Casaletto Pizzeria

- 70 Beekman Ave, Sleepy Hollow, NY 10591

## Introduction / Overview: A Slice of Authentic New York in Sleepy Hollow

For local New York users seeking genuinely authentic and high-quality Italian-American fare, Casaletto Pizzeria stands out as a premier destination in Sleepy Hollow, NY. More than just a simple pizza shop, this establishment has earned a robust reputation for serving what satisfied patrons call the "Best New York Style Pizza ever," combined with an extensive menu of classic Italian Entrees and sides.

Located conveniently on Beekman Avenue, Casaletto Pizzeria offers a winning combination of quality food, friendly service, and highly reasonable prices, creating an experience that customers frequently describe as "fantastic." The atmosphere is designed to be Casual and Cozy, making it ideal for everything from a quick Solo dining experience to a relaxed family Dinner. The establishment is proudly committed to excellence in all areas, with reviews noting that the service is "outstanding" and orders consistently come out quickly—a key highlight noted as Fast service.

The menu is a testament to its comprehensive culinary offering, extending far beyond the traditional Classic Cheese Pie. Diners can explore unique specialty pizzas, like the famous, locally-themed Headless Horseman Pie (Pepperoni, peppers, onions & mushrooms), alongside beloved Italian dishes such as Chicken Parmigiana and Lasagna. Furthermore, the professionalism of the operation is highlighted by its praised ability to maintain "perfect timing on big orders," confirming its reliability for both large family meals and extensive Catering needs. This quality, convenience, and commitment to the local community make Casaletto Pizzeria a must-visit spot in the Sleepy Hollow region.

## Location and Accessibility: Convenient Dining on Beekman Avenue

The location of Casaletto Pizzeria makes it a highly accessible and central food hub for the Sleepy Hollow community. You can find this acclaimed pizza restaurant at: 70 Beekman Ave, Sleepy Hollow, NY 10591, USA. Situated on a well-known thoroughfare, it is easy to reach for both local residents and Tourists drawn to the area.

Understanding the importance of convenience in the New York area, Casaletto Pizzeria provides practical accessibility features for its patrons. While on-site parking is not guaranteed, Paid street parking is available nearby for those driving. Crucially, the establishment ensures broad accommodation, featuring a Wheelchair accessible parking lot to assist all visitors.

For pet owners who wish to enjoy the local atmosphere, the establishment is accommodating, with Dogs allowed outside in designated areas, adding a welcoming touch for the community. Customers can easily connect with the restaurant to place their orders or ask about services using their professional contact numbers:

Phone: (914) 372-7680

Mobile Phone: +1 914-372-7680

These elements—central location, accessible features, and easy communication—reinforce Casaletto Pizzeria’s role as a dependable and welcoming neighborhood institution.

## Services Offered

Casaletto Pizzeria offers an exceptionally versatile range of services, catering to virtually every dining scenario, from a simple afternoon Quick bite to organizing a large event, all delivered with the noted Fast service philosophy.

• Dine-in: Guests can enjoy the Casual and Cozy atmosphere for Lunch or Dinner, with clean and well-maintained facilities, including clean restrooms.
• Takeout & Delivery: A full suite of off-premise services is available, including standard Delivery, No-contact delivery, and convenient Curbside pickup, ensuring speed and flexibility for busy local users.
• Full-Service Catering: The comprehensive Catering menu includes dozens of half and full trays of Italian favorites, such as Baked Ziti, Chicken Marsala, Penne Ala Vodka, and Lasagna, perfect for parties and business events.
• Meal Periods: The restaurant serves Lunch and Dinner, and also provides a satisfying Dessert menu featuring items like Cannoli, New York Cheesecake, and Nutella Zeppole.
• Beverages & Offerings: The menu is complete with a full range of non-alcoholic Beverages and also offers Alcohol and Beer, complementing the selection of Comfort food.

## Features / Highlights

The standout features of Casaletto Pizzeria are precisely what New York residents look for in a dependable and high-quality local eatery: consistency, speed, and great value. The restaurant’s highlights underscore its commitment to a top-tier customer experience.

• Exceptional Speed and Reliability: The primary highlight is Fast service, complemented by customer reviews praising the staff for being "incredibly friendly and attentive." The restaurant is known for its "perfect timing on big orders," demonstrating high operational efficiency.
• Acclaimed Pizza Quality: Customers attest to the quality, proudly calling it the "Best New York Style Pizza ever." This reputation is built on classic favorites and creative specialty items alike.
• Excellent Value Proposition: The restaurant is noted for having "very reasonable prices for the quality and experience you get," making it easy on the wallet while still delivering outstanding food and service.
• Family and Group Friendly: The establishment is explicitly Good for kids, offering a dedicated Kids' menu, and is Popular for groups, ensuring a welcoming environment for the entire family.
• Specialty Pie Focus: The inclusion of locally-themed specialty items, like the "Headless Horseman Pie" (Pepperoni, peppers, onions & mushrooms), showcases a fun, localized flair that appeals directly to the community and visiting Tourists.
• Convenient Payment Options: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments ensures a fast and frictionless transaction experience, essential for a Quick bite stop.

## What is Worth Choosing: Menu Variety and Consistent Quality

When choosing from the menu at Casaletto Pizzeria, patrons are met with a dizzying array of options, but what is truly worth choosing is the exceptional variety paired with the restaurant's praised consistency and quality. The menu is structured to satisfy every Italian-American craving.

For the quintessential New York experience, one must start with the Pizza. Beyond the highly-rated Classic Cheese Pie (available in 12" up to 18" and Sicilian), the specialty pies are a compelling choice. Customers rave about the Headless Horseman Pie, a savory blend of pepperoni, peppers, onions, and mushrooms. Other unique options like the Chicken Alla Vodka Pie, the deep-dish style Grandma Pie, or the hearty Meat Lovers Pie demonstrate the kitchen's creative breadth. For a quick, affordable meal, the value of a Regular Slice ($3.50), Sicilian Slice ($4.50), or Specialty Slice ($5.50) cannot be overstated.

Beyond pizza, the Calzones & Rolls provide perfect handheld meals. Options like the Chicken Vodka Roll ($9.99) and the Buffalo Chicken Roll ($9.99) offer a complete, flavorful meal in a convenient format. For a more traditional, sit-down Italian experience, the Entrees are the highlight, featuring generous portions of classics like Chicken Franchese ($21.99), Shrimp Parmigiana ($22.99), and the popular Penne Vodka ($16.99).

Choosing Casaletto Pizzeria means selecting a place where customer satisfaction is paramount, evidenced by the combination of "incredible food" and "outstanding service" at "very reasonable prices." Whether you are looking for a classic taste of the Best New York Style Pizza, a rich Italian Entree, or dependable, large-scale Catering for an event, Casaletto Pizzeria consistently delivers a flavorful, high-value, and reliable experience to the Sleepy Hollow community.

Casaletto Pizzeria

70 Beekman Ave, Sleepy Hollow, NY 10591, USA