Make My Fish

- 120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026

In the heart of Harlem, on a block that buzzes with life and community, you’ll find Make My Fish. This is a local institution that has built a reputation not on frills or fancy decor, but on the simple, powerful promise of delicious, high-quality seafood. As a dedicated seafood restaurant, Make My Fish focuses on delivering classic, comforting dishes that have a loyal following. It’s the kind of place where the food speaks for itself, and a great community feel makes every visit a pleasant experience. A customer review perfectly captures this essence, describing the staff as "incredibly friendly and welcoming" and noting that "even the customers seemed happy and easy to talk to."

The restaurant's menu is a celebration of fried fish done right. It’s a place where the classics are perfected, from a crispy "Catfish & Chips" to a savory "Shrimp Dinner." One customer review raved about the catfish, saying it was "crispy on the outside and tender on the inside." Another review praised the shrimp, calling it "lightly breaded" and delicious. The menu also features Southern-style comfort food sides like "Collard Greens," "Macaroni and Cheese," and "Candied Yams," which are often praised by customers as being as good as the main dishes. This commitment to delivering a full, satisfying, and flavorful meal is what makes Make My Fish a true standout in the Harlem food scene.

Make My Fish is also known for its simple and straightforward service model. It's a casual spot designed for a "quick bite," with both delivery and takeout options available, catering to the busy lifestyle of New Yorkers. While there is sometimes a wait, a customer noted that a long line is often a sign of good food, saying, "The line was long but that’s how you know it’s good." This willingness to wait for quality shows the high regard the community has for this local gem. The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, making it a reliable choice throughout the day for a hearty and satisfying meal.

Make My Fish is located at 120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026, USA. This address places it in a vibrant and accessible part of Central Harlem. The restaurant's location on West 116th Street, a major cross-street, makes it easy to find for both locals and those visiting the neighborhood. It is well-connected to public transportation, with several bus stops and subway stations nearby, making it a convenient stop for a meal on the go.

For customers arriving by car, the restaurant is situated in an area that offers both free and paid street parking. This is a crucial detail in New York City, where parking can often be difficult to find. This provides a practical option for those who choose to drive. The restaurant also features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that it is a welcoming place for a diverse range of patrons. This commitment to accessibility and convenience, combined with its central location, makes Make My Fish a practical and easy choice for a delicious meal in Harlem.

Services Offered

• Delivery: Provides the convenience of having delicious seafood and sides brought directly to your home.
• Takeout: A quick and efficient way to order and pick up food to enjoy elsewhere.
• Catering: Offers catering services, making it possible to bring the flavors of Make My Fish to a larger gathering or event.
• Payment options: Make My Fish operates on a cash-only basis. It's important for customers to plan accordingly to ensure a smooth transaction.

Features / Highlights

• Crispy and Tender Fried Seafood: Customers consistently praise the restaurant’s ability to fry fish and shrimp to perfection, ensuring a crispy exterior and a tender, juicy interior.
• Classic Comfort Food Sides: The menu features beloved sides like "Macaroni And Cheese," "Collard Greens," and "Candied Yams," which are often highlighted as a major part of the satisfying meal experience.
• Specialty Items: The menu includes unique items like "Fish And Grits" and a "Triple Play" combo, offering a variety of options for every appetite. The restaurant also has a special "seafood-only" policy on Fridays.
• Great Community Feel: The staff is known for being incredibly friendly and welcoming, creating a positive and warm atmosphere that customers appreciate.
• Cash-Only Policy: This is a notable feature that sets the restaurant apart. Customers should be aware that only cash payments are accepted.

Contact Information

Address: 120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026, USA

Phone: (917) 388-3138

What is worth choosing

When you choose Make My Fish, you're not just choosing a meal; you're choosing a true New York City neighborhood experience. What makes this seafood restaurant truly worth choosing is its unwavering focus on the essentials: high-quality, delicious, and comforting food. The menu is a love letter to classic American fried seafood, and the rave reviews about the crispy catfish, perfectly cooked shrimp, and flavorful sides like collard greens and macaroni and cheese are a testament to their expertise. The fact that customers are willing to brave a wait, and that the place is "usually a wait," speaks volumes about the quality of the food and the satisfaction it provides.

The community-focused and friendly atmosphere is another compelling reason to visit. In a city that can sometimes feel impersonal, Make My Fish stands out with its warm and welcoming staff. This creates an environment where customers feel like they are part of a community, not just a transaction. The convenience of takeout and delivery services is also a huge plus, allowing New Yorkers to enjoy this delicious food from the comfort of their own homes. The restaurant’s clear communication about its cash-only policy and special "seafood-only Fridays" helps set expectations and adds to its authentic charm. For anyone in New York looking for a simple, satisfying, and delicious seafood meal, made with care and served with a friendly smile, Make My Fish is an exceptional and highly recommended choice.

Make My Fish

120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026, USA