Dark Horse Tavern

- 273 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Located in the heart of the bustling Farmingdale Village, Dark Horse Tavern has firmly established itself as a premier destination for locals, groups, and even tourists seeking a fun, casual, and energetic bar experience on Long Island. Functioning expertly as a Bar, a Sports Bar, a Beer Garden, and a full-service Restaurant, this venue offers a remarkable blend of quality pub fare, an exceptional beverage program, and an atmosphere geared toward camaraderie and entertainment. Since its establishment, Dark Horse Tavern has quickly become a standout spot on Main Street, known for its commitment to great food and its welcoming community spirit.

The atmosphere at Dark Horse Tavern strikes a perfect balance: it is both cozy and trendy, maintaining a distinctly casual feel that makes everyone feel at home. It’s an ideal spot for catching up with friends, enjoying a meal with family (they even have a dedicated Kids Menu), or dining solo at the bar. The extensive and creative menu ensures there's something for every craving, from signature burgers like the famous "Juicy Lucy" to diverse tacos and classic pub fare. The dedication to providing a full dining experience, including Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner services, sets Dark Horse Tavern apart from typical bars, while its impressive 28 constantly rotating craft beer draft lines solidify its reputation as a serious beer lover’s destination.

Whether you are stopping in to watch the big game on one of their 16 big-screen TVs, grabbing a quick, delicious lunch, or settling in for an evening of great cocktails and socializing, Dark Horse Tavern provides a consistently high-quality experience with fast and friendly service. It is a genuine Long Island gem that successfully caters to all aspects of the modern New York social and dining scene.

Dark Horse Tavern is conveniently situated at 273 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, making it a prominent fixture on the village's highly active downtown street. Its central Long Island location provides easy access for residents across Nassau and Suffolk counties.

The bar is committed to full accessibility for all patrons. It features a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a wheelchair accessible restroom. This commitment ensures a comfortable visit for guests with mobility needs. Furthermore, the tavern boasts a gender-neutral restroom, reflecting its inclusive and modern approach to hospitality.

For parking, the location benefits from free street parking availability, though drivers should be aware of the overall Farmingdale Village parking situation. While Dark Horse mentions free street parking, it is important to note that Main Street and nearby municipal lots in Farmingdale generally charge non-residents a meter fee (often $0.50 per hour) during evening hours (typically 5:00 p.m. to 1:00 a.m. Monday through Saturday) to help manage the popular downtown area. Guests are advised to look for free spots, utilize the large municipal parking lot located behind the Main Street businesses (which is easily accessible and often has designated accessible spots), or use the convenient "PayByPhone" app for any metered spots. The inclusion of a large parking lot in the back provides a major benefit for visitors.

Dark Horse Tavern provides a comprehensive array of dining and drinking services designed for maximum customer convenience and satisfaction:

• Full-Day Dining: The establishment serves food throughout the day, operating as a Brunch restaurant, Lunch restaurant, and providing full Dinner services. The kitchen is open every day starting at noon.
• Seating Options: Guests can enjoy both indoor and outdoor seating, with the patio area often praised for its comfort, sometimes even featuring barriers for a pleasant sidewalk experience. Indoor seating includes table service and a spacious bar area.
• Takeout and Delivery: As a Takeout Restaurant, Dark Horse ensures its delicious menu is available for those on the go, offering both direct takeout and convenient delivery services.
• Bar and Beverage Offerings: The bar features a massive and constantly changing 28 craft beer draft lines, a full selection of alcohol, hard liquor, and wine, plus excellent cocktails and popular frozen drinks like the 'Rocket Fuel' and 'Miami Vice'.
• Happy Hour Specials: Dark Horse Tavern offers a popular daily Happy hour drinks and Happy hour food, which, according to one public source, runs from 7:00 p.m. until closing, making it an excellent late-evening value spot.
• Convenient Payment: The bar accepts all modern payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and fast NFC mobile payments.
• Amenities: Patrons have access to clean restrooms, a gender-neutral restroom, and Wi-Fi.

The distinct features of Dark Horse Tavern are centered around its quality pub fare, impressive beverage list, and lively social environment:

• Exceptional Burger Menu: The tavern is famous for its creative and juicy burgers, especially the renowned "Juicy Lucy," a 10oz Sirloin patty literally stuffed with a blend of Cheddar, Pepper Jack, and American cheese, often spilling out upon the first bite. Other highlights include the French Onion Soup Burger and the Prime Steakhouse Burger.
• Extensive Pub Fare Variety: Beyond burgers, the menu includes a wide variety of excellent pub staples, such as their 20 varieties of Famous Dark Horse Wings, creative small bites like Tater Tot Nachos and Irish Nachos, and a great selection of tacos (Shrimp, Short Rib, Spicy Steak).
• Outstanding Beer Selection: With 28 constantly changing craft beer draft lines, Dark Horse Tavern is a must-visit for any New York beer enthusiast looking for variety and quality. This commitment to rotation ensures there is always something new and interesting on tap.
• Dedicated Sports Viewing: As a dedicated Sports Bar, the venue ensures you never miss a play, broadcasting your favorite games on 16 Big Screen TVs, creating an immersive, communal viewing experience.
• Social and Community Focus: The tavern is highly popular among all types of crowds—Groups, Locals, and Tourists—and is noted for its friendly staff and welcoming environment, even going the extra mile to accommodate guests with pets in its outdoor seating area.
• Live Entertainment: Dark Horse Tavern often hosts live performances, enhancing its nightlife appeal and ensuring a fun and engaging atmosphere beyond just sports.

To make a reservation, inquire about a live performance schedule, or place a takeout order, New York customers can contact Dark Horse Tavern using the information below:

Address: 273 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Phone: (516) 586-6560

Mobile Phone: +1 516-586-6560

The Dark Horse Tavern is worth choosing for Long Islanders because it excels in three critical areas: quality food, premium drinks, and a top-tier sports-watching experience. The menu is a clear differentiator; where else can you find a spectacular, cheese-stuffed "Juicy Lucy" or a high-quality Prime Steakhouse Burger alongside unique small bites like Irish Nachos and a full selection of tacos? Even when a burger is cooked slightly past a diner's preference, the flavor is still described as "awesome," a strong testament to the kitchen's quality.

Beyond the food, the bar’s extensive offering of 28 craft beer drafts and its daily happy hour specials provide exceptional value and variety for the New York beverage connoisseur. It's the perfect place to grab a cold craft beer and catch up with friends. The staff consistently receives praise for being attentive without being overbearing, a balance that makes solo dining or a visit with a large group equally comfortable. For those looking for a fully accessible, casual, and energetic spot that combines the best elements of a neighborhood bar, a serious beer garden, and a quality restaurant—all while catching the game on one of 16 screens—Dark Horse Tavern in Farmingdale stands out as a reliable and highly recommended choice in the New York region.

Dark Horse Tavern

273 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA