Lucy's Pizza

- 26 S Highland Ave a, Ossining, NY 10562

For residents of Westchester County, and particularly the Ossining area, Lucy's Pizza is far more than just another restaurant—it's a genuine local institution. Known for serving up classic New York-style pizza and a wide-ranging menu of Italian-American favorites, this establishment has cemented its place as a community staple. Having been a fixture in Ossining since 1989, Lucy's has deep roots, with current owners Tony Arpaia and Tony Castellano having taken the reins that year. The restaurant's history includes overcoming a major fire in 2003 and successfully reopening in 2007, demonstrating an enduring commitment to the community it serves. Its prime location across the street from Ossining High School has made it a rite of passage for generations of local students, creating a vibrant, energetic atmosphere that blends the historic with the everyday.

The core appeal of Lucy's lies in its commitment to simple, quality ingredients and a welcoming, casual, cozy, and historic atmosphere. It’s a place where families gather, students grab a quick bite, and local tourists can get a true taste of Westchester dining. From the perfectly crispy, zero-flop pizza praised by locals, to a comprehensive menu that extends far beyond just slices, Lucy's Pizza provides a quintessential, reliable neighborhood dining experience. The friendly service, combined with the assurance of a great, classic "football pizza" slice, ensures that customers who grew up with Lucy's continue to bring their own children back, reinforcing its legacy as an essential part of the Ossining landscape.

The diverse clientele includes college students, large groups, and tourists, all drawn to a spot that manages to offer both comfort food and a quick, satisfying meal. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Cheese Pizza, an inventive specialty like the Penne Ala Vodka Pie with Grilled Chicken (a known favorite among customers), or a full Italian entrée, Lucy's ensures every patron finds something to love. This combination of history, central location, and consistent quality makes Lucy’s Pizza a vital part of the New York region's local business scene.

Lucy's Pizza is conveniently situated at 26 S Highland Ave a, Ossining, NY 10562. This address places it right in the heart of Ossining, making it easily accessible for local residents, workers, and students. The location is particularly notable for being directly across the street from Ossining High School, which contributes to its status as a bustling spot, especially during lunch and after-school hours. The big windows allow patrons to watch the day go by, creating a connection between the restaurant and the rhythm of the community.

For those driving, the location offers practical accessibility solutions. Customers can take advantage of free street parking and paid street parking options nearby, making it reasonably convenient for both quick pickups and longer dine-in experiences. The restaurant's established position on South Highland Avenue ensures it's easy to find and integrate into daily routines, whether you're commuting through the area or visiting one of Ossining's local landmarks.

Lucy's Pizza provides multiple ways for customers to enjoy their food, accommodating various preferences and busy schedules. Their service options prioritize flexibility and convenience, ensuring a great meal is always within reach. The available service options include:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the casual and cozy atmosphere, perfect for solo dining, lunch, or dinner with groups and family. The restaurant is noted as being good for kids.
• Takeout: A quick and efficient way to grab your order and enjoy it at home or on the go.
• Delivery: Have the full menu of pizza and Italian favorites brought directly to your location, making it ideal for busy weeknights or feeding a crowd.
• Catering: Lucy's extends its services to large-scale events with a dedicated catering menu, perfect for parties, family gatherings, and corporate events.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: Open for both lunch and dinner, accommodating dining plans throughout the day.

For payment, Lucy's Pizza accepts various modern methods, streamlining the transaction process for all customers:

• Credit cards
• Debit cards
• NFC mobile payments

The extensive menu at Lucy's Pizza goes well beyond traditional slices, offering a rich variety of Italian and American-Italian cuisine. The offerings are celebrated for their quality and variety, ensuring there's a satisfying option for every taste and diet.

Key features and menu highlights include:

• Classic New York Pizza & Specialty Pies: Renowned for a perfectly crispy, zero-flop crust. Specialties include the Margherita, Vegetarian, White Pizza, Meatlovers, and the popular Salad Pizza. Custom requests, like the noted customer favorite Penne Ala Vodka Pie with Grilled Chicken, are a testament to their accommodating service.
• Entrées and Italian Classics: A full selection of entrées is available for a complete meal, featuring items like Chicken Parmigiana, Veal Cutlet Parmigiana, Eggplant Parmigiana, Chicken Marsala, Veal Marsala, Chicken Francese, and Veal Francese.
• Calzones & Rolls: Handheld favorites such as the Cheese Calzone, Ham & Cheese Calzone, Sausage & Peppers Roll, Chicken & Cheeseroil, and the less common Broccoli & Cheese Calzone and Spinach & Cheese Calzone.
• Pasta Dishes & Baked Specialties: Offering traditional Pasta alongside baked classics like Baked Ziti, Lasagna, Ravioli, Stuffed Shells, and Manicotti.
• Salads & Sides: Healthy options include the Tossed Salad, Chef Salad, Caesar Salad, and the impressive Cold Antipasto. Side orders range from French Fries and Onion Rings to Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, and Broccoli Rabe Saute.
• Accommodating Options: The menu clearly caters to various dietary needs by offering vegetarian options and specializing in comfort food and quick bites.
• Catering Menu: A large selection of platters and full-tray options, including Cold Antipasto Platter, Penne Ala Vodka, Baked Ziti With Ricotta, Eggplant Rollatini, and classic proteins like Chicken Marsala and Sausage & Peppers, Onions.

Lucy's Pizza is easily reachable for placing orders, making catering inquiries, or general questions:

• Address: 26 S Highland Ave a, Ossining, NY 10562
• Phone: (914) 762-0001
• Mobile Phone: +1 914-762-0001

For anyone in the New York region, especially in or near Westchester County, Lucy's Pizza represents the best of local, authentic Italian-American dining. It's an establishment that has proven its dedication to quality and community for decades, making it a reliable and emotionally resonant choice for any meal.

Consistency and Quality: The core reason to choose Lucy's is their commitment to consistency. As one customer noted, the pizza has a great undercarriage and zero flop, characteristics that define a superior New York-style slice. The dough is made fresh daily, and the staff is known for their great customer service and friendly demeanor.

A True Local Staple: Lucy's is recognized as an Ossining staple. Its history, proximity to the high school, and long tenure (since 1989) mean that eating here is an authentic local experience. It's a place where you can genuinely blend in with the community and enjoy a meal in an environment that is truly historic and community-focused.

Diverse Dining Options: Whether you need a full dinner for the family (with good for kids and vegetarian options available), a quick, satisfying lunch slice, or full-scale catering for a large event, Lucy's accommodates it all. The options for delivery, takeout, and a cozy dine-in experience ensure that no matter the occasion or time constraint, a quality Italian meal is always possible. When looking for a restaurant that offers a delicious menu, a welcoming environment, and a deep connection to the Westchester community, Lucy's Pizza stands out as a top choice.

Lucy's Pizza

26 S Highland Ave a, Ossining, NY 10562, USA