Ayala's Bakery

- 81 4th St, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Welcome to Ayala's Bakery, a true neighborhood gem located right in the heart of New Rochelle, NY. For those of us living in and around Westchester County, finding a local spot that consistently delivers both quality and artistry in its baked goods is a real treat—and Ayala’s is just that place. Specializing in a wonderful array of classic American and beloved Latin-inspired pastries, this bakery has quickly become a must-visit destination for everyday cravings, quick coffee breaks, and, most importantly, show-stopping custom celebration cakes. If you're looking for a dependable local bakery where every item is made with care and passion, you’ve found your sweet spot.

Ayala's Bakery prides itself on creating an inviting atmosphere and serving up a menu filled with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Whether you’re stopping by to pick up a morning pastry or placing an order for a major event, the dedicated team at Ayala's is committed to ensuring every customer leaves with a smile and a truly delicious product. The combination of classic bakery staples and unique specialties, like their highly-praised Tres Leches cakes, makes this spot a unique and valuable addition to the New Rochelle culinary landscape.

Location and Accessibility

Ayala's Bakery is conveniently situated at 81 4th St in New Rochelle, NY 10801. This location falls within the New Rochelle area, a vibrant and increasingly developing section of Westchester County, often affectionately referred to by locals as "New Roc City." The neighborhood encompassing 4th Street is part of the larger area served by the 10801 zip code, which is recognized for its proximity to downtown amenities and good local transit options. The area around 4th Street generally allows for easy access to nearby shops and essential services.

For customers relying on public transportation, the bakery is positioned well. The address is conveniently located about a 14-minute walk (less than a mile) from the Pelham Station and a similar 14-minute walk (around 1.1 miles) from the major New Rochelle Station. These stations offer access to the Metro-North commuter rail line, providing a vital connection for those traveling from other parts of Westchester or even a short trip from Manhattan. Additionally, New Rochelle is well-served by the Bee-Line bus system, which operates routes throughout Westchester County and connects to the New Rochelle Transit Center adjacent to the train station. The city also offers CircuitNR, an electric micro-transit shuttle service, which can be useful for getting around the local area on-demand. For drivers, the location offers the convenience of being on a corner lot, and some properties in the immediate vicinity offer limited on-site parking spaces.

Services Offered

Ayala's Bakery is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a full-service bakery focused on customer convenience. Their offerings ensure you can enjoy their delicious products no matter your schedule or location.

UL

LI In-Store Takeout: Perfect for a quick visit when you are in the neighborhood and need a freshly baked treat or a coffee on the go.

LI Delivery Service: For those days when you can't make it to the bakery, or when ordering a full cake for a party, the delivery option brings the sweetness right to your door.

LI Custom and Specialty Cakes: They offer various sizes of cakes, with a noted specialty in the beloved Tres Leches variety, including options for parties of six or more people.

LI Coffee Offerings: Complement your pastry selection with a fresh cup of coffee, making Ayala's an ideal spot for a quick morning or afternoon pick-me-up.

LI Accepted Payments: For a seamless transaction, the bakery accepts major credit cards and debit cards.

/UL

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Ayala's Bakery apart is its menu diversity, exceptional customer service, and dedication to crafting memorable custom desserts. They manage to blend traditional bakery favorites with authentic Latin American specialties, creating a unique and appealing selection for the New York area.

UL

LI Tres Leches Cake Specialization: The bakery is highly praised for its Tres Leches cake, available in various decadent flavors like Chocolate, Coffee, and Strawberry. This is a must-try for any lover of this classic Latin American dessert.

LI Artisanal Pastry Variety: The menu features a delightful mix of options, ranging from traditional Mexican sweet bread like Conchas and Churros De Crema De Vainilla to classic European pastries such as Croissants, Large Cannolis, and Milhojas De Vainilla (Napoleons).

LI Custom Cake Artistry: A key highlight is the bakery's proven ability to execute complex and unique custom cake designs. One customer noted receiving a "stunning" cake for a niche theme, even without providing reference pictures, highlighting the creative and skilled decorating team.

LI Sweet Treats and Desserts: Beyond cakes and pastries, they offer a selection of classic desserts like Flan, Tiramisu, Gelatina, Chocoflan, and Bread Pudding (Budin).

LI Customer Service Excellence: Reviews indicate a high level of customer satisfaction, particularly regarding the beauty and deliciousness of their decorated cakes, suggesting a strong commitment to quality and service.

/UL

Menu Snapshot (A selection of available items)

P

Tres Leches Cakes: Tres Leches Chocolate Cake ($5.25), Tres Leches Coffee With Filling Coffee Mousse ($6.00), Tres Leches De Cajeta / With Caramel Filling ($5.25), and whole cakes for six people, such as Tres Leches Chocolate Cake Filled With Chocolate Mousse ($30.00) and Tres Leches Cake Filled With Strawberry ($30.00).

Pound Cakes and Bread: Pecan Pound Cake ($2.50), Cranberry Pound Cake ($2.50), Banana Pound Cake ($2.50), and Pan De Canela ($2.10).

Pastries and Cookies: Conchas ($1.75), Churros De Crema De Vainilla ($1.75), Croissant ($1.75), Pineapple Pastry ($2.65), Relleno De Manzana / Apple Turnover ($2.65), Chocolate Chip Cookie ($1.75), and Galleta / Cookie With Sprinkles ($1.35).

Classic Desserts: Tiramisu ($5.25), Bread Pudding / Budin ($5.25), Milhojas De Vainilla / Napoleon With Vanilla Filling ($5.25), Flan ($5.25), Chocoflan ($5.25), and Large Cannoli ($4.00).

/P

Contact Information

P

Address: 81 4th St, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA

Phone: (203) 501-4761

/P

What is Worth Choosing

Ayala's Bakery offers a rare and delightful combination of authentic Latin baking tradition and professional cake artistry, making it an outstanding choice for any resident of New Rochelle and the wider Westchester area.

For those who appreciate culturally diverse and deeply flavorful desserts, the array of Tres Leches cakes is an absolute highlight and a compelling reason to choose Ayala's. It is clearly a signature item that has garnered positive attention. Customers rave about this specific cake, noting it is both "delicious and beautifully decorated."

Beyond the everyday pastries, their ability to deliver on highly specific custom cake orders is a major selling point. The testimonial of them successfully creating a beautiful and delicious "K-Pop Demon Hunters" cake without reference images speaks volumes about the skill and willingness of the bakers to take on creative challenges, ensuring your next party centerpiece will be unique and memorable.

In a neighborhood that is both developing and well-connected, Ayala's Bakery serves as an accessible and reliable destination. Whether you need a speedy takeout order, a quick coffee before commuting via Metro-North, or a breathtaking cake for a celebration, Ayala's Bakery is a top-tier local choice that welcomes quick visits and supports payment via credit and debit cards for convenience. If you are in New Rochelle, make a quick stop at Ayala’s Bakery to treat yourself to a pastry and experience the quality that is generating so much positive buzz throughout the community.

The local New York community continues to value businesses that provide quality, convenience, and a personal touch. Ayala's Bakery, with its dedication to exceptional cakes and diverse menu, clearly fits this mold, solidifying its place as a valued asset on 4th Street. Don't miss out on what many consider the best Tres Leches cake in the area!

Ayala's Bakery

81 4th St, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA