Big Jim's Pizzeria

- 281 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646

For decades, Big Jim's Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of the New Milford dining scene, serving Bergen County residents with reliable, hearty Italian-American fare. Located right on Main Street, this establishment is a true local institution that transcends the typical 'pizza place' label. While the pizza—available by the slice, whole pie, or Sicilian style—is a daily staple, Big Jim's operates as a full-service Italian restaurant, offering an expansive menu that includes classic entrees, heroes, salads, and a full catering program.

The atmosphere inside is described as casual, cozy, and quiet, providing a welcoming environment for families, individuals dining solo, and groups alike. Customers often praise the experience of eating a classic New Jersey-style slice with a flavorful blend of sauce and cheese. The commitment to delivering fast service ensures that Big Jim's is the perfect spot for a quick bite during a workday lunch break or a convenient takeout dinner after a long day.

Beyond the pizza, the menu offers a genuine taste of classic Italian-American comfort food, from Baked Ziti and Homemade Lasagna to traditional Chicken Parmigiana and Veal Cutlet entrees. This variety, combined with regular value offerings such as the celebrated "Pizza Sale," cements Big Jim's Pizzeria's role as a versatile and economical dining choice for the New Milford community and surrounding towns.

Big Jim's Pizzeria is centrally and conveniently located at 281 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA. Its Main Street location makes it highly visible and easily accessible for both foot traffic and those traveling by car in Bergen County.

The restaurant provides excellent accommodations for a wide range of customers:

• Customers benefit from Free Parking Lot access, supplemented by available Free Street Parking and designated On-site Parking, eliminating the stress of finding a spot in a busy town center.
• The dining area is fully accessible, featuring a Wheelchair Accessible Entrance and Wheelchair Accessible Seating, ensuring a comfortable visit for all guests.
• The premises include a customer Restroom.
• The casual, cozy setting is popular for both lunch and dinner, and is situated to provide a quick escape for solo diners or a relaxed meal for families.

Big Jim's Pizzeria provides a comprehensive array of service options to meet the needs of its New Jersey customers, whether they need a quick meal or are planning a large event:

• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Full delivery service is available, including convenient no-contact options, making it simple to get your favorite pizza or Italian meal delivered right to your door.
• Takeout Service: A quick and efficient option for picking up slices, whole pies, or full Italian dinners.
• Dine-in with Table Service: Features seating in a casual and cozy atmosphere for those who prefer to enjoy their meal on-site.
• All-Day Dining: Service is available for Lunch, Dinner, and even Late-night food, offering hot meals and quick bites throughout the evening.
• Full-Service Catering: Specializes in large-scale orders with a dedicated menu featuring items like Baked Ziti, Chicken Parmigiana, and 3–6 Ft Heroes, available in full and half trays. The service often includes free delivery and set-up for catering orders.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The restaurant is Good for Kids and provides High Chairs, along with a dedicated Kids' Menu to accommodate young diners.
• Flexible Payments: Accepts all major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for fast and easy transactions.

The core highlights of Big Jim's Pizzeria emphasize quality, variety, and value, making it a beloved local favorite:

• Massive Menu Variety: Goes far beyond pizza to include a full Italian menu with extensive options for Entrees (Veal, Chicken, Shrimp, Eggplant), Pasta Dishes (Homemade Lasagna, Penne with Vodka Sauce, Baked Ziti), Heros (Eggplant Parmigiana, Cheesesteak, Cold-Cut Combo), and a wide selection of Appetizers and Salads.
• Signature Pizza Options: Features classic and specialty pies such as the Whole Cheese Pizza Pie, Sicilian Pizza Pie, the elaborate Big Jim's Special Pie, and unique options like the Margarita Bar Pie and Calamari Pizza Pie.
• Value-Oriented Pricing and Specials: Known for offering extremely competitive prices, especially for pizza by the slice ($2.35) and for their famous, long-running Pizza Sale, which offers deep discounts on multiple pizza pies for parties or large orders.
• Speed and Efficiency: Identified by customers for its Fast service, which caters perfectly to the New Jersey lifestyle where a quick and efficient meal is paramount.
• Late-Night Availability: Offering service until later hours ensures that it is a dependable source for comfort food and quick bites late in the evening.
• Full Catering Capability: The availability of large Catering Trays for almost all menu items, complete with potential free delivery and set-up, makes Big Jim's a go-to choice for local parties, business meetings, and family gatherings.

To place an order for delivery or takeout, inquire about the current pizza special, or discuss catering options for an upcoming event in New Milford, please use the contact details below:

• Address: 281 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA
• Phone: (201) 262-4600
• Mobile Phone: +1 201-262-4600

Choosing Big Jim's Pizzeria is choosing a dependable, high-volume source for virtually all your Italian-American comfort food needs in New Milford. It is worth choosing for three primary reasons: unbeatable variety, value, and speed. The extensive menu ensures that whether one person wants a slice of Pepperoni, another wants Penne with Vodka Sauce, and a third wants a Veal Parmigiana Hero, Big Jim's can satisfy all parties quickly from one convenient location.

Furthermore, the legendary Pizza Sale is a widely recognized community offering that provides exceptional value, making it the top choice for hosting parties or large family dinners on a budget. The convenience of their service options—including fast delivery and a cozy, accessible spot for dining in—solidifies its position. When you are seeking a New Jersey pizzeria that delivers a consistently quick, extensive, and budget-friendly menu of satisfying comfort food, Big Jim's Pizzeria on Main Street is the local destination to rely on.

Big Jim's Pizzeria

281 Main St, New Milford, NJ 07646, USA