Charlotte’s Desserts

- 294 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Charlotte’s Desserts is more than just a typical ice cream shop; it is a beloved local fixture on Long Island, offering a delightful experience for sweet-toothed residents and visitors in the New York region. Located in the heart of Farmingdale, New York, this establishment has built a stellar reputation for providing a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere paired with a wide array of high-quality frozen treats and desserts. It's a true community hub where patrons can enjoy everything from classic soft-serve to gourmet frozen yogurt and even specialty coffee drinks.

Since opening its doors, Charlotte’s Desserts—originally branded as Charlotte's Frozen Yogurt—has become synonymous with quality and variety. The shop goes the extra mile to cater to various dietary needs, ensuring that almost everyone can find a delicious treat, with options including peanut-free, dairy-free, low-fat, and no-fat choices clearly marked and available. This commitment to inclusivity, combined with a focus on fresh, exciting flavors and creative dessert combinations, has solidified its status as a must-visit destination in Farmingdale Village.

The shop's high standing is consistently reflected in customer feedback, which frequently highlights the quality of the products, the extensive selection of toppings, and the friendly service. The overall experience is designed to be joyful and memorable, making it an ideal spot for an afternoon pick-me-up, an after-dinner dessert run, or celebrating special occasions. For local New Yorkers looking for a reliable, top-rated spot for frozen desserts, Charlotte's Desserts provides an experience that is both comforting and exciting.

Furthermore, what truly sets Charlotte’s Desserts apart is its unique dual identity. While it operates as a vibrant, sunny dessert cafe by day, the location harbors a fascinating secret: Charlotte's Speakeasy, a meticulously restored 1920s-era bar hidden beneath the shop. Accessing the speakeasy requires walking past the colorful yogurt handles to a hidden entrance behind a bookcase, adding a layer of mystery and historic charm to the entire establishment. This fusion of a contemporary dessert shop with a clandestine, Prohibition-era bar offers a compelling and distinctive local experience that draws people in for both their sweet cravings and a night of unique entertainment.

The commitment to excellence and community engagement is a key part of the business philosophy. The ownership, brothers Nick and John DeVito, aimed to create a homey atmosphere, and they have successfully cultivated a space that feels personal and inviting. This local ownership and focus contribute significantly to the friendly and approachable tone of the business, making it a place where customers feel like regulars from their very first visit.

Charlotte’s Desserts is conveniently situated at the bustling heart of Farmingdale Village, a vibrant and historic section of Long Island, New York. Its precise address is 294 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735. This prime Main Street location places it directly within easy reach for residents of Farmingdale and surrounding Long Island towns, as well as commuters utilizing the nearby transportation links.

The shop is positioned on a flat, well-maintained sidewalk area, offering good physical accessibility. While the shop itself is street-level, parking in the downtown Farmingdale area is typically found on the street or within nearby municipal parking lots, which are generally located within a block or two of the shop. This central location makes it an easy stop whether you are driving, walking, or utilizing public transportation within the Long Island area. The main entrance, a set of street-level double doors, provides a smooth entry point for all patrons.

Charlotte’s Desserts offers a comprehensive range of frozen treats, beverages, and other services to satisfy any craving. The offerings go beyond simple ice cream to include a rich variety of custom creations.

• Soft Serve Frozen Yogurt: Featuring a rotating selection of fifteen different healthy and delicious flavors, including nonfat, no sugar added, and nondairy options.
• Self-Serve Topping Bar: An extensive selection of toppings, allowing customers to customize their frozen yogurt or ice cream creations.
• Soft Serve Ice Cream: Offering three classic, premium flavors of soft-serve ice cream.
• Sadutto Hand-Packed Ice Cream: A premium, hard-scooped ice cream option available by the scoop.
• Milkshakes and Floats: Classic dessert beverages like milkshakes, Root Beer Floats, and Dr Pepper Floats.
• Full Coffee Bar: Serving a variety of hot and cold imported coffee drinks, including regular coffee, espresso, cappuccino, lattes, and iced coffee, as well as frappes.
• Other Cold Drinks: Including iced tea, soda, bottled water, and lemon ade.
• Dessert Treats: A selection of other sweet treats like candies and cookies, often available for combining with frozen yogurt or ice cream.
• Delivery and Pickup: Services available through major third-party delivery platforms for convenient at-home enjoyment.
• Birthday Party Packages: Offering comprehensive packages that include pizza, frozen yogurt, and entertainment for a stress-free celebration.

The appeal of Charlotte’s Desserts extends beyond its menu through several unique features and highlights that enhance the customer experience.

• High-Rated Customer Experience: Consistent five-star reviews from customers attest to the delicious products, cleanliness, and exceptional service.
• Unique Dual Concept: The location houses the daytime dessert shop and Charlotte's Speakeasy, a hidden, fully restored 1920s Prohibition-era bar accessible through a secret entrance (a bookcase). This provides a compelling reason for adults to visit in the evening.
• Dietary Inclusion: A notable effort to provide options for restricted diets, including peanut-free, dairy-free, low-fat, and no-fat frozen yogurt selections.
• High-Quality Ingredients: Commitment to using premium ingredients, as evidenced by offering Sadutto Hand-Packed Ice Cream and imported coffee from Rome.
• "18 Handles" Concept: Referring to the ten flavors of frozen yogurt and two soft serve ice cream flavors, plus six combination twist flavors, offering a total of 18 self-serve options.
• Local Community Focus: The shop operates with a friendly, homey atmosphere, fostering a strong connection with the local Farmingdale and Long Island communities.

For those located in the New York region looking to visit or inquire about services:

Address: 294 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Phone: (516) 586-8530

For New York-based dessert lovers, choosing Charlotte’s Desserts means opting for a guaranteed excellent experience. The combination of its consistently five-star-rated products, its wide-ranging menu catering to diverse tastes and dietary needs, and its friendly, local, and professional service makes it a standout choice. The shop successfully marries the classic joy of a neighborhood ice cream parlor with the sophisticated variety of a modern dessert cafe. Whether you are craving a guilt-free nonfat yogurt with fresh fruit, a rich scoop of premium Sadutto ice cream, or a perfectly crafted iced latte, Charlotte’s Desserts delivers. Moreover, the unparalleled opportunity to cap off a sweet treat with a journey into the hidden Speakeasy below provides an added, unforgettable incentive for a local night out. It’s a complete package of quality, variety, and unique local character that makes it truly worth the visit.

Charlotte’s Desserts

294 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA