Alfredo's Pizza

- 14 S 4th Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers searching for that quintessential neighborhood pizzeria experience, Alfredo's Pizza stands out as a genuine local institution in Mount Vernon, New York. More than just a simple pizza parlor, this establishment serves as a pillar of comfort food, blending the timeless tradition of Italian American cooking with the fast-paced needs of the Westchester County community. Alfredo’s Pizza is widely recognized for its commitment to consistent quality, offering a broad menu that extends well beyond pizza to include classic Italian entrées, hot wedges (subs), and hearty American fare like burgers and gyros. It’s a reliable, casual, and cozy spot that caters seamlessly to busy locals, college students, and families looking for a delicious, quick bite or a relaxed dinner.

The reputation of Alfredo's Pizza is built on serving up fresh dough and quality ingredients. Customers consistently praise the food for being delicious, hot, and satisfying, often noting the generous portions and excellent value. It has earned a strong local following, indicated by its high ratings on major delivery platforms, reflecting its status as a trusted source for affordable, high-quality comfort food in the Mount Vernon area. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick slice, a family dinner, or ordering delivery to your Bronx or Westchester home, Alfredo's delivers a familiar, satisfying meal every time. It’s the kind of place that becomes part of a family’s routine, with multiple generations returning for their favorite slice—a true hallmark of a beloved New York eatery.

Furthermore, the establishment is proudly recognized as an active participant in the community, with public feedback noting the business’s involvement in "doing a lot of stuff for the community," which adds a layer of goodwill and local pride to every order placed. Alfredo's operates with convenience in mind, welcoming customers without a reservation and offering extended hours to accommodate both lunch and dinner crowds.

Location and Accessibility

Alfredo’s Pizza is ideally situated in the busy urban hub of Mount Vernon, making it easily accessible for residents and visitors throughout the New York region. Located at 14 S 4th Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550, USA, the restaurant is positioned near a downtown area, facilitating quick access for local workers, shoppers, and commuters.

The Fourth Avenue location benefits from Mount Vernon’s central infrastructure, providing straightforward access via car or public transit options serving the area. For those planning a visit, the atmosphere is described as casual and cozy, making it a perfect unpretentious setting for solo dining, a quick lunch, or a meal out with kids. The option for in-person dining allows patrons to soak in the local neighborhood feel, but the primary strength for this New York business is its seamless integration into the delivery ecosystem, ensuring the celebrated quality of their pizza and Italian dishes can reach you quickly across a wide service area. Customers appreciate the option to pay using credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, adding a layer of convenience to the accessibility.

Services Offered

To meet the high-speed demands of the New York metropolitan area, Alfredo's Pizza offers a comprehensive suite of service options tailored for maximum convenience and flexibility.

• Dine-in: Enjoying the casual, cozy atmosphere of the restaurant, perfect for lunch or dinner with family and friends. The space is noted as being good for kids and group-friendly.
• Takeout: Quick and reliable service for customers picking up their orders directly from the counter.
• Delivery: Comprehensive delivery service throughout the local area, ensuring hot food arrives promptly.
• No-contact Delivery: A safe and preferred method for those who prioritize minimal interaction when receiving their food.
• Curbside Pickup: An added convenience feature allowing customers to have their pre-ordered food delivered directly to their vehicle.
• Menu Variety: Beyond core Italian-American offerings, they provide comfort food and quick bites suitable for lunch and dinner, catering to a diverse crowd including college students and locals.
• Payment Flexibility: Acceptance of modern payment methods including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

The menu at Alfredo's Pizza is a celebration of classic American-Italian fare, where variety and value are key features. The quality and extensive offerings ensure there is something for every craving.

• Authentic Pizza Selection: The heart of the menu features classic pies, from the Cheese Pizza (a bestseller) to specialty options like Margherita, Buffalo Chicken, Meat Lovers, and the unique Philly Cheesesteak Pizza. Slices, including Regular Slice and the thicker Sicilian Slice, are always available for a quick, authentic New York experience.
• Signature Hot Wedges: Known regionally as subs or heroes, their hot wedges are a customer favorite, perfect for a filling meal. Popular choices include Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana, Philly Cheesesteak, and Buffalo Chicken.
• Complete Italian Entrées: Offering full-service Italian comfort food, entrées like Chicken Parm, Eggplant Parm, and the creamy Chicken Alfredo are served over a choice of pasta (typically spaghetti or penne) with salad and bread. These dishes are perfect for a traditional, satisfying dinner.
• Diverse Comfort Food: In addition to Italian dishes, Alfredo’s offers classic American comfort food, including a variety of burgers like the Bacon Cheeseburger and the Southwest Burger, all served deluxe with French fries. They also serve Gyros (Chicken or Lamb) and Wings.
• Appetizer and Dessert Favorites: The menu is bolstered by highly popular sides such as Mozzarella Sticks, Buffalo Wings, French Fries, and the delightful Italian mini-doughnuts, Zeppoles. They also offer refreshing Slush Puppies and Italian Ices (seasonally) for a sweet finish.
• Strong Local Rating: The restaurant maintains an impressive 4.4 to 4.9-star rating on multiple platforms, with one customer noting it as a "Great gem in Mt Vernon," showcasing its strong local appreciation and consistent quality.

Contact Information

To place an order for pickup or delivery, or for any general inquiries, customers can easily reach Alfredo's Pizza using the following details:

• Address: 14 S 4th Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550, USA
• Phone: (914) 667-5910
• Operating Hours (General Estimate): Open daily, typically from 10:00 AM – 10:00 PM (check local listings for exact current hours and any holiday closures).

What is Worth Choosing

For first-time visitors or long-time locals at Alfredo’s Pizza, choosing from the expansive menu can be tough. What truly sets this establishment apart is its ability to nail the classics while offering creative twists.

If you are a Pizza Purist: You absolutely must start with the Cheese Pizza or grab a Regular Slice. Customer reviews repeatedly highlight the freshness and consistent quality of their product. The slices are noted to be "very big & thin," embodying the spirit of a classic New York-style slice. If you prefer a thicker crust, the Sicilian Slice is a hearty alternative.

For a Crowd-Pleaser: The Buffalo Chicken Pizza or the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza are fantastic choices. These specialty pies take traditional flavors and layer them onto their quality crust, providing a satisfying, hearty, and flavorful experience that often disappears quickly at any gathering. The Meat Lovers pie, which features ham, pepperoni, meatballs, and sausage, is another surefire way to please a hungry group.

For a Quick and Filling Meal: Step away from pizza for a moment and explore the hot wedges or burgers. The Philly Cheesesteak Wedge is highly recommended for a savory, satisfying lunch, or try the Cheeseburger Deluxe which comes complete with a side of French fries. These options deliver excellent value and are perfect for a quick bite during lunch hours.

When You Want Italian Dinner: For a more traditional, sit-down meal, the Chicken Parm or Eggplant Parm entrées are the essence of Italian-American comfort. Served over pasta with a side salad, these are complete, generous, and flavorful dinners that bring a taste of homestyle cooking to your table. The Chicken Alfredo is a creamy, decadent alternative that never disappoints.

Ultimately, Alfredo’s Pizza is worth choosing because it is a reliable, high-rated local spot that honors the tradition of Mount Vernon’s casual dining scene. It delivers the familiar, beloved tastes of Italian and American comfort food with professionalism and a consistent focus on quality, making it a true gem for anyone in the New York area.

Alfredo's Pizza

14 S 4th Ave, Mt Vernon, NY 10550, USA