Nicky's II Pizza & Deli

- 57 Lake Rd, Congers, NY 10920

For residents across the New York metropolitan area, the pursuit of the perfect slice is a deeply held tradition. While iconic pizzerias populate the city, finding that unparalleled, neighborhood-favorite spot in the outer counties is a true discovery. In Rockland County, and specifically in Congers, that search often leads directly to Nicky's II Pizza & Deli. More than just a simple pizza place, Nicky's II embodies the classic New York experience, offering everything from crispy, perfectly-baked pies to colossal, fully-loaded heroes and comforting Italian dinner classics.

Nicky's II has earned its reputation not just for its extensive and authentic menu, but for its commitment to quality and community. It’s the kind of place where you can grab a quick lunch, settle in for a cozy dinner with the family, or order in for a late-night bite. One devoted customer calls it one of the “Top pizzerias in Rockland county hands down,” highlighting a true local endorsement that speaks volumes. With a focus on serving generous portions of comfort food, this establishment has cemented its status as a cornerstone of the Congers dining scene.

Nicky's II Pizza & Deli is ideally situated to serve the local community and those passing through the Congers area. You can find this popular spot at 57 Lake Rd, Congers, NY 10920, USA. Its location on Lake Road makes it a familiar and easy destination for residents throughout Clarkstown and surrounding Rockland County towns.

Recognizing the diverse needs of the New York populace, Nicky's II has been diligent in ensuring excellent accessibility. The establishment is fully equipped with a wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot, and even a wheelchair accessible restroom and seating, ensuring a welcoming environment for all patrons. For drivers, the convenience is unmatched, offering not only an on-site parking lot but also free parking both on-site and on the street. Whether you're coming alone for a quick bite or with a large group, getting to and settling into Nicky's II is designed to be hassle-free.

As a dual Pizza Restaurant and Deli, Nicky's II provides a comprehensive array of dining services that go well beyond a simple take-out joint.

• Full-Service Dining: Offering Table service, Seating, and a casual, cozy atmosphere for both Lunch and Dinner.
• Takeout and Delivery: Providing the utmost convenience through standard Delivery and Takeout options, including a No-contact delivery option for peace of mind.
• Outdoor Seating: A great amenity for warmer weather, allowing guests to enjoy their meal in the fresh air. This is a Dogs allowed outside spot, making it perfect for pet owners.
• Specialty Catering Services: Offering a wide range of catering trays for events, parties, and office lunches, including Appetizers Catering (like Fried Calamari and Chicken Wings), Salads Catering, Chicken Catering (e.g., Chicken Parm), Pasta Catering (including Baked Ziti and Penne Alla Vodka), and Heroes Catering (Italian and American).
• Late-Night Food: Catering to the late-night cravings that are a hallmark of the New York lifestyle.

What truly distinguishes Nicky's II in the crowded New York food landscape is its dedication to classic Italian-American flavors and its generous, comfort-focused menu.

• The Legendary Square Pizzas: The Grandma Pizza and the highly-praised Vodkarita Pizza are local must-tries. The Vodkarita, with vodka sauce, chicken cutlets, and fresh basil, is so popular that customers often "order a second pie as backup just to keep in the freezer for emergencies."
• Specialty Heroes: The menu features traditional heroes like the Chicken Parm Hero and Meatball Parm Hero, alongside a creative list of Specialty Heros such as the BBQ Blast Hero and the Train Wreck Hero, offering unique and robust flavor combinations.
• Extensive Italian Dinner Menu: Beyond pizza and heroes, Nicky's II serves up full-size dinner plates including classic Pastas (like Pasta With Vodka Sauce and Baked Ziti), Chicken entrees (Chicken Marsala, Chicken Francese), and Seafood dishes (Shrimp Scampi, Shrimp Parmigiana).
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Known for being Family-friendly, offering High chairs, and being a good spot for Groups and Locals. The atmosphere is consistently described as Casual and Cozy.
• Quality Dough and Preparation: Customers frequently compliment the pizza's texture, noting that the crust is "very crispy and not burnt like in other places," a key indicator of quality oven management.
• Convenient Offerings: The menu is packed with quick bites, small plates (like Mozzarella Sticks and Fried Calamari), and delicious Comfort food, perfect for any time of day.
• Flexible Planning: The restaurant Accepts reservations and is happy to accommodate larger groups or planned dining experiences.

Whether you're calling in a pizza order, asking about catering, or planning a dine-in visit, here's how to reach Nicky's II Pizza & Deli.

• Address: 57 Lake Rd, Congers, NY 10920, USA
• Phone: (845) 268-5800 or +1 845-268-5800

For the discerning New York diner, choosing Nicky's II Pizza & Deli means choosing a guaranteed experience of authentic, high-quality, and satisfying Italian-American cuisine delivered with a local touch. It's an establishment that understands the New York craving for *the* slice, and it delivers on that promise, especially with its acclaimed square pies like the Grandma Pizza and the unforgettable Vodkarita Pizza.

What truly makes it worth choosing, however, is its comprehensive menu versatility. You can satisfy a craving for a traditional Italian Pasta Fagioli Soup and Baked Ravioli, or indulge in a massive Specialty Hero. The dual function as both a top-tier pizzeria and a full-service deli and Italian restaurant ensures that every member of a group or family will find something delicious. With the added convenience of late-night food, delivery, and full accessibility, Nicky's II Pizza & Deli isn't just a place to eat; it's a reliable, friendly, and delicious staple of the Congers community, offering a warm, local alternative to the bustling city spots without sacrificing an ounce of flavor or quality. For a true taste of Rockland County's best Italian, this is your destination.

Nicky's II Pizza & Deli

57 Lake Rd, Congers, NY 10920, USA