Bagels Bread & Butter

- 732 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310

For those living in or visiting Staten Island, the search for an authentic, satisfying New York bagel often leads to the doors of Bagels Bread & Butter. This establishment has become a beloved local fixture, extending far beyond the typical bagel shop to offer an expansive menu of deli favorites, robust breakfast options, and catering to the diverse culinary needs of the New York community. Known for a welcoming atmosphere and efficient service, Bagels Bread & Butter is a dependable choice whether you're grabbing a quick morning bite or a substantial lunch. It's a true Staten Island deli experience, committed to quality and variety, making it a highly recommended stop for locals seeking their daily fix or visitors looking for a taste of authentic NYC food culture.

The store prides itself on a wide selection of items, ensuring there's something to please every palate and fit any schedule, from the early riser needing a coffee and a classic bagel with cream cheese, to the lunchtime rush looking for a hearty hero or wrap. The positive customer feedback often highlights the friendly staff and prompt service, cementing its reputation as a great local deli where speed and warmth are part of the deal. While some may note the spacious interior and a focus on efficiency, the primary attraction remains the substantial, freshly prepared food that keeps the loyal clientele returning day after day.

The classic New York bagel is the heart of the operation. Customers can enjoy a simple, perfectly chewy bagel with butter or jelly, or elevate their experience with numerous cream cheese combinations, including flavored options. The menu expands significantly into the realm of a full-service deli, featuring Boar's Head premium meats and cheeses, an array of specialty sandwiches, and various homemade prepared foods, offering convenience and quality beyond a standard bakery or breakfast spot. This blending of a classic bagel shop with an expansive deli menu is precisely what makes Bagels Bread & Butter a standout destination in the Staten Island food landscape.

A quintessential New York meal often begins with breakfast, and Bagels Bread & Butter delivers on this promise in a big way. The menu is stacked with classic egg sandwiches, specialty omelets, and morning staples, providing a perfect start to any day. For those who enjoy a fuller morning meal, options like pancakes and French toast are also available. The commitment to providing diverse dining options is clear, offering more than just quick-serve items but also robust, sit-down quality meals for those on the go.

Bagels Bread & Butter is conveniently located at 732 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310. Situated in the West New Brighton neighborhood, this spot is a central and easily accessible location for residents across the North Shore and beyond. Forest Avenue is a busy thoroughfare, making the shop a simple detour for commuters and locals alike. Accessibility is a key feature, with the establishment providing a free parking lot, eliminating the typical New York City street parking headaches. Furthermore, the premises are designed to be inclusive, offering a wheelchair-accessible entrance and a dedicated wheelchair-accessible parking lot, ensuring that all community members can visit comfortably. Its location on a main avenue also aids in quick visits and easy in-and-out access, ideal for those with busy schedules.

Bagels Bread & Butter provides a variety of service options to meet modern New Yorkers' dynamic needs, catering to both quick visits and those wishing to grab their meal for later.

• Delivery: Offering the convenience of getting your favorite bagels, breakfast, or lunch items brought directly to your door.
• In-store Pickup: Allows for ordering ahead and quickly collecting your meal without waiting in line.
• In-store Shopping: Traditional counter service for browsing and purchasing a wide selection of items on the spot.
• Takeout: Perfect for customers who want to grab their order and enjoy it elsewhere.
• Onsite Services: While primarily a quick-visit spot, the availability of onsite services ensures an efficient and professional experience.
• Extensive Breakfast Menu: Served as a primary dining option, with everything from single bagels to full omelets and breakfast platters.

The reputation of Bagels Bread & Butter is built upon several core features that appeal directly to the Staten Island and greater New York demographic looking for quality, variety, and efficiency.

• Authentic NY Bagels: Serving up the classic New York-style bagel, known for its distinct chew and flavor. Options include single bagels, half-dozens, and dozens, with mini bagels also available.
• Boar's Head Premium Meats: A dedicated selection of sandwiches and by-the-pound deli meats featuring the high-quality Boar's Head brand, including Ovengold Turkey, EverRoast Chicken, and Deluxe Ham.
• Diverse Prepared Foods: Offering homemade items such as chicken cutlet, grilled chicken, chicken salad, tuna salad, and egg salad, available on a bagel, hero, or by the pound.
• All-Day Options: While a bagel shop, the menu extends through breakfast (including omelets, pancakes, and French toast) and a full deli lunch with specialty sandwiches like The NYPD, The FDNY, and various hero options.
• Beverage Selection: Featuring essential breakfast beverages like hot coffee and iced coffee (available in a box of joe for groups), perfectly paired with any meal.
• Convenient Payment Options: Accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a fast and frictionless transaction experience.

For placing an order, inquiries, or simply to confirm business hours, you can reach the shop using the information below:

• Address: 732 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
• Phone: (718) 447-3331
• Mobile Phone: +1 718-447-3331

Choosing Bagels Bread & Butter is an easy decision for anyone in the Staten Island area who values a combination of classic New York quality and modern-day convenience. The sheer breadth of the menu ensures that whether you're craving a simple, hot bagel with cream cheese, a massive "Super Mario Special" breakfast platter with eggs, bacon, sausage, cheese, and home fries, or a fully loaded Boar’s Head hero for lunch, you will find a satisfying option. The presence of numerous specialty sandwiches, such as the "Belly Buster" or the "Sopranos Sandwich," speaks to the true New York deli tradition of creating signature, hearty meals that are hard to find elsewhere.

The commitment to high-quality ingredients, notably the use of Boar's Head products for their premium meats, ensures that every sandwich and hero is made with excellence. Furthermore, the availability of both individual items and bulk options (like a dozen bagels or a pound of prepared salad) makes it perfect for both personal dining and feeding a group. The services offered, including delivery, in-store pickup, and a free parking lot, showcase an understanding of the local customer's need for speed and ease of access. When you choose Bagels Bread & Butter, you are choosing a local business that prioritizes friendly service, generous portions, and an authentic taste of New York’s best breakfast and deli culture, making it a reliable and excellent choice on Forest Avenue.

The fact that the staff is frequently described by customers as "friendly and welcoming" and the service as "prompt" is a testament to the overall positive experience you can expect. For a great deli experience, offering high-quality bagels and a full range of breakfast and lunch options in Staten Island, this location is undoubtedly a top recommendation for all New Yorkers.

Bagels Bread & Butter

732 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA