Five Star

- 2039 1st Ave, New York, NY 10029

In a city famous for its pizza, standing out from the crowd requires more than just a good slice—it requires a commitment to quality food and exceptional service. Five Star, a pizza restaurant located in the heart of East Harlem, seems to have mastered this combination, earning the loyalty and praise of its local patrons. This establishment is a prime example of a neighborhood spot that becomes a trusted part of the community's daily life. It’s the kind of place where, as one customer enthusiastically states, "the staff remember me and my usual orders." This personal touch is a rare and highly valued quality in a city as large and fast-paced as New York, and it speaks volumes about the kind of business Five Star is. It's a place that fosters relationships and makes every customer feel seen and appreciated. Beyond the friendly faces, the food itself is a major draw. The menu extends beyond classic pizza, offering a variety of other items that are just as well-regarded. The fact that a customer specifically mentions "Chicken Fingers, with Fries are great... My kind of fries!" shows that the restaurant takes pride in its entire menu, not just its main offering. This versatility means that Five Star is a great option for a wide range of cravings, whether you're in the mood for a classic New York slice or some comforting fried food. The focus on providing both a great product and a great experience is what truly sets Five Star apart and solidifies its reputation as a reliable and high-quality eatery. For many New Yorkers, a local pizza place is a go-to for a quick, satisfying meal, and Five Star seems to fill this role perfectly, offering both convenience and quality in equal measure.

Five Star is conveniently located at 2039 1st Ave, New York, NY 10029, a prime spot in the vibrant East Harlem neighborhood. Its address on a major thoroughfare makes it easily accessible to a large portion of the community. For those who live or work nearby, the restaurant is a short and simple walk. For those coming from farther away, its location on 1st Avenue ensures it is well-connected to public transportation, with numerous bus lines and subway stations within a manageable distance. This accessibility is a key factor in the restaurant's success, as it allows for both in-person dining and efficient delivery services. The visibility of the location on a main street also helps in attracting new customers who are passing by. The fact that it is a known and trusted spot for locals who frequent the area further enhances its standing as a neighborhood staple. In a city where time is of the essence, having a reliable and conveniently located food option like Five Star is a significant advantage. Its strategic position makes it a perfect choice for a quick lunch, a casual dinner, or a late-night delivery, serving the diverse needs of the East Harlem community at all hours.

Five Star offers a variety of services that are tailored to the needs of its New York City clientele, focusing on convenience, quality, and personalized attention.

• Dine-in and Takeout Options

  The restaurant provides a space for customers to come in and enjoy their meal. However, a major part of its business, as highlighted by customer reviews, is its efficient takeout and delivery service. The fact that "delivery is timely" and "quick" even when an order is placed "a half hour before closing" is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to speed and customer convenience. This service is crucial for a city that relies heavily on food delivery.

• Varied Food Menu

  Five Star offers more than just pizza. The menu includes popular items like "Chicken Fingers, with Fries" and other side dishes. This variety allows the restaurant to cater to different tastes and cravings, ensuring that it is a go-to spot for a variety of meals, not just pizza nights.

• Personalized Customer Service

  A key service is the friendly and personalized customer care. A customer review specifically mentions that the staff "remember me and my usual orders." This level of attention makes customers feel valued and builds a strong sense of loyalty, turning a simple transaction into a positive, personal interaction.

The features and highlights of Five Star are what truly make it a standout pizza place in a city full of options. These attributes are what turn a customer into a regular.

• Exceptional Food Quality

  The food is described as "great." Customers praise both the pizza and the non-pizza items, like the chicken fingers and fries. This consistency in quality across the menu is a significant highlight and a major reason for the restaurant's positive reputation. The photos shared by a customer further serve as a visual testament to the quality of the food.

• Personalized and Friendly Staff

  The staff's ability to remember regulars and their orders is a standout feature. This makes the experience feel much more personal and welcoming, going beyond the typical transactional nature of a quick-service restaurant. This friendliness is a key part of the "Five stars all the way" experience.

• Timely and Quick Delivery

  In a city where delivery speed is paramount, the fact that Five Star's "delivery is timely" and "quick" is a major highlight. This reliability ensures that customers can count on getting their food hot and fresh, even at a late hour, which is a significant advantage over competitors.

• Versatile Menu

  The menu's versatility is a highlight. The ability to offer both classic pizza and popular side dishes like "Chicken Fingers, with Fries" makes the restaurant a convenient and appealing option for a variety of dining occasions and group preferences.

For those in the New York City area, here is the contact information for Five Star:

• Address:

  2039 1st Ave, New York, NY 10029

• Phone:

  (212) 987-1540

What makes Five Star a place worth choosing is its winning combination of great food and outstanding service. In a city saturated with pizza joints, Five Star sets itself apart by making every customer feel valued. The staff's ability to remember regulars and their orders creates a sense of community and personal connection that is rare and highly appreciated. This friendly atmosphere, combined with the consistent quality of the food, makes for a truly reliable and enjoyable experience. The reviews highlight that the food is not just good, but "great," and that this quality extends beyond just the pizza to other menu items like the chicken fingers and fries. This means that Five Star can be your go-to spot for a variety of cravings, not just when you're in the mood for a slice. Furthermore, the efficiency of their delivery service, even during off-peak times, shows a commitment to customer satisfaction that is crucial for a New York City business. The fact that a customer would give a full five-star rating and call the experience "Five stars all the way" is the most powerful endorsement a business can receive. It speaks to a level of consistent excellence that is hard to find. For anyone in the East Harlem area looking for a reliable, high-quality, and friendly pizza place, Five Star is an excellent choice. It's a place that delivers on its promises and, in doing so, earns a loyal customer base that feels like family.

Five Star

2039 1st Ave, New York, NY 10029, USA