Charlie's Sandwich Shop

- 9216 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209

## Charlie's Sandwich Shop: Home of the Authentic New York Italian Hero in Bay Ridge

In a city where quality and authenticity matter above all else, **Charlie's Sandwich Shop** stands out as a true culinary champion in the bustling Bay Ridge neighborhood of Brooklyn. For New Yorkers searching for the quintessential, loaded, and absolutely delicious Italian-style hero or sandwich, Charlie's is often the first—and last—stop. This is not just a place to grab lunch; it’s an experience built on fresh, quality ingredients, generous portions, and the kind of warm, personal hospitality that makes a local spot feel like home.

Charlie's has garnered a dedicated following, thanks to its commitment to excellence, often being hailed as a "sandwich king" that specializes in one thing—sandwiches—and executes it perfectly. Whether you’re a long-time resident or just visiting the borough for the weekend, the promise of an authentic New York Italian sandwich is more than fulfilled here. Customers consistently rave about the **freshness** of the ingredients, the perfect "nice crunch and softness style" of the bread, and the overwhelming flavor profiles of their signature creations. It's the kind of spot where you can taste the care and "love" put into every single item, from the custom balsamic mayo to the toasted, crispy bread.

This establishment has successfully captured the spirit of a classic New York deli with an Italian focus, offering a menu that includes everything from classic Chicken Parmigiana subs to inventive specials that keep the local crowd coming back for more. If you're looking for hearty portions and a friendly face to guide you through their extensive menu of numbered and named heroes, look no further than Charlie's Sandwich Shop on 3rd Avenue.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Charlie's Sandwich Shop is perfectly situated in the heart of one of Brooklyn’s most cherished neighborhoods. You can find this essential New York eatery at: **9216 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA**.

Located on 3rd Avenue, a major commercial thoroughfare in Bay Ridge, the shop is easily accessible whether you are walking from a nearby residence, arriving via public transportation, or driving in. The central location makes it a convenient stop for a quick lunch, a catered office meal, or a planned visit to try one of their famous heroes.

As a key component of the local business community, Charlie's operates primarily as a grab-and-go sandwich destination, specializing in takeout and delivery to serve the busy pace of New York life. While specific details on in-store physical accessibility for mobility aids are not widely advertised for this type of smaller establishment, the service model is designed for maximum convenience, allowing seamless ordering and pick-up. Customers should also note that some patrons have mentioned the shop may be a **Cash Only Place** (though they have been known to offer an ATM on site), which is useful information to know before you go.

---

## Services Offered

Charlie's Sandwich Shop focuses on efficiently delivering a top-tier product to its customers, offering several tailored service options to meet the needs of the Bay Ridge community and beyond.

• **Takeout/Pick-up:** As a classic sandwich spot, fast and friendly in-store pick-up is a core service.
• **Delivery:** The shop partners with major delivery platforms, ensuring that their delicious sandwiches can be delivered right to your door in the New York area.
• **Menu Variety:** Offers a massive selection of **Charlie's Special Sandwiches**, a **Build Your Own Sandwich** option for full customization, and frequently updated **Daily Specials** (such as BBQ Meatballs on Monday or Chicken Francese on Saturday).
• **Catering:** While not explicitly listed as a service type, the volume and size of their menu, alongside their reputation for hearty, high-quality food, makes them an excellent candidate for local catering needs, especially for groups and office lunches.
• **Sides and Extras:** Complements the main offerings with essential sides like **Homemade Potato Salad**, **Macaroni Salad**, **Coleslaw**, and classic Italian sides like **Rice Balls** and **Potato Croquettes**.

---

## Features / Highlights

What sets Charlie's Sandwich Shop apart and makes it a must-visit destination in Brooklyn are several distinct features that guarantee a stellar New York deli experience.

• **Legendary Menu Items:** Home to signature sandwiches like **The #7 "The Che Si Dici"** (Prosciutto di Parma, Sweet Soppressata, Imported Provolone, Sun-dried Tomato, Oil Balsamic) which is highly recommended by Charlie himself, and the **#1 Giant Special** (Ham, Fresh Mozzarella, Fried Eggplant, Balsamic Mayo). Other fan favorites include the **Meatball Sub** (a perfect 10/10 according to reviewers) and the **Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich**.
• **Commitment to Freshness and Quality:** Diners consistently praise the use of **Fresh Mozzarella**, quality Italian meats (like Prosciutto di Parma and Soppressata), and the perfect bread, which is often described as crispy, toasted, and ideal for a hero.
• **Exceptional Hospitality:** The owner, Charlie, is frequently highlighted for his **wonderful hospitality** and being a "great human being." This personal touch is a major draw for customers who appreciate a friendly, welcoming atmosphere.
• **Generous Portions:** The sandwiches are notoriously **huge** and **hearty**, offering excellent value and ensuring that patrons "definitely leave full."
• **Unique Daily Specials:** Their rotating **Daily Specials** (like the Thursday Special with Homemade Roast Beef, Melted Fresh Mozzarella, Caramelized Onions, and Gravy) keep the menu exciting and offer a delightful twist on classic Italian flavors.
• **Signature Flavor Additions:** Customers rave about the **Balsamic Mayo**, which adds a unique and delicious kick to their sandwiches.

---

## Contact Information

Ready to try the best sandwich in Bay Ridge? Here is how you can reach Charlie's Sandwich Shop:

Address: 9216 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Phone: (718) 833-3099

Mobile Phone: +1 718-833-3099

---

## What is Worth Choosing

For New Yorkers who appreciate a classic deli experience focused entirely on crafting the best possible sandwich, Charlie's Sandwich Shop is unequivocally worth choosing. It represents the gold standard of the authentic New York Italian hero—a hearty, flavorful, and expertly constructed meal.

What makes it essential for locals is the combination of **menu depth and ingredient quality**. Whether you are in the mood for the popular **#7, The Che Si Dici**, a perfect blend of high-end cured meats and fresh mozzarella, or the fan-favorite **#1, Giant Special**, the experience is consistent: delicious and very fresh. The perfectly crusty yet soft bread ensures every bite is structurally sound and texturally satisfying. Moreover, the dedication to homemade items, such as their **Homemade Roast Beef** and delicious **Potato Salad**, pushes their offerings well beyond standard deli fare.

Ultimately, choosing Charlie's is choosing a **personal, high-quality, and reliable** local business. The outstanding customer service provided by Charlie himself—who is known for his great recommendations and hospitality—transforms a simple transaction into a truly pleasant neighborhood interaction. In a city full of options, Charlie’s provides a specialized, passion-driven product that keeps customers not only satisfied but eager to return. If you are in Brooklyn, particularly Bay Ridge, and craving an authentic, generous, and fresh Italian hero, Charlie's is the undisputed destination.

Charlie's Sandwich Shop

9216 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA