Barely Disfigured

- 257 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Barely Disfigured is more than just a cocktail bar; it's a meticulously crafted experience that stands out as a unique destination in Brooklyn’s vibrant nightlife scene. Named after a surrealist poem by Paul Éluard, this establishment on Smith Street in Carroll Gardens has embraced a fascinating history, creating a sultry, secretive, and artistic atmosphere. The decor, a sophisticated blend of 1920s French bordello vibes and surrealist touches, transports patrons to a different world. From the moment you step through its unassuming storefront, you are greeted by an intimate corridor leading to a long, swerving marble bar. This attention to detail has not gone unnoticed, with the bar being named one of the "Top 10 Best New Bars" on the East Coast by Tale of the Cocktail. It’s a place where every element, from the dim, moody lighting to the curated vintage decor, works together to create a captivating ambiance. The bar’s rich history, which nods to its past as a former "house of ill-repute," adds to its alluring charm without being crass, and a portion of its proceeds are even donated to the Urban Justice Center’s Sex Workers Project. This combination of a compelling backstory, a visually stunning environment, and a commitment to quality has made Barely Disfigured a favorite among locals and cocktail enthusiasts alike.

The core of Barely Disfigured’s appeal lies in its ambitious and delicate cocktails. The bar's mixologists are widely regarded as "masters of their craft," known for creating drinks with perfectly balanced and unique flavors. The menu, which includes signature cocktails with intriguing names like "The Dirty Old Man" and "The Harlot's Progress," showcases a passion for innovation and high-quality ingredients. Customers consistently rave about the "fabulous and so creative" cocktails, and some have even praised the “spectacular” clarified cocktails, a true mark of a skilled bar. Beyond the exquisite drinks, Barely Disfigured offers a carefully curated selection of food options, including share plates, a charcuterie board, and a highly-praised raw bar. The fresh oysters, for example, have been called "the best in the city," and are a perfect accompaniment to the sophisticated drinks. The bar also features a stunning 1,800-square-foot backyard garden, a luxurious outdoor oasis that offers a different atmosphere from the intimate interior. Complete with its own outdoor drinks and raw bar, the space is perfect for enjoying a drink during warmer months. The staff contributes significantly to the overall experience, with reviews frequently highlighting their friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable service. This makes the bar a welcoming and safe space for all, including the LGBTQ+ and transgender communities.

The overall vibe at Barely Disfigured is a harmonious blend of upscale elegance and comfortable, casual charm. It's an ideal spot for a romantic date night, an intimate gathering with friends, or simply a place to relax and enjoy a meticulously crafted drink. The bar's reputation has grown, and it is now a sought-after location for private events, celebrations, and even film shoots, having been featured in the HBO series "High Maintenance." The fact that it maintains an intimate, "first-come, first-served" policy on most nights speaks to its dedication to providing a high-quality, personal experience for every patron. The music and general ambiance are carefully curated to match the sophisticated, low-key vibe, creating a perfect backdrop for conversation and connection. The bar’s owners have been praised for their charismatic presence and willingness to engage with patrons, making the experience feel even more personal and special. This hands-on approach, combined with the bar’s creative menu and beautiful spaces, has cemented its status as a true gem in Brooklyn. For New Yorkers seeking a unique and enchanting night out, Barely Disfigured offers an unparalleled experience that feels both luxurious and welcoming.

Barely Disfigured is nestled in the charming and accessible neighborhood of Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, at 257 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA. Its convenient location on Smith Street, close to public transport options like the F and G train lines, makes it easy to get to from various parts of the city. The bar is also committed to accessibility, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible restroom, ensuring that all guests feel welcome and comfortable. Paid street parking is available in the vicinity for those traveling by car.

• Dine-in: Enjoy a full-service experience inside or in the lush outdoor garden.
• Outdoor seating: A spacious backyard patio with its own bar and seating area.
• Table service: Relax and let the professional and friendly staff take care of your needs.
• Happy hour: Specials on drinks and oysters at the start of the evening.
• Wi-Fi: Stay connected while you unwind.
• Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

• Expertly crafted cocktails: A diverse and creative menu of drinks with perfectly balanced flavors.
• Unique atmosphere: A cozy, romantic, and upscale vibe with a surrealist-meets-French salon theme.
• Lush outdoor garden: A beautifully designed 1,800 sq. ft. backyard space perfect for al fresco drinks.
• Raw bar and share plates: A curated food menu that includes fresh oysters and charcuterie.
• Friendly and knowledgeable staff: Bartenders who are masters of their craft and offer great conversation.
• LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender safespace: A welcoming and inclusive environment for all patrons.
• Live performances and music: Occasional live entertainment to enhance the ambiance.
• Historic and artistic backstory: The bar’s name and decor are inspired by a surrealist poem and its intriguing past.

Address: 257 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Phone: (718) 858-5646

Barely Disfigured is truly worth choosing for anyone in New York looking for a bar experience that transcends the ordinary. Its primary appeal lies in the exceptional quality of its cocktails, which are crafted by truly skilled bartenders. For cocktail aficionados, this is a place to discover new flavors and experience a level of mixology that is a cut above the rest. The bar’s unique atmosphere, which is both seductive and comfortable, makes it an ideal spot for a variety of occasions, from a romantic date to a sophisticated night out with friends. The space itself is a key highlight, with its moody interior, curving marble bar, and a luxurious back room, all leading out to a magnificent outdoor garden. This versatility in setting means there is a perfect spot for every mood and season. Furthermore, the food menu, particularly the raw bar and share plates, adds a layer of culinary sophistication that pairs perfectly with the drinks. Beyond the tangible offerings, the bar's staff and owners have cultivated a truly welcoming and inclusive environment, which is a rare and valuable quality in the city’s nightlife. The combination of its ambitious, high-quality offerings, unique and artistic atmosphere, and its commitment to customer satisfaction makes Barely Disfigured a standout destination. It's not just a place to grab a drink; it's a place to be delighted, surprised, and to create a memorable night out in Brooklyn.

Barely Disfigured

257 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA