Make Bagels

- 4003 Broadway, New York, NY 10032

For many New Yorkers, the quintessential bagel is not just a morning food item—it’s a way of life, a key component of the city’s culinary identity, and a non-negotiable standard for any true bakery. Make Bagels, a beloved local spot nestled in the vibrant Washington Heights neighborhood, is a testament to this tradition. This establishment is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it’s a dedicated bakery specializing in crafting authentic, fresh-baked New York-style bagels, along with a full menu of deli essentials that make it a cornerstone of the Uptown community. Whether you're a long-time resident or just exploring the northern reaches of Manhattan, Make Bagels offers a warm, friendly atmosphere and a commitment to quality that shines through in every bite. Known for their extensive variety of bagel flavors, house-made cream cheese spreads, and substantial, high-quality sandwiches featuring Boar's Head meats, this local business has cemented its reputation as a must-visit destination for those craving a true taste of New York. In an era where many businesses compromise on quality for speed, Make Bagels remains dedicated to the traditional bagel-making process—ensuring that satisfying chew and crisp crust that New Yorkers demand. This professional yet friendly approach has earned the bakery a loyal following, often praised for both the food's consistency and the staff's welcoming service.

Make Bagels is conveniently situated in the heart of Washington Heights, a location that places it perfectly for both local patrons and those utilizing New York City’s excellent public transit system. You can find this essential neighborhood spot at:

4003 Broadway, New York, NY 10032, USA

The location on Broadway, a major thoroughfare in Upper Manhattan, makes it highly accessible. For commuters, the bakery is easily reachable via the New York City Subway, with the 1 train and the A/C train lines offering nearby stops, ensuring a simple trip from most parts of Manhattan. For those utilizing local buses, numerous routes stop within a short walking distance. Its position in a bustling commercial area of Washington Heights means it is surrounded by other essential services and is a natural stop during a morning commute or a midday errand run. The accessibility of 4003 Broadway contributes significantly to its popularity as a go-to spot for daily breakfast and lunch needs in the Uptown region. The lively street scene further adds to the authentic New York experience, making a visit to Make Bagels a genuine immersion into the local culture of the Heights.

Make Bagels prides itself on offering a comprehensive menu of services that extend well beyond a simple bagel-and-schmear. Their dedication to a full-service experience ensures customers have options for any time of day, ranging from quick grabs to full, hearty meals.

Services include:

• Fresh-Baked Bagels: A wide array of classic New York-style bagels, available as singles, half-dozens, or a Baker's Dozen (13). Popular flavors include Plain, Everything, Sesame, Poppy Seed, Cinnamon Raisin, Garlic, Onion, Salt, Whole Wheat, Pumpernickel, Egg, and Whole Wheat Everything.
• Cream Cheese and Spreads: An impressive selection of spreads, including classic Plain Cream Cheese, Scallion, Vegetable, Jalapeño, Walnut Raisin, Olive, Lox Spread, and Tofu Cream Cheese options, served on a bagel or by the half-pound.
• Bagel Sandwiches: Custom-made breakfast and lunch sandwiches on your choice of bagel, roll, or bread.
• Deli Sandwiches: A robust selection of specialty and custom-order sandwiches featuring high-quality Boar’s Head cold cuts and cheeses. Sandwich options cover everything from traditional Italian Combos and Chicken Clubs to specialized items like "The Nova Scotia" (lox, cream cheese, red onions, tomato, and capers).
• House-Made Salads: Freshly prepared Chicken Salad, Tuna Salad, Egg Salad, and Whitefish Salad, available as sandwiches or by the half-pound.
• Muffins and Pastries: A rotating selection of fresh-baked goods, often featuring classic New York bakery items such as Blueberry, Corn, Lemon Poppy, and Double Chocolate Muffins.
• Beverages: A full range of hot and cold drinks, including fresh-brewed coffee, hot tea, iced coffee, and various specialty beverages.
• Catering Options: While not explicitly detailed, local bagel shops often provide bulk orders (Baker's Dozens) and sandwich platters, making it a viable option for local office meetings or family gatherings.

What sets Make Bagels apart and keeps New Yorkers coming back is a combination of quality ingredients, traditional preparation methods, and deep community roots.

Key highlights and features include:

• Authentic New York Bagels: The core offering is a true New York bagel—traditionally kettle-boiled before being baked, resulting in the distinct chewy interior and slightly crisp exterior that bagel aficionados love.
• High-Quality Deli Meats: The use of premium Boar's Head products for all deli and specialty sandwiches ensures a level of freshness and quality in their cold cuts and cheeses.
• Wide Variety of House-Made Spreads: The sheer number of cream cheese flavors, including savory, sweet, and low-fat/tofu options, caters to diverse tastes and dietary preferences.
• Full-Service Menu: Beyond just bagels, the extensive menu of deli sandwiches, homemade salads, and fresh-baked muffins provides a complete breakfast and lunch solution.
• Neighborhood Favorite Status: Often cited by locals as having some of the best bagels north of 125th Street, Make Bagels has a strong reputation within Washington Heights for consistency and quality.
• Convenient Uptown Location: Its position at 4003 Broadway makes it an easily accessible staple for the daily routines of Washington Heights and surrounding Upper Manhattan residents.
• Generous Portions: Customers frequently note the substantial size and generous portions of the spreads and sandwich fillings, ensuring excellent value for a New York meal.

For local residents planning a visit, a pick-up order, or seeking catering inquiries, the details for Make Bagels are as follows:

P: 4003 Broadway, New York, NY 10032, USA

P: The phone number for Make Bagels is (212) 928-2300.

Choosing Make Bagels is a clear choice for any New Yorker in the Uptown area looking for uncompromised quality and an authentic experience. What makes it particularly worth a visit is its genuine adherence to the classic New York bagel tradition, which is increasingly hard to find. The bagels are consistently fresh, providing that perfect balance of crunch and chew that defines the city's best. The establishment's commitment to using high-grade ingredients, particularly the Boar's Head meats and the wide variety of house-made cream cheeses (including specialty options like their Lox Spread or the various fruit and vegetable flavors), elevates the simple bagel shop experience to a deli-quality destination.

For a first-timer, the "Everything" bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese is a can't-miss classic, representing the best of their baking and spread-making capabilities. If you're looking for a hearty lunch, the Specialty Sandwiches, such as "The Nova Scotia" or the generous Italian Combo, are built to satisfy. Ultimately, Make Bagels is not just a commercial bakery; it is a dedicated local business that serves as an essential part of the Washington Heights community, providing a daily dose of authentic, delicious New York fare with friendly, efficient service. Supporting this local spot means investing in the neighborhood and enjoying one of the city's finest examples of its culinary tradition.

Make Bagels

4003 Broadway, New York, NY 10032, USA