I Love NY Pizza

- 1739 E 172nd St, Bronx, NY 10472

If you're in the Bronx and craving a taste of classic New York-style pizza and hearty Italian American comfort food, look no further than I Love NY Pizza. Located on East 172nd Street, this local establishment is a well-known stop for residents seeking a quick, satisfying meal for lunch or dinner. It's a quintessential Bronx pizza joint that offers far more than just your average slice, providing an extensive menu designed to satisfy nearly any Italian-food craving, from gourmet pies to loaded hot heroes and full pasta entrees.

I Love NY Pizza operates as a straightforward and casual dining spot, focusing on providing delicious, high-volume comfort food with efficiency. They have cemented their role in the neighborhood as a reliable place for a quick bite or a family catering order. Whether you are grabbing a quick lunch, ordering a pie for dinner, or catering an event, this pizza restaurant is dedicated to serving the local New York community.

The core of the business is its dedication to pizza, with a broad selection of pies including classics, white pizzas, and specialty options like Lasagna Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza. However, the menu's true depth lies in its variety, extending into calzones, strombolis, gyros, burgers, and numerous baked pasta dishes, ensuring there is a comforting meal for everyone, no matter their preference.

It is worth noting that while I Love NY Pizza aims to please with its vast offerings, some customer reviews indicate inconsistencies in food quality, specifically regarding the condition of items like garlic knots and the presentation of certain pizzas. The establishment does, however, receive praise for its speedy service and, in one instance, a willingness to quickly correct order errors, suggesting a commitment to customer service and satisfaction.

The vast menu is a strong point for the restaurant, giving patrons the flexibility to choose between a simple slice of cheese pizza, a full Chicken Parmigiana dinner with pasta, or a savory Lamb Gyro. This variety makes it a great spot for groups with differing tastes, catering to both traditionalists and those looking for unique pizza creations.

In the competitive New York pizza landscape, I Love NY Pizza positions itself as the local, all-inclusive, Italian-American comfort food destination, ready to serve the community in the Bronx with speed and convenience.

***

Location and Accessibility

I Love NY Pizza is conveniently situated in the Bronx, serving the local community with ease. Its physical location is an accessible spot for both neighborhood patrons and those passing through the area, with practical options for receiving your order.

The specific address is: 1739 E 172nd St, Bronx, NY 10472, USA. This placement in the Bronx makes it a regular hub for daily meals, and its dedication to multiple service options ensures accessibility regardless of how you prefer to dine. The premises are set up to accommodate a broad customer base, including specific accessibility features to ensure a comfortable experience for all.

In terms of accessibility for dining, the restaurant proudly offers a wheelchair accessible entrance, making it welcoming for all members of the community to come and enjoy a meal.

***

Services Offered

I Love NY Pizza excels in providing a multitude of convenient services, focusing on flexibility and ease for all customers. Their operational model prioritizes getting you your food quickly and in the manner that best suits your busy New York lifestyle. The key services available include:

• Dine-in: Customers can enjoy their meal in a casual atmosphere directly at the restaurant.
• Delivery: A primary service, allowing local patrons to receive hot food right to their door.
• No-contact Delivery: An option provided for customers preferring a minimal-contact transaction.
• Takeout: Orders can be picked up quickly by customers for enjoyment at another location.
• Curbside Pickup: An added convenience for quick, in-and-out collection of orders.
• Lunch Service: Open and popular for mid-day meals.
• Dinner Service: Available for evening meals, catering to families and individuals.
• Catering: Large-scale orders are offered to accommodate parties, meetings, and events.

***

Features / Highlights

The establishment's reputation in the Bronx is built on several customer-focused highlights and a broad menu that caters to diverse tastes, making it a reliable choice in the neighborhood.

• Fast Service: The business is highlighted for its quick turnaround time, perfect for a speedy meal on a lunch break or a late-night craving.
• Gourmet and Specialty Pizzas: The menu features a wide array of options beyond the classic cheese, including the popular Margarita Pizza, Lasagna Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and a Veggie Delight Pizza.
• Comfort Food Selection: A deep menu featuring all the Italian-American staples New Yorkers love, from baked pasta dishes like Homemade Baked Ziti and Eggplant Parmigiana to Gyros and Hot Sub Sandwiches.
• Late-Night Food Options: Positioned to serve those in need of a quick bite outside of regular dining hours.
• Casual Atmosphere: The dining environment is relaxed and unpretentious, suitable for everyday meals.
• Good for Kids: The menu selection and atmosphere are appropriate and welcoming for children.
• Diverse Payment Methods: Accepts both credit cards and debit cards for easy transactions.
• Appetizer and Side Staples: Offers classic sides like French Fries, Onion Rings, and the always-popular Garlic Knots.

***

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about catering, or find the location:

Address: 1739 E 172nd St, Bronx, NY 10472, USA

Phone: (718) 860-3446

***

What Is Worth Choosing

While the menu at I Love NY Pizza is expansive, offering nearly every Italian-American and comfort food item imaginable, there are distinct categories that truly showcase the restaurant's range and what makes it a local fixture in the Bronx.

For pizza enthusiasts, the specialty pies stand out. The Margarita Pizza, with its plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh mozzarella, and basil, is a perennial favorite and often listed as a "Best Seller." For those looking for something truly unique, the Lasagna Pizza—featuring tomato sauce, ricotta cheese, beef, and mozzarella—offers a marriage of two classic comfort dishes on a single crust. Another top pick for a hearty slice is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, combining chicken cutlets and ranch dressing in a zesty buffalo sauce.

Beyond pizza, the extensive pasta menu provides exceptional value and comforting portions. A must-try in this section includes the Homemade Baked Ziti, a New York Italian staple. The fully baked pasta dishes, such as Chicken Parmigiana With Pasta or Eggplant Parmigiana With Pasta, are perfect for a satisfying dinner. For something creamier, the Fettuccine Alfredo With Chicken is a rich, flavorful choice. The variety is truly comprehensive, from simple Spaghetti Or Ziti Marinara to specialties like Penne Al Vodka and Homemade Meat Lasagna.

For a quick, non-pizza bite, the Calzones and Hot Sub Sandwiches offer filling options. The calzones come stuffed with classic fillings like Spinach, Meatball, and Pepperoni. Among the hot heroes, the traditional Chicken Parmigiana Hero and Meatball Parmigiana Hero are always reliable choices, while the Steak & Cheese Sub provides a delicious alternative to Italian fillings. Their Chicken Gyro or Lamb Gyro also provides a quick, savory meal for a change of pace.

And, of course, no order is complete without a side of their famous Garlic Knots (often praised as crispy by customers) or a classic New York treat like the NY Cheesecake or a Cannoli for dessert.

I Love NY Pizza is truly a local treasure in the Bronx, providing a robust menu and quick service that makes it an easy choice for any meal. The sheer volume and variety of their Italian and comfort food selections mean repeat customers can always find something new and satisfying to order.

I Love NY Pizza

1739 E 172nd St, Bronx, NY 10472, USA