped w/melted mozzarella w/side of marinara
Bread Wheel $7.00
8 piece bread wheel with marinara cup
Pane Al Formaggio $9.00
deep fired dough stuffed with mozzarella cheese with a side of marinara sauce. 3 to an order
Garlic Bread $5.00
loaf of house made garlic bread
Pin Wheel Of The Day $4.00
order one and be surprised or give us a call and ask "whats in the pinwheel of the day?"
Garlic Knots $1.50
2 per order cheesy knots are 6 per order w/marinara loaded knots are 6 per order w/marinara

Extras
Honey Bbq Sauce $1.00
house made
Calabrian Chili Hot Sauce $2.00
house made
Mike's Hot Honey $2.00
side of mike's hot honey
Blue Cheese $1.00
bleu cheese dressing
Ranch $1.00
ranch dressing
Nutella $1.00
Marinara Sauce $1.00
house made
Sweet Habanero Sauce $1.00
house made

Square Pizzas
The New Yorker, Sq $21.00
sicilian
Amore Vegetale, Sq $27.00
house made fresh mozzarella, fried eggplant, broccoli rabe, red onion, goat cheese & drizzled fresh lemon juice
Bianco, Sq $24.00
mozzarella & seasoned ricotta
Broccoli Rabe & Hot Sausage, Sq (Red) $27.00
mozzarella, broccoli rabe & hot sausage, sprinkle of seasoned panko bread crumbs & a touch of lemon zest
Tangy Bbq Chicken Pizza, Sq $28.00
The "Irwin Special", Sq $25.00
cheese pizza topped w/extra sauce & fresh garlic. cooked well done/crispy
Fig & 3 Cheese, Sq $27.00
mozzarella, pecorino romano, goat cheese & fig jam
Grandma, Sq $24.00
house made fresh mozzarella topped w/seasoned plum tomato
Marsala Tartufo, Sq $27.00
house made fresh mozzarella, marsala mushrooms & caramelized onions
Margherita, Sq $21.00
cheese pizza
Caramelized Bianco, Sq $27.00
mozzarella, seasoned ricotta & caramelized onions
Salad Pizza, Sq $27.00
The "3 Sauce-Keteers" Pizza, Sq $26.00
the sauce trifecta! fresh mozzarella vodka sauce, pesto sauce & tomato pizza, an explosion of flavor!
Pepperoni, Sq $24.00
cheese pizza topped w/pepperoni
Loaded Veggie New Yorker, Sq $30.00
square new yorker cheese pizza topped with marsala mushroom, black olives, bell pepper, and white onion. garnished with fresh basil and pecorino. available with no sauce.
Speziata Calabria, Sq $27.00
house made fresh mozzarella topped w/hot sopressata & drizzled calabrian chili hot sauce
Sweet Diavola, Sq $27.00
the new yorker topped w/hot sopressata & drizzled mike's hot honey
Loaded New Yorker, Sq $33.00
square new yorker topped w/hot sopressata, pepperoni, sausage & bacon
Eggplant Rollatini Margherita, Sq $35.50
house made fresh topped w/eggplant rollatini
Arugula Di Parma, Sq $27.00
house made fresh mozzarella, bed of arugula, drizzled balsamic glaze & thin sliced prosciutto. crust is hot while the toppings are served cold for a refreshing crisp taste!
Meatball Marinara, Sq $27.00
meatball, fresh garlic, house made fresh mozzarella & marinara sauce
Broccoli Rabe & Hot Sausage, Sq (White) $27.00
mozzarella, broccoli rabe & hot sausage, a sprinkle of seasoned panko bread crumbs & a touch of lemon zest
Buffalo Hot Sauce Chicken Pizza, Sq $28.00
Drunken Grandma $26.00
vodka sauce grandma pie topped with fresh basil and pecorino

Specials
Heart Shaped Bianco Pizza $25.00
mozzarella & seasoned ricotta shaped into a heart for your loved one!
Scarpariello Bro Wings $15.00
8 jumbo wing tossed in scarpariello sauce with Battaglia Bros sweet sausage sauce and hand cut fries
Heart Shaped Burrata Pizza $28.00
cheese pizza topped w/house made burrata shaped into a heart for your loved one!
Mike's Hot Honey Bro Wings $14.00
8 crispy JUMBO wings smothered in mike's hot honey ranch or bleu cheese on the side
Heart Shaped Nutella Pie $14.00
layer of nutella topped w/banana, crumbled chocolate chip cookies, toasted marshmallows & confectioner's sugar
Garlic Knot Burrata Hot Honey Sliders $15.00
choice of chicken cutlet or eggplant topped w/house made burrata, caramelized onions, drizzled mike's hot honey served on our famous garlic knot sliders!
Garlic Knot Chicken Bacon Ranch Sliders $15.00
topped w/cheddar cheese, 3 per order.
Heart Shaped Pepperoni Pizza $25.00
cheese pizza topped w/pepperoni shaped into a heart for your loved one!
Heart Shaped Margherita Pizza $22.00
house made fresh mozzarella & fresh basil shaped into a heart for your loved one!
Garlic Knot Vodka Parmigiana Sliders $15.00
chicken or eggplant smothered in 4 bros vodka sauce, house made fresh mozzarella served on our famous garlic knot slider buns
Heart Shaped New York Pizza $22.00
cheese pizza shaped into a heart for your loved one!

Sandwiches
Garlic Caprese Sandwich $12.00
house made fresh mozzarella & fresh garlic seasoned sliced tomato, drizzled w/balsamic glaze on house made bread
Hot Sausage & Peppers Sandwich $14.00
sausage & peppers topped w/house made burrata on house made bread
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich $13.50
chicken cutlet, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo on house made bread
Eggplant & Roasted Red Peppers Sandwich $14.00
breaded eggplant, roasted red peppers, fresh garlic, house made fresh mozzarella, red onion, drizzled vinegar & oil on house made bread
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich $13.50
chicken cutlet topped w/marinara & melted fresh mozzarella on house made bread
Vodka Parmigiana Sandwich $16.00
chicken cutlet or fried eggplant layers of marinara and fresh mozzarella on house made bread topped with fresh basil and grated pecorino
Champs Triple Decker $15.00
arugula, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella layered between 3 chicken cutlets with our house dressing
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich $13.00
fried eggplant topped w/marinara & melted fresh mozzarella on house made bread

Entrees
Vodka Chicken Parmigiana $25.00
Cheesy Grilled Chicken Bacon Ranch $24.00
grilled chicken bacon melted cheddar cheese drizzled ranch dressing
Eggplant Rollatini Entree $25.00
crispy eggplant rolled and stuffed w/seasoned ricotta, topped w/marinara, house made fresh mozzarella, fresh basil & pecorino side of fresh pasta or salad
Grilled Chicken Over Parmesan Veggies $24.00
sautéed red onion, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, black olives parmesan cheese grilled chicken drizzled vinegar & oil
Chicken Parmigiana Entree $23.00
chicken cutlet topped w/marinara & melted fresh mozzarella side of fresh pasta
Grilled Chicken Over Broccoli Rabe Entree $24.00
grilled chicken served over sautéed broccoli rabe
Eggplant Parmigiana Entree $23.00
fried eggplant topped w/marinara & melted house made fresh mozzarella side of fresh pasta
Vodka Eggplant Parmigiana $24.00
Broccoli Rabe & Hot Sausage Entree $24.00
sautéed broccoli rabe & hot sausage

Common
Add Chicken Cutlet $3.00
Dessert Of The Day $6.00
Give us a call or be surprised
Ice Cup $1.50
Add Grilled Chicken $3.00

Small 12" Round Pizzas
Broccoli Rabe & Hot Sausage, Sm (Red) $16.50
mozzarella, broccoli rabe & hot sausage, sprinkle of seasoned panko bread crumbs & a touch of lemon zest
Meatball Marinara, Sm $16.50
meatball, fresh garlic, house made fresh mozzarella & marinara sauce
Tangy Bbq Chicken Pizza, Sm $17.00
Fig & 3 Cheese, Sm $16.50
mozzarella, pecorino romano, goat cheese & fig jam
Speziata Calabria, Sm $16.50
house made fresh mozzarella topped w/hot sopressata & drizzled calabrian chili hot sauce
Margherita, Sm $13.50
house made fresh mozzarella & fresh basil
The "3 Sauce-Keteers" Pizza, Sm $16.00
the sauce trifecta! fresh mozzarella vodka sauce, pesto sauce & tomato pizza, an explosion of flavor!
Bianco, Sm $15.00
mozzarella & seasoned ricotta
Pepperoni, Sm $15.00
cheese pizza topped w/pepperoni
Sweet Diavola, Sm $16.50
the new yorker topped w/hot sopressata & drizzled mike's hot honey
Marsala Tartufo, Sm $16.50
house made fresh mozzarella, marsala mushrooms & caramelized onions
Caramelized Bianco, Sm $16.50
mozzarella, seasoned ricotta & caramelized onions
Buffalo Hot Sauce Chicken Pizza, Sm $17.00
The New Yorker, Sm $13.50
cheese pizza
The "Irwin Special", Sm $15.50
cheese pizza topped w/extra sauce & fresh garlic. cooked well done/crispy
Amore Vegetale, Sm $17.50
house made fresh mozzarella, fried eggplant, broccoli rabe, red onion, goat cheese & drizzled fresh lemon juice
Loaded New Yorker, Sm $19.50
small 12" new yorker topped w/hot sopressata, pepperoni, sausage & bacon
Salad Pizza, Sm $16.50
cheese pizza topped w/lettuce, carrots, red onion, black olives & dressing of your choice
Broccoli Rabe & Hot Sausage, Sm (White) $16.50
mozzarella, broccoli rabe & hot sausage, sprinkle of seasoned panko bread crumbs & a touch of lemon zest
Arugula Di Parma, Sm $16.50
house made fresh mozzarella, bed of arugula, drizzled balsamic glaze & thin sliced prosciutto. crust is hot while the toppings are served cold for a refreshing crisp taste!
Loaded Veggie New Yorker, Sm $18.00
small 12" new yorker cheese pizza topped with marsala mushroom, black olives, bell pepper, and white onion. garnished with fresh basil and pecorino. available with no sauce.

Sides
Chicken Cutlet $8.00
Broccoli Rabe $6.00
w/fresh garlic
Fried Eggplant $6.00
Meatballs $8.00
house made

Large 16" Round Pizzas
Arugula Di Parma, Lg $25.00
house made fresh mozzarella, bed of arugula, drizzled balsamic glaze & thin sliced prosciutto. crust is hot while the toppings are served cold for a refreshing crisp taste!
Sweet Diavola, Lg $25.00
the new yorker topped w/hot sopressata & drizzled mike's hot honey
The "3 Sauce-Keteers" Pizza, Lg $24.00
the sauce trifecta! fresh mozzarella vodka sauce, pesto sauce & tomato pizza, an explosion of flavor!
Loaded Veggie New Yorker, Lg $28.00
new yorker cheese pizza topped with marsala mushroom, black olives, bell pepper, and white onion. garnished with fresh basil and pecorino. available with no sauce.
Caramelized Bianco, Lg $25.00
mozzarella, seasoned ricotta & caramelized onions
The "Irwin Special", Lg $23.00
cheese pizza topped w/extra sauce & fresh garlic. cooked well done/crispy
The New Yorker, Lg $19.00
cheese pizza
Speziata Calabria, Lg $25.00
house made fresh mozzarella topped w/hot sopressata & drizzled calabrian chili hot sauce
Marsala Tartufo, Lg $25.00
house made fresh mozzarella, marsala mushrooms & caramelized onions
Fig & 3 Cheese, Lg $25.00
mozzarella, pecorino romano, goat cheese & fig jam
Buffalo Hot Sauce Chicken Pizza, Lg $26.00
Tangy Bbq Chicken Pizza, Lg $26.00
Broccoli Rabe & Hot Sausage, Lg (White) $25.00
mozzarella, broccoli rabe & hot sausage, a sprinkle of seasoned panko bread crumbs & a touch of lemon zest
Bianco, Lg $22.00
mozzarella & seasoned ricotta
Broccoli Rabe & Hot Sausage, Lg (Red) $25.00
mozzarella, broccoli rabe & hot sausage, sprinkle of seasoned panko bread crumbs & a touch of lemon zest
Margherita, Lg $19.00
house made fresh mozzarella & fresh basil
Meatball Marinara, Lg $25.00
meatball, fresh garlic, house made fresh mozzarella & marinara sauce
Amore Vegetale, Lg $25.00
house made fresh mozzarella, fried eggplant, broccoli rabe, red onion, goat cheese & drizzled fresh lemon juice
Loaded New Yorker, Lg $31.00
new yorker topped w/hot sopressata, pepperoni, sausage & bacon
Salad Pizza, Lg $25.00
cheese pizza topped w/lettuce, carrots, red onion, black olives & dressing of your choice
Pepperoni, Lg $22.00
cheese pizza topped w/pepperoni

Dessert
Choco-Flan Cake $6.00
home made flan over a layer of rich chocolate cake!
Mocha Mousse Cake With Strawberry Coulis $6.00
oreo crust chocolate mousse with a hit of coffee topped with oreo crumbs and strawberry coulis
Tiramisu $8.00
layers of marscapone and liquor and lady fingers dipped in espresso with a sprinkle of shaved semi sweet chocolate
Zeppoles $8.00
small 6 or large 12 fried dough balls & confectioner's sugar
Pizza Frita W/Nutella $9.00
fried pizza dough topped w/drizzled nutella & confectioner's sugar
Pumpkin Pie $6.00
Apple Puff Pastry $9.00
sliced sweetened apples wrapped in puff pastry crust, drizzled w/nutella
Joe Mama’s Banana Pudding $6.00
layers of vanilla wafers and banana pudding topped with chocolate chunks and fresh banana slices
Nutella Pizza $12.00
layer of nutella topped w/banana, crumbled chocolate chip cookies, toasted marshmallows & confectioner's sugar
Tres Leches Bread Pudding $6.00

4 Bros Pizza Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
College students
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free street parking
Paid parking lot
Paid street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

4 Bros Pizza Photos

4 Bros Pizza Location

4 Bros Pizza

New York Westchester County New Rochelle South Division Street

23 S Division St, New Rochelle, NY 10805, USA

4 Bros Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 169 user reviews.

garlic knotspieveganhandspricescrustslicescheese pizzapepperoniplant based

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Found this little spot while visiting New Rochelle and we were very happy with everything. We were a total party of 12 & the staff were amazing in accommodating us. The prices were great, staff friendly, & the food was so good! The pizza, chicken cutlets and wings were delicious! Definitely will go back & highly recommend. This little spot is a definite gem!
September 07 · Margie Boitel
Review for sandwiches only! I've never had the pizza here but this spot holds my favorite sandwich ever in New Rochelle (amongst lots of spots we've tried including delis and restaurants and grocery stores). The Classic 4 Bros sandwich is heavenly -magic combo, and we're regulars for it. Also, the bread is divine - house made. Yum.
August 29 · Thanh
I just came back from two weeks in Hawaii and my first stop after dropping off my stuff at home was 4 Brother's because I needed a REAL slice of pizza. My go-to for garlic knots and a hearty sicilian slice. Also really appreciate they have plant-based pizzas for the vegans in my life.
August 21 · Kenji Kaneshiro
I Decided to take the kids out for pizza today and went to another pizza place fortunately they were closed so we decided to go to 4bros because they were on our list to try as well. We are so happy we went here. The pizza was amazing! We ordered a pie to bring home. The pie never made it out the shop lol! The customer service was on point. We were greeted on our walk in and they made us feel so comfortable that we decided to sit and have a slice which eventually ended up with us finishing the pie lol. The kids then had ice cream which they took to eat in the car on our way home. This is my new favorite pizza shop! I will definitely be back.
September 08 · Oprah W
Really delicious slice. Crispy crust. Doesn't flop. Has the golden delicious NY oil a pizza should have. Really good crust. Did I say that already about the crust?Sauce is good not to sweet, cheese is just the right amount.The staff are friendly and attentive.Highly recommend if you are in New Rochelle
April 21 · bizzy izzy