Caked Up Cafe

- 40 S Main St, New City, NY 10956

Introduction / Overview

In the heart of Rockland County, just a short drive from the hustle and bustle of New York City, sits Caked Up Cafe—a beloved local institution that has firmly established itself as the go-to destination for spectacular baked goods. Far exceeding the offerings of a typical local bakery, Caked Up Cafe is a trifecta of deliciousness, identified as a Bakery, a Cake shop, and a Coffee shop, creating a sweet and cozy haven for the New City community and beyond.

Caked Up Cafe has garnered a reputation over the years for its wildly creative approach to classic desserts, particularly its extensive and imaginative selection of gourmet cupcakes. They are not content with just vanilla and chocolate; they delve into truly unique and memorable flavor profiles that keep customers returning, including options like Maple Bacon, Chicken and Waffle, and French Toast. This innovative spirit is one of the main reasons the bakery has built a loyal following that includes not only local patrons but also celebrities and professional athletes from the greater New York area.

Beyond the inventive cupcakes, the bakery’s core specialty is custom-designed celebration cakes. These are true works of art, capable of being tailored for any event—from simple birthday parties to elaborate wedding celebrations. Their custom cakes are consistently praised for both their impressive visual detailing and their delicious flavor, whether you choose a classic like Red Velvet or a custom creation with layers like chocolate and Oreo filling.

The cafe also serves as a welcoming spot for a quick visit, offering coffee to pair with their delightful treats. Whether you’re stopping for a giant, half-pound cookie, a slice of classic Crumb Cake, or a specialty cupcake, Caked Up Cafe provides a warm and casual environment.

It is also worth noting that Caked Up Cafe proudly identifies as a women-owned business, adding a layer of community pride to this local gem. Furthermore, they demonstrate a commitment to inclusivity, identifying as LGBTQ+ friendly, ensuring a welcoming space for all patrons.

Location and Accessibility

Caked Up Cafe is strategically located at a central address in New City, NY, making it easily accessible for residents across Rockland County and a convenient stop for those traveling through the area.

The specific address is:

40 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

For local customers in the New York region, accessibility is often a key consideration, and Caked Up Cafe provides several valuable conveniences:

Parking is accommodating with multiple options available for stress-free visits:

• Free parking lot
• Free street parking

In addition to standard parking, the business is dedicated to accessibility for all guests, providing a:

• Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Once inside, guests can utilize a clean and readily available:

• Restroom

The central location and ease of access underscore the cafe's commitment to being a convenient and approachable community hub for sweet treats and coffee.

Services Offered

To accommodate the diverse needs and busy schedules of New York-area customers, Caked Up Cafe offers a flexible range of service options. These ensure that getting your hands on their delicious baked goods is always simple and convenient:

• Delivery: Have your favorite cupcakes, cookies, or cakes brought directly to your home or event location, adding a layer of convenience for large orders or busy days.
• In-store Pickup: A perfect option for pre-ordering custom cakes or large batches of cupcakes, allowing for a quick and organized collection at the cafe.
• Takeout: Ideal for a quick stop to grab a coffee, a cupcake, or a brownie to enjoy on the go.

These service options support the bakery’s reputation as a reliable source for both everyday treats and special occasion desserts.

Features / Highlights

Caked Up Cafe stands out in the competitive New York dessert market due to its dedication to quality, creativity, and customer-focused features. Key highlights include:

• Gourmet Cupcakes: The undisputed signature offering, boasting a rotating and expansive selection of over 30 unique flavors daily, from classic Red Velvet to novel flavors like Jelly Donut and Maple Bacon.
• Custom Cakes: Recognized for creating visually stunning and delicious custom cakes for major events, with a reputation for excellent detail and popular flavor combinations.
• Inclusivity and Ownership: Proudly a women-owned business and an LGBTQ+ friendly space, fostering a welcoming atmosphere for all members of the community.
• Dietary Accommodations: A dedication to offering options for all guests, including at least three popular Gluten Free options readily available, such as macarons, rainbow cake, and rainbow cheesecake, with the ability to pre-order gluten-free custom items.
• Diverse Baked Goods: Beyond cakes and cupcakes, the cafe offers a delightful array of Cookies, Brownies, Cake Pops, and Crumb Cake—including the popular Italian Rainbow Crumb Slice.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.
• Planning: Excellent for a Quick visit, making it an easy addition to an errands run or a quick coffee break.

Contact Information

For placing custom orders, inquiring about daily flavors, or simply planning your visit, the contact details for Caked Up Cafe are as follows:

Address: 40 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

Phone: (845) 499-2929

Mobile Phone: +1 845-499-2929

What is Worth Choosing

For New York-area residents seeking a bakery that blends artistic flair with exceptional flavor, Caked Up Cafe is an undeniable top choice. The most compelling reason to choose this spot is its unparalleled creativity in the world of cupcakes. Rather than settling for a standard bakery, patrons get access to a rotation of nearly 100 total flavors, ensuring there is always something new and exciting to try, like the Cookie Dough Cupcake or the indulgent Death by Chocolate. The sheer variety and the commitment to fresh, gourmet ingredients make the specialty cupcakes an absolute must-try.

Furthermore, the cafe is highly recommended for anyone needing a Custom Cake. The high praise from customers—including those with high standards who grew up in the bakery industry—attests to the quality and artistry of their custom creations. Whether it’s for a wedding or a birthday, their ability to deliver a cake that is both visually stunning and delicious is a key factor in their local popularity.

Finally, the inclusive environment and dedication to catering to specific dietary needs, such as the consistent offering of Gluten Free options, is a significant value-add for the health-conscious New York customer base. A stop at Caked Up Cafe is an investment in a local, women-owned business that promises a delightful, imaginative, and satisfying sweet treat experience.

Caked Up Cafe

40 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA