Benny's Famous Pizza

- 4514 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11219

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers seeking a consistently delicious and reliable spot in Brooklyn, look no further than Benny's Famous Pizza. Located in the heart of the Borough Park neighborhood, this establishment is far more than just your average pizza place. It stands out as a beloved Kosher dairy restaurant specializing in a wide array of pizzas and comforting dairy dishes, making it a true local staple. Benny’s Famous Pizza has cultivated a reputation for serving affordable, high-quality meals and is known for its welcoming, casual atmosphere, catering to everyone from college students and local families to groups and tourists passing through.

Since its establishment, Benny's has been a go-to for many who appreciate both the quality of the food and the convenience of its offerings. Patrons frequently highlight the excellent customer service and the overall positive atmosphere. Whether you are craving a quick slice for lunch, a hearty hot plate for dinner, or a fresh, satisfying salad, Benny's Famous Pizza provides a vast menu that ensures there is something for every palate and every part of the day. The restaurant’s status as a Kosher dairy establishment means all dishes adhere to strict dietary laws, which is a major draw for the local community and visitors alike.

In a city overflowing with pizza options, Benny's distinguishes itself by offering a unique selection of specialty pies and other non-pizza favorites, solidifying its place as a cherished institution on 13th Avenue. One customer review noted, "The best place to come and get a great breakfast, lunch, or supper. The prices are very reasonable and the customer service and atmosphere are out of this world. Highly recommended." The commitment to quality ingredients, combined with an extensive and diverse menu, ensures that Benny's Famous Pizza remains at the top of the list for Brooklyn food enthusiasts.

Location and Accessibility

Benny's Famous Pizza is strategically located at 4514 13th Ave in Brooklyn, NY 11219, placing it squarely in the vibrant and bustling Borough Park neighborhood. The 13th Avenue corridor is a hub of local commerce and activity, making the restaurant easily accessible for those in the area. For those driving, the location benefits from both free and paid street parking options nearby, which, for New York City, is a significant convenience. Its prime location in this dense residential and commercial area contributes to its popularity for quick bites and casual dining.

The restaurant is committed to ensuring a comfortable experience for all its guests, as evidenced by its robust accessibility features. Patrons with mobility needs will find the location accommodating, as it includes a wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible seating, and a wheelchair accessible restroom. This focus on accessibility, combined with the general ease of finding and reaching the establishment in Borough Park, enhances its appeal as a friendly neighborhood spot for the New York community.

Services Offered

• Dine-in: A casual atmosphere with seating available for a relaxed meal.
• Takeout: Convenient options for ordering ahead and picking up to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Delivery: The restaurant provides delivery service, ensuring your favorite items can be enjoyed without leaving your home or office.
• Catering and Group Dining: The location is suitable for groups and is a popular choice for planning quick, casual meals.
• Payment Options: Accepts major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for seamless transactions.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: Equipped with high chairs and is noted to be good for kids, making it an excellent choice for family dining.
• Dining Throughout the Day: Popular for all major meals, including Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner, as well as late-night food options.

Features / Highlights

• Kosher Dairy Specialization: Benny's is a fully Kosher dairy restaurant, offering peace of mind to customers seeking meals that adhere to these dietary standards.
• Local Specialty Food: The menu is recognized for serving local specialty dishes, with items like their 'famous knishes' and 'falafels' noted as signature and very popular choices.
• Unique Pizza Selections: Beyond the classic Cheese Pizza, Benny's offers distinctive specialty pies such as Baked Ziti Pizza, Falafel Pizza, Chicago Pizza, Whole Wheat W/Veg. Pizza, and the Sourdough Personal Pizza Pie, offering diverse choices for any pizza lover.
• Extensive Menu Variety: The offerings extend well beyond pizza, featuring a robust selection of Hot Plates (like Baked Ziti, Lasagna, and Eggplant Parmesan), fresh Salad Platters, hearty Fish Platter Specials (including Baked and Grilled Salmon), comforting Soups, and various Calzones and Wraps.
• Comfort Food Central: The menu is rich in comfort food items and quick bites, including the famous Garlic Knots, Poutine, Spicy Poutine, Cheese Blintzes, Cream Cheese Sticks, and Baked Potatoes with various toppings.
• Vegetarian Options: With its dairy and fish-based menu, the restaurant naturally provides extensive vegetarian options, from all the pizzas and pastas to wraps, salads, and vegetable-focused hot plates.
• Highly Accessible: Features include a wheelchair accessible entrance, seating, and restroom, making it easily navigable for all patrons.
• Popular for All Dining Types: Highly popular for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, as well as solo dining, indicating its suitability for any dining need throughout the day.

Contact Information

Address: 4514 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11219, USA

Phone: (718) 438-2369

What is worth choosing

When stepping into Benny's Famous Pizza, you are met with an overwhelming yet exciting array of options. The biggest draw for many is, of course, the pizza. While the classic Cheese Pizza is a reliable and satisfying option, New Yorkers should truly explore the specialty pies. The Falafel Pizza is a standout local specialty, representing a unique fusion that you won't easily find elsewhere and has garnered positive attention from customers for its different and great texture. The Chicago Pizza is another fan favorite, offering a deeper-dish experience in a city known primarily for thin crusts.

Beyond the pizza, the menu's true depth lies in its Hot Plates and classic appetizers. The Hot Plates, such as the Baked Ziti Hot Plate or the Lasagna Hot Plate—both priced affordably for a hearty meal—are perfect comfort food, especially on a chilly New York day. For an authentic experience, ordering the Falafel Balls or the highly-rated Garlic Knots is a must to start your meal. These items are noted for their quality and are signature dishes of the restaurant.

For a healthier alternative, the selection of Salad Platters is noteworthy. The Israeli Salad and Greek Salad With Cheese platters are substantial and satisfying, making them excellent lunch options. Furthermore, Benny's commitment to accommodating various dietary needs is highlighted by its Gluten Free Pizza and numerous vegetarian choices, making it a reliable option for all New Yorkers, regardless of preference. The final choice should always include trying one of their celebrated dishes—whether it’s a slice of their unique Falafel Pizza or a comforting order of Creamed Spinach—to fully appreciate why Benny's Famous Pizza has maintained its popularity in the heart of Brooklyn.

Benny's Famous Pizza

4514 13th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11219, USA