Beni’s Trattoria Garnerville NY: Authentic Italian Dining in Rockland County

Beni’s Trattoria Introduce

For New York area residents, especially those in Rockland County, the search for authentic, homestyle Italian dining often leads to a beloved local secret: Beni’s Trattoria in Garnerville. Located at 81 N Central Hwy, this family-owned and operated restaurant is much more than a typical local eatery; it's a destination that brings generations of Italian culinary tradition to the table. Offering a warm, casual, and cozy atmosphere, Beni's provides a dedicated dining experience that caters equally well to a quick solo lunch, a family dinner, or a gathering of friends.

The core of Beni's appeal lies in its extensive menu, which skillfully balances the traditional favorites of an Italian Trattoria with a wider array of Italian-American comfort food. Diners can expect everything from classic New York-style appetizers to a full repertoire of Italian entrees. The focus is always on freshness, generous portions, and flavors that feel genuinely homemade. This commitment to quality and value is what has earned Beni’s a loyal following in the New York-New Jersey metro region.

The culinary offerings span numerous categories, ensuring there is a delicious option for every craving. The menu features an impressive "Pasta Barilla" selection, ranging from the creamy richness of Penne Vodka and Fettuccine Alfredo to the savory complexity of Farfalle with Sausage and Broccoli Rabe. For those who love the baked Italian classics, the "Old Italian Favorites" section includes comforting dishes like Meat Lasagna, Baked Ziti, and various stuffed ravioli, including the decadent Lobster Ravioli. These are the dishes that define a true Italian-American experience.

Beyond pasta, the menu shines with its robust selection of main courses. The "Chicken Entrees" feature staples such as Chicken Parmigiana, Chicken Marsala, and Chicken Francese, alongside more specialized options like Chicken Saltimbocca. The "Veal Entrees" offer a similarly strong showing, with Veal Parmigiana, Veal Picatta, and Veal Marsala promising tender, flavorful preparations. Seafood lovers, or "Pesce," are well catered to with options like Fruta Di Mare—a medley of jumbo shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels, and scallops served over linguine—and perfectly prepared Pan Seared Salmon, ensuring that every palate is satisfied.

Location and Accessibility

Beni’s Trattoria is centrally located at 81 N Central Hwy, Garnerville, NY 10923. This position in Garnerville makes it an easy and convenient stop for residents of Rockland County and those traveling through the North Central Highway corridor.

The restaurant is dedicated to providing a welcoming experience for all patrons, highlighting its commitment to accessibility:

Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Additionally, for drivers, the venue provides ample Free parking lot access, complemented by Free street parking, making visits stress-free and convenient—a significant advantage for New York-area diners.

Services Offered

Beni’s Trattoria offers a full range of modern dining and service options to suit various needs and preferences:

Dine-in: Full table service in a casual, cozy, and family-friendly atmosphere.
Takeout: Convenient pickup service for enjoying meals at home.
Delivery: Available for both no-contact and standard delivery options, bringing hot and fresh Italian food directly to local homes and businesses.
Curbside Pickup: A dedicated service option for maximum convenience and minimal contact.
Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, making it an excellent choice for planning group gatherings or ensuring a table during peak dining hours.
Catering: While not explicitly listed as a service option in the provided information, the generous portions, family-style meals, and range of heroes, wraps, and entrees strongly suggest a capability to handle larger orders for parties and catered events.
Bar and Beverage Offerings: Provides a selection of Alcohol, Beer, Wine, and Coffee to complement any meal.

Features / Highlights

The experience at Beni’s Trattoria is defined by a few key elements that consistently draw positive attention:

Fast Service: Recognized as a highlight, ensuring a prompt and efficient dining experience, ideal for both a quick lunch and a relaxed dinner.
Great Dessert: A known highlight that completes the meal experience, suggesting a dedicated focus on quality sweets and concluding courses.
Authentic and Diverse Menu: Features a wide array of classic Italian favorites, from Baked Ziti and specialty ravioli to a large selection of veal, chicken, and seafood entrees.
Lunch and Casual Options: Beyond the dinner entrees, the restaurant is highly popular for lunch, offering excellent value on cold heroes, hot heroes, wraps, and paninis.
Family-Centric Atmosphere: The venue is described as casual, cozy, family-friendly, and provides high chairs and a dedicated Kids' Menu, welcoming groups and families.
Community Inclusion: The establishment actively fosters an inclusive environment, noting its status as LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace, making it a welcoming spot for everyone in the community.

Contact Information

To place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about the menu, please use the following contact details:

Address: 81 N Central Hwy, Garnerville, NY 10923

Phone: (845) 942-1222

What is Worth Choosing Beni’s Trattoria?

For diners in the New York region, choosing Beni’s Trattoria means selecting a dining experience that perfectly marries authentic Italian flavors with a welcoming, local atmosphere. It's an excellent choice for multiple reasons. First, the sheer breadth and quality of the menu—from the satisfying simplicity of Pasta Fagioli and delicious homemade bread to complex entrees like Fruta Di Mare—guarantees an appealing option for every member of a party. The ability to cater to both the full-service dining crowd with table service and the on-the-go crowd with fast takeout and a selection of heroes and wraps makes it versatile.

Furthermore, the high regard for customer service, noted by patrons who praise the attentive staff, along with the commitment to accessibility, makes Beni's Trattoria a hassle-free and genuinely pleasant place to eat. When you are seeking a reliable, high-quality, and comfortable Italian meal in Rockland County, where you know you will receive great portions, authentic recipes, and excellent service, Beni’s Trattoria is a clear standout. It is the definition of a dependable, local-favorite Italian restaurant.

Beni’s Trattoria Services

Appetizers
Buffalo Wings $14.95
Comes with 10 jumbo wings.
Mozzarella Sticks $9.95
Chicken Tenders and Fries $10.95
Comes with 4 chicken tenders and French fries.
Marinara Mussels $14.95
Shrimp Cocktail $12.95
Comes with cocktail sauce
Coconut Chicken $12.95
Delicious coconut chicken topped with orange marmalade sauce.
Fried Calamari $13.95
Eggplant Rollatini $11.95
Eggplant rolled with ricotta served with sauce and parmigana
Mozzarella Pomedore $11.95
Plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & olive oil
Cold Antipasto Salad $15.95
Prosciutto, ham, marinated eggplant, sun-dried tomatoes, black olives, Gorgonzola cheese, roasted red peppers, & fresh mozzarella drizzled with balsamic glaze.

Soups
Pasta fagioli
16 oz. - $6.95 / 32 oz. - $11.95
Escarole & Bean
16 oz. - $6.95 / 32 oz. - $11.95
Chicken Noodle
16 oz. - $6.95 / 32 oz. - $11.95
Spinach Egg Drop
16 oz. - $6.95 / 32 oz. - $11.95

Salads
Tossed Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, roasted peppers, & olives. Small - $6.95 Large - $9.95
Chef Salad
Spring mix lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, salami, ham, provolone cheese, pepperoni, and hard boiled eggs.
Greek Salad $13.95
Romain lettuce, tomatoes, Kalamata, olives, stuffed grape leaves, and feta cheese
Spinach and Grilled Shrimp $15.95
Spinach, goat cheese, sautéed, shiitake, mushrooms, and balsamic vinaigrette
Caesar Salad
Romain lettuce, croutons, Parmesan cheese, and Caesar dressing. Small- $7.95 / Large- $10.95
Chopped Salad $10.95
Mixed Romaine lettuce, iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and balsamic vinaigrette
Mista salad $13.95
Spring mixed lettuce, fresh chicken cutlet, tomatoes, Parmesan cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette.
Buffalo Chicken Salad $13.95
Mixed green lettuce, Breaded buffalo chicken, tomatoes, crumbled blue cheese.
Roman Salad $13.95
Mixed green lettuce, chopped grilled chicken, apples, craisins, walnuts, and balsamic vinaigrette.
Add Chicken $5.00
Add chicken to any salad or extra chicken
Add Shrimp $8.00
Add shrimp to any salad or extra shrimp
Add Salmon $14.00
Add salmon to any salad

Pasta Barilla
Penne Marinara $16.95
Pasta w/ marinara sauce. Entree comes with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Penne Vodka $17.95
Pasta w/ light tomato creamy vodka sauce. Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Linguine with Clam Sauce $19.95
Little neck clams w/ red or white sauce. Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Stuffed Rigatoni Bolognese $18.95
Jumbo rigatoni pasta stuffed w/ ricotta cheese in our house made creamy meat sauce. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Linguine and Meatballs $17.95
Pasta w/ marinara sauce and our house made meatballs. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Farfalle Sausage and Broccoli Rabe $20.95
Served with garlic and oil. //Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Rigatoni Carbonara $17.95
Rigatoni pasta with bacon bits and parmigiana reggiano sauce. //Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Cavatelli Chicken Broccoli $19.95
Served in garlic & oil. //Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Penne Romano $18.95
Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, garlic & oil topped with a touch of marinara sauce. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Fettuccine Alfredo $17.95
House made pasta fettuccini with creamy Alfredo sauce. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Pasta Trattoria $20.95
Grilled chicken, sun dried tomatoes, zucchini, & broccoli in a garlic white wine sauce served with penne pasta. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Add Chicken to Pasta $6.00
Extra chicken
Add Shrimp to Pasta $10.00
Add shrimp

Old Italian Favorites
Stuffed Shells $18.95
Stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella cheese.
Baked Ziti $18.95
Meat Lasagna $18.95
Cheese Ravioli $18.95
Spinach Ravioli $18.95
In vodka sauce
Lobster Ravioli $20.95
Tortellini Pomodoro $19.95

Sides
Side of Meatballs or Sausage $6.95
Side of French Fries $6.95
Broccoli with Garlic and Oil $8.95
Broccoli Rabe with Garlic Oil $9.95
Sautéed Spinach with Garlic and Oil $9.95
Potato Croquettes $6.95
3 potato croquettes
Side of Grilled Chicken $8.95
Garlic Bread $4.00
With a side of marinara sauce
Garlic Bread with Cheese $4.95
With a side of marinara sauce

Eggplant Entrees
Eggplant Parmigiana $19.95
Topped with marinara & mozzarella served with linguine. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Eggplant Rollatini $19.95
Stuffed with ricotta cheese, topped with marinara & mozzarella served with linguine. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.

Chicken Entrees
Chicken Parmigiana $18.95
Breaded chicken, topped with marinara and mozzarella served with linguine. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Chicken Cacciatore $20.95
Sautéed chicken with fresh mushrooms, onions & peppers in a red wine sauce with a touch of marinara. Served with potato croquettes & mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Chicken Milanese $20.95
Lightly breaded chicken breast sautéed in butter served with a side of broccoli garlic & oil. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Chicken Francese $20.95
Lightly battered & sautéed in lemon & white wine sauce, served with potato croquettes and mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Chicken Marsala $20.95
Sautéed in a Marsala white wine served with fresh mushrooms, potato croquettes & mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Chicken Saltimbocca $22.95
Chicken breast layer w/ prosciutto & topped with fresh mozzarella in a cream cherry sauce, served with potato croquettes & mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Chicken Portobello $22.95
Sautéed chicken, portobello mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes, shallots, in a light brown sauce, served with potato croquettes and mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Chicken Arrabiata $22.95
Sautéed chicken w/ lemon white sauce, mushrooms, cherry peppers, & a touch of marinara sauce, served with potato croquettes and mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Rabe $22.95
Sautéed in garlic & oil. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Chicken Florentine $22.95
Grilled eggplant, fresh mozzarella, white wine sauce & a touch of marinara. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.

Veal Entrees
Veal Parmigiana $20.95
Breaded & topped with marinara & mozzarella. Served with linguine. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Veal Picatta $24.95
Sautéed in a white wine, lemon & caper sauce, served with potato croquettes and mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Veal ala Principessa $24.95
Eggplant, prosciutto, tomatoes & white wine sauce, served with potato croquettes and mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Veal Cacciatore $24.95
Onions, peppers, & mushrooms in a red wine w/ a touch of marinara sauce served with potato croquettes. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Veal Francese $22.95
Lightly battered & sautéed in lemon & white wine sauce, served with potato croquettes & mixed vegetables. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Veal Marsala $22.95
Sautéed in a Marsala white wine sauce w/ fresh mushrooms, served with potato croquettes & mixed vegetables.
Veal Milanese $24.95
Lightly breaded veal sautéed in butter served with a side of broccoli garlic & oil. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.

Steak Entrees
Grilled NY Sirloin $28.95
Served with sautéed mixed vegetables & potato croquettes.

Pesce (Fish) Entrees
Calamari Marinara $24.95
Sautéed in our garlic, basil, & tomato sauce, served over linguine. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Shrimp Marinara $24.95
Sautéed in our garlic, basil & tomato sauce. Served over linguine. // Entree served with a side salad or soup of your choice and bread.
Fruta Di Mare $26.95
Jumbo shrimp, calamari, clams, mussels & scallops, in a red or white sauce served over linguini. // Entree served with a choice of salad or soup.
Sole Oreganata $24.95
Topped w/ seasoned breadcrumbs served w/ potato croquettes & sautéed baby spinach // Entree served with your choice of salad or soup.
Scampi Provencale $26.95
Shrimp & scallops sautéed w/ plum tomatoes & fresh basil in a garlic & white wine sauce served over capellini // Entree served with your choice of salad or soup.
Pan Seared Salmon $26.95
Served w/ Kalamata olives, sun-dried tomatoes & artichoke hearts in a white wine garlic sauce & side of broccoli // Entree served with your choice of salad or soup.

Beni’s Trattoria Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great dessert

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Coffee
Comfort food
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Locals
Transgender safespace

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Beni’s Trattoria Photos

Beni’s Trattoria Location

Beni’s Trattoria

New York Rockland County Thiells Garnerville North Central Highway

81 N Central Hwy, Garnerville, NY 10923, USA

Beni’s Trattoria Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 64 user reviews.

pizzapricespiefood and servicechicken parmdeliverydinnersaucevealslices

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

My daughter and I had a wonderful dinner tonight at Beni’s. Our waitress, EZRA was friendly and very attentive. Our dinners, Cavatelli and broccoli with chicken and the fruttii Di mara with white sauce were absolutely delicious. Also really enjoyed their homemade bread with a nice olive oil for dipping.I also come here for lunch and have never been disappointed the cold heroes, hot-heroes ,wraps and Panini’s Are always good in a real value for your money. Also, all of their soups are excellent and are served steaming hot. Come to Beni’s, and you won’t be disappointed
August 17 · Gina Goswick
I usually only stop in for pizza but today I decided to get my fav chicken dish and it was SO good! Great portion/price and flavor. You could tell the veggies were fresh and the lemon sauce on chicken was perfect!
July 07 · Christina Costanzo
I always get delivery from door dash from this place. The food is phenomenal best pizza and chicken parm in this side of town. Should have more hype around it tbh
July 20 · Melanie Gomez
Excellent restaurant! The veal was so incredibly tender, you won't find this often even in Manhattan restaurants. Pasta and pizza the kids ordered were also great. Portions were enormous. Our waitresses Zona and Erza were very sweet. Highly recommended!
August 09 · O.T. Vinta
Wonderful family restaurant, exceptional food and service, diverse menu and very reasonable prices. Satisfaction guaranteed.A++
June 18 · Richard DuBoff