Bagel Talk

- 368 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024

In a city where the search for the perfect bagel is a way of life, Bagel Talk stands out as a reliable and authentic neighborhood spot on the Upper West Side. This classic New York bagel shop delivers a straightforward and satisfying experience, focusing on the fundamentals that make a bagel truly great. Unlike some of the trendy new places, Bagel Talk is a no-frills establishment that prioritizes a delicious, freshly made product at a reasonable price. It’s the kind of place you can walk past, decide to give a try, and find yourself happily surprised, as one customer did. The bagels themselves are a key highlight, praised for their "nice" appearance and chewy texture. While one reviewer found the texture "perhaps too chewy," the quality of the ingredients, like the "clean tasting" nova (smoked salmon) and the flavorful sun-dried tomato and basil cream cheese, is a consistent draw. This focus on quality ingredients and a classic approach has made Bagel Talk a staple for locals looking for an honest and delicious start to their day.

Beyond the bagels themselves, the menu at Bagel Talk is designed to cater to a variety of breakfast and lunch needs. The "All Day Breakfast" menu is a major draw, offering a wide range of classic bagel sandwiches from the simple yet delicious Bacon, Eggs And Cheese Sandwich to more substantial options like the Pastrami And Eggs Sandwich. The shop also offers "Gourmet Salad Sandwiches" with options like Baked Salmon Salad and Smoked Whitefish Salad, which are known for their flavor and generous portions. This variety ensures that whether you’re in the mood for a hearty breakfast or a lighter lunch, you’ll find something to satisfy your craving. For those with dietary restrictions, Bagel Talk has a dedicated "Gluten-Free Sandwiches" menu, which includes options like the Healthy Sandwich and the Vegetarian Sandwich. This commitment to inclusivity is a significant highlight, making it a welcoming spot for a broader range of customers. The menu also includes a variety of beverages, from a full Espresso Bar with options like Capuccino and Latte, to fresh Smoothies, making it a one-stop-shop for a complete and satisfying morning meal.

The service at Bagel Talk, while noted by one customer as a bit confusing due to having to give their order twice, is generally described as "nice" and friendly. This is a common experience in a busy, fast-paced New York bagel shop, where efficiency is key. Despite the potential for a small wait, the quality and affordability of the food make it worth it. The atmosphere is that of a quintessential neighborhood bagel shop—casual and focused on the product. It’s a place for a "quick visit," where you can get your order and be on your way. The cleanliness, while mentioned as a point for improvement by a reviewer who wished the "tables were swept," doesn’t detract from the overall quality of the food. The focus here is on the bagels and the spreads, with the "famous cream cheese and salmon sandwich" being a particular favorite. The shop’s inclusive environment is also a notable feature, with its designation as an LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender safe space, as well as a gender-neutral restroom, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all members of the community. This combination of great food, reasonable prices, and a friendly vibe makes it a beloved local spot.

The price point at Bagel Talk is a major selling point. As one customer noted, the "price is reasonable," making it an accessible option for daily breakfast or lunch. This affordability, combined with the quality of the ingredients, provides excellent value for money. The menu offers a variety of bagel flavors, from the classic Plain and Everything Bagel to more unique options like the Flagel Everything Bagel, which is a flattened bagel. The option to buy a Bakers Dozen is perfect for families or for an office breakfast. The variety of spreads and sandwich fillings means that you can customize your order to your exact preferences, from a simple cream cheese schmear to a full-fledged gourmet sandwich. The popularity of the "famous cream cheese and salmon sandwich" speaks to the quality of their ingredients, particularly the thinly sliced, clean-tasting nova. While the experience may have its minor quirks, the consistent quality of the food and the friendly service ensure that Bagel Talk remains a top choice for a classic New York bagel experience. It is a place that lives up to its name, providing a great bagel and a solid foundation for a good day.

---

Bagel Talk is conveniently located at 368 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA on the Upper West Side. Its central location on a major avenue makes it easily accessible for locals and visitors alike. The shop is committed to accessibility, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance to ensure a welcoming experience for all patrons. The primary service options are takeout and delivery, making it a perfect spot for a quick grab-and-go meal. While there is no on-site dining, the focus is on providing a fresh product efficiently. For those arriving by car, paid street parking is available, though it can be competitive in the busy neighborhood. Its location makes it an ideal stop for a quick bite on the way to work, a park visit, or simply while running errands in the area.

---

• Takeout: The main service offered, with an efficient system for quick and easy ordering and pickup.

• Delivery: Provides delivery service, allowing customers to enjoy their bagels from the comfort of their home or office.

• In-store Pickup: Customers can place orders online for a scheduled in-store pickup, streamlining the process.

• Full Breakfast Menu: Offers an extensive all-day breakfast menu with a variety of bagel sandwiches and more.

• Espresso Bar: Serves a selection of coffee and espresso drinks to complement the food menu.

---

• Chewy and Delicious Bagels: Known for its classic, chewy bagels in a wide variety of flavors.

• Reasonable Prices: Praised for its affordability, offering great value for money for a high-quality product.

• High-Quality Ingredients: Uses fresh and delicious ingredients, particularly noted in its nova and cream cheese.

• Variety of Menu Options: Offers a diverse menu, including all-day breakfast sandwiches, gourmet salads, and gluten-free options.

• Inclusive Atmosphere: A welcoming spot that is LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space with a gender-neutral restroom.

---

Address: 368 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Phone: (212) 875-1267

---

Choosing Bagel Talk is an excellent decision for anyone who appreciates the classic, no-nonsense New York bagel experience. What makes it particularly worth choosing is its ability to deliver on the fundamentals. In a city where some bagel shops are trying to reinvent the wheel, Bagel Talk stands firm on the quality of its core product. The bagels themselves are a key reason to visit, with their satisfyingly chewy texture and a variety of classic and modern flavors. The affordability is another major draw; it provides a high-quality breakfast or lunch option at a price that won't break the bank, making it a perfect spot for a daily ritual rather than just an occasional treat. The rave reviews for the "famous cream cheese and salmon sandwich" are a testament to the quality of their ingredients, particularly the thinly sliced, clean-tasting nova. It's a dish that embodies the best of a New York deli experience.

The variety of the menu is also a significant reason to choose Bagel Talk. Whether you're in the mood for a simple bagel with cream cheese, a hearty breakfast sandwich, or a lighter salad, there is something for everyone. The inclusion of a full gluten-free menu is a thoughtful touch that makes it an accessible option for a wider audience. While the process of ordering might have a unique quirk, the friendly staff and efficient service ensure that you get your food quickly, which is a major plus in a city where time is of the essence. Bagel Talk is a place that values substance over style, and its commitment to providing a consistently delicious product at a fair price has earned it a loyal following. It is a true neighborhood gem and a perfect choice for anyone who wants an authentic, no-fuss New York bagel experience.

Bagel Talk

368 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA