Court Street Grocers

- 485 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Court Street Grocers is more than just a sandwich shop; it's a cornerstone of the Carroll Gardens neighborhood in Brooklyn and a true New York gem. Combining the quality of a gourmet grocery with the heart of a local deli, this establishment has earned a stellar reputation for its expertly crafted sandwiches, made with both regional-American flair and a commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients. For locals and visitors alike, it serves as a go-to destination for a superior comfort food experience, covering everything from a simple, satisfying breakfast to a deeply flavorful, complex lunch. This isn't your average bodega sandwich; Court Street Grocers elevates the classic hero into an art form, making it a pivotal spot in the competitive New York City food scene.

The shop's approach is defined by an updated take on deli staples, using components like house-cured meats (such as corned short rib for the Reuben) and house-made spreads, all served on carefully sourced, quality bread. The atmosphere is casual, cozy, and trendy, making it an ideal spot for solo dining or a quick bite to refuel during a busy day in the city. Whether you're craving a hearty morning meal or a substantial hero for lunch, Court Street Grocers offers a consistently great experience that keeps New Yorkers coming back for more.

Location and Accessibility

The primary location of Court Street Grocers is situated in the charming and popular Carroll Gardens neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it a convenient spot for many New York City residents.

Address: 485 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Getting to the shop is manageable, though as with many places in Brooklyn, paid street parking is the typical option if driving. The establishment is designed to be accessible to everyone, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance. This focus on accessibility, combined with a central location, makes it a welcoming and simple stop for all New Yorkers.

Contact Information

If you need to contact the shop for general inquiries or to place an order for pickup, the main line is readily available.

Phone: (833) 533-3200

For your convenience, the mobile number is also provided: +1 833-533-3200. Please note that while the shop is a great spot for takeout, its popularity often means you should plan ahead, especially during peak lunch hours.

Services Offered

Court Street Grocers operates as a multi-faceted food business, serving a number of roles within the community:

• Sandwich Shop: The core of the business, specializing in creatively constructed and elevated classic sandwiches for both lunch and all-day dining.
• Breakfast Restaurant: Offering a full menu of breakfast sandwiches and associated drinks to start your morning.
• Gourmet Grocery Store: Functioning as a grocer with a curated collection of specialty and regional-American pantry items.
• Takeout and Delivery: Services include traditional takeout, delivery, and no-contact delivery, making it easy to enjoy your food anywhere in the city.
• Dining Options: Offering indoor seating for breakfast, brunch, lunch, and a quick bite in a casual, cozy environment.
• Dessert: Sweet treats, such as the popular Chocolate Chip Cookie, are available for a perfect ending to your meal.

Features / Highlights

The shop is celebrated for several key attributes that contribute to its standing as a top-tier New York food spot:

• High-Quality Beverages: The menu is highlighted by a great coffee selection and a great tea selection, perfect for pairing with a breakfast sandwich or a lunchtime hero.
• Artisanal Ingredients: Many ingredients are house-made or carefully sourced, such as the house-corned short rib used in the Reuben or their specialty “CSG hoagie spread,” which contains a tangy mix of ingredients like olives and pickled peppers.
• Diverse Menu: The offerings successfully blend classic "comfort food" with unique, inventive creations, ensuring there’s something for every palate, including a robust vegetarian selection.
• Casual and Welcoming Atmosphere: The establishment is noted for its casual, cozy, and trendy vibe, which is also considered "Good for kids."
• Convenient Payment Options: Accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a quick and seamless transaction.
• Popularity: The shop is highly popular for breakfast, lunch, and solo dining, suggesting a consistent, high-demand product.

What is Worth Choosing

For first-timers and loyal regulars, the menu at Court Street Grocers features several standout sandwiches that have achieved near-legendary status in New York City. The expert layering of flavor and texture is what truly makes their offerings worth the elevated price point, justifying its reputation as an elevated sandwich experience in an elevated neighborhood.

For the Classics:

• The Reuben: Often cited as one of the best in NYC, this sandwich features house-corned short rib, Swiss, sauerkraut, and their unique 'comeback' sauce on quality Orwasher's rye bread. The use of corned short-rib instead of standard brisket adds a richer, fattier, and more flavorful element to this deli staple.
• Italian Combo: This is a TKO (Technical Knockout) in the world of heroes. It’s packed with mortadella and soppressata, three cheeses (Swiss, mozzarella, pecorino), arugula, white onion, mayo, and their signature 'CSG hoagie spread.' The meticulous balance of thinly-sliced cured meats, sharp cheeses, and tangy spread makes it a deeply satisfying choice.
• Pork Roll: A nod to Jersey-style breakfast, this is a must-try morning option. It features soft scrambled eggs, Taylor ham (pork roll), and American cheese on a white bun, providing a perfect and hearty start to the day.

For the Inventive and Vegetarian:

Court Street Grocers is particularly lauded for its creative vegetarian and vegetable-forward options, proving that a great hero doesn't always need meat.

• Vegitalian Combo: A brilliant meatless take on the classic combo, which one customer called a "perfect sandwich: sweet, savory, salty, tangy." It substitutes the cured meats with thinly sliced roasted sweet potato. This is then combined with Swiss, mozzarella, pecorino, arugula, white onion, mayo, and the essential 'CSG hoagie spread.'
• Ollieflower: A very popular vegetarian option, featuring roasted cauliflower, provolone, broccoli rabe, a kick of crystal hot honey, and mayo on a seeded hero. The unexpected pairing of cauliflower and hot honey creates a unique and impactful flavor profile.
• Broccoli Reuben: Another excellent meat-free spin on a classic, this sandwich uses roasted broccoli in place of corned beef, combined with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and comeback sauce on rye bread.
• Tunaberry: An incredibly unique and popular fish sandwich that combines tuna salad with horseradish mayo, white onion, cranberry apple sauce, and arugula on Sullivan Street Stecca bread. The blend of horseradish heat and cranberry sweetness makes this an unexpected crowd-pleaser.

In conclusion, Court Street Grocers consistently delivers a quality, memorable sandwich experience in Carroll Gardens. Its commitment to quality ingredients, inventive combinations, and superior execution ensures its place as a favorite New York City spot for both comforting classics and exciting new flavors.

Court Street Grocers

485 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA