I Bagel Cafe Introduce
If you're a New Yorker, you know a bagel isn't just a bread product—it's a way of life. The perfect combination of a chewy interior and a crisp, well-baked crust is a culinary necessity for any local. On Long Island, and specifically in the Albertson area, I Bagel Cafe has established itself as a must-visit destination for those seeking that authentic, quality bagel experience. Serving up fresh, daily-made goods and an expansive menu that goes far beyond a simple schmear, this cafe is a true local gem. Whether you're starting your morning commute or grabbing a weekend brunch, I Bagel Cafe offers a wide variety of delicious options to satisfy your New York-sized bagel craving.
This article serves as a comprehensive guide for Long Island residents and visitors, spotlighting everything you need to know about I Bagel Cafe, from its convenient location to its extensive offerings of specialty sandwiches, smoked fish, and more. It's the ideal spot for a quick, high-quality bite, affirming its reputation as a key player in the competitive local bagel scene.
## Introduction / Overview
I Bagel Cafe is more than just a typical bagel shop; it's a dedicated local institution focused on delivering high-quality, freshly prepared food to the Albertson community and surrounding areas of Long Island. Specializing in the quintessential New York-style bagel, the cafe also boasts a creative menu that includes a variety of breakfast and lunch options, ensuring there's something for every palate and dietary preference. The atmosphere of a great bagel shop is often one of hustle and bustle, a place where people rely on quick, efficient service to get their day started right, and I Bagel Cafe certainly meets that demand.
For New York locals, the quality of the bagel itself is non-negotiable, and I Bagel Cafe works to uphold this standard. Beyond the traditional plain or everything bagel, they feature unique items like Flagels (flattened bagels), Mini Salads, and Lettuce Wraps for those looking for a different take or a lighter meal. Their commitment to variety is evident in the menu's sheer breadth, covering everything from classic spreads and deli meats to gourmet smoked fish and specialty salads. It's a fantastic spot for a morning coffee run, a hearty breakfast sandwich, or a satisfying lunch.
The menu is highly flexible, allowing customers to choose their preferred base—sandwich, mini salad, flagel, or lettuce wrap—and pair it with an incredible array of fillings. This customization ability is a major draw, especially for regular patrons who appreciate having their favorites prepared just the way they like. From basic Butter Sandwiches to indulgent Lobster Sandwiches and every type of cream cheese and smoked fish in between, I Bagel Cafe is prepared to elevate your next meal.
## Location and Accessibility
I Bagel Cafe is conveniently situated at 180 I U Willets Rd, Albertson, NY 11507, USA, placing it in a prime spot on Long Island for both local residents and those passing through. Albertson is a bustling area in Nassau County, making the cafe an accessible stop whether you are running errands, heading to or from the city, or simply looking for a nearby breakfast location. Its location on a main thoroughfare makes it easy to find and reach by car.
Accessibility is a key factor for any community-focused business, and I Bagel Cafe provides options to ensure all customers can easily access their services. According to available public information, the cafe offers important accessibility features:
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
These features demonstrate a commitment to serving the entire community. Furthermore, the cafe's services are designed for maximum convenience, fitting seamlessly into the fast-paced New York lifestyle. With service options including Delivery, In-store pickup, Takeout, and Dine-in, patrons can choose the option that best suits their day, whether they have time to linger over a coffee or need to grab and go for a quick visit.
## Services Offered
I Bagel Cafe is a full-service bagel shop that focuses on speed, quality, and variety. The main offerings are centered around their fresh bagels and wide selection of fillings and spreads, but they also provide a range of complementary services that make them a convenient stop for any meal.
- Extensive Bagel and Spreads Menu: Featuring classic bagels, Flagels, and specialty items like the Rainbow Bagel. Spreads include a vast selection of regular and low-fat cream cheeses (Plain, Vegetable, Scallion, Lox Spread) and Tofu Spreads (Plain, Vegi, Cinnamon Raisin).
- Diverse Sandwich Options: A comprehensive list of sandwiches on your choice of bagel, including classic options like the Egg Sandwich and more adventurous items such as Lobster Sandwich, various tuna salads (Plain, Vegetable, Cranberry), and multiple chicken salad options (Regular, Diet).
- Gourmet Smoked Fish: High-quality smoked fish served as sandwiches or by the quarter-pound, including Nova, Belly Lox, Sable, Baked Salmon, and Sturgeon, along with White Fish and Herring With Cream Sauce.
- Breakfast and Egg Dishes: Dedicated egg offerings, including single or double eggs (regular or egg white), and specialty breakfast sandwiches like the Bacon Egg Cheese, Lox Onion Egg, and a classic BLT.
- Alternative Base Options: For those looking for lighter options, most fillings can be served as a Mini Salad or a Lettuce Wrap, offering a low-carb alternative to the traditional bagel sandwich.
- Coffee and Beverages: A range of freshly brewed Hot Coffee, Iced Coffee, and Flavored Hot Coffee to perfectly complement any breakfast or lunch order.
- Take-Home Pints: Customers can purchase their favorite cream cheeses and salads by the Half Pound to take home, including all spreads, egg salad, tuna, chicken salad, and smoked fish salads.
## Features / Highlights
I Bagel Cafe stands out from other local eateries due to several key features that enhance the customer experience and the quality of their food. They’ve tailored their operation to meet the needs of the busy New Yorker.
- Extremely Diverse Menu and Customization: The ability to choose any filling—from a simple Plain Cream Cheese to a Chunky White Fish Salad—and have it served on a bagel, flagel, mini salad, or lettuce wrap is a huge advantage. This flexibility ensures all patrons can find a meal that fits their appetite and dietary goals.
- Specialty Smoked Fish Selection: The offering of high-end smoked fish like Sable and Sturgeon alongside Nova and Lox positions them above many standard bagel shops, catering to the true aficionado of the classic New York 'appetizing' experience.
- Comprehensive Payment Options: For maximum convenience, the cafe accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making quick transactions easy for customers on the go.
- All-Day Breakfast Focus: While offering lunch options, the core focus on fresh bagels, specialty cream cheeses, and egg dishes makes it an outstanding spot for Breakfast at any point during their operating hours, which supports a quick visit for those needing a reliable morning stop.
## Contact Information
For local customers in the Albertson and greater Long Island area, here is the essential contact information for I Bagel Cafe:
- Address: 180 I U Willets Rd, Albertson, NY 11507, USA
- Phone: (516) 747-4040
- Mobile Phone: +1 516-747-4040
## What is Worth Choosing
I Bagel Cafe is truly worth choosing for Long Islanders who prioritize fresh ingredients, extensive variety, and speed of service. The sheer depth of the menu means you can visit dozens of times and never run out of new combinations to try. For the traditionalists, the quality of their classic spreads and Plain Bagels is what brings people back. For those looking for a splurge, the specialty fish options, particularly the Sable Sandwich or Sturgeon Sandwich, offer a true taste of New York deli culture. The ability to order almost any of the fillings as a Mini Salad or a Lettuce Wrap is a significant value proposition for health-conscious diners or those watching their carb intake, without having to sacrifice flavor.
Furthermore, the convenience offered by the various service options—Delivery, In-store pickup, Takeout, and Dine-in—ensures that I Bagel Cafe is a practical choice for any schedule. The positive reviews that highlight the Great bagels + spread confirm that the core product is excellent and a reliable option for the community. The cafe’s efficient setup and accessibility features make it a dependable and welcoming stop for a quick, delicious, and authentically New York meal in Albertson, Long Island.
I Bagel Cafe Bagel
Sandwich
- Butter Sandwich $3.66
- Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich $4.66
- Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich $6.32
- Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich $6.32
- Lox Spread Sandwich $7.98
- Low Fat Plain Sandwich $4.66
- Low Fat Vegi Sandwich $6.32
- Low Fat Nova Scallion Sandwich $7.98
- Plain Tofu Sandwich $4.66
- Vegi Tofu Sandwich $6.32
- Cinnamon Raisin Tofu Sandwich $6.32
- Egg Sandwich $9.65
- Moe Sandwich $11.64
- Egg White Salad Sandwich $12.97
- Lobster Sandwich $15.96
- Plain Tuna Sandwich $10.64
- Vegetable Tuna Sandwich $10.64
- Cranberry Tuna Sandwich $10.64
- Smooth White Fish Sandwich $13.30
- Chunky White Fish Sandwich $13.30
- Baked Salmon Sandwich $13.30
- Poached Salmon Sandwich $13.30
- Regular Chicken Sandwich $10.64
- Diet Chicken Sandwich $10.64
Mini Salad
- Mini Butter Salad $2.99
- Mini Plain Cream Cheese Salad $4.66
- Mini Vegetable Cream Cheese Salad $6.32
- Mini Scallion Cream Cheese Salad $6.32
- Mini Lox Spread Salad $7.98
- Mini Low Fat Plain Salad $4.66
- Mini Low Fat Vegi Salad $6.32
- Mini Fat Nova Scallion Salad $7.98
- Mini Plain Tofu Salad $4.66
- Mini Vegi Tofu Salad $6.32
- Mini Cinnamon Raisin Tofu Salad $6.32
- Mini Egg Salad $9.65
- Mini Moe Salad $11.64
- Mini Egg White Salad $11.97
- Mini Lobster Salad $15.96
- Mini Plain Tuna Salad $10.64
- Mini Vegetable Tuna Salad $10.64
- Mini Cranberry Tuna Salad $10.64
- Mini Smooth White Fish Salad $13.30
- Mini Chunky White Fish Salad $13.30
- Mini Baked Salmon Salad $13.30
- Mini Poached Salmon Salad $13.30
- Mini Regular Chicken Salad $10.64
- Mini Diet Chicken Salad $10.64
Flagel
- Butter Flagel $4.66
- Plain Cream Cheese Flagel $6.32
- Vegetable Cream Cheese Flagel $7.65
- Scallion Cream Cheese Flagel $7.65
- Lox Spread Flagel $9.31
- Low Fat Plain Flagel $5.99
- Low Fat Vegi Flagel $7.65
- Low Fat Nova Scallion Flagel $9.31
- Plain Tofu Flagel $6.32
- Vegi Tofu Flagel $7.65
- Cinnamon Raisin Tofu Flagel $7.65
- Egg Flagel $11.64
- Moe Flagel $13.64
- Egg White Flagel $14.97
- Lobster Flagel $17.96
- Plain Tuna Flagel $12.64
- Vegetable Tuna Flagel $12.64
- Cranberry Tuna Flagel $12.64
- Smooth White Fish Flagel $15.30
- Chunky White Fish Flagel $15.30
- Baked Salmon Flagel $15.30
- Poached Salmon Flagel $15.30
- Regular Chicken Flagel $12.64
- Diet Chicken Flagel $12.64
Lettuce Wrap
- Butter Lettuce Wrap $4.66
- Plain Cream Cheese Lettuce Wrap $6.32
- Vegetable Cream Cheese Lettuce Wrap $7.65
- Scallion Cream Cheese Lettuce Wrap $7.65
- Lox Spread Lettuce Wrap $9.31
- Low Fat Plain Lettuce Wrap $5.99
- Low Fat Vegi Lettuce Wrap $7.65
- Low Fat Nova Scallion Lettuce Wrap $9.31
- Plain Tofu Lettuce Wrap $6.32
- Vegi Tofu Lettuce Wrap $7.65
- Cinnamon Raisin Tofu Lettuce Wrap $7.65
- Egg Lettuce Wrap $10.64
- Moe Lettuce Wrap $12.64
- Egg White Lettuce Wrap $13.97
- Lobster Lettuce Wrap $17.96
- Plain Tuna Lettuce Wrap $12.64
- Vegetable Tuna Lettuce Wrap $12.64
- Cranberry Tuna Lettuce Wrap $12.64
- Smooth White Fish Lettuce Wrap $15.30
- Chunky White Fish Lettuce Wrap $15.30
- Baked Salmon Lettuce Wrap $15.30
- Poached Salmon Lettuce Wrap $15.30
- Regular Chicken Lettuce Wrap $12.64
- Diet Chicken Lettuce Wrap $12.64
Pound
- 1/2 Lb. Butter $9.98
- 1/2 Lb. Plain Cream Cheese $8.65
- 1/2 Lb. Vegetable Cream Cheese $9.98
- 1/2 Lb. Scallion Cream Cheese $9.98
- 1/2 Lb. Lox Spread $10.64
- 1/2 Lb. Low Fat Plain $8.65
- 1/2 Lb. Low Fat Vegi $9.98
- 1/2 Lb. Low Fat Nova Scallion $10.64
- 1/2 Lb. Plain Tofu $8.65
- 1/2 Lb. Vegi Tofu $9.98
- 1/2 Lb. Cinnamon Raisin Tofu $9.98
- 1/2 Lb. Egg $11.98
- 1/2 Lb. Moe $14.64
- 1/2 Lb. Egg White $15.97
- 1/2 Lb. Lobster $20.62
- 1/2 Lb. Plain Tuna $12.64
- 1/2 Lb. Vegetable Tuna $12.64
- 1/2 Lb. Cranberry Tuna $12.64
- 1/2 Lb. Smooth White Fish $15.30
- 1/2 Lb. Chunky White Fish $15.30
- 1/2 Lb. Baked Salmon $15.30
- 1/2 Lb. Poached Salmon $15.30
- 1/2 Lb. Regular Chicken $12.64
Entrees
- Bagels $2.66
- Mini Bagel $2.00
- Flagels $3.33
- Whole Wheat Bagel $2.66
- Rainbow Bagel $3.99
Smoked Fish Sandwich
- Nova Sandwich $19.95
- Belly Lox Sandwich $19.95
- Sable Sandwich $19.95
- Baked Salmon Sandwich $19.95
- Stugeon Sandwich $31.92
1/4 lb. Smoked Fish
- 1/4 Lb. Nova $18.62
- 1/4 Lb. Belly Lox $18.62
- 1/4 Lb. Sable $18.62
- 1/4 Lb. Baked Salmon $18.62
- 1/4 Lb. Sturgeon $30.59
- 1/4 Lb. White Fish $11.97
- 1 Piece Herring With Cream Sauce $10.64
Eggs
- 1 Egg $5.32
- 2 Eggs $5.99
- 1 Egg White $5.66
- 2 Egg White $6.65
- Bacon Egg Cheese $8.98
- Lox Onion Egg $20.95
- BLT $9.31
Coffee
- Iced Coffee
- Hot Coffee
- Flavored Hot Coffee
Open Face
- Open Face With Cream Cheese $1.33
- Open Face With Salad $2.00
- Open Face With Fish $2.66
I Bagel Cafe Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
I Bagel Cafe Photos










I Bagel Cafe Location
I Bagel Cafe
180 I U Willets Rd, Albertson, NY 11507, USA
I Bagel Cafe Reviews
pricecream cheesesaladsiced coffeespreadsloxlobstercaramelturkeytakeaway
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I ordered garlic bagel, scallion cream cheese with lox and a egg and cheese wrap, one caramel iced coffee and one regular. Judging by how busy this place was, I knew my order was going to get messed up. The lady had to ask me to repeat myself 3 times to the point where I removed my mask to slowly repeat. Somehow they still messed my order up. No scallion cream cheese, and instead of regular they gave me French vanilla. The coffee tastes like milk with ice, not even sweet. The wrap tasted very stale, turkey doesn’t even look like turkey. My total came out to $30. I’m not going here again.
August 16 · A ShafiGreat bagels + spread, love going here. My wife loves the flavored iced coffee, it's a little too sweet for me so I get mine unflavored.
December 30 · AW HubbardVery welcoming. Delicious food. Their tuna, salmon spread, and white fish salads are amazing! Definitely will go back
March 14 · Milana SadykovaCame here for the first timeLoves loved it i rarely write reviews but this place deserved it got sausage egg and cheese on a ww toast and hazelnut ice coffee and it was delish I wish I lived closer 😋
March 03 · Jennifer HwangI used to go regularly. On my last takeout order they gave me tofu cream cheese instead of regular. No big deal. We used butter and I tried to return the container marked tofu cream cheese. They refused to refund the $7. At first they claimed that the tofu was the same price, and then said they don't carry tofu cream cheese even though the package said it was. I left the container and walked out,NEVER to return. They were more considered about $7 and being right than taking care of a customer. No problem as I now go to Bagel Boss,
May 28 · Fred Adler
More restaurants near me

607 Willis Ave, Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

597 Willis Ave, Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

579 Willis Ave, Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

541 Willis Ave, Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

60 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

66 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

66 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

66 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

66 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

66 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

74 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

72 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts





