Montague Street Bagels

- 108 Montague St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

There's nothing more quintessentially New York than a great bagel, and for locals in Brooklyn Heights, Montague Street Bagels is a neighborhood staple that delivers the genuine article. Nestled right on the busy thoroughfare it's named for, this bagel shop has earned a reputation for providing that perfect, chewy-on-the-inside, crisp-on-the-outside ring that defines the true NYC bagel experience. It’s a low-key, local gem—a welcome respite from the tourist-heavy spots, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes every visit feel like coming home.

From the moment you step in, you're greeted with the aroma of freshly baked bread and rich, local coffee. While the menu is anchored by its legendary bagels, Montague Street Bagels is far more than just a morning stop. It functions as a full-service deli and bakery, providing a comprehensive selection of breakfast, lunch, and catering options that keep Brooklynites fueled throughout the day. Whether you’re grabbing a Bagel with Cream Cheese and Lox to start your workday or an oversized specialty sandwich for lunch, you'll find quality and a commitment to flavor here that is a hallmark of great Brooklyn food culture.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Montague Street Bagels is conveniently located at 108 Montague St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA, placing it directly in the heart of the historic and picturesque Brooklyn Heights neighborhood. This area is known for its beautiful brownstones, quiet side streets, and proximity to major transportation hubs, making the bagel shop easily accessible for commuters, residents, and visitors exploring this charming part of the borough.

The shop’s location on Montague Street means it’s just steps away from local businesses, the stunning views of the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, and various subway lines. For those driving, paid street parking is available, though in a busy area like Brooklyn Heights, a quick visit is often the most practical option. The shop welcomes quick visits and provides several options for service, including in-store pickup, delivery, and takeout, ensuring you can grab your order quickly, no matter how tight your schedule is. While some sources indicate varied weekend hours, the shop is a consistent go-to spot for those needing breakfast or lunch in the area, with online ordering hours generally extending into the late afternoon.

---

## Services Offered

Montague Street Bagels prides itself on being a one-stop-shop for a wide array of food and service options. The offerings extend well beyond the typical bagel shop fare, encompassing a full deli and catering service.

• In-Store Experience: Customers can enjoy the cozy, local atmosphere with dine-in options, or quickly grab their order via takeout.
• Delivery and Pickup: For maximum convenience, the shop offers in-store pickup for online orders and robust delivery service throughout the area.
• Breakfast and Bakery: The foundation of the business, offering hand-rolled bagels, flagels, and bialys sold individually or by the Half Dozen and Dozen Bagels. The bakery also features fresh items like House Baked Plain Croissant, Apple Turnover, and Crumb Cake.
• Extensive Cream Cheese Selection: An unparalleled variety of cream cheese and spread options, including standard spreads like Plain CC, Scallion CC, and Lox Spread, as well as specialty flavors like Jalapeno Cheddar Cream Cheese, Bacon Sriracha Cream Cheese, and various Low Fat and Tofu Spread options. These are all available for purchase by the bagel or by the pound.
• Full Deli and Sandwich Menu: Serving up everything from classic breakfast sandwiches like a Bagel With 2 Eggs, Meat And Cheese to large, named Specialty Sandwiches and Hot Sandwiches like the Philly Cheese Steak and NY Yankees. Customers can also Make Your Own Sandwich with Boar's Head cold cuts.
• Housemade Salads and Burgers: The menu includes Housemade Salad Sandwiches (like Whitefish Salad and Baked Salmon Salad), various Wrap Station options, and a full Burgers Galore selection, featuring a classic Bacon Cheeseburger and a Mushroom Swiss Burger.
• Catering Services: Ideal for office meetings or large events, the shop offers full Catering Breakfast Platters (including the Lox Platter A La Carte) and larger Catering Platters like a Cheese Platter, Antipasto Platter, and Fresh Fruit Platter.
• Beverage Options: A wide range of hot drinks like Coffee, Tea, and Hot Chocolate, along with cold selections like Iced Cold Brew Coffee, Naked Juice, and assorted sodas and bottled water.

---

## Features / Highlights

Montague Street Bagels stands out in the crowded New York food scene by focusing on quality ingredients, a massive variety of spreads, and a genuinely authentic local feel.

• Authentic New York Bagels: Praised by local customers for delivering the authentic NYC bagel experience: perfectly chewy on the inside with a crisp bite on the outside, ensuring they hold up to generous fillings.
• Hand-Rolled Bagels: As a true old-school bagel shop, the bagels are reportedly hand-rolled on-site, a testament to the traditional craft that produces a superior texture and flavor compared to machine-made alternatives.
• Expansive Cream Cheese Variety: With over twenty different cream cheese and tofu spread options, the selection is immense. Patrons can choose traditional flavors or try inventive options like Lox Scallion Tofu Spread, Cucumber Dill Cream Cheese, or Bacon Cheddar CC.
• Full Meal Destination: Unlike smaller shops, Montague Street Bagels offers a comprehensive menu that extends well past breakfast. With Specialty Sandwiches, Hot Sandwiches, and Burgers, it serves as a reliable spot for lunch and a potential dinner option, too, as evidenced by their dinner announcements in the past.
• Local, Cozy Vibe: Customers frequently describe the atmosphere as warm and homey, offering a true local experience without the “tourist hype.” It's the quintessential neighborhood counter where the focus is on great food and friendly, quick service.
• Catering for Any Event: The large selection of catering options, from the simple Dozen Bagels to full Specialty Salads Platter and Coffee Service, makes it a prime resource for local business meetings and family gatherings in Brooklyn.

---

## Contact Information

Ready to grab an authentic Brooklyn bagel or inquire about a catering order? Here is the essential contact information for Montague Street Bagels:

Address

108 Montague St

Brooklyn, NY 11201

USA

Phone

(718) 237-2512

---

## What is Worth Choosing

When you're faced with a menu as extensive as the one at Montague Street Bagels, it helps to know what the local favorites are. The top reason people visit is for that perfect New York bagel, and their preparation style is highly praised.

For a quintessential morning experience, you can't go wrong with the basics done right. The Bagel with Cream Cheese and Lox is a consistently popular choice, allowing the high-quality cream cheese and fresh lox to shine against the crisp bagel texture. For those who prefer a hearty, savory start, the Bagel With 2 Eggs, Meat And Cheese is a top seller and a classic comfort food that truly satisfies. Customers also highlight their classic egg and cheese sandwiches as a good value.

If you're looking to explore the incredible variety of spreads, trying a bagel with one of their unique flavors is a must. Options like Lox Spread Cream Cheese, Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese, or a tofu-based option like Veggie Tofu Cream Cheese allow you to customize your breakfast entirely. Beyond breakfast, the deli menu offers satisfying, generous portions. Specialty options like the Fat Tony (chicken cutlet, melted Muenster, and bacon on a toasted garlic hero) or the classic Reuben make for an ideal, filling lunch. Ultimately, whether you need a quick, delicious coffee and bagel or a full deli feast, Montague Street Bagels delivers authentic, high-quality New York fare right in the heart of Brooklyn Heights.

Montague Street Bagels

108 Montague St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA