Catskill Bagel Co.

- 1416 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11226

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Catskill Bagel Co. stands as a local gem, offering a wide-ranging menu that goes far beyond just bagels. This establishment has cemented its place in the neighborhood as a go-to spot for everything from a quick morning bite to a hearty lunch. With a contemporary, yet welcoming vibe, the shop invites patrons to step in and enjoy a classic New York experience. From the moment you walk through the door, the aroma of freshly baked goods and brewed coffee fills the air, promising a satisfying meal. While the name pays homage to the Catskill Mountains, a source of water often credited with making New York bagels unique, the shop itself is a distinctly Brooklyn affair, serving up a diverse menu that caters to a variety of tastes and dietary needs. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, Catskill Bagel Co. provides a friendly and fast-paced environment where quality food is the top priority.

The food at Catskill Bagel Co. is a testament to its popularity. The bagels themselves are notably large and exceptionally airy, with a texture that compresses nicely with each bite. They are known for a crackly, chewy exterior and are often praised for their generous, one-sided application of toppings, particularly the garlic and onion, which are complemented by a perfect ratio of salt crystals. This attention to detail extends to their cream cheese, which is served cool, silky smooth, and rich. Beyond the bagels, the menu is impressively extensive, featuring a full range of breakfast and lunch items. Regulars rave about the Cortelyou Lox sandwich, a delicious combination of homemade lox, cream cheese, capers, minced red onion, tomato, and lemon. The all-day breakfast menu is a major draw, offering everything from classic bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches to fluffy pancakes and omelettes. For lunch, the options are seemingly endless, including a variety of homemade salad sandwiches, hot sandwiches like the Reuben, and a selection of hero sandwiches named after iconic Brooklyn bridges.

Beyond the main courses, Catskill Bagel Co. also provides a selection of fresh-made juices, smoothies, and a full coffee bar, with both hot and iced options. The bakery counter is a treat, with offerings like Grandma's Muffins, rainbow cookies, and sea salt brownies. While some online reviews note occasional inconsistencies with delivery orders, such as forgotten items or food arriving cold, many customers consistently praise the food's delicious flavor and the overall value for the price. The staff is often described as friendly and efficient, especially for in-person visits, which tend to be popular and can get busy during peak hours. The commitment to providing fresh, well-portioned food makes Catskill Bagel Co. a reliable choice for locals looking for a classic deli and bagel shop experience.

Catskill Bagel Co. is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a fixture in the community. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, with indoor and outdoor seating available for those who want to take their time. While it can get busy during the morning rush, there is usually seating available later in the day, making it a comfortable spot for a casual breakfast or lunch. The establishment is also known for being kid-friendly, with many customers noting how much the children they bring enjoy the food. The wide array of vegetarian options and the staff's willingness to accommodate dietary restrictions make it a welcoming place for everyone.

Whether you are craving a traditional bagel with a schmear, a hearty breakfast platter, a flavorful deli sandwich, or a fresh smoothie, Catskill Bagel Co. has something to satisfy your appetite. The variety and quality of the food, combined with a friendly and efficient service model, contribute to its strong reputation in the area. While delivery experiences can sometimes vary, the general consensus among customers is that the food is worth it, and the in-store experience is consistently positive.

Location and Accessibility

Catskill Bagel Co. is conveniently located at 1416 Cortelyou Rd in Brooklyn, NY. The shop is situated in a vibrant neighborhood, and its inviting facade with tile floors and warm lighting makes it a pleasant place to visit. For those traveling by car, there is plenty of street parking available nearby, though it is not a dedicated lot. The establishment is wheelchair accessible, ensuring that all customers can easily enter and enjoy their meal. As for getting there, it is a well-known spot in the area and is easily reachable for locals.

Services Offered

• Delivery: Catskill Bagel Co. offers delivery services, reaching up to 5 miles from its location. Orders can be placed through third-party platforms or directly through the company's website.
• In-store Pickup and Takeout: Customers can place orders for in-store pickup, which is a popular and often faster option, especially during busy hours.
• Dine-in: The establishment offers both indoor and outdoor seating, providing a comfortable space for guests to enjoy their meals.
• Catering: The shop provides catering services, making it a great option for events and gatherings.
• Payment Options: They accept a variety of payment methods including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a seamless transaction process.

Features / Highlights

• Extensive Menu: Catskill Bagel Co. boasts a comprehensive menu with a wide variety of options for all-day breakfast, lunch, and snacks, including an impressive selection of sandwiches, wraps, salads, and more.
• Fresh Bagels and Cream Cheese: The bagels are large and known for their airy, chewy texture and dense toppings. The cream cheese is described as silky smooth and rich.
• Fresh Juices and Smoothies: In addition to coffee and tea, the shop offers a variety of fresh-squeezed vegetable and fruit juices, as well as refreshing smoothies.
• Vegetarian and Dietary Accommodations: The menu includes many vegetarian options, and the staff is generally accommodating to specific dietary restrictions, making it a flexible choice for various diets.
• Casual and Welcoming Atmosphere: The store features a contemporary and chic design with a tile floor and warm lighting, creating a comfortable and inviting environment for customers.

Contact Information

Address: 1416 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA

Phone: (718) 282-5049

What is worth choosing

When you visit Catskill Bagel Co., you'll be greeted with a menu that offers a variety of compelling choices, making it easy to find something you'll love. The standout item that many locals recommend is the classic bagel with cream cheese. The bagels are celebrated for their size and texture, providing a perfect foundation for a simple yet delicious breakfast. The cream cheese is equally praised for its rich and smooth consistency.

For those with a bigger appetite, the "Cortelyou Lox" on a toasted everything bagel is a top choice. It's a flavorful combination of homemade lox, cream cheese, capers, and fresh vegetables that makes for a satisfying and authentic New York experience. Another popular option is the "Bacon, Egg and Cheese," which is a quintessential breakfast sandwich that delivers a hearty and classic taste.

Beyond the breakfast fare, the sandwich menu is worth exploring. The "Brooklyn Bridge" and "Verrazano Bridge" sandwiches are notable options, named after local landmarks, they offer a taste of the neighborhood. The "Reuben Sandwich" is also a fan favorite, made with sliced pastrami, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese on rye. For a lighter but equally flavorful meal, the "Homemade Salad Sandwiches," such as the fresh lox or chicken salad, are excellent.

If you're looking for a refreshing drink, the "Nitro Organic Cold Brew" is a unique offering, and the variety of fresh juices and smoothies, like the "Pineapple and Banana Smoothie" or the "Carrot and Apple Juice," are great for a healthy boost. Finally, don't forget to check out the bakery counter. The crumb cake and various muffins and cookies provide a perfect ending to any meal.

While the menu offers many choices, the best experience often comes from sticking to what the shop does best: fresh bagels and hearty breakfast and deli sandwiches. The friendly service and efficient kitchen make it a reliable spot for a quick and delicious meal on the go, or a leisurely stop to enjoy the neighborhood atmosphere.

Catskill Bagel Co.

1416 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA