Carnegie Diner & Cafe: Your Classic NYC Diner Experience on 8th Avenue

Carnegie Diner & Cafe Introduce

In the vibrant tapestry of New York City's dining scene, few places hold the same iconic status as a classic diner. Carnegie Diner & Cafe is a quintessential example, a place where the spirit of the old-school diner meets modern culinary excellence. Situated on the bustling 8th Avenue, it’s a go-to spot for locals and tourists alike, offering a comfortable and lively atmosphere that feels like a true taste of New York. Whether you're in search of a hearty breakfast to kick off your day, a satisfying lunch, or a delicious late-night meal, Carnegie Diner & Cafe delivers on all fronts with a menu that is as extensive as it is delicious.

The moment you step inside, you're greeted with the unmistakable "typical New York diner feel"—a perfect blend of cozy and lively. The restaurant's walls are adorned with "lovely art work," creating a visually engaging space that invites you to linger and explore. Despite the bustling environment, the service is consistently praised for being "on the ball" and the staff for being "friendly, professional," and genuinely welcoming. One reviewer highlighted their server, Alexandra, who provided "great insight on the menu" and was attentive to dietary needs, a testament to the high level of service you can expect. This warm, personal touch is a key reason why so many people feel a strong connection to the place and promise to return.

The menu at Carnegie Diner & Cafe is a testament to the sheer variety and quality of American comfort food. From breakfast and brunch staples like Avocado Toast and classic Benedicts to a vast selection of omelets, pancakes, and waffles, the morning meal is a serious affair here. But the offerings don't stop there. The diner also excels at lunch and dinner with a wide range of burgers, sandwiches, and entrees. The Smashed Double Burger, for instance, was described as "delicious, juicy and cooked just right," and "one of the best burgers I've had in New York so far." The menu also thoughtfully includes a variety of vegan, vegetarian, and healthy options, like the Lentil Soup and Farmers Salad, ensuring there's something to satisfy every craving and dietary preference.

Beyond the food, Carnegie Diner & Cafe is also celebrated for its beverages, from its "great coffee" to a selection of "great cocktails" and wines. The cocktails, mocktails, and a full bar onsite make it an excellent spot for a celebratory meal or a relaxed drink. The entire experience, from the moment you are warmly greeted to the quick arrival of your food and the friendly farewell, is what truly sets Carnegie Diner & Cafe apart. It’s not just a restaurant; it's a true New York institution that embodies the spirit of hospitality, great food, and a timeless atmosphere.

Location and Accessibility

Carnegie Diner & Cafe is perfectly located at 828 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019. This prime address places it in the vibrant Theater District, just a stone's throw away from Times Square and a major hub of activity. The location makes it an ideal spot for a pre-theater dinner, a post-show drink, or a meal during a day of sightseeing. Its central position ensures it is easily reachable for locals and tourists alike.

The diner is highly accessible via public transportation, with numerous subway lines serving the area, including the C, E, 1, and 2 trains. This makes it a convenient and stress-free destination regardless of where you are coming from. For those with their own vehicles, paid street parking is available, though it can be competitive in this popular neighborhood. A major highlight of Carnegie Diner & Cafe is its commitment to accessibility for all patrons. The venue features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible restroom, and wheelchair-accessible seating, ensuring that everyone can dine comfortably and without barriers. Additionally, the diner is pet-friendly, with dogs allowed, making it a great option for pet owners.

Services Offered

Dine-in, Takeout, and Delivery: The diner offers flexible service options to meet every need. Whether you want to enjoy a full meal inside, grab something to go, or have your food delivered right to your doorstep, Carnegie Diner & Cafe makes it easy. No-contact delivery is also available for added safety.
Catering: For events and gatherings, the diner provides catering services, making it a reliable choice for feeding a large group with delicious American comfort food.
Reservations: Carnegie Diner & Cafe accepts reservations, which are particularly recommended for brunch, helping to ensure you get a table without a long wait during busy times.
Full Bar: A bar is located onsite, offering a selection of alcohol, beer, wine, hard liquor, and "great cocktails," perfect for a variety of occasions and preferences.
Happy Hour: Enjoy happy hour drinks and food, providing a great value for an after-work get-together or a quick bite.
Kid-Friendly Amenities: The diner is designated as "good for kids" and offers a kids' menu, high chairs, and a changing table, making it a welcoming and convenient spot for families.
Inclusive Amenities: The diner provides a gender-neutral restroom, highlighting its commitment to being a welcoming space for all. It is also designated as LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space.

Features / Highlights

Fast Service: Customers consistently praise the speed of the service. Food arrives "within minutes," making it an excellent choice for a quick meal before a show or during a tight schedule.
Great Cocktails and Desserts: The bar offers a variety of "great cocktails," and the diner is famous for its "great dessert" selection, including the 24 LAYER Chocolate Cake and NEW YORK Style Cheesecake, making it a perfect spot for a sweet treat.
Extensive Menu: The menu is vast, covering breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner, with a wide range of options from classic diner fare to healthy and organic dishes. The variety caters to every taste and craving.
Family-Friendly and Inclusive: Carnegie Diner & Cafe is a welcoming space for all. Its designation as family-friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, and a transgender safe space, along with amenities for children, makes it a comfortable and safe environment for a diverse crowd.
Classic NYC Diner Vibe: The atmosphere is a key highlight, providing a "typical New York diner feel" that is both cozy and lively, creating a genuine and enjoyable experience.
High-Quality Food: Despite its casual nature, the food is described as fresh, delicious, and cooked just right, with items like the Smashed Double Burger and Pastrami Sandwich receiving rave reviews.
Late-Night Food: For those with late-night cravings, the diner offers food well into the evening, making it a great option for a post-show meal or a late dinner.

Contact Information

To experience the classic diner feel and delicious food, you can contact Carnegie Diner & Cafe at:

Address: 828 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (212) 399-4444

What is worth choosing

In a city with an endless number of dining establishments, Carnegie Diner & Cafe stands out as a true New York institution, and for a variety of reasons, it is absolutely worth choosing. The most compelling reason is its ability to deliver a genuine, high-quality, and comprehensive dining experience in a single, convenient location. This isn't just a place for a quick meal; it's a destination that perfectly embodies the classic American diner feel. The cozy and lively atmosphere, complemented by the unique artwork on the walls, makes every visit feel special and authentic. It's a place where you can comfortably enjoy a solo meal, a family brunch, or a late-night bite with friends.

The food is another major draw. While many diners offer a wide menu, Carnegie Diner & Cafe excels by serving dishes that are consistently praised for their quality and flavor. A reviewer's comment that the Smashed Double Burger was "one of the best burgers I've had in New York so far" speaks volumes. The sheer variety of the menu, from an extensive breakfast and brunch selection to delicious burgers, sandwiches, and entrees, ensures that no matter what you're craving, you'll find a satisfying option. The thoughtful inclusion of healthy, organic, and vegan choices also makes it a place that can accommodate all dietary needs, a significant plus in today's dining landscape.

Finally, the exceptional service and hospitality are what elevate the entire experience. The staff is not only friendly and professional but also remarkably efficient, with food arriving "within minutes." This is a huge benefit in a busy city like New York and makes the diner a reliable choice for any occasion, from a rushed lunch to a leisurely brunch. The diner's commitment to inclusivity, with gender-neutral restrooms and an LGBTQ+ friendly environment, further enhances its welcoming atmosphere. For anyone seeking a place that combines classic American comfort food, fast service, a friendly vibe, and excellent value, Carnegie Diner & Cafe is an outstanding choice that will not disappoint.

Carnegie Diner & Cafe Menu

BREAKFAST / BRUNCH
Avocado Toast $18.95
toasted seven grains bread, smashed avocado, chopped tomatoes, diced onions, cilantro, poached eggs, house salad
Avocado Toast with Maine Lobster $27.95
Toasted seven grains bread, smashed avocado, chopped tomatoes, diced onions, cilantro, poached eggs, house salad, Maine lobster
Steak & Organic Eggs $26.95
dry aged 8oz. bistro fillet, eggs any style, hash browns and farmer’s market greens.
Classic Benedict $19.95
poached eggs and bacon on an English muffin with Hollandaise sauce, hash browns and farmer’s market greens.
Classic Benedict with Smoked Salmon $23.95
poached eggs and bacon on an English muffin with Hollandaise sauce, hash browns and farmer’s market greens with smoked salmon
Classic Benedict with Maine Lobster $28.95
poached eggs, Maine lobster and bacon on an English muffin with Hollandaise sauce, hash browns and farmer’s market greens
BLT Quinoa Bowl $16.95
organic quinoa, chopped bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, organic poached eggs and Hollandaise sauce
Greek Yogurt $15.95
Greek yogurt, granola, berries and honey
Symphony Breakfast $26.95
Served with rustic toasted bread 3 organic eggs any style served with potatoes, fresh fruit and your choice of: Applewood smoked bacon, black forest ham, artisan Greek sausage, OR smoked salmon +2.95. Served with coffee or tea orange juice

OMELETS
Californian $19.95
3 organic eggs, avocado, mushroom, tomato, pepper-jack cheese, hash browns, farmer's market green & rustic sliced bread
Country Style $20.95
3 organic eggs, applewood bacon, ham, sausage, sharp cheddar cheese, hash browns, farmer's market green & rustic sliced bread
Powerhouse $21.95
3 organic eggs, grilled chicken, spinach, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, hash browns, farmer's market greens & rustic sliced bread
Protein Sunshine $22.95
egg whites, spinach, grilled chicken, feta cheese, hash browns, farmer’s market greens & rustic sliced bread
Greek $19.50
3 organic eggs, Feta, tomato, spinach, Kalamata olives, hash browns, farmer’s market greens & rustic sliced bread
Vegetarian $18.95
3 organic eggs, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, green peppers, hash browns, farmer’s market greens & rustic sliced bread

BREAKFAST SIDES
Applewood Smoked Bacon $5.95
Turkey Bacon $5.95
Chicken Sausage $4.95
Pork Sausage $4.95
Nova Scotia Smoked Salmon $9.95
French Fries $4.00
Canadian Bacon $5.00
Hash Browns $5.00
Cup of Fresh Fruit $5.00
Sliced Avocado $5.00
Wagyu Pastrami $9.95
Corned Beef $8.95

PANCAKES
Buttermilk $14.95
our classic buttermilk pancakes made fresh to order, served with fresh fruit and whipped cream
Blueberry $17.95
buttermilk pancakes, blueberries, blueberry jam & whipped cream served with fresh fruit
Bacon $18.95
our classic buttermilk pancakes, applewood smoked bacon, Canadian Bacon, served with fresh fruit and whipped cream
Apple Pie $18.95
our classic buttermilk pancakes, walnuts, raisins, fresh baked, apple/cinnamon sauce, served with fresh fruit and whipped cream
Greek Yogurt $18.95
our classic pancakes with Greek yogurt, walnuts and honey, served with fresh fruit and whipped cream
Peanut Butter & Bacon $19.95
pancakes baked with peanut butter chips & bacon, peanut butter sauce, served with fresh fruit and whipped cream
Chocolate $18.95
Belgian chocolate chips, Hershey’s chocolate syrup, strawberries & whipped cream, served with fresh fruit and whipped cream
Free Range Chicken $18.95
fluffy pancakes served with southern boneless fried chicken tenders, fresh fruit and whipped cream
Banana Nutella Strawberries $19.95
pancakes with fresh bananas & strawberries and Nutella hazelnut spread
Pancake Lollipops $16.50
mini pancake lollipops

WAFFLES
Plain Waffle $14.95
served with warm syrup & whipped cream
Salted Caramel $17.95
chopped bacon, whipped vanilla mascarpone, brown sugar roasted walnut crumble, caramel drizzle & coarse sea salt
Tropical Crunch $17.95
fresh bananas, strawberries, mango, crunchy granola & side of strawberry reduction
Southern Chicken & Waffles $19.95
wedges topped with fried chicken tenders, chopped bacon, sweet dried cranberries & our own sausage gravy

FRENCH TOAST
Classic $16.95
cooked in our own batter of vanilla, whipped eggs, brown sugar, cinnamon, fresh cream & 100% real maple syrup
Nutella French $18.95
Nutella, sliced roasted almonds, fresh chopped strawberries
Bacon Toast $18.95
topped with sweet mascarpone, sugar walnuts, caramel drizzle & chopped smoked bacon
Caramel French Toast $19.95
topped with vanilla mascarpone, fresh slices of golden delicious apples, honey walnuts & caramel sauce

BAKED GOODS
Bagel $3.00
plain, cinnamon, everything
Bagel with Butter $3.50
Bagel with butter
CROISSANT
MUFFINS
Bagel with Cream Cheese $3.95
Bagel with cream cheese
Bagel with Lox & Cream Cheese $13.90
Bagel with Lox & Cream Cheese

APPETIZERS
Chicken Soup - Cup of Soup $5.95
hearty chicken, vegetable & rice soup, made fresh daily
Chicken Soup - Bowl of Soup $8.75
hearty chicken, vegetable & rice soup, made fresh daily
Lentil Soup - Cup of Soup $5.95
vegan, all organic vegetables and tomato broth
Lentil Soup - Bowl of Soup $8.75
vegan, all organic vegetables and tomato broth
Vegan Meatballs $15.95
baked in fresh marinara sauce with mint & vegan mozzarella cheese
Hummus $9.95
home made recipe, carrots, celery sticks, chips
Homemade Chili $11.95
ground sirloin steak with beans tricolor tortilla chips & cheddar cheese
Spinach Artichoke Dip $12.95
served with tortilla chips
Carnegie Nachos $15.95
fresh made tortilla chips, grilled chicken, velveeta cheese sauce, jalapeños, Fresno chili, scallions, white cheddar cheese, guacamole, sour cream
Guacamole $14.50
freshly made and served with tortilla chips
Spinach Pie $9.95
phyllo dough pie with spinach, feta cheese and herbs
Mac & Cheese $8.95
Mac & Cheese with Bacon $11.95
Mac & Cheese with Lobster $17.90
Coconut Shrimp $15.95
served with Sweet Chili Sauce
Calamari $15.95
fried calamari served caper aioli sauce
Mozzarella Sticks $9.95
5 Pieces - served with marinara sauce
Onion Rings $9.95
freshly fried and served with our signature homemade sauce
Chicken Wings - 6 pieces $9.95
our chicken wings are made fresh to order, served with ranch dressing, carrots & celery sticks
Chicken Wings - 9 pieces $14.95
our chicken wings are made fresh to order, served with ranch dressing, carrots & celery sticks.
Chicken Wings - 12 pieces $19.95
our chicken wings are made fresh to order, served with ranch dressing, carrots & celery sticks.
CHOOSE YOUR STYLE
Naked
CHOOSE YOUR STYLE
buffalo
CHOOSE YOUR STYLE
bbq boneless (mild sauce)

CHEF’S SALADS
Cranberry Salad $15.95
organic mixed greens, dried cranberries, roasted candied almonds, cranberry vinaigrette, extra virgin olive oil
Quinoa $18.95
mixed organic quinoa, baby spinach, diced peppers, cherry tomatoes, Feta cheese, raisins, balsamic vinaigrette
BBQ Chicken Salad $20.95
chicken breast with BBQ sauce, seasonal mixed greens, tomatoes, scallions, Parmesan cheese, BBQ vinaigrette dressing
Kale Chicken Ceaser $19.95
organic kale, grilled chicken, chopped romaine, Parmesan cheese, cherry tomatoes, Caesar dressing
Greek $18.95
tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, feta cheese, onions, Kalamata olives, capers and Greek salad dressing
“IMAGINE” Strawberry Fields $18.95
seasonal mixed greens, Parmesan cheese, balsamic vinaigrette, fresh sliced strawberries, roasted pecans, roasted beets
Farmers Blue $18.95
chopped organic kale and baby spinach, roasted beets, organic dry figs, blue cheese, hazelnuts, croutons and grilled lime vinaigrette
MAKE YOUR SALAD A MEAL $5.50
Add Grilled Chicken
MAKE YOUR SALAD A MEAL $6.50
Roasted Shrimp
MAKE YOUR SALAD A MEAL $6.50
Grilled Steak
MAKE YOUR SALAD A MEAL $6.50
Grilled Salmon

BURGERS
Carnegie Classic Burger $17.95
organic burger, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, homemade sauce
The Corner Burger $19.95
organic cheeseburger, cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, homemade sauce
Central Park $21.95
organic cheeseburger, blue cheese, mushrooms, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, homemade sauce
Columbus Circle $21.95
organic cheeseburger, smoked gouda, bacon, sliced avocado, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, caper aioli sauce
Morning Sunshine $21.95
organic cheeseburger, American cheese, fried egg, applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, homemade sauce
Times Square $23.95
spicy fried chicken + cheeseburger, applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, chipotle sauce
Five Hills $24.95
double stack organic cheeseburger, cheddar cheese, Applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, homemade sauce
Chili Burger $22.95
organic cheeseburger, American cheese, beef chili, caramelized onions & roasted red peppers
Smashed Double Stack $24.95
double stack organic cheeseburger, American cheese, caramelized onions, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, chipotle sauce
The Late Night $23.95
organic cheeseburger, pepper jack cheese, caramelized onions, guacamole, tomatoes, lettuce, pickle, homemade sauce
THE AMAZING our Signature Burger $24.95
organic cheeseburger served in a Mac and Cheese bun, cheddar cheese, bacon, fried egg, lettuce, tomato, homemade sauce
Pastrami Burger $26.95
American Wagyu pastrami, organic beef burger, swiss cheese, caramelized onions, mushrooms, Reuben sauce & handcut fries

SIGNATURE SIDES
Mashed Potatoes $8.00
with feta, balsamic glaze
Mac & Cheese $8.95
Mac & Cheese with Bacon $11.95
Mac & Cheese with Lobster $17.90
Mixed Sauteed Vegetables $8.95
broccoli, hearts of cauliflower & onions
Brussel Sprouts $9.95
sauteéd brussel sprouts with bacon, onions, parmesan cheese & balsamic glaze
Hand-Cut French Fries $5.00
Hand Cut Fries with Feta Cheese & Oregano $7.00
Hand Cut French Fries with Parmesan & Truffle Oil $10.00

PASTRAMI
Pastrami Sandwich $23.95
half pound of naval wagyu pastrami, served on rye bread
Egg-Strami Sandwich $24.95
2 sunny side up eggs, half pound of naval wagyu pastrami & Swiss cheese served on rye bread
Corned Beef Sandwich $23.50
half pound of corned beef, served on rye bread
WOW Pastrami $29.95
18 ounces of naval wagyu pastrami served on rye bread
Corned Beef Reuben $24.95
half pound of Corned Beef with Swiss cheese & Russian dressing served on rye bread
Pastrami Reuben $24.95
half pound of Pastrami with Swiss cheese & Russian dressing served on rye bread
Peter's Special $29.95
half pound of corned beef & half pound of naval wagyu pastrami, served on rye bread
Pastrami Burger $26.95
American Wagyu pastrami, organic beef burger, swiss cheese, caramelized onions, mushrooms, Reuben sauce & handcut fries

CHICKEN SANDWICHES
Southern $18.95
Spicy buttermilk fried chicken, tomatoes, lettuce, Chipotle sauce
Movie Star $19.95
Grilled chicken, Swiss cheese, sliced avocado, tomatoes, lettuce, caper aioli sauce
BLT Chicken $18.95
Fried chicken, Applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes, lettuce, homemade sauce
Californian $18.95
Marinated grilled chicken, American cheese, sliced avocado, tomatoes, lettuce, caper aioli sauce

THE CLASSICS
Tuna Sandwich $19.95
Tuna Sandwich with cheese melt $20.95
Smoked Turkey $18.95
sliced turkey with lettuce, tomato & mayo, served cold
Chicken Salad Sandwich $19.95
homemade mayo. chicken served cold.
Ham Sandwich $18.95
sliced ham, Black Forest ham, lettuce, tomato, mayo, served cold

TRIPLE DECKERS
Grilled Chicken $19.95
bacon, tomato, Swiss cheese, lettuce, mayo, homemade sauce served with hand cut fries.
Grilled Chicken & Avocado $21.95
bacon, tomato, Swiss cheese, lettuce, mayo, homemade sauce served with hand cut fries.
Smoked Turkey $19.95
sliced smoked turkey with bacon, tomato, Swiss cheese, lettuce, mayo, homemade sauce served with hand cut fries.
Turkey & Avocado $22.95
bacon, tomato, Swiss cheese, lettuce, mayo, homemade sauce served with hand cut fries.

PASTA
Fettuccine Alfredo $19.95
fettuccine pasta, in a light cream sauce with fresh herbs & Parmigiano Reggiano
Bolognese $22.95
free range beef ragu made with fresh tomato sauce, herbs, served with spaghetti pasta, Parmigiano Reggiano
Spaghetti Carbonara $23.95
an Italian classic, smoked bacon, mushrooms, Parmesan cream sauce.
Penne $24.50
penne pasta with grilled chicken, garlic, jalapeños, chopped parsley, extra virgin olive oil, Parmigiano Reggiano in a fresh herb tomato sauce

SEAFOOD
Atlantic Salmon $29.95
roasted olive oil & lemon, Greek oregano mashed potatoes and fresh vegetable
Shrimp & Spaghetti $28.50
jumbo shrimp, fresh cherry tomatoes & basil, dusted with Parmigiano cheese in vodka sauce.
Fish N’ Chips $19.00
fresh beer battered cod fish served with hand cut fries

MEATS
Organic Roast Chicken $19.50
half chicken oven roasted, gravy, served with hand cut Greek fries.
Pork Chop $26.50
grilled bone-in pork chop, roasted brussel sprouts & bacon mashed potatoes with our signature rub
NY Strip Steak $39.95
14 oz. prime cut Black Angus beef with hand cut fries, onion rings and our signature rub
Rib Eye $46.00
16 oz. prime cut Black Angus beef with hand cut fries and our signature rub

PLANT BASED - APPETIZERS
Lentil Soup Cup $5.95
Vegan, all organic vegetables and tomato broth
Lentil Soup Bowl $8.75
Vegan, all organic vegetables and tomato broth
Vegan Meatballs $14.95
Baked on fresh tomato sauce, fresh chopped mint
Guacamole $14.50
Served with carrots & celery sticks
Hummus $9.95
Served with carrots and celery sticks

PLANT BASED - SALADS
Farmers Salad $18.95
chopped organic kale and baby spinach, roasted beets, organic dry figs, hazelnuts, croutons and grilled lime vinaigrette
“IMAGINE” Strawberry Fields $18.95
seasonal mixed greens, Balsamic vinaigrette, fresh sliced strawberries, roasted pecans, roasted beets
Quinoa $18.95
mixed organic quinoa, baby spinach, diced peppers, cherry tomatoes, raisins, balsamic vinaigrette
Cranberry Salad $15.95
cranberries, roasted candied almonds, cranberry vinaigrette, extra virgin olive oil

PLANT BASED - SANDWICHES
Impossible Vegan Burger $25.95
Impossible Burger plant based protein with gluten-free bun, lettuce, tomato, pickle, ketchup, mushrooms & caramelized onions
Yeero $22.95
vegan yeero, tomatoes, caramelized onions, vegan mozzarella cheese, vegan mayo-mustard sauce on a wheatberry sprouted grain bread. Served with mix green salad, honey lime vinaigrette, hand cut fries
Souvlaki $22.95
vegan meatless souvlaki, tomatoes, caramelized onions, vegan caper aioli sauce on a wheatberry sprouted grain bread. Served with mixed green salad, honey lime vinaigrette, hand cut fries
Vegetables Only $21.95
roasted red peppers, grilled zucchini, sliced tomato, avocado, fresh onions, hummus
Meatballs $22.95
vegan meatballs, marinara sauce, vegan mozzarella cheese, focaccia bread. Served with mixed green salad, honey lime vinaigrette, hand cut fries
Egg Breakfast $22.95
plant based egg omelet, vegan mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, onions, cherry tomatoes, on a focaccia bread, (option for a non-vegan bagel), honey lime vinaigrette, hand cut fries

DESSERTS
24 LAYER Chocolate Cake $14.95
NEW YORK Style Cheesecake $10.55
Coconut Custard Pie $10.25
Chocolate Mousse $10.95
Bavarian Cream Cake $10.95
Tiramisu Cake $11.25
Tres Leches $10.55
Strawberry Cheesecake $11.95
Outrageous Chocolate Cake $11.95
Chocolate Fudge Cake $11.45
Gourmet Red Velvet Cake $10.75
Gourmet Carrot Cake $10.75
Oreo Cookie Layer Cake $10.95
Key Lime Pie $9.95
Large Baklava $9.95
German Chocolate Cake $10.50
Orange Pie $9.95
Chocolate Pie $9.95
Ice Cream $9.50
two scoops w/whipped cream

MILK SHAKES
Waffle Ice Cream Sandwich $15.00
vanilla ice cream, vanilla frosted rim, mini waffles caramel sauce & whipped cream
Chocolate Pancake Strawberry Milkshake $15.00
strawberry ice cream, chocolate frosted rim, pancakes, strawberries, strawberry sauce & whipped cream
Brownie Extravaganza $15.00
chocolate ice cream, chocolate frosted rim, brownie, chocolate sauce & whipped cream
Oreo Cookie Cake $15.00
vanilla ice cream, chocolate frosted rim, Oreo cookie cake, chocolate sauce, Oreo cookies & whipped cream
Strawberry Cheesecake $15.00
strawberry ice cream, vanilla frosted rim, cheesecake, strawberries, strawberry sauce & whipped cream

CUPCAKES
Vanilla Fudge $4.95
Red Valvet $4.95
Black Out $4.95
Carrot $4.95
Cookie Dough $4.95
Brownie $4.95
Oreo $4.95
Apple Pie $4.95
Peanut Butter Cup $4.95
Chocolate Butter Cream $4.95

BEVERAGES
Coffee $3.95
Bottomless cup of fresh coffee
Espresso $3.95
Double Espresso $4.95
Almond Milk Latte $5.50
double espresso & steamed Almond milk
Latte $5.00
double espresso & steamed milk
Cappuccino $5.50
double espresso, steamed milk & foam
Mocha $5.95
espresso, chocolate, steamed milk & whipped cream
Vanilla Heaven $5.95
espresso, vanilla, steamed milk & whipped cream
Freddo Espresso $4.95
iced espresso
Freddo Cappuccino $5.50
iced cappuccino
Caramel Macchiato $5.95
double espresso, caramel, vanilla & steamed milk
Hot Chocolate $5.45
real chocolate, steamed milk & whipped cream
Black Tea $4.50
Earl Grey, English Breakfast, Chai
Green Tea $4.50
Genmaicha, Gunpowder
Herbal Tea $4.50
Berry Blossom, Cinnamon Chamomile, Lemon

MOCKTAILS - Our Signature non-Alcoholic Cocktails
Cucumber Fresh $15.00
Cucumber, mint, lemon juice, simple syrup, tonic
Apple Pie $15.00
Apple juice, homemade cinnamon cordial, lemon juice, soda water
Redfreshment $15.00
Homemade hibiscus cordial, lime juice, grapefruit juice, grapefruit soda
Bee-Hind $15.00
Homemade honey ginger cordial, lemon juice, cranberry juice, club soda

COCKTAILS
Watermelon Breezer $16.00
Absolut watermelon, cranberry juice, club soda
Espresso Martini $16.00
Absolut vodka, espresso, homemade Guinness, espresso cordial
French Connection $16.00
Hendricks gin, green chartreuse, homemade prosecco cordial, lime
Jalisco Rioja $16.00
Altos Plata tequila blanco, mezcal, homemade spicy hibiscus cordial, lime, egg white
Big Apple $16.00
bourbon, apple juice, homemade cinnamon cordial, lemon
Prohibition $16.00
bourbon, dark rum, homemade honey ginger cordial, bitters, ginger beer
Bittersweet Symphony $16.00
Absolut vodka, campari, lime, homemade grapefruit cordial, grapefruit soda
Margarita (Classic - Pineapple - Spicy - Strawberry) $10.00
Tequila, lime juice & salted rim
Mimosa $9.95
Bellini $9.95
Bloody Mary $9.95
Unlimited Mimosa $19.95
per person, entire table must order - 2 hour maximum

MULE BAR
Grey Goose Strawberry Mule $14.00
Grey Goose vodka, fresh strawberries ginger beer, lime, mint.
Texas Mule $13.00
Titos vodka, ginger beer, lime, mint.
Tropical Mule $13.00
Skyy vodka, ginger beer, pineapple, mint.
Mediterranean Mule $13.00
Fig vodka, ginger beer, lime, mint.
Bourbon Mule $13.00
Makers Mark bourbon, lemon juice, honey, ginger beer, bitters.

WHITE WINE
PINOT GRIGIO Santa Cristina, ITALY - Glass $11.00
fresh, fruity and crisp
PINOT GRIGIO Santa Cristina, ITALY - Bottle $44.00
fresh, fruity and crisp
RIESLING Starling Castle, GERMANY -Glass $12.00
ripe peach flavors, hints of lime
RIESLING Starling Castle, GERMANY -Bottle $48.00
ripe peach flavors, hints of lime
SAUV. BLANC Brancott NEW ZEALAND - Glass $13.00
fruit flavors with a dry finish & guava notes
SAUV. BLANC Brancott NEW ZEALAND-Bottle $49.00
fruit flavors with a dry finish & guava notes
MOSHOFILERO Mantinia, GREECE -Glass $13.00
lemon & orange blossom aromas
MOSHOFILERO Mantinia, GREECE -Bottle $49.00
lemon & orange blossom aromas
CHARDONNAY Layer Cake, CALIFORNIA -Glass $13.00
full flavors of green apples and nectarines
CHARDONNAY Layer Cake, CALIFORNIA -Bottle $48.00
full flavors of green apples and nectarines
ASSYRTIKO Anhydrous, Santorini, GREECE -Glass $15.00
crisp, dry and flavorful
ASSYRTIKO Anhydrous, Santorini, GREECE -Bottle $52.00
crisp, dry and flavorful

RED WINE
PINOT NOIR Le Grand Noir, FRANCE -Glass $10.00
bright red cherry and strawberry
PINOT NOIR Le Grand Noir, FRANCE -Bottle $40.00
bright red cherry and strawberry
CABERNET Columbia Crest, USA -Glass $12.00
full body, flavors of dark fruits.
CABERNET Columbia Crest, USA -Bottle $48.00
full body, flavors of dark fruits
MERLOT Ploes, Drama, GREECE- Glass $11.00
cherry, mocha, cedar & cinnamon aromas.
MERLOT Ploes, Drama, GREECE- Bottle $44.00
cherry, mocha, cedar & cinnamon aromas.
AGIORITIKO flowers, GREECE - Glass $12.00
medium to full body, wild cherries.
AGIORITIKO flowers, GREECE- Bottle $48.00
medium to full body, wild cherries.
CHIANTI Straccali, ITALY - Glass $10.00
medium body, aroma of cherries & violets.
CHIANTI Straccali, ITALY - Bottle $40.00
medium body, aroma of cherries & violets.
MALBEC Oko, organic ARGENTINA -Glass $11.00
fruitful Flavor, truffle and vanilla notes.
MALBEC Oko, organic ARGENTINA -Bottle $44.00
fruitful Flavor, truffle and vanilla notes.

THE BUBBLES
ROSE Campo Viejo, SPAIN - Glass $11.00
tasting and crisp, with citrus aroma and notes of nectar/honey
ROSE Campo Viejo, SPAIN - Bottle $44.00
tasting and crisp, with citrus aroma and notes of nectar/honey
PROSECCO Benvolio, ITALY -Glass $13.00
PROSECCO Benvolio, ITALY -Bottle $49.00
CHAMPAGNE Vollereaux FRANCE - Glass $19.00
quality Champagne, slight sweetness balanced with clean acidity
CHAMPAGNE Vollereaux FRANCE - Bottle $79.00
quality Champagne, slight sweetness balanced with clean acidity

BEERS
Bucket Of Beers $20.00
Choose any 4 domestic beers
Coors Light, Lager Colorado $6.00
Budweiser, USA $6.00
Bud Light, USA $6.00
Corona Lager, Mexico $7.00
Stella Artois Lager, Belgium $7.00
Sam Adams Ale, Boston $6.00
Presidente Dominican Republic $7.00
Fix Lager, Greece $7.00
Michelob Ultra, USA $6.00
Heineken, Netherlands $7.00
Beck's Germany $7.00
Blue Moon, USA $6.00

Carnegie Diner & Cafe Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Healthy options
Late-night food
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Planning
Brunch reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Has changing table(s)
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Paid street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed

Carnegie Diner & Cafe Photos

Carnegie Diner & Cafe Location

Carnegie Diner & Cafe

New York New York County New York 8th Avenue

828 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019, USA

Carnegie Diner & Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 2958 user reviews.

pastrami sandwichtimes squarebroadwaymimosasavocado toastpastrami burgerlobster rollpastrami reubentourist trapnew york cheesecake

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

It was our first time at Carnegie Diner & Cafe and we loved it. I went for the Smashed Double Burger and it was delicious, juicy and cooked just right. The flavour and texture were spot on. I'd say this is one of the best burgers I've had in New York so far. My wife had the ham sandwich, which was also excellent: fresh, generously filled and very flavourful.The service was on the ball, the staff were friendly, and the food arrived nice and hot. We also really liked the atmosphere – a typical New York diner feel, cosy and lively at the same time.All in all, it was a great experience. We'll definitely be back and can highly recommend Carnegie Diner & Cafe!
September 15 · Marc Goebel
Needed to grab some breakfast with the family preparing for a very busy day. The reviews on Carnegie Diner & Cafe were excellent and did not disappoint. We were warmly greeted upon entering and had a few minutes wait before being seated. The restaurant has SO much lovely art work adorned on the walls that I found myself daydreaming of each and everyone. Our server was Alexandra, and she was friendly, professional and provided us with great insight on the menu and asked about any dietary restrictions. After placing our order within minutes our food had arrived. My youngest son flipped over their pancakes on a stick, they were truly a hit. Our entire meal, service and experience was a total success. Would rate 10/10 on all levels, and would recommend to anyone looking for a great meal, reasonably priced and great service, please check out Carnegie Diner & Cafe, you will not be disappointed. Enjoy!
July 14 · John Smith III
Carnegie Diner & Cafe is one of those places you immediately want to come back to. From the moment you sit down, you notice how welcoming and efficient the service is—super attentive without ever feeling rushed.The menu is impressively large, offering a wide variety of choices to suit any craving. Whether you’re in the mood for classic deli staples, juicy burgers, hearty steaks, or shareable appetizers, you’ll find something that hits the spot.A highlight for me is their pastrami—it’s cooked to perfection, tender, and seasoned just right. You can taste the care that goes into preparing it, and it captures that authentic New York deli flavor with a little extra finesse.With generous portions, great flavors, and top-notch service, Carnegie Diner & Cafe feels like the perfect balance between a classic New York deli and a modern comfort spot. Definitely a place worth trying, whether you’re a local or just visiting the city.
September 02 · Mansoor Almulla
My husband discovered this place when reading reviews for a good lunch spot during our busy day sightseeing. He had the reuben, daughter had pesto pasta, and I ordered fettuccine alfredo. Everything was delicious. My daughter has an obsession with pesto and absolutely loved her meal. Service was great, with very reasonable prices. It was a nice place to eat while cooling off from walking around all morning in the August heat.
August 16 · Heather Hanson
Fantastic Meal at Carnegie Diner & Café – Times Square Vibes Done Right!We had an outstanding experience at Carnegie Diner & Café in Times Square! From the moment we walked in, the service was excellent and impressively fast — a big plus in such a busy area. The decor screamed Times Square in the best way, with bold design and oversized, super comfy booths that made our whole visit extra enjoyable.I ordered the pastrami Reuben, and wow — it was stacked with half a pound of juicy, flavorful pastrami, perfectly melted cheese, and tangy Russian dressing on toasted rye. I upgraded to the truffle oil & Parmesan fries, and they were absolutely to die for — crispy, rich, and addictive.Our table also tried a classic burger (juicy and satisfying), crispy onion rings, chicken and waffles (a perfect sweet-and-savory combo), and a creamy, comforting fettuccine Alfredo. We kicked things off with a spinach pie appetizer — it had a flaky, light crust filled with savory spinach, cheese, and herbs. Truly a delicious start!This place checks all the boxes — delicious food, speedy service, and a fun, comfortable setting in the heart of NYC. A definite must-visit if you're in the Times Square area!
July 14 · Scott Best