Casella Bagel Coffee Shop: Downtown Brooklyn's Premier Spot for Bagels, Sandwiches, and Comfort Food

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Introduce

Introduction / Overview

In the heart of bustling Downtown Brooklyn, New York, lies a true local favorite that consistently delivers on freshness, variety, and a friendly, cozy atmosphere: Casella Bagel Coffee Shop. Located at 66 Willoughby Street, this establishment has cemented its place as a quintessential NYC spot, combining the best features of a classic bakery, a quick-service sandwich shop, and a welcoming neighborhood coffee house. It's the perfect stop for New Yorkers on the go, whether you're rushing to work, meeting a colleague for a casual bite, or simply craving a satisfying, high-quality meal any time of day.

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop is particularly celebrated for its extensive menu that spans far beyond the typical bagel shop fare. While the "Bagel" in the name promises New York's iconic morning staple, the comprehensive selection of omelettes, breakfast platters, hot and cold sandwiches, wraps, burgers, and classic diner-style sides ensures there is something to satisfy every craving. Patrons consistently praise the commitment to fresh, made-to-order food, which is the cornerstone of the shop's reputation. Reviews often highlight the "friendly and relaxed atmosphere" and the overall value, making it a reliable choice for locals and visitors exploring Brooklyn's vibrant culinary scene.

This beloved Downtown Brooklyn fixture embodies the spirit of a versatile urban eatery, catering to those who appreciate speed without sacrificing taste or quality. It truly operates as a one-stop-shop, ensuring that whether you're looking for an immediate caffeine fix, a classic breakfast, or a robust lunch, Casella Bagel Coffee Shop has you covered with its extensive and thoughtfully curated offerings.

Location and Accessibility

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop boasts a prime location in one of New York City's most dynamic and accessible neighborhoods: Downtown Brooklyn. Situated at 66 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA, the shop is easily reachable for the countless commuters, residents, and business professionals who frequent the area. Its proximity to major transportation hubs and offices makes it an ideal spot for a quick visit, aligning perfectly with the fast-paced New York lifestyle.

For those traveling by public transit, the Downtown Brooklyn location offers excellent accessibility to numerous subway lines. While the exact proximity to each subway entrance may vary, the neighborhood's dense transit network ensures that Casella Bagel is just a short walk from several key lines, providing a convenient start to the day for New Yorkers traveling from any borough. Car users should note that the location is primarily served by paid street parking, which is typical for a busy commercial district like Downtown Brooklyn.

The shop provides a cozy indoor dining experience for those who wish to sit down and enjoy their meal, as public data confirms all dining is conducted indoors. The atmosphere is described as warm and inviting, providing a comfortable respite from the surrounding city bustle.

Services Offered

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop offers a variety of services designed to accommodate the varied needs of a busy New York clientele, from dine-in comfort to quick takeaway options. The array of offerings ensures maximum convenience throughout the day.

Dine-in Service: Enjoy the friendly, relaxed, and cozy atmosphere with full dine-in service.
Takeout: All menu items are available for quick and convenient in-store pickup.
Delivery Service: For those unable to visit the physical location, the shop partners with various online platforms to offer reliable delivery right to your door in the Brooklyn area.
Onsite Services: The establishment offers general onsite services to cater to its patrons.
Catering to Diverse Palates: With a menu covering everything from bakery items and classic breakfast to burgers, gyros, and hearty sandwiches, the shop effectively acts as a bakery, sandwich shop, and diner rolled into one.
Payment Flexibility: Accepts major payment methods, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments, making transactions fast and seamless.
Accessibility: Customers can utilize the on-site restroom facility during their visit.

Features / Highlights

The appeal of Casella Bagel Coffee Shop lies not only in its excellent location but also in its dedication to a diverse menu and a reliably pleasant customer experience. Here are some of the standout features and menu highlights:

Bagels and Breakfast Staples: As a New York bagel shop, the basics are covered, offering freshly baked Bagels with a variety of spreads, including plain, Veggie, and Scallion Cream Cheese, as well as options like Nutella and Peanut Butter & Jelly. The shop also offers classic griddle items like Pancakes, French Toast, and Belgian Waffles, available plain or with eggs and meat.
The Legendary Hungry Man Sandwich: A true New York staple, this massive breakfast sandwich is a featured highlight. The Hungry Man comes loaded with Bacon, Ham, Sausage, three eggs, and Home Fries, all served on a hero roll, providing a seriously substantial meal for the hungriest customer.
Extensive Omelette Selection: The menu features over a dozen omelette options, including the signature Casella Omelette (with sliced turkey, onions, peppers, and tomato), the hearty Athenian Omelette (with Gyro meat, spinach, tomatoes, onions, peppers, and feta cheese), and the Avocado Omelette (with avocado, peppers, onions, and cheddar cheese).
All-Day Sandwich & Lunch Options: Beyond breakfast, the shop excels with a wide range of hot and cold sandwiches and wraps, including popular choices like the Cuban Sandwich, Reuben Sandwich, Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich, and various club sandwiches like the Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich and Roast Beef Club Sandwich. Wraps include favorites like the Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap and the substantial California Wrap (Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, avocado, bacon, and ranch dressing).
Quick and Friendly Service: Customers consistently mention the quick service and the friendly nature of the staff, which is crucial for a dependable, daily stop in a busy city setting.
Diner-Style Variety: The menu includes comforting diner-style food, such as Beef and Turkey Burgers, Gyro Platters, and a substantial selection of side orders like French Fries, Onion Rings, and Mozzarella Sticks.
Specialty Coffee and Beverages: A full coffee bar offers everything from a standard cup of Coffee and Lipton Tea to specialty drinks like Café Latte, Café Mocha, and various Flavored Iced Coffee options, ensuring a quality brew to pair with any meal.

Contact Information

For local residents and visitors planning a visit or placing an order, here is the essential contact information for Casella Bagel Coffee Shop:

Address: 66 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Phone: (718) 522-5641

What is worth choosing

For any New Yorker seeking a reliable, high-value, and delicious meal in the Downtown Brooklyn area, Casella Bagel Coffee Shop stands out as an excellent choice. It’s an essential local business that skillfully blends the traditions of a New York bagel shop with the expansive menu of a classic American diner, all while maintaining a welcoming neighborhood feel.

What makes Casella truly worth choosing is its incredible menu versatility. Unlike more specialized eateries, you can find a morning coffee and a fresh Bagel with Cream Cheese, an over-the-top breakfast like the Hungry Man, a lighter option such as a Greek Salad, or a filling lunch like the Reuben Sandwich all in one place. The shop is clearly dedicated to serving high-quality, freshly prepared food that keeps locals coming back. The fact that customers consistently praise the food quality, variety, and very reasonable pricing—especially for the quantity and fresh nature of the meals—reinforces its status as a top-tier spot for a satisfying and budget-friendly experience.

Furthermore, for those on a tight schedule, the service options are perfectly tailored for speed and convenience. The quick service, coupled with the availability of delivery, takeout, and a cozy dining room, ensures that Casella Bagel Coffee Shop fits seamlessly into any part of a busy day in Brooklyn. Whether you are craving a comfort food classic or simply need a quick, quality breakfast to kickstart your day, choosing Casella means opting for consistency, flavor, and a genuine, friendly New York dining experience.

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Menu

Salads
Green Salad $5.00
Tuna Salad $8.75
Chicken Salad $8.75
Chicken salad with lettuce tomatoes and mayo.
Greek Salad $10.00
Caesar Salad $8.00
Classic caesar salad with crisp romaine, parmesan, croutons, and signature caesar dressing.
Chef Salad $12.50
Egg Salad $7.00

Beverages
Cappuccino $4.50
Rich espresso topped with velvety milk foam. options for large or small.
Flavored Coffee $4.00
Coffee in large or small sizes. choose from banana, caramel, chocolate, french vanilla, hazelnut, raspberry, or strawberry flavors.
CafÃ© Mocha $4.75
Espresso with steamed milk, chocolate, topped with whipped cream. options for large or small sizes.
Smart Water $3.00
20 oz.
Milkshake $5.25
Vanilla, strawberry, chocolate.
Bottled Water $2.25
Iced Tea $4.50
Refreshing iced tea. options include large or small.
CafÃ© Latte $4.50
Steamed milk and espresso, available in large or small.
Iced Coffee $4.50
Favorite.
Lemon Pure Leaf Tea $3.50
Brewed using freshly picked tea leaves so every sip is as sweet as the last.
Gatorade $2.50
Sports drink available in cool blue, fruit punch, or orange flavors.
Jarritos $3.75
Herbal Tea $3.75
Herbal tea in large or small. choose from 14 flavors including chamomile, green tea, and peppermint among others.
Cranberry Ocean Spray $3.00
Bottled Soda $3.00
Bottled soda available in a variety of flavors including citrus, cola, ginger ale, and sparkling grape. choose from brands like pepsi, coke, canada dry, and more.
Flavored Iced Coffee $5.50
Iced coffee available in large or small, with flavors including amaretto, banana, caramel, chocolate, french vanilla, hazelnut, irish cream, raspberry, and strawberry.
Canned Soda $2.00
Canned soda available in a variety of flavors including citrus, cola, diet options, and sparkling grape. choose from brisk, several canada dry varieties, coke, pepsi, and more.
Vitamin Water $3.50
Dragon-fruit, tropical citrus, â€‹acai-blueberry-pomegranate.
Coffee $3.00
Lipton Tea $3.00
A sunny, refreshing taste with a delicious blend of tea and tasty citrus flavor.
Simply Juice $2.75
Simply juice, available in mango, orange, or raspberry lemonade flavors.
Orange Juice $3.25
Favorite.
Espresso $4.00
Decaf Coffee $3.00
Snapple $3.50
Snapple tea in various flavors including apple, diet peach, fruit punch, and more. choose from classic and diet options.
Hot Chocolate $4.00
Apple & Eve Juice $3.00

Gyro
Gyro Sandwich $10.75
Gyro Platter $13.00
Comes with small salad, small French fries, tzatziki sauce, choice of meat. No substitution isâ€‹ available.
Chicken Gyro Platter $13.00
Chicken Gyro Sandwich $10.75

Breakfast Sandwiches
1 Egg With Cheese Sandwich $6.25
One egg and cheese on a choice of breads, including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. variety of flavors like cinnamon raisin, onion, whole wheat, and sesame seed.
1 Egg With Meat & Cheese Sandwich $8.50
Favorite.
1 Egg Sandwich $5.50
One egg sandwich with a choice of bread: bagels (various types including cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, sesame seed, whole wheat), wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), and more (bialy, croissant, hero, roll, rye toast, white toast, whole wheat toast).
Hungry Man $12.75
Only served on hero. Bacon, ham, sausage with three eggs and home fries.
1 Egg With Meat Sandwich $6.50
1 egg sandwich paired with choice of meat: bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options. select from 16 bread types, including bagels, wraps, and toasts.

Burritos
Grilled Chicken Burrito $12.00
The delicious burrito comes with rice, beans, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and sour cream.
Roast Pork Burrito $12.00
This delicious burrito comes with rice, beans, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and sour cream.
Beef Steak Burrito $14.50
The delicious burrito comes with rice, beans, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and sour cream.

Hot Sandwiches
Cuban Sandwich $14.00
Favorite. Most popular* a staple in our restaurant!.
Tuna Melt Sandwich $11.50
Tuna melt on choice of bread: bialy to whole wheat wrap. various bagels, wraps, and toast options.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $10.25
Grilled chicken bacon lettuce tomato mayo and french fries.
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich $13.50
Choice of various breads envelops tender chicken cheesesteak: from bagels and wraps to toasts and rolls. options include bialy, croissant, and more for customization.
Sausage & Peppers Sandwich $11.00
Sausage & peppers with choice of bread: including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants.
Fish Flounder Sandwich $12.00
Comes on a hero.
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich $14.00
Comes on a hero.
Meatball Sandwich $11.00
Reuben Sandwich $14.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $7.00
Steak & Onions Sandwich $12.00
Roast Pork Sandwich $12.00
Roast pork sandwich with multiple bread options including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose from bialy to whole wheat varieties.
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich $10.25
Crispy chicken cutlet with a variety of bread options including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose from classics to whole wheat varieties.
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich $13.50
Most popular.

Breakfast Platters
2 Eggs With Meat $11.75
Price can vary depending on meat chosen and add-ons.
2 Eggs With Steak $18.75
Price can vary depending on meat chosen and add-ons
2 Eggs With Fish Flounder $14.25
Two eggs, choice of preparation, paired with tender fish flounder. served with a side of french fries, grits, or home fries.
2 Eggs Any Style $10.75
Two eggs prepared to order: choose from egg whites, over easy, hard, medium, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up. served with a side: fries, grits, or home fries.

Salad Sandwiches
Egg Salad Sandwich $9.00
Egg salad nestled between your choice of bread including bagels, wraps, croissants, or toast with a variety of flavors like plain, sesame seed, everything, and more.
Chicken Salad Sandwich Deluxe $16.00
Chicken salad with a deluxe assortment of bread options including bagels, wraps, toasts, and more. choose from 16 varieties like bialy, croissant, or spinach wrap.
Tuna Salad Sandwich Deluxe $16.00
Tuna salad sandwich with customizable bread options, including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose your favorite from a variety of flavors and types.
Chicken Salad Sandwich $10.00
Chicken salad with a variety of bread options, including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. select from classic to whole wheat varieties.
Tuna Salad Sandwich $10.00
Boiled egg lettuce tomato and french fries.
Egg Salad Sandwich Deluxe $16.00
Egg salad sandwich with choice of bread: bagels, wraps, toast varieties, croissant, or hero.

Sandwiches
BLT Sandwich $8.50
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Ham Sandwich $9.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Turkey Bacon LT Sandwich $9.50
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $7.00
Roast Beef Club Sandwich $16.00
Roast beef, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Turkey Club Sandwich $16.00
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Turkey Sandwich $11.00
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich $11.00
Turkey & cheese sandwich with a variety of bread options: bagels, wraps, toast, and croissant. select from bialy, plain to whole wheat choices.
Pastrami Sandwich $10.00
Pastrami layered generously between choice of breads, including bagels, wraps, and toasts with selections from plain to whole wheat varieties.
Tuna Salad Club Sandwich $14.00
Boiled egg, lettuce, tomato and French fries.
Ham & Cheese Sandwich $10.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Roast Beef Sandwich $10.00
Roast beef swiss lettuce tomato mayo and french fries.
Genoa Salami Sandwich $9.00
Genoa salami sandwich with a selection of bread including bagels, wraps, toast, and more. choice options range from bialy to whole wheat varieties.
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich $18.00
Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.

Breakfast Griddle Originals
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs & Meat $13.50
Plain Belgian Waffle $9.00
The ice cream is not included, only powdered sugar.
Plain French Toast $9.00
We also have old fashioned French toast available.
Short Stack $6.25
French Toast With Meat $12.00
French toast paired with choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options.
Silver Dollar Pancakes $11.00
Chocolate Chip Pancakes $11.00
Pancakes With 2 Eggs & Meat $13.50
Pancakes served with two eggs, choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options. eggs prepared to preference.
Belgian Waffle With Meat $12.00
French Toast With 2 Eggs & Meat $13.50
French toast paired with two eggs, your choice of preparation, and a selection of traditional or turkey-based meats.
Pancakes $9.00
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs $11.50
Pancakes With Meat $12.00
Pancakes With 2 Eggs $11.50
French Toast With 2 Eggs $11.50
French toast served with your choice of eggs: white, over easy/medium/hard, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up.

Beverages
Flavored Iced Coffee $5.50
Iced coffee available in large or small, with flavors including amaretto, banana, caramel, chocolate, french vanilla, hazelnut, irish cream, raspberry, and strawberry.
Simply Juice $2.75
Simply juice, available in mango, orange, or raspberry lemonade flavors.
Coffee $3.00
Hot coffee, available in large or small sizes.
CafÃ© Mocha $4.75
Espresso with steamed milk, chocolate, topped with whipped cream. options for large or small sizes.
Gatorade $3.00
Sports drink available in cool blue, fruit punch, or orange flavors.
Decaf Coffee $3.00
Canned Soda $2.00
Canned soda available in a variety of flavors including citrus, cola, diet options, and sparkling grape. choose from brisk, several canada dry varieties, coke, pepsi, and more.
Bottled Soda $3.00
Bottled soda available in a variety of flavors including citrus, cola, ginger ale, and sparkling grape. choose from brands like pepsi, coke, canada dry, and more.
Vitamin Water $3.50
Dragon-fruit, tropical citrus, â€‹acai-blueberry-pomegranate.
CafÃ© Latte $4.50
Steamed milk and espresso, available in large or small.
Orange Juice $3.25
Favorite.
Smart Water $3.00
20 oz.
Iced Coffee $4.50
Favorite.
Iced Tea $4.50
Refreshing iced tea. options include large or small.
Snapple $3.50
Snapple tea in various flavors including apple, diet peach, fruit punch, and more. choose from classic and diet options.
Herbal Tea $3.75
Herbal tea in large or small. choose from 14 flavors including chamomile, green tea, and peppermint among others.
Flavored Coffee $4.00
Coffee in large or small sizes. choose from banana, caramel, chocolate, french vanilla, hazelnut, raspberry, or strawberry flavors.
Cappuccino $4.50
Rich espresso topped with velvety milk foam. options for large or small.
Lipton Tea $3.00
Lipton tea; choice of large or small.
Bottled Water $2.25
Bottled water in various sizes: 16.9 oz, 23.7 oz, 33.8 oz, 50.7 oz.
Jarritos $3.75
Mexican soda in various fruit flavors including fruit punch, citrus, mango, pineapple, or tamarind.
Cranberry Ocean Spray $3.00
Lemon Pure Leaf Tea $3.50
Brewed using freshly picked tea leaves so every sip is as sweet as the last.
Milkshake $5.25
Vanilla, strawberry, chocolate.
Apple & Eve Juice $3.00
Espresso $3.00
Espresso, available in double or single shots.
Hot Chocolate $4.00
Creamy hot chocolate, available in large or small sizes.

Hot Sandwiches
Steak & Onions Sandwich $12.00
Tender steak and caramelized onions on choice of bialy, various bagels, croissant, hero, wrap, roll, toast including whole wheat, spinach, and plain options.
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich $13.50
Most popular.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $7.00
Grilled cheese on choice of bread: from classic white toast to whole wheat wrap and everything in-between, including onion and sesame seed bagels.
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich $14.00
Comes on a hero.
Tuna Melt Sandwich $11.50
Tuna melt on choice of bread: bialy to whole wheat wrap. various bagels, wraps, and toast options.
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich $10.25
Crispy chicken cutlet with a variety of bread options including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose from classics to whole wheat varieties.
Meatball Sandwich $11.00
Meatballs nestled with marinara sauce in choice of breads including bialy, various bagels, wraps, or toast.
Roast Pork Sandwich $12.00
Roast pork sandwich with multiple bread options including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. choose from bialy to whole wheat varieties.
Cuban Sandwich $14.00
Favorite. Most popular* a staple in our restaurant!.
Fish Flounder Sandwich $12.00
Comes on a hero.
Reuben Sandwich $14.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Sausage & Peppers Sandwich $11.00
Sausage & peppers with choice of bread: including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants.
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich $13.50
Choice of various breads envelops tender chicken cheesesteak: from bagels and wraps to toasts and rolls. options include bialy, croissant, and more for customization.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $10.25
Grilled chicken bacon lettuce tomato mayo and french fries.

Wraps
Chicken Cheesesteak Wrap $13.50
Grilled chicken, onions, peppers and cheese.
Tuna Salad Wrap $11.25
Tuna salad with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Chicken Salad Wrap $11.25
Chicken salad with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
Philly Cheesesteak Wrap $13.50
Steak with onions, peppers and cheese.
Grilled Chicken BLT Wrap $12.75
Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato and bacon.
Vegetarian Wrap $12.00
Lettuce, tomatoes, broccoli, mushrooms, onions, peppers and avocado.
Grilled Chicken Wrap $12.00
Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese and mayo.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.00
Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing.
California Wrap $16.25
Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, avocado, bacon and ranch dressing.

Hamburgers
Chicken Burger $10.00
Turkey Burger $8.75
Double Burger $9.00
Salmon Burger $8.75
Cheeseburger $8.25
Bacon Burger $8.00
Beef Burger $7.00
Casella Burger $11.00
Ham, cheese, one egg and avocado.
Mushroom Burger $7.00

Side Orders
Rice $5.00
Home Fries $5.50
French Fries $5.50
Buffalo Chicken Wings $9.75
6 pcs.
French Fries With Cheese $6.50
Onion Rings $5.50
Green Plantains $5.50
Mozzarella Sticks $8.75
6 pcs.
Beans $5.00
Ripe Plantains $5.50

Breakfast Omelette Platters
Western Omelette $12.00
Ham, tomatoes, onions and peppers.
Athenian Omelette $15.00
Gyro meat, spinach, tomatoes, onions, peppers and feta cheese.
Casella Omelette $13.00
Sliced turkey, onions, peppers and tomato.
Bacon Omelette $10.50
Bacon omelette served with your choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. choose a side of french fries, grits, or home fries.
Spinach Omelette $10.50
Tomatoes onions and peppers with red sauce.
Turkey Bacon Omelette $11.50
Turkey bacon mixed into fluffy eggs, served with choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. options for side include french fries, grits, or home fries.
Veggie Omelette $11.00
Tomatoes, onions, peppers and mushrooms.
Cheese Omelette $10.50
Cheese omelette served with choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. includes side options of french fries, grits, or home fries.
Low Cholesterol Omelette $11.50
Onion, peppers, mushrooms and egg whites.
Avocado Omelette $12.00
Avocado, peppers, onions and cheddar cheese.
Ham Omelette $10.50
Ham omelette served with your choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. choice of french fries, grits, or home fries on the side.
Greek Omelette $11.50
Feta cheese and tomato.
Spanish Omelette $11.50
Tomatoes, onions and peppers with red sauce.
Plain Omelette $9.00
Plain omelette served with your choice of rye, white, or whole wheat toast. select a side from french fries, grits, or home fries.

Breakfast Morning Starters
Bagel With Peanut Butter & Jelly $6.50
Bagel served with peanut butter and jelly. choice of bread includes bagels, wraps, toast variants, and more.
Oatmeal $5.00
Bagel With Peanut Butter $5.75
Bagel spread with creamy peanut butter. bread options: bialy, various bagels (cinnamon raisin + more), croissant, hero, wraps, toast (rye, white, whole wheat).
Muffin $4.25
Muffin With Butter $4.00
Butter-topped choice of banana, blueberry, corn, honey raisin bran, or walnut muffin.
Bagel With Veggie Cream Cheese $7.50
Served with veggie cream cheese, choice of bread including everything, onion, sesame seed, whole wheat bagels, croissant, wraps, and various toasts.
Bagel $3.25
Bagel served with choice of bread, including bialy, various bagels (cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, sesame seed, plain, whole wheat), croissant, hero, wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), and toast options (rye, white, whole wheat).
Bagel With Cream Cheese $5.50
Bagel, schmeared with cream cheese, choice of bialy, various bagels, croissant, wraps, or toast options.
Bagel With Butter $4.25
Served with butter, choice of bread includes bialy, varied bagels (cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, plain, sesame seed, whole wheat), croissant, hero, wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), and toast options (rye, white, whole wheat).
Bagel With Nutella $6.25
Creamy nutella spread on a choice of breads, including bagels, croissants, wraps, and toasts with various flavors.
Muffin With Butter & Jelly $4.75
Choice of muffin: banana, blueberry, corn, honey raisin bran, or walnut. served with butter and jelly.
Grits $5.00
Bagel With Butter & Jelly $5.00
Bagel served with butter & jelly. choose from bialy, cinnamon raisin, croissant, and various bagels or wraps including whole wheat options.
Bagel With Nutella & Banana $6.00
Bagel toasted with hazelnut spread and banana slices.
Bagel With Scallion Cream Cheese $7.50
Scallion cream cheese spread over choice of bread, including wraps, toasts, and bagels with various toppings.

Breakfast Morning Starters
Bagel With Nutella & Banana $5.75
Bagel toasted with hazelnut spread and banana slices.
Bagel With Scallion Cream Cheese $6.75
Bagel With Butter & Jelly $4.25
Bagel served with butter & jelly. choose from bialy, cinnamon raisin, croissant, and various bagels or wraps including whole wheat options.
Bagel With Cream Cheese $4.75
Bagel With Nutella $5.50
Creamy nutella spread on a choice of breads, including bagels, croissants, wraps, and toasts with various flavors.
Muffin $3.50
Bagel With Veggie Cream Cheese $6.75
Bagel $3.00
Muffin With Butter $3.75
Bagel With Butter $3.50
Oatmeal $4.00
Grits $4.00
Muffin With Butter & Jelly $4.00
Choice of muffin: banana, blueberry, corn, honey raisin bran, or walnut. served with butter and jelly.
Bagel With Peanut Butter $5.00
Bagel spread with creamy peanut butter. bread options: bialy, various bagels (cinnamon raisin + more), croissant, hero, wraps, toast (rye, white, whole wheat).
Bagel With Peanut Butter & Jelly $5.75
Bagel served with peanut butter and jelly. choice of bread includes bagels, wraps, toast variants, and more.

Hamburgers
Double Burger $9.00
Two patties, selection of meat temperature: medium to well done.
Beef Burger $7.00
Beef burger with choice of meat temperature: medium, medium rare, medium well, rare, well done.
Bacon Burger $8.00
Bacon-topped hamburger, choice of meat temperature: from rare to well done.
Turkey Burger $8.75
Casella Burger $11.00
Ham, cheese, one egg and avocado.
Cheeseburger $8.25
Cheeseburger with choice of meat temperature: medium, medium rare, medium well, rare, well done.
Chicken Burger $10.00
Salmon Burger $8.75
Mushroom Burger $7.00

Sandwiches
Roast Beef Club Sandwich $16.00
Roast beef, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Pastrami Sandwich $10.00
Pastrami layered generously between choice of breads, including bagels, wraps, and toasts with selections from plain to whole wheat varieties.
Ham & Cheese Sandwich $10.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Turkey & Cheese Sandwich $11.00
Turkey & cheese sandwich with a variety of bread options: bagels, wraps, toast, and croissant. select from bialy, plain to whole wheat choices.
Turkey Bacon LT Sandwich $9.50
Turkey bacon with crisp lettuce and tomato, choice of bread including bagel varieties, wraps, and toasts.
Turkey Club Sandwich $16.00
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Ham Sandwich $9.00
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Tuna Salad Club Sandwich $14.00
Boiled egg, lettuce, tomato and French fries.
Roast Beef Sandwich $10.00
Roast beef swiss lettuce tomato mayo and french fries.
BLT Sandwich $8.50
most popular a staple in our restaurant
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich $18.00
Grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and French fries.
Turkey Sandwich $10.00
Turkey sandwich with choice of bread: bagels (various), wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), croissant, hero, rolls, toast (rye, white, whole wheat).
Genoa Salami Sandwich $9.00
Genoa salami sandwich with a selection of bread including bagels, wraps, toast, and more. choice options range from bialy to whole wheat varieties.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $7.00

Breakfast Griddle Originals
Pancakes $9.75
Chocolate Chip Pancakes $11.75
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs $12.25
Belgian waffle served with two eggs, choice of egg whites, over easy, over hard, medium, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up.
French Toast With 2 Eggs $12.25
French toast served with your choice of eggs: white, over easy/medium/hard, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up.
Plain French Toast $9.75
We also have old fashioned French toast available.
Plain Belgian Waffle $9.75
The ice cream is not included, only powdered sugar.
Belgian Waffle With 2 Eggs & Meat $14.25
Belgian waffle served with choice of two eggs prepared to preference, and a selection of bacon, ham, sausage varieties including beef or turkey.
Silver Dollar Pancakes $11.75
Pancakes With 2 Eggs $12.25
Pancakes served with choice of egg whites, over easy, over hard, over medium, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up.
French Toast With 2 Eggs & Meat $14.25
French toast paired with two eggs, your choice of preparation, and a selection of traditional or turkey-based meats.
Short Stack $7.25
French Toast With Meat $12.75
French toast paired with choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options.
Pancakes With Meat $12.75
Pancakes served with choice of ham, various sausages including turkey and beef, or bacon.
Pancakes With 2 Eggs & Meat $14.25
Pancakes served with two eggs, choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options. eggs prepared to preference.
Belgian Waffle With Meat $12.75
Belgian waffle, choice of bacon, ham, sausage varieties including beef and turkey options.

Breakfast Wraps
American Wrap $11.50
Bacon, egg, cheese, home fries
Mexican Wrap $12.25
Chicken, egg, cheese, jalapeño, onions, peppers
Florentine Wrap $11.50
Ham, egg, onions, peppers, olives
Low Wrap $11.75
Turkey, egg white, Swiss, onions, peppers

Breakfast Sandwiches
1 Egg With Cheese Sandwich $5.50
One egg and cheese on a choice of breads, including bagels, wraps, toast, and croissants. variety of flavors like cinnamon raisin, onion, whole wheat, and sesame seed.
Hungry Man $12.00
Only served on hero. Bacon, ham, sausage with three eggs and home fries.
1 Egg Sandwich $4.75
One egg sandwich with a choice of bread: bagels (various types including cinnamon raisin, everything, onion, sesame seed, whole wheat), wraps (plain, spinach, whole wheat), and more (bialy, croissant, hero, roll, rye toast, white toast, whole wheat toast).
1 Egg With Meat & Cheese Sandwich $8.00
Favorite.
1 Egg With Meat Sandwich $7.00
1 egg sandwich paired with choice of meat: bacon, ham, sausage varieties, or turkey options. select from 16 bread types, including bagels, wraps, and toasts.

Breakfast Wraps
Low Wrap $11.00
Turkey, egg white, Swiss, onions, peppers
Florentine Wrap $10.75
Ham, egg, onions, peppers, olives
Mexican Wrap $11.50
Chicken, egg, cheese, jalapeño, onions, peppers
American Wrap $10.75
Bacon, egg, cheese, home fries

Breakfast Platters
2 Eggs Any Style $10.00
Two eggs prepared to order: choose from egg whites, over easy, hard, medium, poached, scrambled, or sunny side up. served with a side: fries, grits, or home fries.
2 Eggs With Steak $18.00
Price can vary depending on meat chosen and add-ons
2 Eggs With Meat $11.00
Price can vary depending on meat chosen and add-ons.
2 Eggs With Fish Flounder $13.50
Two eggs, choice of preparation, paired with tender fish flounder. served with a side of french fries, grits, or home fries.

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Restroom

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Parking
Paid street parking

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Photos

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Location

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop

New York Kings County Downtown Brooklyn Willoughby Street

66 Willoughby St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Casella Bagel Coffee Shop Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 189 user reviews.

lunchcheesetake outdinerplattermorningtunaponyfood and servicearea

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Casella Bagel is a great spot for breakfast! There’s a wide variety of options, and everything I tried was fresh and tasty.The prices are very reasonable, especially considering the quality of the food.The place has a friendly and relaxed atmosphere, perfect for starting the day on a good note.Highly recommended if you’re looking for a solid, satisfying breakfast without breaking the bank!
July 09 · Pietro Alfano
Nice little coffee shop. Food is made fresh to order, they have a lot of breakfast options and sandwiches. Staff is friendly and the service is quick.
April 06 · H L
Get the cheese empanadas, they make them fresh and they’re so good. Crunchy and lots of cheeeese
May 09 · Michie Aranguren
I got FLEECED by them towards the end of their day because they didnt make their sales goal and they think Ive never been to a Dominican spot before.Charged me $26 for two large rice and beans and maduros. No one ever, especially in this dingy hole in the wall, ever charged this amount for JUST rice and beans.I heard the chef tell the hostess they need to make more maduros, which they didnt; instead of selling me one, they just put what they had in 2 containers and charged it as 2 orders. The photo is simply not $5 each of maduros. Pretended not to hear me when I told them I just want sides.The hostess called it a "veggie platter", which, frankly, is not a thing here.
January 15 · Jennifer Cheng
Visited this place based on reviews and glad I did. The breakfast was delicious. It reminded me of diner food which I love. The staff was really sweet. I also thought the price was really reasonable as well. If I stay in this area again, I will be back!
February 21 · Brittenay Causieeetko