Brown Butter Bakes

- 276 Chestnut St, Brooklyn, NY 11208

Introduction / Overview

Brown Butter Bakes is a celebrated Brooklyn bakery that has quickly earned a reputation far beyond its East New York roots. Specializing in decadent, beautifully designed, and—most importantly—incredibly moist cakes and gourmet desserts, this establishment has become the go-to vendor for celebration cakes, custom orders, and daily indulgences across the New York metropolitan area. Operating out of the dynamic Cypress Hills/East New York Community Center, Brown Butter Bakes is a dedicated cottage bakery that pours love, high-quality ingredients, and immense detail into every single treat.

The bakery’s core philosophy, evident in every bite, is that special occasion desserts should not only look stunning but should also taste phenomenal. This commitment to quality has led to rapturous customer reviews, particularly for their signature cakes. One customer described their experience with the Red Velvet cake at a bridal shower as the "second best surprise of the day," praising it as the "BEST cake I've ever had," and noting its supreme moisture and delicious flavor. This focus on moistness, flavor, and avoiding excessive sweetness is a hallmark of the bakery's craft.

Brown Butter Bakes offers an extensive menu of baked goods, ensuring there is a perfect treat for every occasion and craving. From standard and signature cupcakes to creatively flavored cookies, innovative brownies and bars, and convenient, individually portioned cake jars, the variety is designed to delight. The bakery is particularly recognized for pushing culinary boundaries with its unique flavor combinations and specialty items, including the sought-after "Boozy Bakes" and a wide selection of gourmet dessert jars. For New Yorkers searching for a reliable, passionate, and high-end baking experience, Brown Butter Bakes is a must-try local favorite that consistently exceeds expectations for both taste and presentation.

Location and Accessibility

Brown Butter Bakes is situated at 276 Chestnut St, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA. This address places it within the heart of the Cypress Hills and East New York community. The bakery operates from within the Cypress Hills East New York Community Center, a vibrant local hub that is known for fostering local economic development and providing community resources. While the bakery itself is focused on culinary excellence, its location within this community-centric building speaks to its strong ties to the neighborhood.

For New York residents, accessibility is a crucial factor. The 11208 zip code benefits from numerous local bus routes and is generally considered accessible via the MTA system, making it convenient for both local pickups and delivery services. As the bakery is frequently part of the activities hosted at the larger community center, which is a key local landmark, finding the location for in-store pickup is straightforward. Furthermore, the space features a wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that all customers have easy access to their delicious baked goods. Given its Brooklyn location, Brown Butter Bakes is ideally positioned to serve the immediate Cypress Hills area, while its reputation attracts customers from across the borough and beyond, relying on its efficient delivery and pickup options.

Services Offered

Brown Butter Bakes offers a range of flexible services tailored to the fast-paced lifestyle of New Yorkers, ensuring customers can easily get their hands on their favorite sweets.

• Delivery: The bakery provides efficient delivery service, making it possible for customers to enjoy their gourmet cakes and treats from the comfort of their home or workplace. This includes local delivery through popular platforms.
• In-store Pickup: Customers can pre-order and collect their items directly from the Cypress Hills location, perfect for quick visits and large celebration cake pickups.
• Takeout: Offering a variety of freshly baked treats for immediate purchase, the takeout option caters to those who are looking for a spontaneous, quick bite.
• Custom Celebration Cakes: A core service, the bakery designs and creates bespoke single- and multi-tiered cakes for special events like weddings, bridal showers, birthdays, and anniversaries.
• Gourmet Dessert Variety: Beyond cakes, they offer an expansive menu including cookies, brownies, blondies, dessert jars, and specialty cupcakes, available for individual purchase and in curated bundles.
• Online Ordering: Facilitating a smooth customer experience, most services are supported by a streamlined online ordering and pre-order process.

Features / Highlights

Brown Butter Bakes distinguishes itself through a number of unique features that appeal to the discerning New York dessert aficionado.

• Supreme Moistness and Flavor: Unanimously praised in customer reviews, the cakes are known for being incredibly moist, intensely flavorful, and perfectly sweetened—a rare achievement in custom cake artistry.
• Specialty Cake Jars: A popular offering for individual indulgence or easy gifting, the cake jars come in both standard (e.g., Red Velvet, Chocolate Mousse) and signature (e.g., Oreo, Lemon-Blueberry Cheesecake, Henny Sidecar) flavors.
• Innovative Boozy Bakes: The unique Boozy Bakes menu, featuring items like Chocolate Honey Whiskey Cake Slices and Bailey's Irish Coffee cupcakes and cake jars, provides an adult-friendly twist on classic desserts.
• Extensive Signature Cupcake Selection: The variety is remarkable, with gourmet options such as Nutella Tiramisu, Crème Brûlée, Biscoff Pumpkin Spice, and Banana Pudding cupcakes, ensuring a treat for every palate.
• Gourmet Brownies and Blondies: The bakery elevates standard treats with unique flavors like Red Velvet Cheesecake Brownie, Peach Cobbler Blondie, and White Chocolate Biscoff Blondie.
• Commitment to Quality: The baker, Chioma, is highly regarded for her attention to detail, using quality ingredients, and delivering desserts that are both beautiful in design and superior in taste, often described as 'flawless' and 'a beautiful work of art.'
• Quick Visit Planning: Catering to the NYC need for speed, the bakery is well-suited for a quick, efficient visit to grab a delicious pre-ordered item.

Contact Information

For orders, consultations, or inquiries, the bakery can be reached at the following contact points:

• Address: 276 Chestnut St, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA
• Phone: (917) 765-0405

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Brown Butter Bakes means prioritizing quality and flavor above all else, a decision that has turned many first-time customers into loyal, enthusiastic patrons. For New Yorkers looking for a dessert that genuinely lives up to the hype—especially for significant celebrations—this Brooklyn bakery is the definitive choice. The recurring theme in all customer feedback is the unmatched moistness of their cakes. As one review highlighted, many people expect beautiful custom cakes to be dry, but Brown Butter Bakes is "dead wrong" about that assumption, proving that stunning presentation and exceptional taste can, and do, coexist. The level of dedication from the baker is palpable, with customers frequently mentioning the "love and detail" poured into the baking process.

While their custom celebration cakes are the headliner, the accessibility of their smaller treats is what makes them a daily indulgence. The Cake Jars are a particularly ingenious concept for the modern New Yorker—perfectly layered, individually portioned versions of their celebrated cakes, ideal for a personal treat or a thoughtful gift. The rumored future possibility of shippable cake jars is an exciting prospect for customers living further away, like the one who "think weekly about getting my hands on this" cake despite living three hours away.

Moreover, the creative menu selection, including the variety of standard and signature cupcakes like the Nutella Tiramisu and Crème Brûlée, demonstrates a playful but skilled approach to baking. The specialized Boozy Bakes are a unique standout, offering sophisticated, spirit-infused treats that are perfect for adult gatherings. Essentially, Brown Butter Bakes is worth choosing because it is a professional operation committed to delivering high-end, hand-crafted baked goods that are consistently delicious, beautiful, and tailored to the demanding standards of the New York dessert scene. It is a source of joy and memorable flavors, delivered right from the heart of Brooklyn.

Brown Butter Bakes

276 Chestnut St, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA