Athenian Greek Taverna

- 2188 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725

For Long Island residents and New York food enthusiasts craving the fresh, vibrant, and comforting flavors of the Aegean, **Athenian Greek Taverna** in Commack stands out as a premier destination. More than just a local eatery, this establishment is a dedicated Greek restaurant committed to serving authentic Hellenic cuisine using traditional, time-tested family recipes—often referred to as “Yiayia’s way.” While its name suggests a traditional taverna setting, the restaurant provides a **Casual** and **Cozy** atmosphere with **Table service**, focusing on the quality of its homemade food and providing a fantastic dining experience for all.

The restaurant offers a genuinely diverse menu that caters to every taste and dietary need, including substantial main courses, light **Vegan options**, **Vegetarian options**, and hearty **Comfort food** platters. Popular for both **Lunch** and **Dinner**, it has become a favorite spot for **Groups** and even **Solo dining** in the Commack area. The kitchen is committed to high-quality preparation, as highlighted by customers who praise the food for tasting genuinely **homemade** and fresh. Dishes like the savory *Spanakopita* and the various perfectly prepared *Kebab* options exemplify their culinary dedication.

While the atmosphere may lean toward a modern, comfortable restaurant rather than a rustic, festive tavern, the quality of the food and the extensive beverage program—featuring an excellent **Great wine list**, **Beer**, **Cocktails**, and **Hard liquor** from their **Bar onsite**—ensure a memorable and enjoyable Greek outing right here in New York.

Athenian Greek Taverna is conveniently located on a main thoroughfare in Commack, making it easily accessible for anyone traveling through Long Island's Suffolk County.

The physical address is **2188 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725, USA**.

Accessibility is a key focus for the establishment, ensuring a smooth visit for all patrons.

• **Parking:** Visitors benefit from a **Free parking lot** and the option for **Free street parking**, which simplifies arrival and departure.
• **Wheelchair Accessibility:** The restaurant is fully equipped for accessibility, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**.
• **Pet Policy:** Adding to its welcoming nature, the Taverna permits **Dogs allowed** in designated areas, typically outdoor seating.

Athenian Greek Taverna provides a comprehensive suite of services, accommodating everything from a quick lunch break to a large catered event.

• **Dining Options:** Available throughout the day, guests can choose from **Dine-in**, quick **Takeout**, or convenient **Delivery** to enjoy their Greek favorites at home.
• **Full Table Service:** The restaurant features full **Table service** for a more relaxed and professional dining experience.
• **Event Planning:** The Taverna offers extensive **Catering** services, allowing customers to bring the delicious taste of Greece to their own events.
• **Reservations:** The venue **Accepts reservations**, a useful feature for planning dinners, especially for **Groups**, ensuring a table is ready upon arrival.
• **Children's Amenities:** The restaurant is **Good for kids**, offering **High chairs** and a dedicated **Kids' menu**, making it a stress-free option for family dining.
• **Special Promotions:** A highlight is the **Happy hour food** and drink specials, with one review noting a "Two for one" offer on select beer, wine, and well mixed drinks during specific weekday hours.
• **Connectivity:** **Wi-Fi** is provided, and there is a **Gender-neutral restroom** on site, reflecting modern hospitality standards.

The true highlight of Athenian Greek Taverna is the authentic, high-quality, and creative menu that brings the best of Greek food to Long Island.

**Signature Culinary Excellence:**

• **Homemade Appetizers:** Known for incredible small plates, one must-try item is the *7 Layer Dip* (a Greek-inspired dip featuring layers of hummus, spicy feta, and other fresh ingredients) praised by customers. Other excellent choices include the spicy *Htipiti* (spicy feta dip), *Grilled Halloumi Cheese*, and the traditional *Saganaki* (broiled cheese served on fire).
• **Exceptional Gyros and Sandwiches:** The Taverna’s offerings go beyond the basic, featuring **Sandwiches** and **Platters** like the highly-rated *Zeus Gyro* and the unique *Yanni's Gyro* with spicy feta and sriracha-spiked tzatziki. Platters like the *Mt. Olympus Platter* combine lamb, chicken, beef, and pork souvlaki for a feast.
• **Gourmet Mains and Seafood:** The menu showcases traditional entrees like *Spanakopita* and *Yemistes Pipergies* (stuffed bell peppers), along with high-end options from the **Filet Bar** (*Salmon Fillet*, *Rainbow Trout*) and the **From the Sea** section, which includes *Grilled Octopus*, *PEI Mussels*, and the extravagant *Shrimp & Salmon Mykonos*.
• **Authentic Recipe Focus:** The menu is filled with traditional items prepared in a way that truly tastes fresh and homemade, exemplified by the reviewer’s praise for the **Falafel** and the zesty **Lemon Potatoes** which are considered a **local specialty**.

**Atmosphere and Service Points:**

• **Beverage Selection:** The full **Bar onsite** ensures a wide selection of **Alcohol**, including **Cocktails** and a **Great wine list**, making it suitable for a celebratory meal or a relaxed evening drink.
• **Dessert:** The restaurant is noted for its **Great dessert** options, which include Greek classics like *Baklava*, *Kataifi*, and *Rice Pudding*—a perfect finish to any meal.

To make a reservation, place a takeout order, or inquire about catering options for your next event, the Athenian Greek Taverna is easily accessible using the following contact details.

**Address:** 2188 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725, USA

**Phone:** (631) 499-7660

**Mobile Phone:** +1 631-499-7660

Choosing Athenian Greek Taverna offers New York area diners a sophisticated yet comfortable dive into authentic Greek cuisine without having to leave Long Island. It is a standout choice for those who value high-quality, fresh ingredients prepared with traditional care.

**It is worth choosing Athenian Greek Taverna because:**

• **Uncompromising Food Quality:** The commitment to using "Yiayia's recipes" translates to dishes that consistently receive praise for their freshness and homemade taste. Their unique appetizers, like the highly-praised **7 Layer Dip**, and freshly-made options like the falafel, distinguish their food from standard casual fare.
• **Extensive Full-Service Offerings:** From the extensive **Great wine list** and full **Bar onsite** to offering **Catering** and accepting **Reservations**, the Taverna provides a comprehensive dining experience that can cater to anything from a relaxed solo lunch to a major group celebration. The two-for-one **Happy hour** is an excellent feature for enjoying their extensive drink and **Small plates** menu.
• **A Wide Spectrum of Greek Flavors:** The menu successfully spans the entire range of Greek cuisine. Whether you want a simple, delicious *Zeus Gyro*, a healthy *Horiatiki Salad* (traditional Greek salad without lettuce), a hearty **Kebab** (available in **Gluten Free!** options), or an indulgent seafood entree like the *Grilled Octopus*, the Taverna offers authentic and diverse choices.
• **Exceptional Hospitality:** Repeated customer mentions of friendly, attentive staff contribute to an overwhelmingly positive experience. The combination of great food and professional, personalized service ensures every visit is welcoming and satisfying.

For Long Islanders seeking an accessible, authentic, and high-quality Greek dining experience, Athenian Greek Taverna delivers a taste of the Mediterranean right here in Commack.

Athenian Greek Taverna

2188 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725, USA